4Unity archive

Christ's  Genealogy Legitimately

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

Can Christ's  Genealogy Legitimately be Traced Back Through His Foster Father?

Answering some objections to Christ's role as Messiah  

    

  

[OBJECTION] "Tribal affiliation is conferred through the birth father only (for which they cite Numbers 34:14, Numbers 1:18-44, Leviticus 24:10)"

It is true that "Tribal affiliation is conferred through the birth father" but they could and often were passed on through adoption as well. This is evident in Gen.17:5  Where Jacob adopts Ephraim and Manasseh as his sons. This adoption gave Ephraim and Manasseh the right of inheriting from Jacob; for the obvious intent of the passage is to account for the establishment of two tribes, Ephraim and Manasseh, with distinct territories, on an equality with the tribes claiming descent from Jacob's sons. (for more on this read this article in the Jewish Encyclopedia )

[OBJECTION]  "Because you claim that Jesus had no human father, he would have had no tribal affiliation and would be eliminated from messianic consideration."

Not so, as the article in  the Jewish Encyclopedia explains, among the Jews of that time it was the practices for men with no male heir (for example St. Joseph) to marry a woman and adopt her son in order to carry on his linage. The adopted sons became their true heirs and true children in every sense and legality of the terms. We shall explain this further in the next answer.

[OBJECTION]  "Further, the tribal affiliation could not be conferred through adoption and thus adopted sons could not inherit their step-father's genealogy."

This of course is not true. Among the Jews, a adopted Child was considered, as a "heir" and a "son" in every sense of the terms, and as legitimate as a birthed Child. This was the common understanding of adoption at the time of Christ's Birth, even among the Pagans,  the respect Biblical scholar Andrew Robert Fausset M.A explains: 

"By the Roman law of adoption, which required a due legal form, the adopted child was entitled to the father's name, possessions, and family sacred rights, as his heir at law." (Bible Cyclopedia, compiled by A. R. Fausset M.A., (C) 1909. p. 18)

The adopted child received both the fathers tribal affiliation, and could rightfully trace his genealogy back through his adopted father. A good example of this is the genealogy found in the gospel of  Luke,  as Mr. Fausset M.A explains 

"Mary, being daughter of Heli, and Joseph her husband being adopted by him on marrying his daughter, an heiress (as appears from her going to Bethlehem to be registered in her pregnancy), Joseph is called in Luke's genealogy son of Heli." (Bible Cyclopedia, compiled by A. R. Fausset M.A., (C) 1909. p. 18)

[OBJECTION]  "There is no Biblical Hebrew word for ‘adoption’"

Weather or not the biblical Hebrew had a specific word for adoption is irrelevant, the practice of adoption was widely accepted and practiced among the Old testament Jews. For example according to Josephus ("Ant." i. 7, § 1), Abraham, being at first childless, adopted Lot as his son. According to Philo ("Vita Mosis," i. 5) and Josephus ("Ant." ii. 9, § 7), the daughter of Pharaoh formally adopted Moses as her son (Ex. ii. 10).

It should also be pointed that the Biblical Greek did have a word for adoption, It was "huiothesia":

"Adopt/adoption... Greek word huiothesia is found five times in the NT (Ro 8:15, “sonship”; 8:23; 9:4; Gal 4:5, “full rights of sons”; Eph 1:5)” (New International Encyclopedia of Bible Words, by Lawrence O. Richards Th.M. Ph.D. , 1991, p. 20-21)

As we can see from the New Testament usage of the term it entitled the adopted son to to the full rights of a son.   

                             [OBJECTION]  "There is also no Biblical Hebrew word for ‘step-father’."

This point is also mute, the distinction between "father" and "step father"  is a modern one, and did not exist in the ancient Jewish culture at that time. As we have already pointed out, adopted children were considered the same as birth children in every way, including rights of inheritance. With no cultural distinctions being made between the two types of children, it is only natural that the Hebrew had no term for the word "step-father".

[OBJECTION]  “The Aramaic word for ‘Family’ had ‘zera’ at it's root, meaning ‘from the seed of the master of the house'. Hence, 'You shall count the children according to the house of their father' has an important meaning."

This is a very shallow argument, and easily refuted, the primary Hebrew word used in the Old Testament for Family was "Mishpahah" which means:       

"Mishpahah occurs around three hundred times with the primary sense of  'family', 'clan', or 'tribe.” (Expository Dictionary of Bible Words, edited by Stephen D Renn, 2005, p. 365)

A simple examination of the Old Testament text will show that the Hebrew word "Mishpahah" has a very wide meanings, it was used to indicate an entire people or nation (Ezek. 20:32; Mic. 2:3); an ethnic or racial group (Gen. 10:5; 12:3); a tribe (Josh. 7:17; Judg. 13:2; 18:2, 11). It is even used to  identify a  guild of scribes in one verse (1 Chr. 2:55). It can also represent a species or kind of animal (Gen. 8:19). The respected Biblical Scholar Lawrence O. Richards Th.M. Ph.D Explains:

In American culture, the family is increasingly perceived as the nuclear unit of husband and wife and their children. Both mispahah and bayit are terms with much more flexible meaning. Depending on context, a family or household in the OT might be the nuclear family, an extended family of three or more generations plus any servant living with them, or an even wider circle of relatives who trace their family bond back to a common male ancestor. Thus when we read “family’ or “household” in the OT, we need to let the context determine how many persons this very flexible term is intended to include. (New International Encyclopedia of Bible Words, by Lawrence O. Richards Th.M. Ph.D. , 1991, p. 263)

It is clear that the Jewish understanding of Family was not in any way limited to "the seed of the master of the house". the Jews had broad understanding of family which could even include distant relatives and servants. So we can see that this argument also holds not validity.

By the ancient Jewish understanding, Christ could justly trace his genealogy back through St. Joseph, fulfilling the Biblical requirement of the Messiah being of the tribe of Judah and a descendant of David.