4Unity archive

Canonical_Debate

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

The Canonical Debate From The First Century To The Fourth

For the first 300 years of Christianity, different Christian communities had distinct collections of New Testament books, and individual leaders expressed differing views as to what books should and should not he included in the canon. Esentially, the canon was closed in 367. At that time St. Athanasius, the great "Doctor of the Catholic Church and patriarch of Alexandria" (The Columbia Encyclopedia, copyright 1958, p. 114), wrote his Easter letter to the churches and monasteries of his diocese and identified the books they were to include in their New Testament Scripture. In doing so he was in fact the first person to apply the term canon to the contents of the Bible, and he introduced the verb canonize, meaning "to give official sanction to" a written document. The church agreed. Athanasius’ canon had long been accepted by the church in Rome by the time it was confirmed by Pope Damasus (A.D. 382). In North Africa his canon was ratified by church leaders in Hippo Regius in 393 and in Carthage in 397. Carthage formally reaffirmed its acceptance of the canon in 419."

The chart below offers a simple overview of the debate over the canonicity of Christian writings during the course of three centuries.

  Marcion Muratorian Canon Irenaeus of Lyons Tertullian Origen Eusebius Athanasius  
Matthew              
Mark              
Luke              
John              
Acts              
Romans              
1&2 Cor.              
Galatians              
Ephesians              
Philippians              
Colossians              

KEY

1&2 Thes.               Accepted  
1&2 Tim.               Accepted but others disputed  
Titus              
Philemon               Disputed  
Hebrews               considered authoritative but not canonical   
James              
1 Peter              
2 Peter               Rejected  
1 John               Did not Mention  
2 John              
3 John               Inconclusive information  
Jude              
Revelation               This information is taken from the "Bible Through the Ages" edited by Robert V. Huber, copyright 1996,  p. 214
Shepherd of Hermas              
Apoc. of Peter              
Wisd. of Solomon              
Didache              
Epistle of Barnabas              
Acts of Paul