4Unity archive

Answeres to CEC

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

"Mary as Mediator"

This is a refutation of a deceitful Protestant article by the same name, found on the Anti-Catholic  Christians Evangelizing to Catholics websites.  

 When I set out engage a anti-Catholic site I usually try to refute four or five articles from it. This better enables the reader to see the the  dishonesty, and ignorance or the protestant site, providing multiple examples.   The site this article came from is a very small and poorly designed site run by a man name Bill Jackson. Normally I would not pay attention to such a small site, but Mr. Jackson posted a article attacking a pamphlet put out by some friends of mine at Our Lady of the Rosary Library, (based out of Louisville Kentucky).

In this refutation I will address Mr. Jackson's point one by one in the order in which they were posted. For the ease of the reader, and to prevent confusion, all of Mr. Jackson's statements will be in "red"  and my replies will be Black. In his article, Mr. Jackson quote by a Catholic named "John Curran", outlining what Mr. Jackson felt was the Catholic position on the topic. Since The goal of this refutation is to address Mr. Jackson's  anti-Catholic arguments, I felt this portion was not necessary, and removed it, allowing us to immediately begin dealing with his Protestant arguments. 


[Mr. Jackson's] The basic Roman Catholic belief is that Jesus is the one mediator between God and man, but that lesser mediation can be undertaken by Mary.

In order to understand this topic we must understand the biblical forms of mediation, first we will examine the mediating role Christ paled in our redemption. St. Paul explained it best when he said:

"for there is one God. There is also one Mediator between God and the Human Race, who gave himself  as ransom for all" (1 Tm. 5-6 NAB)

The Great Apostle Paul was discussing a specific type of mediation, the payment for our sins and the ransom of our salvation (1 Tim 2:6), which was achieved on the Cross. This ransom was paid for the blood of Christ, and in this specific sense there is only ONE mediator or redeemer. The Church has always taught that this all-inclusive power belongs exclusively to Jesus Christ, the Supreme Mediator "between God and men".

But in the general sense of the term there anyone can mediate or intercede on our behalf to God the Father. For when we ask another Christian to pray for use are we not really asking them to Intercede/mediate with God for our benefit. Most Protestants both accept and use this form of mediation, as did the apostles. It is in this general sense that find the great Apostle Paul in his epistles asking the early Christian to intercede or mediate with God, through prayer, on his behalf:

  • Rom. 15:30, Col. 4:3, I Th. 5:25, II Th. 3:1, Heb. 13:18-19

We also Find St Paul himself mediating with God, through prayer, on the behalf of others:

  • Rom. 1:8; I Cor 1:4; II Cor 1:3; Eph. 1:15-16; Col. 1:3; I Th. 1:2, 2:13, 3:9; II Th. 1:3, 11, 2:13; Phm. 1:4; 2 Tim. 1:3;   

The power of this mediation through prayer is clearly shown in the scriptures, in his second epistle to the Corinthians (1:11) St Paul thanks the Church in Corinth for its prayers on his behalf, and assures them that these prayers were answered. In the Book of Act's we read how the whole Church prayed for the released of St. Peter from prison, and how these prayers were answered. St. James in his epistle ( 5:16) list Paying for one another as a important Christian act.

It is in this general sense that Catholics ask Mary and the Saints to mediate on our behalf.  For who is in a better position to petition God, on our behalf? "The prayer of the just availeth much," says St. James (5:16).  Surely the canonized saints are foremost among "the just"; having conformed to the will of God in an heroic degree. These Saints have already achieved the glory of heaven, the friendship of Christ, and see the very face of our God.  Mary, St. Anne, and the other saints with Christ in heaven, are personal friends of Christ; hence they have more influence with Him than have we humans. Therefore Catholics go indirectly to Christ through the petitions of the saints, as well as to Him directly. 

 (Note to the Reader: The was quote by a Catholic named John Curran here it was removed for it is not necessary.)

[Mr. Jackson's] In the above paragraph, John failed to note the difference between an intercessor and a mediator. An intercessor is one who supplicates for another, while a mediator (Greek: mesites) is one who intervened between two warring parties to make peace. This is specifically why Christ is our only Mediator - it was only He Who could make peace between us and God.

Here Mr. Jackson attempts to deceive the reader into believing  there is only one possible Greek meaning of the term, "mesites" (i.e. "mediator" ), and bases his argument on this deception. The truth is Greek noun "mesites",  does not require "warring parties", it can simply means a "go-between" or a person "in the middle": 

"Noun: mesites, GK 3542 (S 3316), 6x. This noun derives from the Gk. adjective mesos, which means 'in the middle." (“Mounce’s Complete Expository Dictionary of Old and New Testament words”, printed by Zondervan Publishing, 2006, Pg.225)

"mesites (3316) lit., 'a go-between' (from mesos, 'middle' an eimi 'to go')" (Vine's complete Expository Dictionary Of New Testament Words, by W. E Vine, copyright 1996, pg 400)

"mesites... an internuncius, one that is the Medium of communication between two parties, a mid-party" (The New Analytical Greek Lexicon, By Wesley J. Perschbacher, copyright 2006, pg. 217)

"mesites... mediator; on who guarantees; intermediary, broker, It mean some one who stands between two parties as a negotiator, a middle person, an arbitrator, a go-between" (The Practical Word Studies in the New Testament, By Alpha-Omega Ministries inc., copyright 1998, Volume 2, pg. 1357)

"The Greek word mesites, is comprised of the words mesos, meaning 'middle' and eimi meaning 'to go.' Thus, literal means 'a go-between' and connotes 'mediator' between to parties." (Holman treasury of Key Bible Words, by Eugene E. Carpenter & Philip W. Comfort, published 2000, pg. 333)

"mesites, as a noun means lit., 'a go-between' (from mesos, 'middle' an eimi 'to go')" (The New Strong's Expanded Dictionary of Bible Words, James Strong, LL.D., S.T.D., copyright 2001, pg 1230)

"mesites, middle, a person in the middle" (A Pocket Lexicon To The Greek New Testament, By Alexander Souter, M.A., copyright 1946, pg. 156)

The term is used six times in the new testament, and not all of them refer to Christ. St Paul in his letter to the Galatians (3:19-20), He refers to Moses twice as a "mesites" (i.e mediator) between man and God. So we see that the scriptures do not limit the role of "mesites" (i.e. mediator) only to Christ. Not only is Mr. Jackson's knowledge of the Greek faulty, but his understanding of the scripture is as well.

Secondly, Bill is splitting hairs to create a straw man argument.  If he had bothered looked up the Definition of the word "intercessor" he would read that it is "One who goes between, or intercedes; a mediator." (Link to the Dictionary Definition). So we see that Mr. Jackson's answer is not only lacking but dishonest.

[Mr. Jackson's] In order to introduce other mediators into "Christian" thinking, Satan waited until the reality of Jesus' presence was lost by a backsliding church.

As we have seen above Mr. Jackson's knowledge of the scriptures is very lacking, verging on pure ignorance. As I pointed out earlier, the New Testament scriptures themselves give other examples of  mediators, for example Moses (Gal:3:19-20), and St. Paul (Rom. 1:8; I Cor 1:4; II Cor 1:3).  In the book of Revelation, John sees Angels Interceding/mediating on our behalf, offering their prayers and incense upon the golden altar before the throne. (Rev. 8:3-4). and the only backsliding here is Bill's faulty argument.

[Mr. Jackson's] As Jesus became more obscure, most thought of Him as a far-away Majestic King. Because He was thought inapproachable, a second mediator was sought.

This is of course incorrect, and a contradiction to Mr. Jackson's first statement in this article, where he acknowledges that we hold Christ to be our main  mediator. The Church has always encouraged prayer and devotion to Christ.  

[Mr. Jackson's] At the same time, pagan forms were coming into the church, and the female deity of paganism was introduced under the name of Mary, and prayers were made to her.

Bill, now resorts to spewing unsubstantiated lies and falsehoods. Not only has he repeatedly contradicted himself , and his knowledge of the scriptures been proven lacking, he has failed to make a single valid point or argument. He has resorted to the age old Protestant tradition of basing the catholic Churches respect and love of Mary. We do not make her into a "female deity", or anything close to it. there are countless articles on the web refuting the age old Protestant claims. The Catholic positions on this topics  is easy to research, and I invite the reader to do so.  

[Mr. Jackson's] To most Roman Catholics, Mary is the primary mediator to whom they turn for help.

The Reader can see that Bill contradicts his own opening statement again, and shows his ignorance of the Catholic Faith. Any Catholic can tell you that the greatest and most important prayer of the Church is the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, and it is directed to Christ not Mary.  The Church has always encouraged prayer and devotion to Christ.


FOOT NOTES

1. Gal. 3:19-20 "What, then, was the purpose of the law? It was added because of transgressions until the Seed to whom the promise referred had come. The law was put into effect through angels by a mediator. A mediator, however, does not represent just one party; but God is one." (Gal. 3:19-20 New International Version)