4Unity archive

apolo 32

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

IMAGES OF JESUS

    

While serving the net recently encounter this article on a anti-Catholic Protestant propaganda page Entitled "MYTH:I need a picture to remind me about Jesus." Written by a Jenny Tarbell. A 27 years old, married woman with one son. Jenny claims to be a "full time Bible Believing Christian".

although I did not feel the article was well-written or the points made new or original, I did feel it gave me a good opportunity to dispel some common misconceptions about images The author starts off with a touching story of How he used to have a picture of "Jesus..in a beautiful wood frame, and I would sit and look at it for several minutes at a time, several times a day. I would look at it and see how gentle and beautiful he looked." Before she was "saved" and then she picked up his Bible and began to miss interpret the words within. He start his "argument" with:

Our opponent’s comments will appear in red, while ours will remain in normal colored text.

In Exodus 20:4-6 we read the following:

4 Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth:5 Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me; 6 And shewing mercy unto thousands of them that love me, and keep my commandments.

This here seems pretty cut and dry. God says you will not do this. You will not. Not you 'may' not, or 'sometime later it will be ok, but not now because this is the old testament', but THOU SHALT NOT make an image of anything and bow before them, or serve them.

First, let us look at these scriptures again:

"THOU SHALT NOT HAVE STRANGE GODS BEFORE ME. Thou shalt not make to thyself a graven thing, nor the likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or in the earth beneath, nor of those things that are in the waters under the earth. THOU SHALT NOT ADORE THEM, NOR SERVE THEM" (Ex., xx, 3-5).

It is of course obvious that the emphasis of this law is in the first and last clauses -- "no strange gods", "thou shalt not adore them". Still any one who reads it might see in the other words too an absolute command. The people are not only told not to adore images nor serve them; they are not even to make any graven thing or the likeness, it would seem, of anything at all. One could understand so far-reaching a command at that time. If they made statues or pictures, they probably would end by adoring them. How likely they were to set up a graven thing as a strange god is shown by the story of the golden calf at the very time that the ten words were promulgated. In distinction to the nations around, Israel was to worship an unseen God, there was to be no danger of the Israelites falling into the kind of religion of Egypt or Babylon. This law obtained certainly as far as images of God are concerned. Any attempt to represent the God of Israel graphically (it seems that the golden calf had this meaning -- Exodus, xxxii, 5) is always put down as being abominable idolatry.

But, except for one late period, we notice that the commandment was never understood as an absolute and universal prohibition of any kind of image. Throughout the Old Testament there are instances of representations of living things, not in any way worshiped, but used lawfully, even ordered by the law as ornaments of the tabernacle and temple. The many cases of idolatry and various deflections from the Law which the prophets denounce are not, of course, cases in point. It is the statues made and used with the full approval of the authorities which show that the words, "Thou shalt not make to thyself any graven image", were not understood absolutely and literally. It may be that the Hebrew word translated "graven image" had a technical sense that meant more than a statue, and included the idea of "idol"; though this does not explain the difficulty of the next phrase. In any case it is certain that there were "likenesses of that which is in the sky above and on earth below and in the waters" in the orthodox Jewish cult. Whatever one may understand the mysterious ephod and theraphim to have been, there was the brazen serpent (Num., xxi, 9), not destroyed till Ezechias did so (IV Kings, xviii, 4), there were carved and moulded garlands of fruit and flowers and trees (Num., viii, 4; III Kings, vi, 18; vii, 36); the king's throne rested on carved lions (III Kings, x, 19-20), Iions and bulls supported the basins in the temple (III Kings, vii, 25, 29). Especially there are the cherubim, great carved figures of beasts (Ezech., i, 5; x, 20, where they are called beasts), that stood over the ark of the covenant (Ex., xxv, 18-22; III Kings, vi, 23-8; viii, 6-7, etc.). The ephod was certainly once a statue of human form (Judges, viii, 27; xvii, 5; I Kings, xix, 13, etc.), the human heads of the cherubim (Ezech., xli, 19, Ex., xxv, 20, the references to them when combined seem to point irresistibly to some such figures as the Assyrian winged bulls with human heads), and what were the theraphim (Judges, xvii, 5)? Both were used in orthodox worship.

God says he is a jealous God, and that he most definitely punishes for this sin. Let's talk about jealous. We often hear that it is bad to be jealous. Envy and lust are definitely sins. There is however, a GODLY jealousy that paul speaks about in 2 Corinthians 11:2:

For I am jealous over you with godly jealousy: for I have espoused you to one husband, that I may present you as a chaste virgin to Christ.

See how it says "I have espoused to you ONE husband"? Who is this husband? Paul here says our husband is Christ. In Isaiah we read:

Isaiah 54:5 For thy Maker is thine husband; the LORD of hosts is his name; and thy Redeemer the Holy One of Israel; The God of the whole earth shall he be called.

It is true, that Christ is the husband of the chaste virgin, but who the virgin? obviously not just anybody can claim to be the bride of Christ, St. Paul goes on to tell us that this virgin bride is the church (Eph. v. 24-27) which Christ founded upon the "rock" Peter (Matt xvi. 18).

So by these two not only can we state that Jesus is God, but also that God is our husband.

True Jesus is God, but as shown on above Christ’s bride is the church built upon Peter, unfortunately (for you) you do not adhere to this church therefore you cannot claim to be the bride of Christ or Christ at your husband.

And we know God is jealous, and we also know (not just think people, know. Remember we take God for his word, believeing that he means what his word says) that he commands us not to make an image of ANYTHING, bow before it or serve it. That includes an image of GOD.

Wrong, if yet bothered to read the scripture before this the altar were noted this was in reference to "STRANGE GODS" of course the shares the inherent danger of pulling one verse out of context. Images can be traced back to pre-Biblical times in the Old Testament. The Jews made use of images (Num., xxi, 9; Ezech., i, 5; x, 20; Ex., xxv, 18-22; III Kings, vi, 23-8; viii, 6-7;) by Divine edict. The ancient Christians made use of images in the catacombs, as the following statements shows:

"That Christians from the very beginning adorned their catacombs with paintings of Christ, of the saints, of scenes from the Bible and allegorical groups is too obvious and too well known for it to be necessary to insist upon the fact. The catacombs are the cradle of all Christian art. Since their discovery in the sixteenth century -- on 31 May, 1578, an accident revealed part of the catacomb in the Via Salaria -- and the investigation of their contents that has gone on steadily ever since, we are able to reconstruct an exact idea of the paintings that adorned them. That the first Christians had any sort of prejudice against images, pictures, or statues is a myth (defended amongst others by Erasmus) that has been abundantly dispelled by all students of Christian archaeology. The idea that they must have feared the danger of idolatry among their new converts is disproved in the simplest way by the pictures even statues, that remain from the first centuries." (Encyclopedic Dictionary of Christian History, p. 394)

The Christian writer Eusebius described some very ancient statues at Caesarea Philippi representing Christ and the woman He healed there (Matt., 9:20-22), in his Ecclesiastical History, vol. VII, xviii. The earliest sarcophagi had bas-reliefs. As soon as the Church came out of the catacombs, became richer, had no fear of persecution, the same people who had painted their caves began to make statues of the same subjects. The famous statue of the Good Shepherd in the Lateran Museum was made as early as the beginning of the third century, the statues of Hippolytus and of St. Peter date from the end of the same. "The idea that the Church of the first centuries was in any way prejudiced against pictures and statues is the most impossible fiction." (century.Catholic Encyclopedia, 1911)

Isaiah chapter 53 is a prophecy of Jesus Christ. It summarizes how people were going to feel about Jesus when he came. Verse two, however, especially concerns the theme of this article, images of Jesus.

Isaiah 53:2 For he shall grow up before him as a tender plant, and as a root out of a dry ground: he hath no form nor comeliness; and when we shall see him, there is no beauty that we should desire him.

"Knowing this first, that no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation."(2 Peter 1-20) . It seems the author has violated a direct command of scripture by attempting to privately interpret the above prophecy for us. Secondly the fallacy of his interpretation becomes evident when one reads the new Testament. We note that when the Christ came the first time the vast majority of people rejected him and eventually put him to death.

Do you think the image above represents what this scripture is saying? Do you think if the artist went by that description to paint the picture, this is what he would come up with? The man in that image is not without form or comliness. There is much beauty in him. Also,why does "Jesus" have long hair, when the word of God tells us:

1Co 11:14 Doth not even nature itself teach you, that, if a man have long hair, it is a shame unto him?

Christ, had long hair because sacred scripture commanded the Jews not to have short hair (Lev. 19:27), Even today devout Jews still where long hair. In the old Testament Times men as well as women were long hair. Both Sampson and Absalom were admired for the long, full hair (Judg. 16:13-14; Sam. 14:25-26). Baldness was considered an embarrassment (2 Kings 2:23-24; Is. 3:24) so we see scripturely Christ would’ve indeed been proper to have had long hair. So why the St. Paul teach that men should not have long hair? St. Paul taught that many of the practices and customs of the Jews were not relevant to the gentile Christians. It is interesting to note that the early Christian paintings of Christ ALL pretray Christ with long hair.

So we can see here that this image (and all the others) do not even look like Jesus.This is an image created out of the imagination of man's heart (see Gen 6:5, and others).

This assumption is based upon the author’s ignorance of sacred scripture, Jewish customs, Jewish practices, biblical times and early Christian art. It is a clear-cut example of why this author should not be writing on matters a religion.

Ask yourselves this question people: How would I feel if my husband found a picture of a better looking woman, that looked nothing like me, put it in a frame, hung it up on the wall, and said it was a picture of me? Why, I'd be mad! I'd be downright JEALOUS! I would rip that thing off the wall and ask my husband if he was crazy. If this thing would make us jealous, why don't you think God would be jealous if we did it to him? Especially when he so clearly commands us not to do it!

Of course this is irrelevant, the author has failed approve these pictures do not look like Christ. Secondly, I would not dare to put myself on the same plane as God nor Judge God reaction by my feeble mortal reaction this vergas on blaspheme.

(Snip.. Snip..)The author then proceeds to give a list of versus showing the glory of God.

Notice in particular John 14:26. He says the Holy Ghost will bring all the things Jesus said to our remembrance. That doesn't mean we sit around waiting for a revelation. It means that we have to learn what his words are, and know them. How?

Christ, established a church to which he commanded " go forth and teach all nations" to this church (his bride) Christ promised to send the Holy Ghost. Of course pictures are not necessary for the remembrance of Christ or any person, but we must remember that humans by nature visual creatures, as visual creatures images are indeed a great help. I asked the reader even though you still have your children with you visit not a pleasure in a refreshing reminder to look back upon the infant pictures? Who among us do not keep pictures of loved ones who are passed on such as parents or grandparents? Of course we still remember these loved ones, but being visual creatures these pictures were images help us to remember the reality and the humanity of these loved ones.

You do not need an image to remind you. God gave us the great gift of his spirit, to teach us, comfort us, keep us.

Correction, Christ gave the great gift of the holy spirit to his church nowhere does scripture promise a Holy Spirit to absolutely everyone.

He gave us the great gift of His written word, preserved for all generations (Psa 12:6,7) Believe Him! Do not give the glory only due to God to a picture of a man! Don't you think if we call a picture of some man 'Jesus' thats what we're doing? Do you realize that we're also saying that is a picture of 'Alpha and Omega, the Almighty'(See Rev 1:8)?

Interesting, I sense a denial of the fact that Christ was both God and man. The fact that Christ was also true man is a testified clearly and scripture (Matt. I. 21-25; Luke ii. 6-7; john i. 14; Gal. iv.4-5; Heb. ii. 14-17) and cannot be denied. Once again we see the danger pulling individual scriptures out of their proper context.

See that ye do it not! Repent! God says he would not give His praise to a graven image(Isa 42:8). That means he will never ever say 'All these images are vanity, but this graven image is not.' NEVER! If God would not ever do such a thing, why would we?

of course the ridiculous list of the alters arguments become obvious when one reads stricture in its entirety. The Jews made use of images (Num., xxi, 9; Ezech., i, 5; x, 20; Ex., xxv, 18-22; III Kings, vi, 23-8; viii, 6-7;) by Divine edict. Clearly not all images were condemned by God only those dealing with strange gods I wish to make the next statement of the authors my own:

I ask you to pray and consider these things. Go and study graven images further...God bless you dear readers.