One simple example of why the "Scripture Alone" concept does not work

The very concept of "Scripture Alone" as it is held by Protestants is illogical. This is Especially so when one considers the fact that their Versions of the Bible today can not even agree of what really is scripture, and what is not. Let me Give you just one example [there are many], lets look at John 7:53-8:11.
The AAT and the WNTLT simply removes these verse completely, with no foot-note or Margin- note addressing were the twelve verses went or why.
The NCV, NIV, NWT, and the TKIT remove these verses from the Text and place them in sort of a footnote form, with a note openly denying there legitimacy
The NEB and the REB remove these verses from the Text and from the book of John, and place them as sort of a footnote ant the end of the book [of John], with a note openly denying there legitimacy
The ASV, ED, ESV, GNB, HCSB, ITAM, LB, LBP, NASV, NKJV, NLT, NOAB, NRSV, RSV, RV, SEV, SRE [KJV and NIV], and the WT have these verses in the text but have footnotes casting doubt on [or in some cases openly denying] there legitimacy.
The BNTLT, and the NKJV, have these verses in the text, but oddly enough they have one footnotes casting doubt on there legitimacy, and one footnote supporting there legitimacy. These translations actually seems confessed as to if we should accept these Verses.
The ANT has one footnote, it starts by casting doubt on the verses, then makes a curiously statement that they "accepts it as authentic".
The CEV, CT, CWE, DB, DV, GB, GT, HGKSB, LNT KJV, MLB, MRB, MT, PG, RBV, RDB, and the WB seem to openly accept these verse as part of the Text with out reservation.
We find that there are over 40 such verses in the New Testament that are also contested in the Modern Protestant Bibles, starting with Matt 12:47 all the way to I John 5:7, this is not counting the scores of contested partial verses, and hundreds of wording variations.
The Protestant confusion about John 7:53-8:11 does not discredit the scriptures, but to show the hypocrisy of this "Protestant" Belief. In order to verify ANY VERSE or ANY BOOK as being really scripture they must leave there "authority" [the Bible itself] and rely on Man who is fallible. Hence in truth there is not one "Protestant" out there who really thinks about honestly cannot truly believe what he preaches about "Scripture alone", hence the hypocrisy.
As for Catholics there is no confusion about the legitimacy these verses, or any verses in sacred scripture, for we have a Infallible Church to guide us and determine what is scripture and what is not.
![]()
LISTING OF BIBLES ABBREVIATIONS REFERENCED: Note ALL the Versions of the Bible listed in this article are of Non-Catholic origin.
AAT:
An American Translation (Both the "Complete Bible", and the "Short Bible")ANT: Amplified New Testament
ASV
: American Standard VersionBNTLP: Beck's New Testament in the Language of the Today
CEV
: Contemporary English BibleCT: The Collin’s Bible
CWE: The Christian Workers Edition
DB: Darby’s Bible
DV
: Dratmouth VersionED: Emphatic Diaglott
ESV: English Standard Version
GB
: Great BibleGT
: The Geneva TranslationGNB
: Good News BibleHCSB: Holman Christian Standard Bible
HGKSB
: Hebrew-Greek Key Study Bible, KJV versionITAM
: Interlinear Translation by Alfred MarshallKJV
: King James VersionLB
: Living BibleLBP: Living Bible Paraphrased
LNT
: Laymen’s New TestamentMLB: Modern Language Bible
MRB: Modern Readers Bible
MT: Matthew’s Translation
NAS
: New American Standard VersionNCV
: New Century VersionNEB
: New English VersionNIV: New International Version
NKJV: New King James Version: New King James Version
NLT: New Living Translation
NOAB: New Oxford Annotated Bible
NRSV: New Revised Standard Version
NTJM
: New Translation by James MoffatiNWT
: New World TranslationPB: Polyglott Bible
REB
: Revised English VersionRBV: The Revised Bereley Version
RDB
: Readers Digest BibleSEV: The Simple English Bible
SRE
: Scofield Reference Editions (The KJV and NIV editions)TKIT: The Kingdom Interlinear Translation of the Greek Scriptures
WB
: Webster’s BibleWNTLT: William's New Testament in the Language of the Today
WT: Worrell's Translation of the New Testament With Notes
Please sign our Guest book!
This page has helped
People find the truth since November 1999