4Unity archive

apolo 15

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

The Early Church and the Bible

"The idea of a complete and clear-cut canon of the New Testament existing from the beginning, that is from Apostolic times, has no foundation in history. The Canon of the New Testament, like that of the Old, is the result of a development, of a process at once stimulated by disputes with doubters, both within and without the Church, and retarded by certain obscurities and natural hesitations, and which did not reach its final term until the dogmatic definition of the Tridentine Council." (The Catholic Encyclopedia 1913)

    The Early Christians of the 1nd through the 4th centuries Had no definite Canon of The New Testament and there was a lot of confusion as to which books were truly sacred and scripture. It was not until St. Athanasius, a Catholic Bishop, assisted by the great Bible Scholar St. Jerome [Translator of the Catholic Latin Vulgate], came along that work towards forming a definite Canon for the New Testament was begun. The Canon of the Old Testament  the Church had already been established in the early church. The early Christians unanimously used the Septuagint (translated in Alexandria by a group of 70 Hebrew scholars, around the year 200 B.C.).

"The language of much of the early Christian church was Greek, and it was in the Septuagint text that many early Christians located the prophecies they claimed were fulfilled by Christ. Jews considered this a misuse of Holy Scripture, and they stopped using the Septuagint. Its subsequent history lies within the Christian church."(The encyclopedia Britannica 1999)

    The creation of the new Testament Canon was a slowing gradual process which took place over three centuries   most Bible scholars and historians agree that  the 27 books of the New Testament were written between AD 50 and 150 concerning matters of belief and practice in Christian communities. It is likely that many or all of the documents were written in Greek; however, translations into other languages existed as early as the 2nd century. So it is safe to say that there was no possible way further to have been a cannon of the new Testament in the first century.

The earliest attempt to establish a New Testament canon was made about 150 by a heretical Christian named Marcion. By 200, 20 of the 27 books of the New Testament were likely regarded as authoritative. In 367 the 27 books that now constitute the New Testament were determined (The Encarta Concise Encyclopedia 1999)

Late 2nd Century Canons

    By the end of the 2nd century, Irenaeus used the four canonical Gospels, 13 letters of Paul, I Peter, I and II John, Revelation, Shepherd of Hermas (a work later excluded from the canon), and Acts. Justin Martyr (died c. 165), a Christian apologist, wrote of the reading of the Gospels, "the memoirs of the Apostles," in the services, in which they were the basis for sermons. In his writings he quoted freely from the Gospels, Hebrews, thejeromegif.gif (31329 bytes) Pauline Letters, I Peter, and Acts. Justin's Syrian pupil, Tatian (c. 160), although he quotes from John separately, is best known for his Diatessaron (literally, "through four" [gospels], but also a musicological term meaning "choral" "harmony"), which was a life of Christ compiled from all four Gospels but based on the outline and structure of John. This indicates both that Tatian was aware of four gospel traditions and that their canonically was not fixed in final form at his time in Syria. Although Tatian was later declared a heretic, the Diatessaron was used until the 5th century and influenced the Western Church even after four separated gospels were established.

    The first clear witness to a catalog of authoritative New Testament writings is found in the so-called Muratorian Canon, a crude and uncultured Latin 8th-century manuscript translated from a Greek list written in Rome c. 170-180, named for its modern discoverer and publisher Lodovica Antonio Muratori (1672-1750). Though the first lines are lost, Luke is referred to as "the third book of the Gospel," and the canon thus contains [Matthew, Mark] Luke, John, Acts, 13 Pauline letters, Jude, two letters of John, and Revelation. Concerning the Apocalypse of Peter, it notes that it may be read, although some persons object; it rejects the Shepherd of Hermas as having been written only recently in Rome and lacking connection with the apostolic age. The Wisdom of Solomon (a Jewish intertestamental writing), is included in the accepted works as written in Solomon's honor.

    Some principles for determining the criteria of canonicity begin to be apparent: apostolicity, true doctrine (regula fidei), and widespread geographical usage. Such principles are indicated by Muratori's argument that the Pauline Letters are canonical and universal--the Word of God for the whole church--although they are addressed to specific churches, on the analogy of the letters to the seven churches in Revelation; in a prophetic statement to the whole church, seven specific churches are addressed, then the specific letters of Paul can be read for all. Thus, the catholic status of the Pauline letters to seven churches is vindicated on the basis of the revelation of Jesus Christ to John, the seer and writer of Revelation. Wide usage in the church is indicated in calling Acts the Acts of all the Apostles and in the intention of the "general address"--e.g., "To those who are called," in Jude--of the Catholic (or general) Letters--i.e., I and II Peter, I, II, and III John, James, and Jude. The criterion of accordance with received teaching is plain in the rejection of heretical writings. The Muratorian Canon itself may have been, in part, a response to Macron's heretical and reductive canon.

    The criteria of true doctrine, usage, and apostolicity all taken together must be satisfied, then, in order that a book be judged canonical. Thus, even though the Shepherd of Hermas, the First Letter of Clement, and the Didache may have been widely used and contain true doctrines, they were not canonical because they were not apostolic nor connected to the apostolic age, or they were local writings without support in many areas.

    During the time of the definitive formation of the canon in the 2nd century, apparent differences existed in the Western churches (centered in or in close contact with Rome) and those of the East (as in Alexandria and Asia Minor). It is not surprising that the Roman Muratorian Canon omitted Hebrews and accepted and held Revelation in high esteem, for Hebrews allows for no repentance for the baptized Christian who commits apostasy (rejection of faith), a problem in the Western Church when it was subjected to persecution. In the East, on the other hand, there was a dogmatic resistance to the teaching of a 1,000-year reign of the Messiah before the end time--i.e., chiliasm, or millenarianism--in Revelation. There was also a difference in the acceptance of Acts and the Catholic Letters. With the continued expansion of the church, particularly in the 2nd century, consolidation was necessary.

Canonical Standards of the 3rd and 4th Centuries

    Clement of Alexandria, a theologian who flourished in the late 2nd century, seemed to be practically unconcerned about canonicity. To him, inspiration is what mattered, and he made use of the Gospel of the Hebrews, the Gospel of the Egyptians, the Letter of Barnabas, the Didache, and other extracanonical works. Origen (died c. 254), Clement's pupil and one of the greatest thinkers of the early church, distinguished at least three classes of writings, basing his judgment on majority usage in places that he had visited: (1) homologoumena or anantirrheta, "undisputed in the churches of God throughout the whole world" (the four Gospels, 13 Pauline Letters, I Peter, I John, Acts, and Revelation); (2) amphiballomena, "disputed" (II Peter, II and III John, Hebrews, James, and Jude); and (3) notha, "spurious" (Gospel of the Egyptians, Thomas, and others). He used the term "scripture" (graphe) for the Didache, the Letter of Barnabas, and the Shepherd of Hermas, but did not consider them canonical. Eusebius shows the situation in the early 4th century. Universally accepted are: the four Gospels, Acts, 14 Pauline Letters (including Hebrews), I John, and I Peter. The disputed writings are of two kinds: (1) those known and accepted by many (James, Jude, II Peter, II and III John, and (2) those called "spurious" but not "foul and impious" (Acts of Paul, Shepherd of Hermas, Apocalypse of Peter, Letter of Barnabas, Didache and possibly the Gospel of the Hebrews); finally there are the heretically spurious (e.g., Gospel of Peter, Acts of John). Revelation is listed both as fully accepted ("if permissible") and as spurious but not impious. It is important that Eusebius feels free to make authoritative use of the disputed writings. Thus canon and authoritative revelation are not yet the same thing.

Determination of the canon in the 4th century

Athanasius, a 4th-century Catholic bishop of Alexandria and a significant theologian, delimited the canon and settled the strife between East and West. On a principle of inclusiveness, both Revelation and Hebrews (as part of the Pauline corpus) were accepted. The 27 books of the New Testament--and they only--were declared canonical. In the Greek churches there was still controversy about Revelation, but in the Latin Church, under the influence of Jerome, Athanasius' decision was accepted and confirmed at the Council of Hippo.

The following is a citation from the Catholic Encyclopedia 1913 on the Canon of the Sacred Scripture, and where/when it was formulated into a definite Canon by the Catholic Church. As the following citation from the Catholic Encyclopedia points out, it was not until the [Catholic] Synod of Hippo that the suggested Canon of Saints Athanasius and Jerome was officially accepted by Holy Mother Church, this was also confirmed at the Council of Hippo, and several of the [Catholic] Carthaginian Councils in the late 4th century and early 5th.

"It was some little time before the African Church perfectly adjusted its New Testament to the Damasan Canon. Optatus of Mileve (370-85) does not used Hebrews. St. Augustine, while himself receiving the integral Canon, acknowledged that many contested this Epistle. But in the Synod of Hippo (393) the great Doctor's view prevailed, and the correct Canon was adopted. However, it is evident that it found many opponents in Africa, since three councils there at brief intervals--Hippo, Carthage, in 393; Third of Carthage in 397; Carthage in 419--found it necessary to formulate catalogues. The introduction of Hebrews was an especial crux, and a reflection of this is found in the first Carthage list, where the much vexed Epistle, though styled of St. Paul, is still numbered separately from the time-consecrated group of thirteen. The catalogues of Hippo and Carthage are identical with the Catholic Canon of the present. In Gaul some doubts lingered for a time, as we find Pope Innocent I, in 405, sending a list of the Sacred Books to one of its bishops, Exsuperius of Toulouse."(The Catholic Encyclopedia 1913)

This Council of Hippo was composed of 43 Bishops of the Catholic Church, including St. Augustine, Bishop of Hippo. They decided, for instance, that 27 of the manuscripts, which formed the New Testament were Divinely inspired writings. This Canon of Holy Scripture was submitted by the Council to the Bishop of Rome, the Pope, for confirmation, as the Bishops recognized, as do Catholics today, that supreme Christian authority centers in the occupant of the Chair of Peter, that was instituted by Christ.

Apocryphal New Testament Books

As it is, it’s really quite ridiculous for Protestants to hold to some theory, such as the following:

"The New Testament Canon was established, exactly like the Old, was accepted and recognized by a consensus of the believers as it was being written is clear from the historic evidence."

This is incorrect. As it is, there were numerous apocryphal "gospels," "epistles," "acts," "apocalypses," etc., floating around. As the I pointed out above, there was a large amount of confusion with regards to which books were canonical, or even written by the authors whose names they bear.  the new Testament Canon was established by the consensus and authorities of the Roman Catholic Church

"Apocryphal New Testament, title that refers to more than 100 books written by Christian authors between the 2nd and 4th centuries. The books have two characteristics in common: (1) In general form they resemble New Testament writings (see Bible); (2) they belong neither to the New Testament canon nor to the writings of the recognized Fathers of the Church. These books were written for a variety of reasons, including for use by sects such as the Gnostics" (The Encarta Concise Encyclopedia 1999)

The fact that the "Gnostics or Carpocratians" Followers of Carpoerates, an Alexandrian philosopher, who flourished during the reign of the Emperor Hadrian (117-138). The Carpocratians held that everyone has two souls; believed in the transmigration of souls; maintained that the world was created by angels; denied the divinity of Christ, and advocated the practice of immorality as a means of union with God.  Carpoerates also held the believe that the old Testament was written by the Devil

"It was only the Roman Catholic Church that saved the Protestant truths. It may be right to rest on the Bible, but there would be no Bible if the Gnostics had proved that the Old Testament was written by the Devil, or had succeeded lettering the world with Apocryphal Gospels"(UPON THIS ROCK by G.K. Chesterton)

attempted to discredit the true Scriptures by pointing out the fact that the world was, indeed, littered with apocryphal books. For some examples of the TRULY Apocryphal works that proliferated among the early centuries, permit me to list a few:

Apocryphal New Testament Acts.

The Acts of Andrew, The Acts and Martyrdom of Andrew, The Acts of Andrew and Matthew, The Acts of Barnabas, Martyrdom of Bartholomew, The Acts of John, The Mystery of the Cross-Excerpt from the Acts of John, The Acts of John the Theologian, The History of Joseph the Carpenter, The Book of John Concerning the Death of Mary, The Passing of Mary, The Acts and Martyrdom of Matthew, The Martyrdom of Matthew, The Acts of Paul, The Acts of Paul and Thecla, The Acts of Peter, The Acts of Peter and Andrew, The Acts of Peter and Paul, The Acts of Peter and the Twelve Apostles, The Acts of Philip, The Report of Pontius Pilate to Tiberius, The Giving Up of Pontius Pilate, The Death of Pilate, The Acts of Thaddaeus,The Acts of Thomas, The Book of Thomas the Contender, The Consummation of Thomas

Apocryphal New Testament Gospels.

The Infancy Gospel of Thomas [Greek Text ], The Infancy Gospel of Thomas [Latin Text], A 5th Century Compilation of the Thomas Texts, An Arabic Infancy Gospel, The Gospel of James, The Gospel of the Nativity of Mary, The Gospel of Mary [Magdalene], The Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew, The Gospel of Nicodemus [Acts of Pilate], The Gospel of Bartholomew, The Gospel of Peter, The Gospel of Thomas, The Gospel of Philip, The Gospel of the Lord [by Marcion], The Secret Gospel of Mark

Apocryphal New Testament Apocalypse.

The Apocalypse of Adam, The Revelation of Esdras, The First Apocalypse of James, The Second Apocalypse of James, The Revelation of John the Theologian, The Revelation of Moses,The Apocalypse of Paul, Fragments-The Apocalypse of Paul,The Revelation of Paul,The Apocalypse of Peter, The Vision of Paul, The Revelation of Peter, Fragments-The Apocalypse of Peter, The Apocalypse of Sedrach, The Revelation of Stephen, The Apocalypse of Thomas,The Apocalypse of the Virgin

Of course, the True Church (which was founded upon Peter [Matt. 16:18-19), knew the difference between the false texts and the true Scriptures. Which is precisely why St. Augustine(354-430) said the following:

"I would not believe in the Gospel if the authority of the Catholic Church did not move me to do so." (St. Augustine, Conra Epist. Fundam. i,6)

    Of course, before the Canon was determined the Gospel was indeed preached, and quoted. We can study the quotations from the Gospels in the writings of the early church fathers I will mention here the number of quotations made by only a few of these writers :

Irenaeus (died 202 A.D.) quotes the Gospels 1038 times and Acts 194 times.

Clement of Alexandria (died 217 A.D.) quotes the Gospels 1017 times and Acts 44 times.

Origen (died 254 A.D.) quotes the Gospels 9231 times and Acts 349 times.

Tertullian (died 220 A.D.)quotes the Gospels 3822 times and Acts 502 times.

Justin the Martyr (died 150 A.D.) quotes the Gospels 268 times and Acts 10 times.

    But, unfortunately, so were the many false "gospels," (and so for) and it is for this reason that the Catholic Church set to work determining which "gospels" were apocryphal, and which were not, in order to eliminate this confusion. Hence, we now have the 27 books of the Canon known as the New Testament accepted and used by every "Christian" religion. thanks to the Catholic Church, and no thanks to the 20,000 Protestants Sects and denominations.