| "...that an end could be put to
their machinations in no other way than cutting them off by an
ignominious death" (John Calvin).
The great declaration of the Reformation was "Sola Scriptura,"
Scripture Alone. But for John Calvin it clearly was not just
Scripture alone. "It was Scripture plus the sword of the state,
hangings, burning at the stake, prison, tortures..." (The Other Side
of John Calvin, p. 54).
Below is evidence that this is not overstatement!
Most who call themselves Calvinist say very little about the
famous Reformer having a persecuting side. This reflects a selective
silence that began quite early. Many Protestants point to the
biased and ridicules book by
John Foxe (his "Book of Martyrs") for detailing the supposed
terrible atrocities meted out by "Papal Rome". But Foxe, a
contemporary and friend of Calvin (he outlived Calvin by 23 years),
gives not one paragraph to the many persecutions that took place at
Calvin's Geneva and elsewhere across Europe. Only those who suffered
at the hand of Rome are mentioned (Pike, n.122).
CHRONOLOGY OF CALVIN'S LIFE
1509 -- Born at Noyon, northwest of Paris. His father was
lawyer-secretary to the local Catholic bishop.
1521 -- Placed on church payroll as a "benefice."
1523 -- Sent to the University of Paris to study for the
priesthood. Begins to be attracted to anti Romanist views.
1528 -- His father and older brother are excommunicated from
the Catholic Church. Leaves Paris to study law at Orleans and
then at Bourges. Comes under the influence of the reformer
Melchoir Wolmar.
1531 -- After death of father he returns to Paris to study
Greek and Hebrew, but shortly after resumes law studies at
Orleans. There he receives a doctorate with highest honours.
1533 -- Comes under the influence of a cousin, Olivetan, a
Waldensian pastor and translator of the Bible into French. Makes
final break with the Catholic Church and declares himself a
Protestant. His writings do not give a clear testimony of his
own salvation experience (Pike, pp.7-9).
1533-36 -- Flees Paris, takes up residence in Basel. Finishes
first edition of his Institutes of the Christian Religion.
1536 -- Arrives in Geneva, a city that had recently declared
itself free from the Catholic Church. Is persuaded by William
Farel to develop a church-state system for Geneva. All in the
city are required to attend the Reformed Church. All must give
an oath of allegiance to a code of faith and discipline on fear
of banishment from the city. In less than two years Calvin and
Farel are forced to flee Geneva because of the harshness of
their system.
1538 -- Oversees a church of French refugees in Strasbourg.
Comes under the influence of Martin Bucer. Revises his
Institutes. Writes a commentary on Romans. Does all in his power
to oppose the Anabaptists.
CALVIN'S STATEMENTS SUPPORTING PERSECUTION
- Prefatory Address in his Institutes to Francis, King of the
French, 1536. "But when I perceived that the fury of certain bad
men had risen to such a height in your realm, that there was no
place in it for sound doctrine, I thought it might be of service
if I were in the same work both to give instruction to my
countrymen, and also lay before your Majesty a Confession, from
which you may learn what the doctrine is that so inflames the
rage of those madmen who are this day, with fire and sword,
troubling your kingdom. For I fear not to declare, that what I
have here given may be regarded as a summary of the very
doctrine which, they vociferate, ought to be punished with
confiscation, exile, imprisonment, and flames, as well as
exterminated by land and sea. This, I allow, is a fearful
punishment which God sends on the earth; but if the wickedness
of men so deserves, why do we strive to oppose the just
vengeance of God?"
- Letter to William Farel, February 13, 1546. "If he [Servetus]
comes [to Geneva], I shall never let him go out alive if my
authority has weight."
- Letter to the Lord Protector of Somerset, adviser to King
Edward VI, October 22, 1548. "[They] well deserve to be
repressed by the sword which is committed to you, seeing that
they attack not the King only, but God who has seated him upon
the throne, and has entrusted to you the protection as well of
His person as of His majesty."
- Letter of August 20, 1553, one week after Servetus arrest.
"I hope that Servetus will be condemned to death."
- Defense of Orthodox Faith against the Prodigious Errors of
the Spaniard Michael Servetus, published in early 1554. "Whoever
shall now contend that it is unjust to put heretics and
blasphemers to death will knowingly and willingly incur their
very guilt. This is not laid down on human authority; it is God
who speaks and prescribes a perpetual rule for his Church. It is
not in vain that he banishes all those human affections which
soften our hearts; that he commands paternal love and all the
benevolent feelings between brothers, relations, and friends to
cease; in a word, that he almost deprives men of their nature in
order that nothing may hinder their holy zeal. Why is so
implacable a severity exacted but that we may know that God is
defrauded of his honour, unless the piety that is due to him be
preferred to all human duties, and that when his glory is to be
asserted, humanity must be almost obliterated from our memories?
Many people have accused me of such ferocious cruelty that I
would like to kill again the man I have destroyed. Not only am I
indifferent to their comments, but I rejoice in the fact that
they spit in my face."
- Preface to Commentaries, July 22, 1557. "To these
irreligious characters. and despisers of the heavenly doctrineŠ.
I think that there is scarcely any of the weapons which are
forged in the workshop of Satan, which has not been employed by
them in order to obtain their object. And at length matters had
come to such a state, that an end could be put to their
machinations in no other way than cutting them off by an
ignominious death; which was indeed a painful and pitiable
spectacle to me. They no doubt deserved the severest punishment,
but I always rather desired that they might live in prosperity,
and continue safe and untouched; which would have been the case
had they not been altogether incorrigible, and obstinately
refused to listen to wholesome admonition."
- Comments on Ex. 22:20, Lev. 24:16, Deut. 13:5-15, 17:2-5.
"Moreover, God Himself has explicitly instructed us to kill
heretics, to smite with the sword any city that abandons the
worship of the true faith revealed by Him."
- Letter to the Marquis Paet, chamberlain to the King of
Navarre, 1561. "Honour, glory, and riches shall be the reward of
your pains; but above all, do not fail to rid the country of
those scoundrels [Anabaptists and others], who stir up the
people to revolt against us. Such monsters should be
exterminated, as I have exterminated Michael Servetus the
Spaniard."
PERSECUTIONS AT CALVIN'S GENEVA
The Minutes Book of the Geneva City Council, 1541-59 (translated
by Stefan Zweig, Erasmus: The Right to Heresy):
- "During the ravages of the pestilence in 1545 more than
twenty men and women were burnt alive for witchcraft.
- From 1542 to 1546 fifty-eight judgements of death and
seventy-six decrees of banishment were passed.
- During the years 1558 and 1559 the cases of various
punishments for all sorts of offences amounted to four hundred
and fourteen.
- One burgher smiled while attending a baptism: three days
imprisonment.
- Another, tired out on a hot summer day, went to sleep during
a sermon: prison.
- Some workingmen ate pastry at breakfast: three days on bread
and water.
- Two burghers played skittles: prison.
- Two others diced for a quarter bottle of wine: prison.
- A blind fiddler played a dance: expelled from the city.
- Another praised Castellio's translation of the Bible:
expelled from Geneva.
- A girl was caught skating, a widow threw herself on the
grave of her husband, a burgher offered his neighbour a pinch of
snuff during divine service: they were summoned before the
Consistory, exhorted, and ordered to do penance.
- Some cheerful fellows at Epiphany stuck a bean into the
cake: four-and-twenty hours on bread and water.
- A couple of peasants talked about business matters on coming
out of church: prison.
- A man played cards: he was pilloried with the pack of cards
hung around his neck.
- Another sang riotously in the street: was told 'they could
go and sing elsewhere,' this meaning he was banished from the
city.
- Two bargees had a brawl: executed.
- A man who publicly protested against the reformer's doctrine
of predestination was flogged at all the crossways of the city
and then expelled.
- A book printer who in his cups [columns] had railed at
Calvin, was sentenced to have his tongue perforated with a
red-hot iron before being expelled from the city.
- Jacques Gruent was racked and then executed for calling
Calvin a hypocrite.
- Each offence, even the most paltry, was carefully entered in
the record of the Consistory, so that the private life of every
citizen could unfailingly be held up against him in evidence."
(See Pike, pp. 61-63).
Sources quoted in Philip Schaff's History of the Christian Church,
vol. 8:
- "The death penalty against heresy, idolatry and blasphemy
and barbarous customs of torture were retained. Attendance at
public worship was commanded on penalty of three sols. Watchmen
were appointed to see that people went to church. The members of
the Consistory visited every house once a year to examine the
faith and morals of the family. Every unseemly word and act on
the street was reported, and the offenders were cited before the
Consistory to be either censured and warned, or to be handed
over to the Council for severer punishment."
- Several women, among them the wife of Ami Perrin, the
captain-general, were imprisoned for dancing.
- A man was banished from the city for three months because on
hearing an ass bray, he said jestingly 'He prays a beautiful
psalm.'
- A young man was punished because he gave his bride a book on
housekeeping with the remark: 'This is the best Psalter.'
- Three men who laughed during a sermon were imprisoned for
three days.
- Three children were punished because they remained outside
of the church during the sermon to eat cakes.
- A man who swore by the 'body and blood of Christ' was fined
and condemned to stand for an hour in the pillory on the public
square.
- A child was whipped for calling his mother a thief and a
she-devil.
- A girl was beheaded for striking her parents.
- A banker was executed for repeated adultery.
- A person named Chapuis was imprisoned for four days because
he persisted in calling his child Claude (a Roman Catholic
saint) instead of Abraham.
- Men and women were burnt to death for witchcraft. (See Pike,
pp. 55,56).
From Other Sources:
- Belot, an Anabaptist was arrested for passing out tracts in
Geneva and also accusing Calvin of excessive use of wine. With
his books and tracts burned, he was banished from the city and
told not to return on pain of hanging (J.L. Adams, The Radical
Reformation, pp. 597-598).
- Martin Luther said of Calvin's actions in Geneva, "With a
death sentence they solve all argumentation" (Juergan L. Neve, A
History of Christian Thought, vol. I, p. 285).
- "About the month of January 1546, a member of the Little
Council, Pierre Ameaux, asserted that Calvin was nothing but a
wicked man - who was preaching false doctrine. Calvin felt that
his authority as an interpreter of the Word of God was being
attacked: he so completely identified his own ministry with the
will of God that he considered Ameaux's words as an insult to
the honour of Christ. The Magistrates offered to make the
culprit beg Calvin's pardon on bended knees before the Council
of the Two Hundred, but Calvin found this insufficient. On April
8, Ameaux was sentenced to walk all round the town, dressed only
in a shirt, bareheaded and carrying a lighted torch in his hand,
and after that to present himself before the tribunal and cry to
God for mercy" (F. Wendel, Calvin, pp. 85, 86).
"Doth a fountain send forth at the same place sweet water and
bitter?" James 3:11. |