4Unity archive

WORLDLINESS

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

THE "WORLDLINESS" OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.

[This is a excerpt from a book called "The Catholic Church" by the most Rev. Tihamer Toth, printed in 1944 by Herder Book Co. pg 172-181]

EZCODE CENTER START

THE "WORLDLINESS" OF THE CHURCH

THE

holy Church of Christ has nothing to conceal. Her history is an unbroken chain of beautiful and blessed activity. The few pages that tell us of human weaknesses and offenses cannot lessen the greatness of her work. Because the Church is a society of human beings, it is subject to the law that governs all things human, and she cannot free herself entirely of weaknesses and faults.

A great Hungarian thinker (Baron Joseph Eotvos) has said quite rightly: "In what is almost two thousand years old, we find much that seems ignoble. Like water, the centuries in their course do not deposit their purest portions. If we consider the long past of Christian civilization, we have no admiration for some of its outgrowths, but we must not forget that the tree is judged not merely by its injured trunk, bearing the scars of centuries, but also by its luxuriant foliage, flowers, and fruit. Anyone who considers Christianity in this manner will acknowledge her pre-eminent beneficence."

Today I shall speak of the alleged worldliness of the Church. Who has not heard such speeches: The Catholic Church today has fallen away from primitive Christianity, it is no longer the Church of Christ. Christ said: "My kingdom is not of this world" (John 18:36), but the Catholic Church with its prelates and papal wealth, its pomp and out-ward power, its golden papal tiara and golden vestments, is decidedly of this world. Why has the pope the immense Vatican palace, with its countless rooms and art treasures, when Christ and the Apostles had nowhere to lay their heads? Why the numerous officials, the Peter's pence, when Christ was poor and walked barefoot? Why all the cere-monies, brocade and velvet vestments, precious gems, and works of art, when one can worship God in the quiet of a simple little room? How worldly the Catholic Church has become !

Dear brethren. Who has not heard such objections and criticisms? What shall we do? Shall we let them frighten us? Of course not. Let us only face them honestly and fearlessly.

THE OUTWARD POMP AND WEALTH OF THE CHURCH

The outward splendor of the papacy and the earthly wealth of the Church are most often used as reproaches to us and as conclusive signs of the Church's worldliness.

A. Some persons object to the Vatican, the magnificent palace of the popes, with its many rooms, its officials, its offices, and the entire vast central organization through which the pope directs the affairs of the Church. "What need is there of the whole gigantic organization?" they ask indignantly. "In Christ's time there was none of all this."

1) Well, that is true. In Christ's time there was none of this because there was no need for it.

But we must agree that if our Lord truly wished His Church to spread to all parts of the world, then an elaborate organization became necessary. As the Church grew, its organization had to grow also. In Christ's time there were twelve Apostles and seventy-two disciples; but today the twelve Apostles have become fifteen hundred bishops, and the seventy-two disciples have become almost 400,000 priests.

As the thirty-year-old Christ no longer wore the garments that the three-year-old Christ had worn, so the management of the universal Church requires a number of parishes and dioceses, congregations of cardinals, and various ecclesiastical ministries that did not exist before because they would have been superfluous in the early Church with its few hundred or thousand believers. But this is no reason for saying that the Catholic Church has become too worldly.

2) Further, if Christ wishes His religion to spread over the whole earth, it is not contrary to His will that in Western countries His followers and His priests wear a different style of garment from that of the East, that they live in a different kind of house, and eat a different kind of food, that today priests do not walk barefoot and clad in sack-cloth, and that they do not eat locusts and wild honey. But all this is no reason for saying they have become worldly and that they have become separated from Christ.

Christ did indeed say to His Apostles, "Follow Me." But He did not say: "Copy the material circumstance of My manner of life." Let us copy Him in our soul, in our mind and will, in our conformity to the heavenly Father's will.

Our Lord wore sandals, or perhaps He went barefoot. But nowhere do we read that He said: "Learn of Me and walk barefoot." He did say: "Learn of Me because I am meek and humble of heart" (Matt. Ii: 29).

Our Lord ate bread, fish, dates, and honey; He traveled on foot. But He never said: "If you do not travel and eat as I do, you cannot be My disciples."

Our Lord probably wore long hair and a beard; but His priests have not detached themselves from Him because they cut their hair and shave.

Our Lord went upon the Sea of Galilee in a small boat; today missionaries travel in large steamers. Our Lord entered Jerusalem riding upon an ass; today the successor of the Apostles reaches distant parts of his parish by automobile, and in doing so he has not forsaken Christ and His doctrine. Christ traveled, ate, and spoke in the manner of the people of His time; no one can rightly object if His Church and His priests accommodate themselves in externals to the customs of different peoples and periods. In China some missionaries used to wear queues. I myself have seen a Catholic bishop wearing the magnificent feather headdress of his tribe; but I would not say that in doing so he had forsaken Christ.

B. Someone may say: "We are not speaking merely of such things. Please tell us why the Church needs earthly wealth, estates, and extensive worldly possessions? What need has the pope of the vast sums that are sent to him from all parts of the world under the name of Peter's pence? When diocesan authorities grant a dispensation-for example, in the case of a mixed marriage-they demand a fee. Now special papal coins are being minted. Are not these signs of worldliness?"

To show that the Church has nothing to conceal, I will not avoid these questions.

1) Christ's Church is not of this world, but it works in this world. Like other enterprises in this world, it has need of material means for its activity. It must pay its officials; without money it cannot build churches, assist the poor, and support missions. Our Lord Himself had a common purse with the Apostles, which was in the keeping of Judas (John 12:6). Christ would certainly not object to His Church having a cashbox.

2) The management of the universal Church requires money, much money; and this is contributed by Catholics as Peter's pence. It is a sort of tax that members of the Church pay to defray the expenses of the Church. And it is the only tax that everyone pays gladly.

But the pope does not spend this money on his own kitchen. I think that in all likelihood the table of a prosperous middle-class family is more costly than the pope's.

What use is made of this money, called Peter's pence? It is spent in the management of the Church, in the pope's many charities by which he comes to the relief of distress in all parts of the world, and in the work of spreading the Gospel.

St. Peter's Basilica is not there for the pope's sake, but for the sake of the entire Catholic Church. In the beautiful rooms of the Vatican no wealthy private gentleman lives-let us say a big financier-but the head of 36o million Catholics. In a country with a population, let us say of five mil-lion, it is fitting that the ruler should be surrounded by a certain pomp and live in a palace. Can anyone object if the Catholic Church likes to see its chief ruler in the magnificent rooms of the Vatican?

But I must declare that all this does not belong to the essence of the Church. If a dreadful earthquake were to shake Rome and cause all the walls of St. Peter's Church to collapse, and if fire were to consume all the Vatican museums, works of art, and beautiful rooms, the Church would lose none of its essential values.

Let us remember this truth when superficial persons say that the Church has forsaken its ancient simplicity, and that pomp and power have made the papacy too worldly. With great praise Schiller silenced those who are ignorant of history, when he wrote of the popes as follows:

We have seen emperors and kings, eminent statesmen, and daunt-less warriors who, under the pressure of circumstances, sacrificed

rights, became faithless to their principles, and yielded to expediency. But such things have seldom or never happened to a pope. Even when he wandered about in wretchedness, when he possessed not an inch of land in Italy, when not a single person remained faithful to him, and when he lived on the charity of strangers, even then he endured steadfastly beside the papal throne and for the rights of the Church.... However greatly the popes differed in temperament, in their way of thinking, and in their capabilities, they were uniformly steadfast, uniformly unchanging in their politics. Their capabilities, temperaments, and way of thought apparently played no part at their election; we might almost say that their personalities merged into their office, and their passions died out under the triple crown. Although with the death of every.,, pope the chain of inheritance was broken and had to be newly forged to every new pope, and although no throne in the world changed its ruler so often, was occupied and left unoccupied so stormily, yet this was the only throne in the Christian world that seemed never to change its occupant, because only the popes died but the spirit that animated them was immortal.

THE SPLENDOR OF OUR CEREMONIES

The Church cannot be accused of too great worldliness because it needs an immense hierarchy and many officials in its world-embracing activity. Nor can anyone rightly maintain that the magnificence of our ceremonial and the splendor of our liturgical vestments and sacred vessels are signs of the spirit of worldliness.

"Why all the ceremonies that accompany a pontifical mass, for instance? Officers of the mass stand up, sit down, move here and there; incense is burned, a bell is rung. And those expensive velvet and brocade vestments and gold chalices."

A. First we must remember that our modern liturgy and vestments originated centuries ago, that they are there-fore a venerated inheritance from our Christian forbears.

1) I am convinced that if the Church were to design liturgical vestments and devise the ceremonies today, she would make them different and much simpler.

These vestments and liturgical rubrics and movements were introduced and elaborated many centuries ago, at a time when people themselves lived ceremoniously, and when they themselves appeared in silk and embroidered clothes on festive occasions.

2) "Why are they not simplified, altered according to the modern way of thinking?"

Someone may ask. In the recent past, men, dazzled by technical achievements, were intoxicated by the slogan: "Break with the past. For-get the past. Advance. Go forward."

But today we are beginning to grow more sober. We are beginning to see that, as the future develops from the pres-ent, so the present must be built on the past. Everywhere people are beginning to value the past, in every connection. The family venerates its ancestors and hangs their pictures on the wall with pride. Nations value their history and are proud to teach it to new generations. The colorful costumes and customs of the peasants are again valued and are collected in ethnographical works and saved from destruction. Can anyone really object if the Catholic Church is proud of her long past and if veneration for that past keeps her from making any alteration in her ancient and splendid ceremonies?

Soldiers wear uniforms. On special occasions they wear their best, made of finer cloth and ornamented with gold braid. Why have they uniforms when they could do their work just as well in ordinary clothes or in overalls? They wear uniforms so that everyone may see that they are not mere private persons, but servants of the state. No one criticizes soldiers for wearing uniforms. Then why do our critics not show similar understanding with regard to priests who are celebrating mass? Why do they object to the Church vesting them in festive robes when they step to the altar, and signify by these robes that they are not taking their place there as private persons, but as servants of the Almighty?

B. And here we have come to the second part of our reply. Those who object to beautiful brocade vestments, golden chalices, and decorated churches, forget that all this pomp is not for the glory of men; it is used in the service of God.

1) This truth finds touching expression at the coronation of a pope, when the newly elected vicar of Christ enters St. Peter's Basilica in the greatest magnificence. Then, in the midst of all the splendor, a piece of wick is burned while

these words are said: Beatissime Pater, sic transit gloria

mundi ("Holy Father, thus passes the glory of the world").

Would the Church serve God's cause better if we sold to dealers in antiques the brocade vestments left to us by religious ancestors, that these vestments might adorn drawing-rooms of the rich as sofa covers? Would this be in order? And would reverence for God be increased if every ornament and every sacred picture and statue were removed from the church, so that the walls would resemble those of a whitewashed granary?

If anyone says: "Christ was poor, He lived simply, without pomp and splendor," we must not forget that our ceremonies not only honor Christ who lived on earth in voluntary pov-erty, but also Christ the King who after voluntary suffering entered into heavenly glory. And we must remember that, when Judas complained of the extravagance of pouring costly ointment upon Christ's feet, our Lord Himself in gentle words defended Mary Magdalen's prodigal love.

2) It is true that our liturgy is beautiful and full of color. It is also true that in St. Peter's time there was not yet any Vatican or any St. Peter's Church. But were St. Peter to rise from his tomb today, leave St. Peter's Church, go to the Vatican, and enter Pius XI's study, it is quite certain that he would not look at Pius in surprise, nor would he shake his head in protest. I think he would say something like this:

Brother, I greet you, the rock, that once I was. Nineteen hundred years. A long time according to our reckoning. But in God's sight "a thousand years are as yesterday, which is past" (Ps. 89:4)

Since then life has changed. My garments were different from those you wear. My dwelling-place was different from yours. My language was different from yours. Many things today are different from what they were in my time. But in one thing there is no difference between us, in our faith. What you teach about Jesus Christ, that I also taught. What you teach about the redemption in your apostolic writings, that I also taught.

Our religion is one and the same. And our love is also one and the same. I took my stand for Christ before Nero; you take your stand before the Nero’s of today. What I see today in the Catholic Church, the liturgy, the beautiful vestments, the feast days, the pilgrimages, even if I did not know them, are all natural developments of the seed that was sowed by Christ. I think Peter would say something like that to the present pope and would then return to his tomb. Quite certainly he would go neither to Wittenberg nor to Geneva nor to Ox-ford nor to Moscow nor to Constantinople to find rest, but would seek his resting-place anew in Catholic Rome.

My dear brethren. Some blame the Church for being worldly, others blame her for not progressing but remaining behind the times, for not understanding the voice of the