4Unity archive

apolo 17

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

WAS TYNDALE'S BIBLE THE FIRST ENGLISH BIBLE ?

By David Goldstein LL.D, 1943. A Jewish convert to Catholicism.
Named a "Knight of St. Gregory" by Pope Pius XII in 1955.

 I am writing against absolutely false Protestant claim that "Tyndale died for your right to read the Bible;" and thet "Tyndale's was the first Bible translated in to English," which it was not.

In the first place bear this in mind, the Catholic Church was the originator of that Divine Library, which she designated The Bible. Secondly, the Catholic Church made the Bible accessible to the populace, through St. Jerome's translation of it from the Hebrew and Greek into Latin, over eleven centuries before your disreputable Bible hero was born. The very name of that fourth century translation, "The Vulgate," signifies the issuance of it in the language of the populace.

 You tellers of false Bible history disregard the fact, or know not that Latin was a world language at the time the vulgate translation was made; and even during the lifetime of Tyndale, when most people who could read at all, read Latin. Therefore Macau-lay could say, in his Essay on Bacon, that "at the time of Henry the Eighth and Edward the Sixth, a person who did not read Greek or Latin could read nothing or next to nothing. It was the language of the courts as of the schools. It was the language of diplomacy; it was the language of theological and political controversy," etc., etc. The universality of Latin, the language in which the Catholic Church made it possible for the people to read the Bible as early as the fourth century, was seen in our country in which Yale College required ability to read that language, in order that students be admitted. It was not until the year 1790 that Harvard College substituted ability to translate Latin for speaking that language, in order that students be admitted. Students in the schools and colleges of New England studied the Latin, and not the English language Bibles.

The circulation of Bibles among the populace was not possible until the invention of printing; thanks to the Catholic Gutenberg, the struggling inventor who was enabled to carry on his work through the generosity of the Catholic Archbishop of Mayence. This took place before the 16th century Lutheran Deformation divided the Christian world. This invention was followed by the publication of forty editions of the Bible by the Catholic Church, in eleven languages, between the years 1450-1520.

Your  assertion that Tyndale was the "Bible's first English translator" is without any foundation in historic fact. The Venerable Bede, Doctor of the Church, who lived during the years 672-735 A.D., translated nearly the whole Bible into the English of his day. The Encyclopedia Britannica declares that:

"(In) Eadwine's Psalterium triplex,(A.D. 1180) which contained the Latin version accompanied by Anglo-Norman and Anglo-Saxon renderings, appeared... By 1361 a translation of most of Scripture in this dialect (Anglo-Norman) had been executed."(© 1999-2000 Britannica)

This was 20 years before Wycliffe "translated" his version

"From August 1380 until the summer of 1381, Wycliffe was in his rooms at Queen's College, busy with his plans for a translation of the Bible" (© 1999-2000 Britannica)

St. Thomas More, Lord Chancellor of England, said in his "Dialogue" (p.138), that:

"the whole Bible was long before Wycliff's day (who lived during the century before Tyndale) by virtuous and well learned men translated into the English tongue and by good and godly people with devotion and soberness, well and reverendly read . . ."

Even Cranner, Henry Viii's Archbishop of Canterbury, said in the preface of the "Great Bible," that the. Holy Bible:

"was translated and read in the Saxon tongue, which at that time was the mother tongue, whereof there remaineth yet divers copies. ..; and when this language waxed old and out of common use, it was translated into the (English) language, whereof yet also many copies remain and be daily found."

The very Preface of the 1611 Authorized Version says:

"Bede by Cister- tiensis, to have turned a great part of them (the books of scripure) into Saxon: Efnard by Trithemius, to have abridged the French Psalter, as Beded had done the Hebrew, about the year 800: King Alfred by the said Cistertien- sis, to have turned the Psalter into Saxon: [Polydor. Virg. 5 histor.] ...even in our King Richard the second's days , John Trevisa translated them into English, and many English Bibles in written hand are yet to be seen with divers, translated as it is very probable, in that age".

Even Foxe, the martyologist, makes the same acknowledgment:

"If history be well examined we shall find both before the conquest and after, as well before John Wickliffe was born as since, the whole body of the scriptures was by Sundry men translated into our country tongue." (This was in 1571, in the declaration to Queen Elizabeth, written by Foxe).

For more examples of this point please see the appendix

It is love of the God-inspired books in the Bible that caused the Catholic Church to protect the people from counterfeit translations as ardently as the State endeavors to protect the people from counterfeit currency. The "right to read the Bible," which is a moral right, does not include imbibing such a blasphemous and distorted translation as came from the contemptible ex-Catholic pen of Tyndale. His translation was ordered to be destroyed, not because it appeared in the English language, as you assume, but because it was a faulty, corrupted translation, which was a deliberate profanation of the Sacred Text.

St. Thomas More commented that searching for errors in the Tyndale Bible was similar to searching for water in the sea. Even King Henry VIII in 1531 condemned the Tyndale Bible as a corruption of Scripture. In the words of King Henry's advisors: "the translation of the Scripture corrupted by William Tyndale should be utterly expelled, rejected, and put away out of the hands of the people, and not be suffered to go abroad among his subjects." (Where We Got The Bible 1977 p. 128-130.)

Protestant Bishop Tunstall of London declared that there were upwards of 2,000 errors in Tyndale's Bible. Tyndale translated the term baptism into "washing;" Scripture into "writing;" Holy Ghost into "Holy Wind," Bishop into "Overseer," Priest into "Elder," Deacon into "Minister;" heresy into "choice;" martyr into "witness;" evangelist into "bearer of good news;" etc., etc. Many of his footnotes were vicious. For instance, Tyndale referred to the occupant of the Chair of Peter, as "that great idol, the whore of Babylon, the anti-Christ of Rome."

Tyndale was a religious Benedict Arnold, a violator of solemn vows made to Almighty God, at the time of his ordination in the Franciscan Order. He, like all such excommunicated creatures, set up his perverse concept of things Christian, against those who speak with Divine authority in the Church that Christ established; the Church that made it possible for the world to have a Christian Bible.

Tyndale died not for the right to read the Bible, as you arrogantly claim. He was put to death by the civil judges of the father of the English Protestant Deformation, for doctrines subversive of law and order, which Dr. James Gardiner, Protestant, said "was intended to produce an ecclesiastical and social revolution of a most dangerous character. . ."

These Protestaint claims about  Tyndale is an offense. It is a perversion of historic truth. The Protestaint  defense of Tyndale's blasphemy and treason is very likely due to Protestaints  being ignorant of Bible history; having a bigoted concept of the Christ-established Catholic Church.

May your darkness be turned into the Divine Light, that shines in and through the Catholic Church.


THE APPENDIX

"To refute once more the common fallacy that John Wycliff was the first to place an English translation of the Scriptures in the hands of the English people in 1382. To anyone that has investigated the real facts of the case, this fondly-cherished notion must seem truly ridiculous...To begin far back, we have a copy of the work of Caedmon, a monk of Whitby, in the end of the seventh century, consisting of great portions of the Bible in the common tongue. In the next century we have the well-known translations of Venerable Bede, a monk of Jarrow, who died whilst busy with the Gospel of St. John. In the same (eighth) century we have the copies of Eadhelm, Bishop of Sherborne; of Guthlac, a hermit near Peterborough; and of Egbert, Bishop of Holy Island; these were all in Saxon, the language understood and spoken by the Christians of that time. Coming down a little later, we have the free translations of King Alfred the Great who was working at the Psalms when he died, and of Aelfric, Archbishop of Canterbury; as well as popular renderings of Holy Scripture like the Book of Durham, and the Rushworth Gloss and others that have survived the wreck of ages. After the Norman conquest in 1066, Anglo-Norman or Middle-English became the language of England, and consequently the next translations of the Bible we meet with are in that tongue. There are several specimens still known, such as the paraphrase of Orm (About 1150) and the Salus Animae (1250), the translations of William Shoreham and Richard Rolle, hermit of Hampole (died 1349). I say advisedly ‘specimens' for those that have come down to us are merely indications of a much greater number that once existed, but afterwards perished."(Where we got the Bible 1911, )

In the preface of The Coverdale Bible the world was told that "much about the time (1360), even in King Richard the Second's days, John Trevisa translated them into English, and many English Bibles in written hand are yet to be seen that divers translated..., so that to have the Scriptures in the mother tongue is not a quaint conceit lately taken up and out in practice of old, even from the first times of the conversion of any nation."

Anglican dignitary, Dean Hook, tells us that "Long before Wycliff’s time there had been translator’s of the Holy Writ."(Where we got the Bible 1911, )

The Protestant scholar Mr. Karl Pearson, says: "The Catholic Church has quite enough to answer for, but in the 15th century it certainly did not hold back the Bible from the folk: and it gave them in the vernacular (i.e. their own tongue) a long series of devotional works which for language and religious sentiment have never been surpassed. Indeed, we are inclined to think it made a mistake in allowing the masses such ready access to the Bible. It ought to have recognized the Bible once for all as a work absolutely unintelligible without a long course of historical study, and, so far as it was supposed to be inspired, very dangerous in the hands of the ignorant." (Academy, August, 1885)

Sir Francis Palgrave said, in his History of England, that "From the Anglo-Saxon age down to Wycliffe, we in England can show such a succession of Biblical versions in metre and prose, as are not equaled amongst any other nation in Europe."

"In England there were current from early times(A.D. 800) vernacular versions of the Bible, especially of the Gospels, since the Gospel was often read at Mass in the vernacular after its recitation in Latin" (The Columbia Encyclopedia, copyright 1958, p. 197)

Archbishop Ussher of Armagh quotes a fragment from the Worcester Cathedral library, "The Venerable Bede translated the Bible, at least the greater part of it, into English, in many copies of his version are sill found in English monasteries." (Historia Dogmatica, 1763, XII, page 356)

"The Latin Vulgate (q.v.), from which a considerable number of versions were made into that form of English commonly called Anglo-Saxon, the most noted translators being Aldhelm, Bishop of Sherborn, Bede (8th c.); Alfred (6th c.); and Aelfric (10th c.)." (The Imperial Encyclopedia and Dictionary, volume 4, copyright 1902)