![]()
Original Sin: Baptismby David Goldstein LL.D, 1943. A Jewish convert to Catholicism.
Named a "Knight of St. Gregory" by Pope Pius XII in 1955.
Before telling of the happy
ending of the grievous fault of our first parents, it seems advisable to say, what you
very likely know, that much idle talk comes from doubters when discussing original sin.
They want to know "Why did not God make man so he could not be tempted?"
"Why did God make such a vicious creature as a serpent?" "Why do the
innocent have to suffer for the guilt of Adam?" "Why was Adam so severely
punished for merely eating an apple?" All such queries are off the main issue, as God
does what He wills to do, doing all things perfectly, as He is Perfection. His creatures
have no right to question the judgment or justice of the Creator, though they may
speculate about the reason for this, that, and everything else.
It is easy to prove that such querulous interrogators are usually mentally
deficient in things of a religious nature, even the history of them. For instance, they
know not that the Book of Genesis does not say that Adam ate an apple, it is called
"fruit." Hence they may believe that Adam ate an apple, a peach, or a banana, or
any other kind of fruit, even going so far as to say Eve gave Adam a lemon. Moses
emphasized the principle Adam violated rather than the way he did it, for Adam had already
disobeyed God the minute he assented to disobey God's command. The "offense" of
Adam was "disobedience," doing what was positively forbidden, as we are told in
the Epistle to the Romans (5:19). It was "pride" that caused the
disobedience, says Ecclesiasticus (10:14). It was Adam's inordinate ambition to
"be as gods, knowing good and evil" (Gen. 3:5), that caused his
downfall. A tradition in Israel says that "the Torah (the Law given to Moses) was to
be bestowed upon Adam, but he forfeited it through disobedience."
It is a universal religious principle that atonement, reparation for sin,
must be made in accordance with the moral and intellectual status of the person sinning,
the gravity of the offense committed, and the dignity of the person offended. Having that
in mind, let us look at the blessings conferred by God upon Adam, before applying the
principle. His home was the Garden of Paradise; he was given dominion over all animal
creation and natural resources; his mind was illumined with spiritual insight such as no
other man has since possessed, save the God-man, Jesus. Adam was in a state of innocence;
he had complete mastery over his senses; and was free from pain and death. His only
subjection was to the will of God, whose command he was obligated to obey as a condition
of continuing the enjoyment of these sublime gifts.
Adam violated the one command, that he eat not of "the tree of knowledge
of good and evil." He disobeyed, his "eyes were opened," self-consciousness
of sin entered his mind; henceforth he could no longer go about naked like an innocent
child, as shame and terror entered his heart. He brought a curse upon himself and deprived
his descendants of the gifts they would have inherited had their first parents been
obedient.
With all this in mind, just consider the infinite holiness, the great
munificence of the personage Adam offended, the Infinite God. Neither Adam, nor the
holiest of holy men could make adequate atonement for such a gross offense. Someone had to
make amends if ever the supernatural status, God's grace, was to be restored that Adam had
robbed man of by taking what did not belong to him.
Though God punished Adam, He did not end his existence or forsake him. God,
in His infinite mercy, paved the way for the personage who alone could come and atone for
Adam's transgression, when He made the solemn promise that the head of Satan would be
crushed by the "seed of a woman" (Gen. 3:15). That Seed was to be the
Second Adam, who was to make the amends that would restore supernatural life to the soul
that the first Adam had deprived man of through sin. He was to come from the Second Eve,
who, instead of being beguiled into violating the command of God, as was the first Eve,
would triumph over the spiritual enemy by crushing Satan's head. There was only one person
born of the "seed of a woman," as Moses said he would be born, instead of the
seed of man. He is Jesus, the Second Person of the Triune God, the Messiah, the Son of the
Blessed Virgin Mary, who is called the Redeemer because He became a substitutional victim
through whom atonement was to be made for the sin of Adam, and the stain thereof wiped
from the soul of man. He is true God as well as true man.
Thus God alone could and did make an adequate atonement for the sin of Adam;
and thus brought back to man the gift of supernatural life, the grace that alone can give
spiritual life to the soul. Isaiah said that "God himself would come and save
you" (Isa. 35:4). "The Lord Himself shall give you a sign. Behold a
virgin shall bear a son, and his name shall be called Emmanuel, God with us" (Isa.
7:14). Isaiah calls Him "God the Mighty...the Prince of Peace" (Isa.
9:6).
Rabbi S.... was right, "the starting point of Christian belief is
original sin," though he failed to recognize the fact that the end of original sin is
the Messiah, Jesus. St. Augustine said, over fifteen centuries ago, that
"The whole Christian religion may be summed up in the intervention of two men, one (Adam) to ruin us, the other (Jesus) to save us."
Jesus instituted the sacrament of Baptism for
the purpose of washing away the stain of original sin. Jesus came, as he told us,
"that men may have life and have it more abundantly" (St. John 10:10).
The thing "lost" that Jesus promised to restore, sanctifying grace, being as
much needed for supernatural life, union of the soul with God, as natural life is
dependent upon the union of the soul with the body.
Jesus said to you and to me, and to every one else, what He said to
Nicodemus,
"Amen, amen, I say to thee, unless a man be born again of water and the holy spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of heaven" (St. John 3:5).
By natural birth we become children of our
parents; by rebirth through baptism, we become adopted children of God.
While after baptism we are still subject to death, it is the death of the
body, and not the soul; while we are not restored to the Garden of Paradise in
Mesopotamia, the place where Adam is said to have lived until he sinned, the gates of the
Eternal Paradise, that were shut through original sin, were opened for us by Christ
through the sacrament of baptism. Come "put on Christ," says the Church;
"be incorporated into the Body of Christ through baptism."
It ought not to be difficult for religious Jews to accept baptism as a
sacrament. The Abrahamic covenant (which is of the historic past) made the descendants of
Abraham sons of the Covenant, partakers of the Messianic promises, chosen children of God,
through circumcision. In the new Covenant all persons (not merely Jews) are called upon to
become adopted children of God, brothers of Jesus the Messiah, through being baptized. Do
get this point clearly in mind, Catholic theologians hold that the stain of original sin
was washed from the souls of Jews by circumcision, the "laver of blood," but in
expectation, in belief in the coming of the Messiah. The period of expectation ended when
the personage anticipated became a reality, and fulfilled the promises. He, the Messiah,
substituted baptism, the "laver of water," in place of circumcision as a
sacrament. This the Messiah did when He commissioned His Apostles to "Go--and make
disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of
the Holy Spirit" (St. Matt. 28:18).
In conclusion, I want to recall to your mind the part that Elias (Hebrew,
Elijah) plays during the ceremony of circumcision. You know of the special chair that is
reserved for Elias upon which the Sandek (man who holds the child) sits during the
operation, as Elias is assumed to be an invisible participant in the ceremony. I assume
you know that Elias plays the role of forerunner of the Messiah, being so mentioned
frequently in the Jewish liturgy. He was to "appear at any time and from any
parentage."
Elias ceased to be the forerunner of the Messiah when the great personage he
was to precede came in fulfillment of the prophecies. John the Baptist was the Elias in
spirit and power. Elias himself appeared in person, with Moses, at the transfiguration of
the Lord Jesus Messiah. This visible glorification of Jesus took place on Mount Tabor in
Palestine. On that occasion the voice of God was heard, saying,
"This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased, hear Him"
(St. Matt. 17:5-6).
In the presence of Elias with the Messiah, the
Jews of the world were told, inferentially, that they would no longer play the mystical
role of inducting descendants of Israel through the "laver of blood" into the
exclusive sonship of the Abrahamic Covenant. If Elias were on earth today, he would no
doubt re-echo the words of God, intended first for the Jews, "This is the `beloved
Son' of God, `hear Him,' be regenerated through the `laver of water,' listen to your
Messiah, who said, `Amen, amen, unless a man be born again of water and the spirit, he
shall not enter the kingdom of God' (St. John 3:5)."
I hope you will show Rabbi S.... my replies to his statement.
![]()