![]()
The First Century Jew’s Disputed and Restricted Several Biblical Books.
In the first century there were many parts of the Bible (Not Just The so called "Apocrypha" books) that were Disputed or looked at by the Jews with a leery eye, as the "Complete Guide to the Bible" explains:
"Not only were parts of the Bible once deemed top horrifying or erotic deemed top horrifying or erotic for children, some rabbis in ancient times ordered that no one under the age of 30 could read them. Prohibited were Ezeekiel’s nightmarish vision in chapter 1, along with entire Song of Solomon, a sensual discussion between a young man and a young woman in love.
When it came time to discuss which revered Jewish writings belonged in the Hebrew Bible, many rabbis argued against both Ezekiel and Song of Solomon, fearing the damage these books might cause if read aloud in synagogues. Other books and passages were also considered inappropriate for children or even for inclusion in the Bible. The book of Esther met resistance not only because it fails to mention God, but because it presents as good new the story of threatened Jews in Persia descending to the barbarity of their enemies, slaughtering 75, 000 of them." ("Complete Guide to the Bible", The Readers Digest Association Inc. Copyright 1998, Page 224)
The leeriness of the this first century Jews towards the book of Esther is born out in the dead sea scrolls. Of the thirty-nine books of the Hebrew Bible [or twenty-four if the Minor Prophets, Ezra-Nehemiah, 1 and 2 Samuel, 1 and 2 Kings, and 1 and 2 Chronicles are each counted as one] only the book of Esther is missing from the collection of manuscripts unearthed in the caves above the banks of the Dead Sea. The absence of Esther from the twenty or so scrolls found among the ruins of Masada and the hideouts used by the rebels of the Bar Kokhba revolt does not raise much of a question, but the absence of Esther from more than 200 biblical scrolls from the caves at Qumran is a bit more curious. Evidence that has come to light just recently reveals that the absence of Esther was purposeful rather than accidental. The Qumran calendar texts-not generally known before 1991-chart festivals and holy days on the community's 364-day year. The feast of Purim, which has its beginnings in the story of Esther, is missing. As a result, the real question now be-comes: Why was Esther rejected?
Several answers might be suggested. First, the fact that the festival of Purim was a later addition, not mentioned in the Books of Moses, might have caused the Dead Sea Scrolls community to reject the book. Second, the mere fact that the story concerns the marriage of Esther (a Jew) to a Persian king was likely repugnant to the group's conservative sensibilities. Third, the book itself makes no mention of God whatsoever. Finally, the emphasis on retaliation evident in the final chapters of Esther (chapters 7-9) is contrary to the teachings of the Dead Sea Scrolls: "To no man shall I return evil for evil; I shall pursue a man only for good; for with God resides the judgment of all the living, and he shall pay each man his recompense" (1 QS 10:17-18). Any one of these factors would have provided good reason to reject the book of Esther.
![]()
Please sign our Guest book!
This page has helped
People find the truth since November 1999
