4Unity archive

apolo 141

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

The Codex Sinaiticus Was Stolen

Sinai monks say the Bible was stolen and demand oldest Bible back from the The British Library

From the "The Sunday Times," February 20, 2000 By Richard Brooks and Senay Boztas


 
     

"The British Library is under pressure to return one of its most prized possessions to a Middle Eastern monastery supported by the Prince of Wales.

St Catherine's monastery in Egypt, whose patron is the prince, is demanding the return of a 'priceless' 4th-century Bible. Known as the Codex Sinaiticus, it is the world's oldest existing New Testament. 'It belongs to us,' said Father John of the monastery, which is in the foothills of Mount Sinai. St Catherine's has submitted a formal request for the Bible's return.

The prince visited the monastery in 1995 and the following year became patron of St Catherine's Foundation. He has long been interested in eastern Christianity and is a close friend of the composer Sir John Tavener, who is a convert to Greek Orthodoxy. Charles has also expressed private support for the return of the Elgin Marbles to Greece, as did President Clinton last autumn. 'The prince has been a great help in what we're doing,' said Demitri Dondos, one of the monastery's London-based trustees. Both St Catherine's Foundation and St James's Palace said the prince's views about the Codex were private.

The monks claim that the Bible was stolen about a century ago by a German scholar, Count Tischendorf, and was later seized by the Russian royal family. In the 1930s, Stalin sold the Bible to the British Museum. The codex was moved a couple of years ago to the British Library.

Written on parchment, it now resides in the Ritblat Gallery, which also houses the Magna Carta and the Tyndale Bible, which dates from 1525. Michele Brown, the library's curator of medieval and liturgical manuscripts, argues that the Codex Sinaiticus belongs to the nation, having been 'bought', and that it should stay where it is well looked after.

The call for the return of the codex will be examined by the House of Commons culture committee, which next month looks into the restitution of displaced works of art. The most emotive issue remains the Elgin Marbles, but the Labour MP Gerald Kaufman, the committee's chairman, emphasises that its remit will be much wider. Many objects came into British museums in the 19th or the first half of the 20th century in circumstances which would not be tolerated today. But the museums argue that they look after the objects extremely well and legally own them.

'That may be the case, but Britain would be in a better ethical position to defend its right to retain items if the government was seen doing something about antiquity theft,' said Lord Renfrew, professor of history at Cambridge University. Additional reporting: Steve Negus, Cairo"