![]()

Protestant attack: The apocrypha itself denies all notion of inspiration. Referring to the events in the Maccabees the author makes these statements:
"...all such things as have been comprised in 5 books by Jason of Cyrene, we have attempted to abridge in one book. For considering the difficulty that they find that desire to undertake the narrations of histories, because of the multitude of the matter, we have taken care for those indeed that are willing to read,...And as to ourselves indeed, in undertaking this work of abridging, we have taken in hand no easy task, yea. rather a business full of watching and sweat. .. Leaving to the authors the exact handling of every particular, and as for ourselves. according to the plan proposed, studying to brief... For to collect all that is known, to put the discourse in order, and curiously to discuss every particular point, is the duty of the author of a history. But to pursue brevity of speech and to avoid nice declarations of things, is to be granted to him that maketh an abridgement." (2 Maccabees 2: 24-32).
If we actually read the verses cited above, we would not make such a ridiculous claim. In the first place, the citation doesn’t even mention the word "inspiration." In the second place, as the Haydock Bible says:
No easy task
, &c. The Spirit of God, that assists the sacred penman, does not exempt them from labor in seeking out the matter which they are to treat of, and the order and manner in which they are to deliver it. So S. Luke wrote the gospel, having diligently attained to all things. Lk. i. 3. Ch. – This evangelist had to inquire of others. W. – Inspiration preserves from all danger of mistake. When something future is revealed, there is less difficulty, as God must then dictate the very words. Hence Jeremias wrote with the utmost ease, as Baruch testified. Jer. xxxvi. 18, 32. H. – The prophets had, therefore, only to write or speak from the mouth of God. Others were excited by him to treat of history, &c. and were preserved from error, but not from labor. Bellar. Verb. i. 15. – In vain then do our adversaries attempt to prove that this book is not inspired. M. (Haydock Bible, p. 1205, vol. 1)
Just because the book is inspired does not mean that the author is exempt from work. This verse says absolutely nothing about inspiration at all.
Another common attack is 2 Maccabees 15:39-40:
"...I will also here make an end of my narration. Which if I have done well, and as it becometh the history, it is what I desired; but if not so perfectly, it must be pardoned me. For as it is hurtful to drink always wine, or always water, but pleasant to use sometimes the one, and sometimes the other, so if the speech be always nicely framed, it will not be grateful to the readers..." (2 Maccabees 15: 39-40).
This is not said with regard to the truth of the narration, but with regard to the style and manner of writing. As St. Paul said in 2 Corinthians 11:6:
For though I be rude in speech, yet not in knowledge; but in all things, we have been made manifest to you.
This is not a denial of inspiration at all, this is simply a statement to the effect that he is not as polished as some other authors may have been. If it is a denial of inspiration, then let us discard St. Paul’s Second Epistle to the Corinthians as well - in fact, we should discard all of his Epistles for, as he said, he is "rude in speech."
![]()