4Unity archive

apolo 153

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

Why isn't the Eastern Orthodoxy the Whore?


      

First I would like to state that I'm not accusing the Eastern Orthodox, It is instead to illustrate the odd double-think of many anti-Catholics who charge that the Catholic Church is the Whore of Babylon. There is some misportrayal here, but it is in minimal areas and in no way way compares to the horrendous caricature of historic Christianity as portrayed by Protestants on this board. All this is designed to show is that the identity of the Whore of Babylon is not as clear-cut as many anti-Catholics would like to think.

Looking over and over the anti-Catholic proofs on this subject, it strikes me that the anti-Catholic first comes to a conclusion (that the Catholic Church is evil/the Whore) and then searches for evidence to support it. This search is rather selective in nature and covers only the evidence that the anti-Catholic wants to see. In doing so, they ignore the following.

The first is that the Eastern Orthodox Church believes in the following:

- transubstantiation
- the function of the priest as an alter Christus
- purification after death prior to entering heaven ("the tolling houses")
- Sacred Tradition
- Communion of the Saints
- Veneration of Mary
- Seven Sacraments
- Penance
- Indulgences
- Apostolic Succession
- Veneration of Icons
- Veneration of Relics
- Episcopacy

The only thing the Eastern Orthodox doesn't have that Catholicism does is papal infallibility, however, this cannot be final determinant in being the Whore as the accusation that Catholicism was the Whore existed long before papal infallibility was defined (or "invented," to use Protspeak) in the 1800s.

In addition, I notice that many Protestants swallow hook, line, and sinker the idea that the Catholic Church was the Church that existed between 313 and 1453 was Catholic to the core. Why was it not Orthodox, as our Greek friends claim it was? While I believe that it was Catholic, the anti-Catholic Protestant who makes the accusation must (ironically) accept that all existing Catholic doctrines go back at least as far as the fourth century, which basically means that all a Catholic need do to prove apostolic succession is establish that the doctrines existed during the first, second, and third centuries. Never once have I read an anti-Catholic tract explaining how we know the Church was Catholic rather than Orthodox during that millennium of unity. If the Orthodox are correct in their historical claims (a question most anti-Catholics refuse to believe exists), the anti-Catholic has to severely rework their time-table as to when the Catholic Church was "born" and then explain why it is still the Whore, especially since the Orthodox are now responsible for all of the propagandized "atrocities" that occurred against Proto-Protestant groups during the Middle Ages.

In addition, the Whore of Babylon is supposed to be mother of harlots and of the abominations of the Earth. It could easily be claimed that "harlot" refers to spiritual apostacy and that the East was home to numerous Christological heresies such as Arianism, Nestorianism, Monophysitism, Iconoclasm, ect. Abominations could also refer to the caesaropapism that was all-too-often present in the East.

As far as the Whore being drunk on the blood of the saints, note that this term is also applied to Jews and that the Orthodox Tsarist Russia launched some of the most vigorous anti-Semitic progroms against the Jews in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century.

In light of the Whore sitting on seven hills, note the Orthodox Patriarch of Moscow sits at the seat of what was once called (and could easily be again) the "Third Rome" and that the Orthodox Ecumenical Patriarch sits at the See of Constantinople, the "New Rome." So this proof fits the Orthodoxy as well.

I see it as a clear case of the effect proceeding the cause and contradictory beliefs, by no means uncommon in Protestantism.

The early Protestant leader Melanchthon actually attempted to get the sanction of Patriarch Jeremias II of Constantinople in order to claim salvage Protestant claims into some semblance of apostolic succession. Upon learning the two central beliefs of the Reformation, Jeremias II basically told them that only the Latins would fall for an apostacy as self-refuting as that. At least the Bogomils (an Eastern sect of the Cathari) had a consistent theology, whereas the Reformers couldn't even come to a solid belief on the Eucharist.

In any event, my belief is that the Protestant first comes to the conclusion that the Catholic Church is evil, satanic, the Whore, ect., and THEN starts looking for evidence. This isn't exactly the best methodology, as the presupposition colors any evidence that is found into just about any mold the seeker desires to see