![]()

It was only the Roman Catholic Church that saved the Protestant truths. It may be right to rest on the Bible, but there would be no Bible if the Gnostics had proved that the Old Testament was written by the Devil, or had littered the world with Apocryphal Gospels. It may be right to say that Jesus alone saves from sin, but nobody would be saying it if a Pelagian movement had altered the whole notion of sin. Even the very selection of dogmas which the reformers decided to preserve had only been preserved for them by the authority which they denied. (G. K. Chesterton, Upon This Rock"
Several days ago I was surfing the net and I came across an article on a page entitled the "Interactive Bible Homepage," the website of a non-denominational church. this list is from Alexander McClure’s book that was published in 1858 titled, “The Translators Revived.”
His article attempts to attack what he terms the "Apocrypha." At first glance, I agreed with him completely. And was rather eager to find out the seven reasons why Apocrypha aren’t inspired.... until I realized that he was referring to the Deuterocanonical books, and not to any "apocrypha."
Before I continue on and refute his "seven reasons why the Apocrypha is not inspired" - and his following statements - I would like to make several overall comments/questions which I’m sure the readers of this article will be very interested in hearing the answer to. I ask the reader to keep the following citation in mind, which is taken from the "Information about who we are," section of their site - point number three in the sub-section entitled "Our Doctrine" -
We are truly a non-denominational church that has no written standard of doctrinal authority other than the Bible. (Emphasis mine)
After reading the above - particularly the emphasized portions - we must ask the author of the article the following questions:
1. Where do you get the authority necessary to decide what books are a part of the Bible, and what books are not?
2. How do you know which book is Biblical, and which book is not?
3. How do we know that you aren’t wrong on this matter?
We wish to place special emphasis on the last question. For a religion which bases its belief system upon the Bible alone, it is essential that they know which books comprise the Bible, and that they aren’t mistaken in the matter. If they can be mistaken in the matter, then their whole religions falls to pieces. What they would then be basing it on is their personal opinions.... period. A very shaky foundation indeed. The parable concerning the man who built his house upon sand - and not upon a rock - certainly applies here.
In order to figure out which books of the Bible are canonical - without violating their professed doctrinal standard (i.e. the Bible alone) - they must have source outside the Bible. If they do, then they violate their own standard of belief (i.e. sola scriptura). If they don’t, then they are following circular logic - i.e. A is true, because B says so... and we know B is true, because A is true - which is a position which is ultimately devoid of logic, understanding, evidence, and so forth.
The same lack of logic is also used in this statement "We know the Bible is true and the Word of God, because it says so." To even the most unlearned of the readers of this article, the ridiculousness of such a statement should be apparent. Using that as a basis for the determination of what is the Word of God, and what is not, we must also accept the Koran, which also states that it is the Word of God - and is very anti-Christian. So clearly we are forced to have recourse to a source extraneous to the Bible alone on this point. The same applies to the determination of which books are canonical, and which books are not.
If the author of this article does have an outside source, then the afore-mentioned author violates his own belief system. If he doesn’t, then truly we must admit that he redundant circular logic spirals into the realm of ridiculousness - and is obviously something that shouldn’t threaten the faith of anyone, much less a Catholic who knows his stuff.
Therefore, the author of the article, if he is to prove anything at all, must prove the Deutero-Canonical books to be "apocryphal" using a source outside the Bible (1). Furthermore, our non-denominational friend must also prove that he has the authority to decide which books are Biblical and which ones are not.... again, extra-biblically. (2)
We shall continue on and refute his "seven reasons why the Apocrypha is not inspired." The first of which reasons the anonymous author gives as follows:
1. Not one of them is in the Hebrew language, which was alone used by the inspired historians and poets of the Old Testament.
In the above statement, I hope that our opponent is acting in good faith and out of ignorance, and that he truly does not know the truth about the books in question. Though in this case, I must then ask him why he has chosen to write an article on a subject which he knows nothing about? If our opponent is acting in bad faith and out of hatred for the Catholic religion, then I must express my disgust with his stooping so low as to publish on the internet (in an attempt to deceive unsuspecting individuals) such lies, and I must also warn him that his place in Hell will grow deeper with every soul that he drags away from the Catholic Church, outside which there is absolutely no salvation for anyone.
Our opponent is easily proven to be wrong. As St. Francis de Sales said in his famous book "The Catholic Controversy":
"I say the same to you about Ecclesiasticus, which S. Jerome had and found in Hebrew, as he says in his preface on the books of Solomon. Since, then, you reject these books written in Hebrew or Chaldaic equally with the others which are not written in one of these languages, you will have to find another pretext than that which you have alleged for striking out these books from the canon." (3)
So do I say to the author of the article in question. You will have to find another pretext for taking these books out of the Canon, for the one which you have used does not justify the removal of several of the deutero-canonical books.
Furthermore, I would like to ask our opponent upon what does he base his assumption that any books of the Old Testament that are not written in Hebrew are not canonical? If he presumes to base his assumption upon a Bible verse, then I must ask him to provide this verse (or verses if there be more than one), that says that any book of the Old Testament which was not written in Hebrew is not canonical.
If our opponent cannot support his position with a verse from the Sacred Scriptures, then he has violated his own belief system and is relying upon an authority outside the Bible. If he can support his position with a verse from the Sacred Scripture, we must ask him to provide us with proof (extra-biblically) that the book which he cites is Sacred Scripture.
The anonymous author continues:
2. Not one of the writers lays any claim to inspiration.
Is it necessary for the author of a book to lay a claim to inspiration in order for the book to be inspired? If this is so, then let our opponent prove this point through the Sacred Scriptures - which he claims to hold as his sole written doctrinal authority. Furthermore, a claim of inspiration is not proof of anything for or against the book. For even the Koran claims to be inspired -- and I don’t know of any Christian who would want to include that in the Bible on that claim.
Lastly, I would like to ask our opponent to show us where the authors of the books of the Old Testament all claimed inspiration in all the books. Chapters and verses will be appreciated.
My opponent continues.
3. These books were never acknowledged as sacred Scriptures by the Jewish Church, and therefore were never sanctioned by our Lord.
As St. Francis de Sales said:
As to your saying that these books which you call apocryphal are not received by the Jew, you say nothing new or important. S. Augustine loudly exclaims: "It is the Catholic Church which holds the Books of Machabees as Canonical, but not the Jews." Thank God, we are not Jews, we are Catholics. Show me from Scripture that the Christian Church has not as much power to give authority to the sacred books as the Mosaic may have had. There is not in this either Scripture or reason to show for it. (4)
So do I again say to my opponent. The Jews also reject the entire New Testament, and yet our opponent does not reject the New Testament on these grounds. My opponent seems to use the opinions of the Jews only where they agree with his opinions - elsewhere he rejects them.
Secondly, I would also like to point out that my opponent’s ignorance on this subject is again shown by his above statement. The Deuterocanonical books - which he pretends are apocryphal - were accepted by quite a few Jews. (5) In fact, the Deuterocanonical books are still accepted by the Jews in Ethiopia today. As the Encyclopedia Judaica says:
"The group of Jews which met at Javneh became the dominant group for later Jewish history, and today most Jews accept the canon of Javneh. However, some Jews, such as those from Ethiopia, follow a different canon which is identical to the Catholic Old Testament and includes the seven Deuterocanonical books " (6)
Hence, it is completely ridiculous for the anonymous author of the article which we are responding to to make the claim that the "Jewish church" rejected the Deuterocanonical books - for 1) there is no such thing as the "Jewish Church," 2) many Jews do accept the Deuterocanonical books.
Thirdly, the Deuterocanonical books were included in the version of the Scriptures used by Christ and the authors of the New Testament, as the following citation from the Encyclopedia Judaica shows:
"There are approximately 350 quotations in the New Testament of the Old Testament. Of these 350 quotations 300 come from the Greek Septuagint. It was the Old Testament Bible of the first century Christians. Jesus quoted from it. The Septuagint included the Deuterocanonical books which Protestants call the ‘Apocrypha.’ The Jews in Ethiopia to this day still follow the same identical canon which is found in the Catholic Old Testament which includes these seven Deuterocanonical books " (7)
The above citation from the Encyclopedia Judaica shows 1) the Septuagint included the Deuterocanonical books, 2) the New Testament used the Septuagint at least 300 times when citing the Old Testament, 3) Christ quoted from the Septuagint. These facts are easily corroborated by numerous other works/authors. As the Rev. Dr. Milo Gates, one-time vicar of the Protestant Episcopal Church of the Intercession, in New York City said in 1928:
"In the second place, no one can really understand the New Testament without knowledge of these books. There are more than 111 quotations and allusions to the Apocrypha in the New Testament.
"In the third place, some of the most blessed doctrines of the Church come from these books, and others we find developing in these books" (8)
That the Deuterocanonical books were included in the Septuagint - and that the Septuagint was used by the authors of the New Testament - can be corroborated through numerous sources, too many to list here in their entirety. (9)
But if our opponent dares to resist this claim that the Septuagint was the version of the Bible used by the New Testament authors and is used today by many Christians (with the exception of the Deuterocanonical books), then let him answer these questions put forth by the famous Catholic apologist David Goldstein:
If the Septuagint version is invalid, then it is up to Protestants to explain why they give Greek Septuagint names instead of Hebrew names, or their English equivalent names to the books of Moses. Why call those books the Pentateuch instead of the Torah or its English designation, Instruction? Why Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers (translation of the Greek Arithmoi), and Deuteronomy? Instead of the Palestinian Hebrew names, Bereshith, Shemoth, Vayikra, Bemidbar, and Debarim? Or their English equivalents, The Beginning, Names, And He Called, In the Wilderness, and Words? Why call the Book "The Bible," which is the Greek (Anglicized) name the Catholic Church gave the Septuagint in union with the New Testament? (10)
After reading the above, I’m sure the reader will agree with me that this - my opponent’s third "reason" for rejecting the DEUTEROCANONICALS - is insufficient, and cannot be his real reason for so doing.
The anonymous author continues
4. They were not allowed a place among the sacred books, during the first four centuries of the Christian Church.
This statement is utterly and completely ridiculous! The fact that they were "allowed a place among the sacred books" is sufficiently shown by the following citations from the Councils of Rome, Carthage, and Hippo:
(Council of Rome [A.D. 382])
"Now indeed we must treat of the divine Scriptures, what the universal Catholic Church accepts and what she ought to shun. The order of the Old Testament begins here: Genesis, one book; Exodus, one book; Leviticus, one book; Numbers, one book; Deuteronomy, one book; Joshua [Son of] Nave, one book; Judges, one book; Ruth, one book; Kings, four books [that is, 1 and 2 Samuel and 1 and 2 Kings]; Paralipomenon [Chronicles], two books; Psalms, one book; Solomon, three books: Proverbs, one book; Ecclesiastes, one book; Canticle of Canticles, one book; likewise Wisdom, one book; Ecclesiasticus, one book . . . . Likewise the order of the historical [books]: Job, one book; Tobit, one book; Esdras, two books [Ezra and Nehemiah]; Esther, one book; Judith, one book; Maccabees, two books" (Decree of Pope Damasus).(Council of Hippo [A.D. 393])"[It has been decided] that besides the canonical Scriptures nothing be read in church under the name of divine Scripture. But the Canonical Scriptures are as follows: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy, Joshua the Son of Nun, Judges, Ruth, the Kings, four books, the Chronicles, two books, Job, the Psalter, the five books of Solomon, the twelve books of the Prophets, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, Tobit, Judith, Esther, Ezra, two books, Maccabees, two books . . ." (canon 36).
(Council of Carthage III [A.D. 397])"[It has been decided] that nothing except the canonical Scriptures should be read in the Church under the name of the divine Scriptures. But the Canonical Scriptures are: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy, Joshua, Judges, Ruth, four books of Kings, Paralipomenon, two books, Job, the Psalter of David, five books of Solomon [Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs, Wisdom, Sirach], twelve books of the Prophets, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, Tobit, Judith, Esther, two books of Esdras, two books of the Maccabees . . ." (canon 47).
All the above Councils occurred before the end of the fourth century. After one reads the above decrees, the ridiculousness of the fourth reason given by my opponent for the rejection of the Deuterocanonical books is simply and utterly ridiculousness. Now it is up to my opponent to show that the above Councils did not have authority equal to that of the Jews when it comes to the question as to which books are a part of the Canon of the Bible.
That the Deuterocanonical books were accepted and cited by the Early Christians is shown by the response made by my opponent the question "Early Christians quote from the apocrypha proves it belongs in the Bible." To cite him:
Early Christians quoted from all kinds of uninspired writings other than the apocrypha. Why do Catholics not include these in their Bible's?????
Aside from the fact that Catholics do not include the Deuterocanonical books in the Bible on the authority of the Early Christians, but on the authority of the Church, my opponent unwittingly shows that the Early Christians did cite them.
St. Clement of Alexandria in the year 202 A.D., cites the book of "Sirach" (21:6) as "Scripture" (11), as well as the book of Tobit (12). While Hippolytus cites the book of Baruch as Scripture (13). Origen defended the canonicity of Susanna [Daniel 13], Bel and the Dragon [Daniel 14], the prayers of Azarias [Daniel 3] and the hymn of praise of the three youths in the fiery furnace [Daniel 3] in his Epistle to Julius Africanus around the year 254. While in the year 248 A.D., Origen cited the book of Sirach 21:28 as Scripture. (14) The following citation from Origen citing the Book of Maccabees as Scripture shows that it was accepted at that time (230 A.D.):
"But that we may believe on the authority of holy Scripture that such is the case, hear how in the book of Maccabees, where the mother of seven martyrs exhorts her son to endure torture, this truth is confirmed; for she says, ' ask of thee, my son, to look at the heaven and the earth, and at all things which are in them, and beholding these, to know that God made all these things when they did not exist.'[2 Maccabees 7:28]", (15)
St. Cyprian in 252-258 A.D., cites the books of Tobit (16), Sirach (17), and the story of the three youths in Daniel 3:37-43 (18), as Scripture several times in his writings. I could easily double or even triple this list of Early Christians who considered the Deuterocanonical books to be Scriptural, but I believe that this, the fourth reason given by the anonymous author of the article in question for rejecting the Deuterocanonical books, is sufficiently refuted by the information given above - and cannot be his real reason for rejecting them. Hence, we are forced to believe one of two things, either 1) he’s completely ignorant of the subject at hand, 2) he is attempting to deceive the readers of his article.
5. They contain fabulous statements, and statements which contradict not only the canonical Scriptures, but themselves; as when, in the two Books of Maccabees, Antiochus Epiphanes is made to die three different deaths in as many different places.
I’ve checked both books, and have only been able to locate one time that Antiochus Epiphanes died . But, as it is, there were several Kings in the Maccabees with the title of "Antiochus." Epiphanes was the fourth one to take the name of Antiochus. Hence, we see another mis-interpretation of Sacred Scripture.
6. The Apocrypha inculcates doctrines at variance with the Bible, such as prayers for the dead and sinless perfection.
Once again the anonymous author is resorting to circular logic in his "arguments." He says, basically, in order for a book to be Canonical and Biblical, all the doctrines that it teaches must be reconcilable with what is taught elsewhere in the Bible... but how does he know that the books he is referring to are canonical? How does he know that any of the books in the Bible are canonical? Especially if he uses his above-given "reason" as a determining factor.
The danger of circular logic, is that it is not founded on the pillar of evidence or truth. The same arguments are to be made against the other books of the Bible. "No, the other books of the Bible are not true because they do not match what Maccabees says." The point is, where is the starting point? There is no pillar of truth to sit on. The same argument can be used against the other books of the Bible. For example, in Joshua 2:4-6 the woman lied in order to save the lives of some scouts which Joshua sent out to find out the "lay of the land." And when Joshua’s army took over the city, all the houses of everyone but the woman were burned. The woman was rewarded for her actions! Whereas we see in Exodus 20:16 that lying is forbidden! Does that mean that we should discard Exodus? Or Joshua? According to the circular logic of the anonymous author, we must discard one or the other. Which one is it to be?
The point is, when an ignorant person (with no exterior source of truth to appeal to) attempts to build up his own religion through reading a book, there are bound to be misunderstandings. For example, in the above-given case concerning the book of Joshua. At first glance, they look contradictory. But upon further though/reading, it becomes apparent that the woman was not being rewarded for lying, but for saving the life of the two scouts. Period. Hence, it wasn’t contradicting the book of Exodus at all. The same applies to the book of Maccabees. The anonymous authors’ alleged "contradictions" are nothing more than the products of - already blatant (19) - ignorance and circular logic.
Furthermore, I ask the reader to note that the anonymous author is rejecting the Deuterocanonical books on his own private interpretation of the remainder of Scripture. In his opinion, the Deuterocanonical books contradict the rest of the Bible. In his opinion, the Deuterocanonical books are apocryphal, and non-canonical. In his opinion, what they teach is false. What we have here, is not fact... it is merely fallible human opinion. Which one is not obligated to accept and abide by - despite the opinion of the anonymous author to the contrary -, and which are not guaranteed to be without error.
7. It teaches immoral practices, such as lying, suicide, assassination and magical incantation.
In 1 Samuel, chapter 28, Saul has recourse to a witch for help, this witch actually brings back the spirit of the prophet Samuel. through the witch, Samuel prophases the death of Saul's two sons, and his defeat hand of the Philistines. Does that mean that the book was teaching "immoral practices," such as as the use of witchcraft and magical incantation? Or how about where Saul killed himself with his own sword in 1 Samuel, chapter 31? The point is, that throughout the Old Testament, immoral practices are to be found. They aren’t to be found in the Deuterocanonical books alone. But, of course, this does not mean that simply because they are in the Bible the books are promoting such practices as suicide, recourse to witches, adultery, and so forth.
The anonymous author continues.
Let us consider while we are at this point, the subject of the Catholic apocrypha,
In the first place, I ask the reader to note that the anonymous author has already assumed that they are apocryphal, assumed that the reader holds that they are apocryphal, and he also assumes that all those who hold the Deuterocanonical books are Catholic. This would include the Early Church Fathers, the Early Church, Christ (who cited from the Septuagint, which contained the Deuterocanonical books), and the Apostles - which certainly leaves our non-denominational friend out in the dark, doesn’t it? :)
for which they make such great claims; and because of which they deny the Bible in common use by most brethren.
In the first place, the Catholic Church does not go to non-Catholic protestant sects to determine what books are Scriptural, and what books are not. The Catholic Church does not choose which Bible they are going to use according to the "common use" by most infidels (i.e. the anonymous author of the article in question and his non-denominational church). God did not establish a democracy, He established a Church. Rules of faith are not determined by a show of hands. Furthermore, the Catholic Church places a greater value upon the accuracy of the texts they use, rather than upon whether or not the non-Catholics use certain texts.
As it is, though, it’s quite obvious that my opponent really doesn’t believe his own arguments. The reason being, because if he did believe that that mattered, then he’d have to accept the Deuterocanonical books, because the majority of Christians hold them as canonical - Catholicism is the largest religion in the world at present... there are more Catholics in the world at present than there are protestants or non-denominationalists.
2 Macc 12:38-46 seems to be the principal reason they cling to the apocrypha. There is no other doctrine that depends so heavily upon support in the apocrypha. If I were not afraid of absolute statements, I would say that their defense of the apocrypha is only because of the passage and their claims about its teachings.
As it is, it’s completely illogical to keep seven books in the Bible for just 8 verses. Why in the world would Catholicism want to keep seven books in the Bible for just 8 verses? Why not just keep 2 Maccabees? Obviously, there are other reasons than the ones proposed by my opponent. And obviously, there are important parts of all seven books - despite what the anonymous author thinks. Furthermore, I would also like to point out that my opponent has assumed that 1) Catholics are dishonest, 2) Catholics are members of a false religion, 3) they are ignorant (in more ways than one - after all, what person with half a brain would hand-copy seven books by candlelight, hunched over a table in cold monastery, for over a thousand years, just for the sake of eight verses in one book?).
The Catholics have 46 Old Testament books rather than the 39 found in our Bibles. However, they have added much more material to other books which does not appear under separate titles. That material follows: The Rest of Esther added to Esther; The Song of the Three Holy Children, The History of Susanna, Bel and the Dragon added to Daniel; Baruch; 1 and 2 Maccabees; Tobias; Judith; Ecclesiasticus; and the Wisdom of Sirach.
The Catholic religion is not in the habit of adding/subtracting books of the Sacred Scriptures (20). Actually... let me correct that. We did add 27 books to the Bible, but that’s the New Testament which were added to the Bible under the authority of the Catholic Church - which, I assume, my opponent accepts since 1) he uses the Catholic name for the Scriptures (i.e. "Bible"), 2) he uses the Catholic system of "Chapter and Verse," 3) he accepts them as being canonical.
The only powerful support for these books is that they appear in the Septuagint version.
This is simply false. The most powerful support (of many) for these books is that they were approved by the most Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church - as were the 27 books of the New Testament. This is the strongest and most powerful proof in their favor. That they were in the Septuagint is secondary. Even if they weren’t in the Septuagint, it wouldn’t matter at all - Holy Mother Church has accepted them and used them for nearly 2,000 years, and that is sufficient for any Christian.
The point is, we are Christians. And as such, who really cares what the post-Christ Jews believe, or what canon they hold? Even my opponent really doesn’t care what they believe, or what canon they hold, or he would be the first one to reject the New Testament - as the Jews still do.
However, in many of our Bibles there is much material that is uninspired, including history, poetry, maps, dictionaries, and other information. This may be the reason for the appearance of this material in the Septuagint. The apocrypha was not in the Hebrew canon.
I agree, that in many of YOUR Bibles there is quite a bit of material that is uninspired, and many changes in Scriptures. But that doesn’t effect the Catholic Bible at all. No portion of the Scripture is fallible, no portion of it is uninspired. Neither the history in it, nor the poetry. It is completely inspired. There are certain portions that have been added by people over time to strengthen their understanding of the Holy Writ, such as the dictionaries, maps, etc. But, as I have shown above, the DEUTEROCANONICALS were not considered books such as dictionaries, maps, and so forth. They were considered Scriptural.
Furthermore, I would like to point out that my opponent uses the term "may," which points to the fact that this is simply his opinion. This is a problem that has been evident throughout my opponent’s article - his opinion is supreme. It is the supreme judge, let nothing contradict his opinion! His opinion is that the DEUTEROCANONICALS are uninspired, his opinion is that the Deuterocanonical books are apocryphal, his opinion is that the Early Christians did not hold them as Scriptural, his opinion is that the Bible is the sole rule of faith, his opinion is that the writings of the Early Christians really don’t matter any way on this subject, his opinion is that the Deuterocanonical books were historical references, his opinion is that their teachings are contrary to the rest of the Bible.
If our opponent is going to hold the opinion that all the above are true, then let him hold it! But let him not attempt to pontificate to others that they are wrong if they don’t agree with his personal speculations and opinions - regardless of what the facts say.
This is the difference between our non-denominational friend and the Catholic Church, we base our Faith upon the Truths taught to the Apostles by Christ, not upon our own, private, fallible, human opinions. In matters of faith, we have absolutely no right to base our faith upon our own personal opinions. And yet, this is simply Protestantism in a nutshell. It is a religion of opinions, period. And "anything goes," including seven books of Sacred Scripture.
There are reputed to be 263 quotations and 370 allusions to the Old Testament in the New Testament and not one of them refers to the Apocryphal
In the first place, even other more honest protestants would dispute this statement. As the above-given citation from Rev. Dr. Milo Gates shows.
In the second place, even if what our opponent said is true - which I do not admit -, it really doesn’t prove a thing. As the following citation says:
Some have sought to determine the Old Testament canon by the usage of the New Testament: A book was canonical if the New Testament quoted it. But the New Testament does not quote some of the canonical books – Ruth, Qoholeth, Esther, Ezra, Nehemiah, Obadiah, Nahum, and the Song of Songs. (Background to the Bible, p. 47)
If this were truly a requirement for the canonicity of the books of the Old Testament, then we have eight more books that we have to throw out - bringing the total up to fifteeen (counting the DEUTEROCANONICALS).
Lastly, I would like to refer my opponent to a listing of citations which are to be found online on the superb site entitled "Traditional Catholic Apologetics." :
As it is, though, it’s quite obvious that this isn’t the real reason why our opponent refuses to believe that the DEUTEROCANONICALS are canonical - if it were, then he would have to discard quite a few more books. This is also proof of the fact that our opponent hasn’t researched this issue... yet again showing that he is completely ignorant of the topic which he presumes to write a (short) article on.
The usual division of the Old Testament by the Jews was a total of 24 books: The Books of Moses (51, The Early prophets 14; Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings ~, The Late Prophets (4; Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, the 12 Minor Prophets), and the Hagiagrapha (11; Psalms, Proverbs, Job, Song of Solomon. Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, Esther, Daniel, Ezra-Nehemiah, and Chronicles i. These 24 books contain all the material in our numbering of 39.
Josephus spoke concerning the canon, but his book division combined Ruth-Judges and Lamentation-Jeremiah for a total of 22 books rather than 24:
As it is, our opponent is mistaken. According to Flavius Josephus, there are only 22 books "which contain the records of all the past times; which are justly believed to be divine;" To cite Josephus:
"For we have not an innumerable multitude of books among us, ... only 22 books. which contain the records of ail the past times; which are justly believed to be divine;...It is true, our history hath been written since Artaxerxes very particularly, but hath not been esteemed of the like authority with the former by our forefathers;...and how firmly we have given credit to these books of our own nation is evident by what we do; for during so many ages as have already passed, no one has been so bold as either to add anything to them, or to make any change in them." (Flavius Josephus Against Apion Book 1, Section 8). (21)
The Jewish division of the Old Testament was 22 books, not the twenty four claimed by my opponent, after Christ - and refuted by one of my opponent’s own citations.
As it is, though, I am still perplexed by my opponent’s fascination with post-Christ Jews, and what canon they cited. As it is, Josephus also denied and rejected the New Testament, most of which had been written by the time the above-cited statement from Josephus was made.
Plainly Josephus distinguishes between those books written before and after Artaxerxes.
It also eliminates the entire New Testament.
This eliminates most of the apocrypha, especially the Maccabees.
I ask the reader to note the anonymous authors’ fascination with the Maccabees. It would seem that his entire article was written against them. He claims that we defend the DEUTEROCANONICALS because they teach praying for the dead... whereas, we see A) one of the reasons he discards these books is because they teach praying for the dead, B) he is particularly vehement against the books which contain this teaching, C) he has not done much research on the subject. One would not be completely wrong if he were to assume that the anonymous author’s primary reason for attacking the "apocrypha" - as he pretends the Deutero-Canonical books are - is that they contain the teaching that it is good to pray for the dead. (22)
The apocrypha itself denies all notion of inspiration. Referring to the events in the Maccabees the author makes these statements:
"...all such things as have been comprised in 5 books by Jason of Cyrene, we have attempted to abridge in one book. For considering the difficulty that they find that desire to undertake the narrations of histories, because of the multitude of the matter, we have taken care for those indeed that are willing to read,...And as to ourselves indeed, in undertaking this work of abridging, we have taken in hand no easy task, yea. rather a business full of watching and sweat. .. Leaving to the authors the exact handling of every particular, and as for ourselves. according to the plan proposed, studying to brief... For to collect all that is known, to put the discourse in order, and curiously to discuss every particular point, is the duty of the author of a history. But to pursue brevity of speech and to avoid nice declarations of things, is to be granted to him that maketh an abridgement." (2 Maccabees 2: 24-32).
If our opponent had actually read the verses which he cited above, he wouldn’t have made such a ridiculous claim. In the first place, the citation doesn’t even mention the word "inspiration." In the second place, as the Haydock Bible says:
No easy task
, &c. The Spirit of God, that assists the sacred penman, does not exempt them from labor in seeking out the matter which they are to treat of, and the order and manner in which they are to deliver it. So S. Luke wrote the gospel, having diligently attained to all things. Lk. i. 3. Ch. – This evangelist had to inquire of others. W. – Inspiration preserves from all danger of mistake. When something future is revealed, there is less difficulty, as God must then dictate the very words. Hence Jeremias wrote with the utmost ease, as Baruch testified. Jer. xxxvi. 18, 32. H. – The prophets had, therefore, only to write or speak from the mouth of God. Others were excited by him to treat of history, &c. and were preserved from error, but not from labor. Bellar. Verb. i. 15. – In vain then do our adversaries attempt to prove that this book is not inspired. M. (Haydock Bible, p. 1205, vol. 1)Just because the book is inspired does not mean that the author is exempt from work. This verse says absolutely nothing about inspiration at all.
The anonymous authors continues and cites 2 Maccabees 15:39-40:
"...I will also here make an end of my narration. Which if I have done well, and as it becometh the history, it is what I desired; but if not so perfectly, it must be pardoned me. For as it is hurtful to drink always wine, or always water, but pleasant to use sometimes the one, and sometimes the other, so if the speech be always nicely framed, it will not be grateful to the readers..." 12 Maccabees 15: 39-40).
This is not said with regard to the truth of the narration, but with regard to the style and manner of writing. As St. Paul said in 2 Corinthians 11:6:
For though I be rude in speech, yet not in knowledge; but in all things, we have been made manifest to you.
This is not a denial of inspiration at all, this is simply a statement to the effect that he is not as polished as some other authors may have been. If it is a denial of inspiration, then let us discard St. Paul’s Second Epistle to the Corinthians as well - in fact, we should discard all of his Epistles for, as he said, he is "rude in speech."
The anonymous author then continues and compares it with two citations from the New Testament (out of 27 books), Matthew 10:19-20, and 1 Corinthians 2:12-13.
After which citations the anonymous author states:
Catholic arguments:
Early Christians quote from the apocrypha proves it belongs in the Bible???
Early Christians quoted from all kinds of uninspired writings other than the apocrypha. Why do Catholics not include these in their Bible's?????
Very simply because we do not accept the Books of the Bible on the authority of the Early Christians, but on the authority of Holy Mother Church. The reason why the Early Christians are frequently cited by Catholic Apologists is because of the fact that they show the continual acceptance of these books throughout the centuries. Furthermore, they also show the fact that protestants (and their non-denominational friends) depart from the constant teaching of Christians.
The apocrypha does not belong in the Bible because It IS not inspired.
In the first place, I would like to point out that my opponent is pontificating in this matter, and has absolutely no authority over the Sacred Scriptures. In the second place, my opponent could not produce one viable argument against the DEUTEROCANONICALS – other than the fact that the DEUTEROCANONICALS contradict his own personal opinion. (23)
In conclusion, I think it is very obvious to the reader that my opponent is 1) ignorant of the subject at hand, 2) willing to deceive the readers of his article in order to further his own personal gains, 3) is completely and utterly anti-Catholic, with no interest or regard for the Truth. 4) My opponent’s principal reason for rejecting the Deutero-Canonical books, is eight verses in one of the books (namely, the second book of Maccabees), which contradict his own personal fallible human opinion.
This article is dedicated to the greater Honor and Glory of God and the Most Holy Mother of the Lord, Our Lady of Victory.
1. No, private "inspirations" of the "spirit" are not consider evidence.
2. For to attempt to do the opposite would be to fall back upon circular logic.
3. The Catholic Controversy, p. 97.
4. The Catholic Controversy, p. 99.
5. Though I would like to point out that it is practically impossible to speak of any "Jewish church" as whole because it is split up into various denominations - as protestantism is.
6. Encyclopedia Judaica, vol. 6, p. 1147
7. Encyclopedia Judaica, vol. 6, p. 1147
8. New York Times, Dec. 10, 1928
9. Cf. Imperial Encyclopedia and Dictionary, Vol. 34. The Pocket Bible Dictionary, 1996. The Century Dictionary and Cyclopedia, 1904. A Dictionary of the Bible, 1954 p.799.
10. What Say You? p. 256-257.
11. The Instructor, I:8
12. The Stromata, 6:12
13. Against the Noetus, 2
14. Against Celsus,7:12
15. Fundamental Principles,2:2
16. Treatise 4,32
17. Treatise 7,9
18. Testimonies, 20. See also Treatise 4,8.
19. As it is, I believe that I have already proven the ignorance of my opponent on the subject at hand, not to mention his own circular logic.
20. Unlike my anonymous opponent, who has subtracted seven books from the Old Testament on the basis of seven reasons that he doesn’t even really believe himself.
21. My opponent has committed a serious error here... he shows 1) his lack of research, 2) his dishonesty, 3) though it is usual for an author to read his own article before publishing it on the net, it would seem that our opponent takes joy at being very "unusual" in his articles.
22. I ask the reader to note that this is the very self-same reason that he claims we have for defending the Deutero-Canonical books.
23. As was stated earlier, our emphasis should be on facts and evidence, and on the Truth, rather than on our own personal fallible human opinion.
![]()