4Unity archive

apolo 43

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

AGAINST THE ERRORS OF PROTESTANTISM

PROTESTANT ERRORS ON SALVATION

How often is it that one hears Protestants crying out that "salvation is through faith alone, apart from works" and making such erroneous claims as "works are not necessary for salvation"? Indeed, this is one of the two pillars of Protestantism - the other being "Sola Scriptura," Scipture alone - it is on these two pillars that Protestantism is based. When one is knocked down, the other will follow swiftly.

As it is, the pillar of "salvation apart from works" is dependant upon the other - sola scriptura. For without sola scriptura, the other pillar would never have been erected. Yet, we shall herein deal with the errors contained in the pillar of "salvation apart from works," and then move on to refute the protestant error of "scripture alone."

To begin with, the Protestants are quite easily shown to be wrong when it comes to whether or not works are necessary for salvation, and whether or not faith alone will suffice. As the Epistle of Saint James says, "Do you see that by works a man is justified; and not by faith only? For even as the body without the spirit is dead; so also faith without works is dead."

As it is, we see Christ our Lord commanding us to do works in order to be saved throughout the Sacred Scriptures. For example, in John 3:5 Christ commands us to be baptized in order to be saved. And in Matthew 19:16-17 Christ commands us to keep the commandments in order to be saved. While in 1 Corinthians 13:2 the Scriptures tell us that faith without charity is useless.

The Scriptures also tell us that one of the standards by which we shall be judged on the last day, is our works. As Matthew 16:27 tells us, and I quote: "For the Son of Man will come in the glory of his Father with his angels: And then will he render to every man according to his works." The Book of the Apocalypse (otherwise called "Revelations" by protestants) says the same thing in chapter 20 verse 13, while in Chapter 22 verse 13 of the same book it says the following "Behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to render to every man according to his works."

The Scriptures also command us to heed and put into practice the Sacred words of Christ, as the following verses bear witness, John 3:36; 5:24; 12:50; 13:17; 14:15; Luke 6:47; 10:37; 1 John 3:24; 2:5. And since it is necessary for us to put into practice the Sacred Words of Christ, and to heed them, the following also become necessary for salvation:

1. Eating the Flesh and drinking the Blood of Christ (John 6:32)

2. We must be perfect (Matthew 5:48)

3. Hope is necessary for salvation (Romans 8:27; 2 Timothy 4:8 Hebrews 9:28)

4. Holiness is necessary for salvation (Matthew, 5:20)

5. Hearing Christ’s Church is necessary for salvation (Matthew 18:17)

6. Believing is necessary for salvation (Mark 16:16)

7. Being a member of Christ’s Church is necessary for salvation.

Hence we see that, in the light of Sacred Scripture, the protestant theory of salvation through faith alone crumbles into dust. Permit me to take a few moments and to refute some common objections to the necessity of works for salvation. Among the Scripture verses which are frequently twisted by protestants in a desperate attempt to support their position are Romans 11:6, Galatians 2:16, and Romans 4:1-8. These verses have been twisted by protestants, who, primarily through misunderstanding and lack of knowledge on their part, are under the delusion that they refute the Catholic stance on works and salvation. Let us start with Romans 11:6. Permit me to cite the verse in question:

Romans 11:6 [DR] And if by grace, it is not now by works: otherwise grace is no more grace.

If salvation were to come by works, done by nature, apart faith and grace, salvation would not be a grace or favor, but a debt; but such dead works are indeed of no value in the sight of God towards salvation. It is not the same with regard to works done with and by God's grace; for to such works as these he has promised eternal salvation (see the above-cited verses on this question).

Holy Mother Church does not say that grace is not necessary for salvation, nor does She say that Faith is not necessary for salvation. And She is most certainly not saying that one can be saved by works alone. All three of the above are necessary for salvation. Faith without grace and works is dead, just as works without faith and grace would be dead. It is through a misunderstanding of Catholic teaching that this verse is commonly used by Protestants against Catholics, and against the necessity of works for salvation.

To continue on, permit me to cite Galatians 2:16, which says:

Galatians 2:16 [DR] But knowing that man is not justified by the works of the law, but by the faith of Jesus Christ; we also believe in Christ Jesus, that we may be justified by the faith of Christ, and not by the works of the law: because by the works of the law no flesh shall be justified.

As the Haydock's Bible says concerning this verse:

"‘Knowing that a man is not justified by the works of the law.' S. Paul, to the end of the chapter, seems to continue his discourse to S. Peter, but chiefly to the Jewish Galatians, to show that both the Gentiles, whom the Jews called and looked upon as sinners, and also the Jews, when converted, could only hope to be justified and saved by the faith of Christ, and not by the works of the law. – ‘For by the law I am dead to the law.' That is, says S. Jerome, by the evangelical law of Christ I am dead to the ancient law and its ceremonies." (Vol. II p. 244)

And as St. Paul said in his Epistle to the Romans, Chapter 3 verse 20, "Because by the works of the law no flesh shall be justified before him. For by the law is the knowledge of sin." What is obviously being referred to here are the works of the Law of Moses. If it were otherwise, we would have a clear-cut example of a contradiction in the Sacred Scriptures. For does not St. James tell us that Faith without works is dead? And do not the Scriptures elsewhere state that Good works and deeds are necessary for salvation (Luke 10:28; 10:25; 18:18. Matthew 19:16)? Here we see that the protestants are pitting Scripture against Scripture... instead of accepting Scripture in its entirety. The protestants claim to be inspired by the Holy Ghost... but one of the many problems with this is the fact that the Holy Ghost would never accept the words of St. Paul over the words of St. James, and discard the words of the latter. Nor would the Holy Ghost ask one to discard the Words of Christ, as listed in the books of Matthew and Luke, chapters and verses listed above.

The third, and, by far, the most frequently used attack on the necessity of works for salvation, is Romans 4:1-8, which says as follows:

"What shall we say then that Abraham hath found, who is our father according to the flesh. For if Abraham were justified by works, he hath whereof to glory, but not before God. For what saith the scripture? Abraham believed God, and it was reputed to him unto justice. Now to him that worketh, the reward is not reckoned according to grace, but according to debt. But to him that worketh not, yet believeth in him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is reputed to justice, according to the purpose of the grace of God. As David also termeth the blessedness of a man, to whom God reputeth justice without works: Blessed are they whose iniquities are forgiven, and whose sins are covered. Blessed is the man to whom the Lord hath not imputed sin."

A simple, working knowledge of the entirety of the Sacred Scriptures would be more than enough to refute the interpretation given to the above verses, and to put the one using them against the necessity of works for salvation to shame.

As St. James states, referring to the exact same verses to which you are referring above "Was not Abraham our father justified by works, offering up Isaac his son upon the altar? Seest thou, that faith did co-operate with his works; and by works faith was made perfect? And the scripture was fulfilled, saying: Abraham believed God, and it was reputed to him to justice, and he was called the friend of God. Do you see that by works a man is justified; and not by faith only?"(St. James, 2:21-24) When St. Paul stated "For if Abraham were justified by works, he hath whereof to glory, but not before God" what were, again, referred to were works done for the honor and glory of man, not those of God. As the verse very plainly points out. It is not rejecting works altogether, as St. James pointed out above. In fact, St. James uses the verse following the above as  proof for the fact that works are necessary for justification! After all, not only was the offering up of Isaac upon the altar a work (which God required Abraham to do, in order to test Abraham's Faith... which, in turn, shows, yet again, that Faith alone is not enough), but also Abraham's own belief, was a work.

It might be very well to point out here that taking Scripture verses out of context (in an attempt to prove an erroneous belief), is a thing which was used by Satan himself against Christ when Satan tempted Christ in the desert.

Thus falls the theory of salvation through faith alone, not to mention the erroneous interpretations which are frequently given to several verses in the Sacred Scriptures.

PROTESTANT ERRORS ON SCRIPTURE ALONE

Another pillar of Protestantism, is that of Scripture as their sole rule of Faith. This rule requires that they reject Sacred Tradition, as another one of the points upon which the Christian Faith is built. This position is completely and utterly untenable. The fact that we are required to hold to Sacred Tradition is a fact well-founded upon both history and the Sacred Scriptures themselves. To cite St. Paul:

"Therefore, brethren, stand fast; and hold the traditions which you have learned, whether by word or by our epistle." (2 Thessalonians 2:14)

St. Paul further says, also in 2 Thessalonians, that "... we charge you, brethren, in the name of Our Lord Jesus Christ, that you withdraw yourselves from every brother walking disorderly, and not according to the tradition which they have received of us." (2 Thessalonians 3:6)

In addition to the above, permit me to point out that, for example, in the early centuries of Christianity, there was no such thing as the "Bible." As the famous Catholic Apologist, and convert from Judaism to Catholicism, David Goldstein said:

"The Protestant rule of faith is a denial of the faith of the early Christians, who accepted no such Protestant standard of religious judgment. The Church of Christ was in existence for about 15 years before the first Book in the New Testament was written, and the last book was not written until 45 years after that. Think of the thousands of devout persons who lived a Christian life, of the many persons who suffered martyrdom for Christ during the first century without reading a Bible, which was non-existent at that time. They received their crown of glory by depending upon the Apostles of Christ for their guidance. Christ said to his followers, as He says to you and to me, ‘hear the Church’ (St. Matt. 18":17), not to take a non-existing, or a to-come-into-existence Bible, as their rule of faith. Christ commanded His apostles to ‘go and preach the Gospel,’ not to write, though it was within their power and privilege to do so. Christ said – ‘He that heareth you, heareth Me.’ That is why St. Paul told the Romans (10:17), and says to us alike, that "faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the Word of Christ."

"Was Tertullian, the father of Christian Latin literature, lacking in ‘brains’ when (before there was a formally codified Christian Bible) he called Tradition, the tradition of the Church, ‘the only rule of faith.’ (De Vel. Virg., C. 1)? – ‘the rule which the Church received from the Apostles, the Apostles from Christ, Christ from God’ (Prescript, C.XXXVII)? It was the Church that made the Bible a rule of faith in the days after Tertullian, when a final agreement was reached regarding the Canon of Holy Scripture. But it was the Bible explained by and subject to the traditional teachings of the Church, for the written word must be defined by the authoritative and living voice of the infallible teaching Church." (What Say You? p. 262)

The point is, for a hundred years after the Birth of Christ, there was no Bible. And for nearly four hundred years after the Birth of Christ, the Bible itself wasn’t even compiled into a single book, hence there was no Bible. Not to mention the fact that from that point, to when the printing press was invented in the 15th century, the Bible was not readily accessible to the majority of people.

In addition to the above, I would like to point out that for the 15 centuries between the invention of the printing press and the Birth of Christ, the Scriptures were preserved by the Catholic Church alone(and not by any protestant sect, for there were none during that time period), not to mention the fact that the Bible was written by Catholics (Saints Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Paul, and so forth).

To provide yet another lengthy citation, this one from "Scripture Alone" by Joel Peters, on Sacred Tradition and the protestant theory of "Sola Scriptura":

St. Paul both commends and commands the keeping of oral tradition. In 1 Corinthians 11:2, for instance, we read, "Now I praise you, brethren, that in all things you are mindful of me: and keep my ordinances as I have delivered them to you." (4) St. Paul is obviously commending the keeping of oral tradition here, and it should be noted in particular that he extols the believers for having done so ("I praise you...."). Explicit in this passage is also the fact that the integrity of this Apostolic oral tradition has clearly been maintained, just as Our Lord promised it would be, through the safeguarding of the Holy Spirit (cf. John 16:3).

Perhaps the clearest Biblical support for oral tradition can be found in 2 Thessalonians 2:14(15), where Christians are actually commanded: "Therefore, brethren, stand fast; and hold the traditions which you have learned, whether by word, or by our epistle." This passage is significant in that 1) it shows the existence of living traditions within the Apostolic teaching, b) it tells us unequivocally that believers are firmly grounded in the Faith by adhering to these traditions, and c) it clearly states that these traditions were both written and oral. Since the Bible distinctly states here that oral traditions – authentic and Apostolic in origin – are to be "held" as a valid component of the Deposit of Faith, by what reasoning or excuse do Protestants dismiss them? By what authority do they reject a clear-cut injunction of St. Paul?

Moreover, we must consider the text in this passage. The Greek word krateite, here translated "hold," means "to be strong, mighty, to prevail." This language is rather emphatic, and it demonstrates the importance of maintaining these traditions. Of course one must differentiate between Tradition (upper-case "T") that is part of divine Revelation, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, Church traditions (lower-case "t") that, although good, have developed in the Church later and are not part of the Deposit of Faith. An example of something that is part of Tradition would be infant Baptism; an example of a Church tradition would be the Church’s calendar of feast days of Saints. Anything that is part of Tradition is of divine origin and hence unchangeable, while Church traditions are changeable by the Church. Sacred Tradition serves as a rule of faith by showing what the Church has believed consistently through the centuries and how it is always understood any given portion of the Bible. One of the main ways in which Tradition has been passed down to us is in the doctrine contained in the ancient texts of the liturgy, the Church’s public worship.

it should be noted that Protestants accuse Catholics of promoting "unbiblical" or "novel" doctrines based on Tradition, asserting that such Tradition contains doctrines which are foreign to the Bible. However, this assertion is wholly untrue. The Catholic Church teaches that Sacred Tradition contains nothing whatsoever that is contrary to the Bible. Some Catholic thinkers would even say that there is nothing in Sacred Tradition which is not also found in Scripture, at least implicitly or in seminal form. Certainly the two are at least in perfect harmony and always support each other. For some doctrines, the Church draws more from Tradition than from Scripture for its understanding, but even those doctrines are often implied or hinted at in the Sacred Scripture. For example, the following are largely based on Sacred Tradition: infant Baptism, the canon of Scripture, the perpetual virginity of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Sunday (rather than Saturday) as the Lord’s Day, and the Assumption of Our Lady.

Sacred Tradition complements our understanding of the Bible and is therefore not some extraneous source of Revelation which contains doctrines that are foreign to it. Quite the contrary: Sacred Tradition serves as the Church’s living memory, reminding her of what the faithful have constantly and consistently believed and who to properly understand and interpret the meaning of Biblical passages. In a certain way, it is Sacred Tradition which says to the reader of the Bible "You have been reading a very important book which contains God’s revelation to man. Now let me explain to you how it has always been understood and practiced by believers from the very beginning."

Permit me to take a few moments and refute an erroneous interpretation which is given to a Scripture verse which, in turn, is commonly used in support of the "Sola Scriptura" position, namely 2 Timothy 3:16-17. To cite 2 Timothy 3:16-17:

"All scripture, inspired of God, is profitable to teach, to reprove, to correct, to instruct in justice, that the man of God may be prefect, furnished to every good work." (Douay-Rheims version)

This verse is commonly used in defense of the "Scripture alone" position, but a simple reading of this verse (and the ones preceding it) is sufficient to disprove any such theory. To begin with, a reading of the verses preceding the above shows that the verse is *not* referring to the New Testament, but the Scriptures which St. Timothy knew from his infancy (vs. 15), which was the Old Testament.

Furthermore, even if we were to ignore the verses preceding it, the verse alone, and by itself, states that Scripture is "profitable," not "sufficient," to teach, to reprove, to correct, etc. Hence, the verse is not saying that Scripture alone is sufficient... but, rather, that it is profitable.