4Unity archive

apolo 27

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

THE GOSPEL OF THOMAS, AND THE OTHER GNOSTIC APOCRYPHAL GOSPELS

"It was only the Roman Catholic Church that saved the Protestant truths. It may be right to rest on the Bible, but there would be no Bible if the Gnostics had proved that the Old Testament was written by the Devil, or had succeeded lettering the world with Apocryphal Gospels"(UPON THIS ROCK by G.K. Chesterton)

By Sherry Adams

Recently, more and more the validity of gospel of Thomas has become a topic for conversation mainly do to the Hollywood fictional movie titled "Stigmata". Evidence for the Gnostic phenomenon, found in the Church Fathers who opposed Gnostic teachings (Irenaeus, c. 185; Hippolytus, c. 230; Epiphanius, c. 375)

The Nag Hammadi Library, a collection of thirteen ancient codices containing over fifty texts, was discovered in upper Egypt in 1945. This immensely important discovery includes a large number of primary Gnostic scriptures -- texts once thought to have been entirely destroyed during the early Christian struggle to define "orthodoxy" -- scriptures such as the Gospel of Thomas, the Gospel of Philip, and the Gospel of Truth.The discovery and translation of the Nag Hammadi library, completed in the 1970's, has provided impetus to a major re-evaluation of early Christian history and the nature of Gnosticism.

What Muhammad 'Alí discovered at Nag Hammadi, it soon became clear, were Coptic translations, made about 1,500 years ago, of still more ancient manuscripts. The originals themselves had been written in Greek, the language of the New Testament: as Doresse, Puech, and Quispel had recognized, part of one of them had been discovered by archeologists about fifty years earlier, when they found a few fragments of the original Greek version of the Gospel of Thomas.

The GNOSTIC APOCRYPHAL GOSPELS Found at  Nag Hammadi in Alphabetical Order

The Acts of Peter and the Twelve Apostles, Allogenes, The Apocalypse of Adam, The (First) Apocalypse of James, The (Second) Apocalypse of James, The Apocalypse of Paul, The Apocalypse of Peter, The Apocryphon of James, The Apocryphon of John, Asclepius 21-29, Authoritative Teaching, The Book of Thomas the Contender, The Concept of Our Great Power, The Dialogue of the Savior, The Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth, Eugnostos the Blessed, The Exegesis on the Soul, The Gospel of the Egyptians, The Gospel of Philip, The Gospel of Thomas, The Gospel of Truth, The Hypostasis of the Archons, Hypsiphrone, The Interpretation of Knowledge, The Letter of Peter to Philip, Marsanes, Melchizedek, On the Anointing, On the Baptism A, On the Baptism B, On the Eucharist A, On the Eucharist B, On the Origin of the World, The Paraphrase of Shem, Plato, Republic 588A-589B, The Prayer of the Apostle Paul, The Prayer of Thanksgiving, The Second Treatise of the Great Seth, The Sentences of Sextus, The Sophia of Jesus Christ, The Teachings of Silvanus, The Testimony of Truth, The Thought of Norea, The Three Steles of Seth, The Thunder, Perfect Mind, The Treatise on the Resurrection, Trimorphic Protennoia, The Tripartite Tractate, A Valentinian Exposition, Zostrianos

Were these Gnostics realy Christian and could these books be real scripture? First let us look at the Gnostics, scholars tell us that they borrowed their beliefs from Greek philosophy, Jewish cabalistic mysticism, Babylonian mythology, Mithraism, and Persian dualism:

"The chief elements of gnostic religion and philosophy were Greek philosophy, Jewish cabalistic mysticism, Babylonian mythology, Mithraism, and Persian dualism."(Funk & Wagnalls standard Reference Encyclopedia, volume 11, 1950)

So we see the Gnostics realy were not Christian but of pagan philosophy:

"The remarkable form of so-called Christianity but really of pagan philosophy—to which the word in this sense was applied, is religious phenomenon as extraordinary as were the times and causes that gave it birth."(The Imperial Encyclopedia and Dictionary, Volume 16, 1890)

"Gnosticism a term applied to religious philosophies, both Christian and pagan"(Funk & Wagnalls standard Reference Encyclopedia, volume 11, 1950)

"Sects in the first ages of Christianity who taught that they alone had a true knowledge of the Christian religion, and who attempted to incorporate the tenets of the pagan philosophy with some doctrines of Christianity."(The Imperial Encyclopedia and Dictionary, Volume 16, 1890)

"We have stated a the outset, that Gnosticism was but a general name for great number of diverging nominally Christian but really heathen schools."(The Imperial Encyclopedia and Dictionary, Volume 16, 1890)

Let us look at some  fundamental doctrine of the gnostics:

"A fundamental doctrine of the gnostics was a clear-cut dualism between good and evil, between the divine and the material worlds. In some gnostic teachings evil is supposed to have been generated by God or the supreme being by a series of emanations. According to this belief a less perfect world emanated from the divine world, and from this less perfect world a succession of interior worlds, until, as the divine good dwindled and became diluted by distance, the creation of evil was possible. Generally the material world in which men live was regarded as the creation of seven powers, half-angel, half-devil, called Eons, who represented the last link in the chain of emanations. The seven Eons were clearly identified with sun, moon, and five planets of the Babylonian mythology. In some gnostic systems the place of the Eons is taken by a single creative being having similar attributes, the Demiurge.

The gnostics believed that such salvation was attainable by ignoring the material world and concentrating on the divine world of light. As aids in their journey through the intermediate worlds to the perfect world, the gnostics made use of many symbols and sacraments, including sacred formulas, the names of the demons of the lower world and of the Eons and anointment with holy oil...Gnostic systems Sophia (Gr., "wisdom") or the Great Mother played a prominent part. She was regarded as the goddess of heaven and the mother of the stars. This goddess was obviously the equivalent of the mother goddess of a number of Asiatic faiths who was worshiped under such names as Aphrodite, Astarte, Cybele, and Isis. A parallel figure was the Primal Man, who existed before the creation of the world, appeared on the earth in many forms, and finally became a man in the form of Christ. The resurrection of the Primal Man and his ascent into heaven served as the basis for the hope of personal salvation among the gnostics."(Funk & Wagnalls standard Reference Encyclopedia, volume 11, 1950)

The fact that the "Gnostics or Carpocratians" Followers of Carpoerates, an Alexandrian philosopher, who flourished during the reign of the Emperor Hadrian (117-138). The Carpocratians held that everyone has two souls; believed in the transmigration of souls; maintained that the world was created by angels; denied the divinity of Christ, and advocated the practice of immorality as a means of union with God.  Carpoerates also held the believe that the old Testament was written by the Devil attempted to discredit the true Scriptures by pointing out the fact that the world was, indeed, littered with apocryphal books.

"They by degrees excluded from the code most of the books of they New Testament, especially those in which there were distinct attacks against themselves; and substituted a number of other epistles and religious documents of their own in Greek and Syriac, such as the Prophecies of Cain, Writings of Pachur, Psalms by Valentinus and Bardesanes, Gnostic Hymns by Marcos, Books of Adam, Enoch, Moseh, Eliah, Isajah, etc. Not to mention a host of writings by newly invented prophets of such peculiar names as Pachor Barkor, Armagil, Barbelon, Balsamum, Lensiboras, etc., (Hier. ad. Themod. iii. 6, etc.)"(The Imperial Encyclopedia and Dictionary, Volume 16, 1890)

"Apocryphal New Testament, title that refers to more than 100 books written by Christian authors between the 2nd and 4th centuries. The books have two characteristics in common: (1) In general form they resemble New Testament writings (see Bible); (2) they belong neither to the New Testament canon nor to the writings of the recognized Fathers of the Church. These books were written for a variety of reasons, including for use by sects such as the Gnostics" (The Encarta Concise Encyclopedia 1999)

For some examples of the TRULY Apocryphal works that proliferated among the early centuries, permit me to list a few:

Apocryphal New Testament Acts.

The Acts of Andrew, The Acts and Martyrdom of Andrew, The Acts of Andrew and Matthew, The Acts of Barnabas, Martyrdom of Bartholomew, The Acts of John, The Mystery of the Cross-Excerpt from the Acts of John, The Acts of John the Theologian, The History of Joseph the Carpenter, The Book of John Concerning the Death of Mary, The Passing of Mary, The Acts and Martyrdom of Matthew, The Martyrdom of Matthew, The Acts of Paul, The Acts of Paul and Thecla, The Acts of Peter, The Acts of Peter and Andrew, The Acts of Peter and Paul, The Acts of Peter and the Twelve Apostles, The Acts of Philip, The Report of Pontius Pilate to Tiberius, The Giving Up of Pontius Pilate, The Death of Pilate, The Acts of Thaddaeus,The Acts of Thomas, The Book of Thomas the Contender, The Consummation of Thomas

Apocryphal New Testament Gospels.

The Infancy Gospel of Thomas [Greek Text ], The Infancy Gospel of Thomas [Latin Text], A 5th Century Compilation of the Thomas Texts, An Arabic Infancy Gospel, The Gospel of James, The Gospel of the Nativity of Mary, The Gospel of Mary [Magdalene], The Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew, The Gospel of Nicodemus [Acts of Pilate], The Gospel of Bartholomew, The Gospel of Peter, The Gospel of Thomas, The Gospel of Philip, The Gospel of the Lord [by Marcion], The Secret Gospel of Mark

Apocryphal New Testament Apocalypse.

The Apocalypse of Adam, The Revelation of Esdras, The First Apocalypse of James, The Second Apocalypse of James, The Revelation of John the Theologian, The Revelation of Moses,The Apocalypse of Paul, Fragments-The Apocalypse of Paul,The Revelation of Paul,The Apocalypse of Peter, The Vision of Paul, The Revelation of Peter, Fragments-The Apocalypse of Peter, The Apocalypse of Sedrach, The Revelation of Stephen, The Apocalypse of Thomas,The Apocalypse of the Virgin

Of course, the True Church (which was founded upon Peter [Matt. 16:18-19), knew the difference between the false texts and the true Scriptures. Which is precisely why St. Augustine(354-430) said the following:

"I would not believe in the Gospel if the authority of the Catholic Church did not move me to do so." (St. Augustine, Conra Epist. Fundam. i,6)

Gospel of Thomas, About the dating of the manuscripts themselves there is little debate. Examination of the datable papyrus used to thicken the leather bindings, and of the Coptic script, place them A.D. 350-400. But scholars sharply disagree about the dating of the original texts. Some of them can hardly be later than A.D. 140-150, since Irenaeus, the orthodox Bishop of Lyons, writing C. 180, declares that heretics "boast that they possess more gospels than there really are,'' and complains that in his time such writings already have won wide circulation--from Gaul through Rome, Greece, and Asia Minor.

Quispel and his collaborators, who first published the Gospel of Thomas, suggested the date of  A.D. 140 for the original. Most  Scholars (Catholic and Protestant) agree that this gospel was not written by the apostle Thomas, since it was written later than the gospels of the New Testament, which are dated A.D 60-l 00.

Of course, there are many theological problems in the Gospel of Thomas we shall highlight one of them now. Most Christians believe that Jesus is Lord and Son of God: he remains forever distinct from the rest of humanity whom he came to save. Yet the gnostic Gospel of Thomas relates that as soon as Thomas recognizes him, Jesus says to Thomas that they have both received their being from the same source and bolth just men:

Jesus said, "I am not your master. Because you have drunk, you have become drunk from the bubbling stream which I have measured out.... He who will drink from my mouth will become as I am: I myself shall become he, and the things that are hidden will be revealed to him."

Many scholars have suggested that if the names were changed, the "living Buddha" appropriately could say what the Gospel of Thomas attributes to the living Jesus. Could Hindu or Buddhist tradition have influenced gnosticism?

The British scholar of Buddhism, Edward Conze, suggests that it had. He points out that "Buddhists were in contact with the Thomas Christians (that is, Christians who knew and used such writings as the Gospel of Thomas) in South India." Trade routes between the Greco-Roman world and the Far East were opening up at the time when gnosticism flourished (A.D. 80-200); for generations, Buddhist missionaries had been proselytizing in Alexandria. We note, too, that Hippolytus, who was a Greek speaking Christian in Rome (c. 225), knows of the Indian Brahmins--and includes their tradition among the sources of heresy:

There is . . . among the Indians a heresy of those who philosophize among the Brahmins, who live a self-sufficient life, abstaining from (eating) living creatures and all cooked food . . . They say that God is light, not like the light one sees, nor like the sun nor fire, but to them God is discourse, not that which finds expression in articulate sounds, but that of knowledge (gnosis) through which the secret mysteries of nature are perceived by the wise.

"The development of Christian doctrine was to a large extent a reaction against Gnosticism. The formulation of creedal symbols, the canonization of the New Testament Scriptures, and the emphasis on episcopal authority all were made necessary by the Gnostics' claims."(© 1999-2000 Britannica.com)