4Unity archive

apolo 114.6

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

"Signs of a Cult"?


      

This article originally written by Greg Durel (found at Reaching Catholics for Christ). It really amounts to nothing more than a pitiful attempt from a apostate to attack Christ's Church.  It was poorly researched, and poorly written, But I felt it was a good opportunity to answer some of the more common Protestant misunderstandings about the Catholic Church.

(Greg Durel) There are about seven principle signs that identify a cult. Now when one hears the word "cult," the first connotation is that of some strange obscure religious group. But for our discussion the word cult is simply a word that describes organized heresy. In other words, any religious group that systematically teaches false doctrine. Knowing some of these signs is key to preventing people from following these cults.

Greg, starts his article by claiming that there are "seven principle signs" to determining if a Religion is a "cult". Interesting enough Greg does not list them for the reader to scrutinize them, instead decides to create his very definition "for our discussion".

Greg has decided to define a the word "cult" as "religious group that systematically teaches false doctrine". The question is "false doctrine" according to who?

From the very beginning this article is built on the personal fault reasoning, first Greg expects the reader to accept his fabricated definition of the word "Cult", and then he requires the reader to let him and his personal privet interpretation determine what is "false doctrine"

This truncated definition of the word "cult" can be described as vague at best. And as we shall see with Greg’s next point it is self-defeating.

(Greg Durel) The sign we will focus on here is the teaching of exclusivity. Cults will declare that they are the only way to heaven. Apart from them there is no salvation. They alone are the repositories of truth and all must join them to be saved.

Lets try to put Greg’s faulty circular argument in perspective, Greg believes that any religious group that teaches doctrines that HE considers "FALSE DOCTRINE" is a cult. Is Greg not really declaring HIS Beliefs "ARE THE ONLY WAY TO HEAVEN."? Does he not want the reader to believe that apart from HIS Privet Interpretation "THERE IS NO SALVATION."? Is he not in essence saying that HIS Interpretation "ALONE ARE THE REPOSITORIES OF TRUTH AND ALL MUST JOIN THEM TO BE SAVED."?

Clearly Greg has caught himself in his own trap, If we accept this apostates truncated definition of a "cult" than we must designate Greg as HIS OWN PERSONAL CULT.

(Greg Durel) To demonstrate that Roman Catholicism bears the mark of a cult is quite easy indeed. If we were left to our opinions and personal interpretations, it might be difficult, but Rome has supplied a mass (no pun intended) of evidence to use. For example:

[
Note here Greg lists six citation from Pope Paul VI... Pope Gregory the Great .....Thomas Aquinas.... Pope Boniface VIII..... Pope Pius IX....Vatican II, do to the fact that they are not need we have deleted them]

We heartily, admit to the fact that the Catholic Church has always taught that she alone is the true church that Christ founded, and her doctrines alone to be the teachings of Christ. First it is important to understand that the Catholic teaching of "Outside the Church there is no salvation" does not imply that all non-Catholics are going to hell. We believe that the Catholic Church is the one society for 'Man's salvation instituted by Christ, and that, therefore, man must be affiliated with her in some way to be saved. That is what St. Cyprian meant when he said: "No one can have God for his Father, who has not the Church for his mother" (On the Unity of the Church, 6). But many souls, apparently outside the Church, are really within her fold in the sight of God. While not united with her in fact, they are in communion with her in desire.

The Church has always taught that no one is lost except through his own fault; that no one is held responsible by God for a duty that he cannot fulfill because of his invincible ignorance. How could God condemn a man for not entering a Church of whose very existence he is ignorant? Pope Pius IX states the Catholic doctrine clearly: "Far be it from us to dare set bounds to the boundless mercy of God; far be it from us to desire to search into the depths of the hidden counsels and judgments of God, an abyss that the mind of man cannot explore.... We must hold as of faith, that out of the Apogtolic Roman Church (here is no salvation; that she is the only ark of safety, and whosoever is not in her perishes in the deluge; we must also, on the other hand, recognize with certainty that those who are in invincible ignorance of the true religion are not guilty for this in the eye of the Lord. And who will presume to mark out the limits of this ignorance according to the character and diversity of peoples, countries, minds and the rest" (Allocution, December 9, 1854).

In his Encyclical to the Italian Bishops, August 10, 1863, he writes : "It is known to us and to you that those who are in invincible ignorance of our most holy religion, but who observe carefully the natural law, and the precepts graven by God upon the hearts of all men, and who being disposed to obey God lead an honest and upright life, may, aided by the light of divine grace, attain to eternal life; for God who sees clearly, searches and knows the heart, the disposition, the thoughts and inten_tions of each, in His supreme mercy and goodness by no means permits that anyone suffer eternal punishment, who has not of his own free will fallen into sin."

Intelligent non-Catholics have often recognized the bound_less charity of the Catholic Church, which condemns only those who freely and deliberately sin against the light. Mallock writes: "Never was there a religious body, except the Roman, that laid the intense stress she does on all her dogmatic teachings, and had yet the justice that comes of sympathy for those who cannot receive them.... The holy and humble of heart who do not know her, or who in good faith reject her, she commits with confidence to God's uncovenanted mercies; and these she knows are infinite. . Her anathemas are on none but those who reject her with their eyes open; by tampering with a conviction that she is really the truth. These are condemned, not for seeing that the teacher is true, but because, having really seen this, they continue to close their eyes to it (Is Life Worth Living?, ch. xi., 283_285).

Second, Does the teaching of "Outside the Church there is no salvation" make the Catholic Church a "Cult"? The answer is "NO".

Heresy and heretics have always been rejected by true Christianity. The coming of heretics among the budding Christian Church was clearly foretold by Christ, Matt., xxiv, 11, 23_26: " . . . many false prophets shall rise. and shall seduce many. . . . Then if any man shall say to you: Lo here is Christ, or there, do not believe him. For there shall rise false christs and false prophets, and shall show great signs and wonders, insomuch as to deceive (if possible) even the elect. Behold I have told it to you, beforehand. If therefore they shall say to you: Behold he is in the desert, go ye not out: Behold he is in the closets, believe it not. ".

Christ also indicated the marks by which to know the false prophets: "Who is not with me is against me" (Luke, xi, 23); "and if he will not hear the Church let him be to thee as the heathen and the publican" (Matt., xviii, 17); "he that believeth not shall be condemned" (Mark, xvi, 16). The Apostles acted upon their Master's directions. All the weight of their own Divine faith and mission is brought to bear upon innovators. "If any one", says St. Paul, "preach to you a gospel, besides that you have received, let him be anathema" (Gal., i, 9). To St. John the heretic is a seducer, an anti-Christ, a man who dissolves Christ (I John, iv, 3; II John, 7); "receive him not into the house nor say to him, God speed you" (II John, 10). St. Peter, true to his office and to his impetuous nature, assails them as with a two-edged sword: " . . . lying teachers who shall bring in sects of perdition, and deny the Lord who bought them: bringing upon themselves swift destruction . . . These are fountains without water, and clouds tossed with whirlwinds, to whom the mist of darkness is reserved" (II Pet., ii, 1, 17). St. Jude speaks in a similar strain throughout his whole epistle. St. Paul admonishes the disturbers of the unity of faith at Corinth that "the weapons of our warfare . . . are mighty to God unto the pulling down of fortifications, destroying counsels, and every height that exalteth itself against the knowledge of God . . . and having in readiness to revenge all disobedience" (II Cor., x, 4, 5, 6).

What Paul did at Corinth he enjoins to be done by every bishop in his own church. Thus Timothy is instructed to "war in them a good warfare, having faith and a good conscience, which some rejecting have made shipwreck concerning the faith. Of whom is Hymeneus and Alexander, whom I have delivered up to Satan, that they may learn not to blaspheme" (I Tim., i, 18_20). He exhorts the ancients of the Church at Ephesus to "take heed to yourselves, and to the whole flock, wherein the Holy Ghost hath placed you bishops, to rule the Church of God, . . . I know that, after my departure, ravening wolves will enter in among you, not sparing the flock . . . Therefore watch, . . ." (Acts, xx. 28, 29, :31). "Beware of dogs", he writes to the Philippians (iii, 2), the dogs being the same false teachers as the "ravening wolves".

The practice of Excommunicating [I.E temporarily or permanently excluding someone from the church as punishment for sin or apostasy] these heretics from the true believers can even be found in the Old Testament. In the O.T. excommunication came as a curse from God as punishment for sin (Deut. 27:26; 28:15; Ps. 119:21; Mal. 2:2_9; 4:6). The Jewish community assumed authority to curse on God's behalf (Num. 23:8; Isa. 66:5). Old Testament terms for excommunication include: Karath, to be excluded or cut off (Ex. 12:15, 19; Lev. 17:4, 9); cherem, banish, devote, or put to destruction (Ex. 22:19; Lev. 27:28_29; Josh. 6:17); and gelalah, desolation or thing of horror (2 Kings 22:19; Jer. 25:18). The covenant community protected itself from curse and temptation by distancing covenant-breakers from the community even to the point of executing them. New Testament Expulsion from the synagogue was one form of New Testament excommunication. Christians were frequently subject to expulsion, which was punishment for blasphemy or for straying from the tradition of Moses (Luke 6:22; John 9:22; 12:42; 16:2). Many early Christians thus endured excommunication from the worship place of their fathers to be Christians.

In the New Testament the apostles practiced excommunication based on the binding and loosing authority Jesus gave to them (John 20:23; Matt. 18:18). See Binding and Loosing. They excommunicated church members for heresy (Gal. 1:8) for gross, deliberate sin (1 Cor. 5; 2 John 7) and perhaps for falling away from church belief and practice (Heb. 6:4_8). The purpose was to purify the church and to encourage offenders to repent (I Cor. 5:5_6; 2 Cor. 2:6_10; 2 Thess. 3:15). Punishment ranged in scope from limited ostracism to permanent exclusion and may even have included some form of physical punishment if the church continued synagogue practice (Luke 4:28_30; John 8:2_11; Acts 5:1_5; 7:58). New Testament terms for excommunication include: being delivered to Satan (I Cor. 5:5; I Tim. 1:20); anathema or cursed and cut off from God (Rom. 9:3; 1 Cor. 16:22; Gal. 1:8). The New Testament churches apparently used excommunication as a means of redemptive discipline.

A study of the writings of the Church Fathers show that the Early Christian Church had no more leniency on these perverters of the faith than the Apostles did. A Protestant writer thus sketches their teaching (Schaff_Herzog, s. v. Heresy): "Polycarp regarded Marcion as the first-born of the Devil. Ignatius sees in heretics poisonous plants, or animals in human form. Justin and Tertullian condemn their errors as inspirations of the Evil One; Theophilus compares them to barren and rocky islands on which ships are wrecked; and Origen says, that as pirates place lights on cliffs to allure and destroy vessels in quest of refuge, so the Prince of this world lights the fires of false knowledge in order to destroy men. [Jerome calls the congregations of the heretics synagogues of Satan (Ep. 123), and says their communion is to be avoided like that of vipers and scorpions (Ep. 130).]" These primitive views on heresy have been faithfully transmitted and acted on by the Church in subsequent ages. There is no break in the tradition from St. Peter to the present Pope.

(Greg Durel) This is classic cult mentality

.

If so than Greg must consider the early Church and the Apostles members of a cult.

(Greg Durel) The organization becomes the focus and the savior.

Anybody who has studied the Mass of the Catholic Church, would understand that Christ is the focus of our worship and our savior. A simple examination of the New Testament would demonstrates that Christ chose the church [IE. The Catholic Church] to protect and promulgate his teachings.

( Greg Durel) Allow us to clearly illustrate this fact. In a recent debate with a Jesuit theologian, we were able to ask a very simple yet extremely important question. The question was "what do we have to do to go to heaven?" The Jesuit theologian said to go to heaven we must "do" several things. Firstly, believe the entire Bible. (Sounds like a fundamentalist.)

What can Greg find so unacceptable about this first point? In order to have a faith in Christ you must accept all that he taught, and all that was taught about him. St. Paul says we are required to "STAND FAST, AND HOLD the traditions which YE HAVE BEEN TAUGHT, whether BY WORD, OR OUR EPISTLE." (2 Thes. 2:15), So we can see that we are not only required to "

believe the entire Bible" but we must hold fast to this written sacred word,

(Greg Durel) Secondly, we must be baptized in water

.

When the Apostles were asked by the crowd at Pentecost, what must be done in order to gain the salvation of Christ which St. Peter had preached, what was St. Peters reply:

"Peter said unto them, Repent, and BE BAPTIZED EVERY ONE OF YOU IN THE NAME OF JESUS CHRIST FOR THE REMISSION OF SINS, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost." (Acts 2:38)

Clearly St Peter held Baptism a requirement of salvation.

(Greg Durel) Thirdly, we must keep the commandments.

Did not Christ himself say:

"And he said unto him, Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God: but IF THOU WILT ENTER INTO LIFE, KEEP THE COMMANDMENTS." (Matthew 19:17)

(Greg Durel) Fourthly, we must eat His flesh and drink His blood literally (in the sacrament of the mass). He mentioned a couple of others, but these four should suffice.

Again we turn to the sacred inspired scriptures and the very words of Christ:

"Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, EXCEPT YE EAT THE FLESH OF THE SON OF MAN, AND DRINK HIS BLOOD, YE HAVE NO LIFE IN YOU. WHOSO EATETH MY FLESH, AND DRINKETH MY BLOOD, HATH ETERNAL LIFE; AND I WILL RAISE HIM UP AT THE LAST DAY. For my flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. HE THAT EATETH MY FLESH, AND DRINKETH MY BLOOD, DWELLETH IN ME, AND I IN HIM." (John 6:53-56)

(Greg Durel) The Scripture clearly reveals to one and all that salvation comes from believing in the Lord Jesus Christ alone. (Cf. Acts 16:30-31; Eph. 2:8-9; Titus 3:5)

If "

believing" were in it self sufficient for salvation than the devils would be among the saved, for does not St. James tell us that the devil also believe in God:

"Thou believest that there is one God. Thou dost well: THE DEVILS ALSO BELIEVE AND TREMBLE."(James.2:19).

While it is true that salvation comes from faith in the Lord Jesus Christ. If you Truly believe in Christ and place you faith in him [as we all should] that you will accept and follow his teaching, and live your life accordingly. It is for this reason that St. James tells us:

But wilt thou know, O vain man, that FAITH WITHOUT WORKS IS DEAD? Was not Abraham our father justified by works, offering up Isaac his son upon the altar? SEEST THOU THAT FAITH DID COOPERATE WITH HIS WORKS AND BY WORKS FAITH WAS MADE PERFECT? ...And the scripture was fulfilled, saying: Abraham believed God, and it was reputed to him to justice, and he was called the friend of God...DO YOU SEE THAT BY WORKS A MAN IS JUSTIFIED, AND NOT BY FAITH ONLY?...For even as the body without the spirit is dead: SO ALSO FAITH WITHOUT WORKS IS DEAD." (James.2:20-26)

(Greg Durel) The entire book of Galatians was written to demonstrate the futility of believing that the Law justifies or saves anyone.

Greg has mis-applied these verse, the "

Law" that St. Paul was discussing in the Epistle to the Galatians was that of the old Jewish covenant, this does not apply to the requirements taught by Christ or the apostles.

(Greg Durel) But the "eating" and "drinking" the literal flesh and blood of the Lord Jesus Christ says it all.

Yes It does say it all, if you have faith enough to accept and believe the very words of Christ himself (John 6:53-56), which apparently Greg does not.

(Greg Durel) We commend to your reading Hebrews 7, 8, 9 and 10. The mysticism is clearly not biblical and certainly not necessary for anyone to be saved.

The Catholic Church does not teach or hold any form of "

mysticism", so this point is not only irrelevant but again shows Greg’s ignorance of the Catholic faith.

(Greg Durel) Their insistence on such heresies places them at the top of the list of religious cults

.

What heresies? What biblical or logical arguments has Greg provided? The answer to both of these questions is "NONE". Greg seems to think that the reader will consider these scriptural Based Catholic beliefs as heretical simple because HE said so, not because he has provided any form of reasoning, to support his Anti-Catholic position.

(Greg Durel) That statement may seem a bit harsh, but it is nonetheless true. Catholicism does not differ from any of the cults where our first sign is concerned.

This statement is exactly what we would expect from a disgruntled apostate such as Greg, who seems bent on trying to easing his own mind by attacking the beliefs of those who are still faithful to Christ’s Church.