4Unity archive

apolo 69

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

WAS THE CATHOLIC CHURCH THE FIRST CHURCH?

     

"No man can find salvation except in the Catholic Church. Outside the Catholic Church one can have everything except salvation. One can have honor, one can have the sacraments, one can sing alleluia, one can answer amen, one can have faith in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, and preach it too, but never can one find salvation except in the Catholic Church." (Saint Augustine died A.D. 430 - Sermo ad Caesariensis Ecclesia plebem - )

A friend of mine sent me an article by Diane Groetz - an apostate Catholic and a popular author on the "Former Catholics For Christ" website - entitled "Was Rome the first church? Read about the Anabaptist.") He said "This article will give a lot of laughs... enjoy! :)" Although the article was certainly not very truthful, my friend’s words were. :)

After reading her article, I thought the lady needed some help so I spent a few hours going over it and answering it, thinking this a good opportunity to spread the truth and clear up the "Trail of Blood" or "Baptist Successionism"   myths. Although this article will probably not do Diane Groetz - author for "Former Catholics For Christ," and webmistress of the page "Apostasy Alert" - any good, but it is my hope that this article will prevent other people from falling for Diane’s deceptions.

"But I confess unto thee, that after the way which THEY CALL HERESY, so worship I the God of my fathers, BELIEVING ALL THINGS WRITTEN IN THE LAW AND IN THE PROPHETS."

(Acts 24:14) (Emphasis Diane’s)

It appears that true believers being called "heretics" is not a new thing. Even Paul was accused of following "heresy".

This is true. St. Paul was accused of heresy... as Catholics have been throughout the centuries, by various sects which have risen for one moment, only to disappear the next. Diane’s version of "Christianity" is no different. Soon enough it, too, will perish..... and Catholicism will be left, as has happened numerous times in the past.

A careful study of history will show that from the time of the Apostles till today, those who would believe "all things written in the law and in the prophets" have been labeled as such. The Montanists, the Paulicians, Donatists, Waldenses, the Anabaptists, all labeled heretics.

I ask the reader to take note of the fact that Diane Groetz presumes to state that the "Montanists, the Paulicians, Donatists, Waldenses, the Anabaptists" were all "true believers." A brief examination of the tenets of the above-mentioned religions is in order.... after which, I will leave it up to the reader to decide whether or not they were "true believers."

The Montanist sect began when Montanus, a recent convert to Christianity appeared in a small village in Phrygia about the year 156. While in the village, Montanus fell into a trance, whereupon he began to prophesy "under the influence of the Spirit." Apparently he was soon joined by two women, Priscilla and Maximilla, who likewise began to "prophesy." Thereafter the movement spread throughout Asia Minor.

To cite the Encyclopedia Britannica:

The essential principle of Montanism was that the Paraclete, the Spirit of truth, whom Jesus had promised in the Gospel According to John, was manifesting himself to the world through Montanus and the prophets and prophetesses associated with him. .... It soon became clear, however, that the Montanist prophecy was new. True prophets did not, as Montanus did, deliberately induce a kind of ecstatic intensity and a state of passivity and then maintain that the words they spoke were the voice of the Spirit. It also became clear that the claim of Montanus to have the final revelation of the Holy Spirit implied that something could be added to the teaching of Christ and the Apostles and that, therefore, the church had to accept a fuller revelation. (Encyclopedia Britannica)

This explicitly contradicts Diane’s own article. To cite Diane:

The gospel did not "develop" or "evolve". It does not change according to the century we live in.

This is true, the Gospel does not "develop" or "evolve".... and yet, if Diane is going to hold that the Montanists are "true believers" then she must hold quite the opposite of what she claimed above. She must hold that "something could be added to the teaching of Christ and the Apostles" and that was the "final revelation of the Holy Spirit" given by Montanus.

As it is, throughout Diane’s article she relies heavily upon the Encyclopedia Britannica. She gives at least three citations from it. Either she must 1) hold that the Encyclopedia Britannica is an unreliable source, and must be discarded... or 2) discard one of the positions which she previously held. Either the Gospel "evolves" and "develops" or it does not. If it does not, than these so-called "true believers" were not believing what had been handed down to them, but had added to the Gospel - in more ways than one.

I ask Diane, or anyone who supports her on this issue, if they honestly believe that these Montanists held the truth which Christ taught? Clearly, if Diane had done her homework, as we presume she had, then we must accept and hold to the belief that the Montanus had received a special "final revelation of the Holy Spirit" which was to be added to the teachings of the Apostles and Christ. If Diane rejects this belief of the Montanists as truly not a Christian belief to be held by all loyal followers of Christ - i.e. heresy -, then how can she claim that they were true believers?

The Paulicians was a most interesting sect that originated in the mid-7th century in Armenia. It’s founder was an Armenian named Constantine, who took the additional name of Silvanus. The Encyclopedia Britannica states again:

The fundamental doctrine of the Paulicians was that there are two principles, an evil God and a good God; the former is the creator and ruler of this world, the latter of the world to come. From this they deduced that Jesus was not truly the son of Mary, because the good God could not have taken flesh and become man. They especially honoured the Gospel According to Luke and the Letters of St. Paul, rejecting the Old Testament and the Letters of St. Peter. They rejected also the sacraments, the worship, and the hierarchy of the established church.

They "claimed a gift of prophecy," keeping this in mind, we remind the reader of the following verse found in the Holy Gospel of St. Mark:

St. Mark 13:22 "There will arise up false prophets, and they will show signs and wonders, to seduce (if possible) even the elect. Take you heed therefore; behold I have foretold you all things."

As the book of St. Jeremias (which the Paulicians rejected, and to whom the Baptists, Diane, and all the other "true believers", claim to be related) tells us:

St. Jeremias 14:14 "The Lord saith to me: The prophets prophesy falsely in my name: I sent them not, neither have I commanded them, nor have I spoken to them: They prophesy unto you a lying vision, and divination and deceit, and the seduction of their own heart."

How can Diane claim that the Paulicians were true believers when 1) they were polytheists, they believed in two gods, 2) they rejected large portions of Sacred Scripture, namely the Old Testament and the Letters of St. Peter, 3) they believed that Christ was not the Son of Mary (Luke 1:31; 1:43; 2:7; 2:48)? Yet again, if Diane had done her homework, which I am assuming she did, then she would have known about all of this and should be able to demonstrate how the belief in two gods, the belief that Christ wasn’t the Son of Mary, and how we should reject the Old Testament and the letters of St. Peter, is a Christian belief and should be held by all. If she cannot demonstrate this, then we must hold that the Paulicians were teaching a non-Christian belief, i.e. heresy. Hence, we must come to one of two conclusions, either 1) Diane did not do her research properly... in which case, we must ask why an ignorant person has taken to writing articles on a subject which she knows nothing about? Or 2) she was motivated by malice and hatred towards the Catholic religion - which isn’t surprising considering the fact that she’s an apostate Catholic -, and was willing to sacrifice the Truth in order to "get back" at the Church for some reason or other. I hope for the sake of Diane that the first case is the true one... but I must not, at the same time, close my eyes to the possibility that the second scenario might be true as well. To paraphrase St. Thomas Aquinas "And that settles the Paulicians!"

The Paulicians were also the cause of quite a bit of political unrest in the Byzantine Empire. As the Encyclopedia Britannica states: "The sect seems to have started a widespread political and military rebellion within the empire shortly after its appearance. Between 668 and 698 Constantine III and Justinian II sent two expeditions to repress it." This alone is sufficient to prove that the Paulicians do not fit the "marks of the New Testament Church" which Diane Groetz put forth in her article. To cite mark 10:

Its weapons of warfare—spiritual, not carnal. (2 Cor.10:4; Eph.6:10-20).

The Donatists were a sect that originated in North Africa that broke with the Roman Catholic Church in the year 312 over the election of the Roman Catholic Caecilian as Bishop of Carthage; their name was derived from their leader, Donatus (d. 355 A.D.). The Donatists accepted the validity and legitimacy of the Sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church, but claimed that personal sin or heresy on the part of the minister administering the Sacraments was one of the things that could render a Sacrament invalid. How can Diane consider the Donatists to be "true believers" when they accept the same Sacraments as the Catholic Church, most of which - or possible all? - Diane rejects?

Founded by Peter Waldo in 12th century France, the Waldensians were broken up into several classes. Firstly, we have the "perfect," and the "Friends or believers."

"Among the Waldenses the perfect, bound by the vow of poverty, wandered about from place to place preaching. Such an itinerant life was ill-suited for the married state, and to the profession of poverty they added the vow of chastity. Married persons who desired to join them were permitted to dissolve their union without the consent of their consort. Orderly government was secured by the additional vow of obedience to superiors. The perfect were not allowed to perform manual labour, but were to depend for their subsistence on the members of the sect known as the friends. These continued to live in the world, married, owned property, and engaged in secular pursuits. Their generosity and alms were to provide for the material needs of the perfect. The friends remained in union with the Catholic Church and continued to receive its sacraments with the exception of penance, for which they sought out, whenever possible, one of their own ministers." (Catholic Encyclopedia 1913)

I ask the reader to take note of the fact that the Waldensians were, for the most part, still in union with the Catholic Church. They received Her Sacraments, took vows of chastity, etc., all of which are rejected by the majority of protestants today, including Diane.

The Waldensians taught that one could divorce ones spouse - even without that spouse’s consent -, which is contrary to the teaching of Christ found in Mark 10:11-12. Furthermore, they held that all marriage was evil. To cite Reinerius Saccho’s, "Of the Sects of Modern Heretics" (1254), on the Waldensians:

"Also, they (the Waldensians) condemn the sacrament of Marriage, saying that married persons sin mortally if they come together without the hope of offspring-also, they disregard compaternity-also, they despise the degrees of affinity, carnal and spiritual, and the impediments of Orders, and of public decency, and of ecclesiastical prohibitions-also, they say that a woman after child-bearing does not require benediction, or introduction-also, they say that the church has erred in prohibiting the marriage of the Clergy, while even those of the East mary - also, they say that the continent do not sin in kisses and embraces."

Not just that, but they had their own Priests who administered the Sacrament of Confession! The organization "Former Catholics For Christ" (hereafter referred to as FCFC) has written extensively against the Sacrament of Confession ( ). How can Diane consider the Waldensians to be "true believers" when they 1) reject the Teachings of Christ found in Mark 10:11-12, 2) accepted all the Sacraments of the Catholic Church including Holy Communion (which FCFC has also written extensively against), 3) had their own ministers who administered the Sacrament of Confession?

To further cite the Catholic Encyclopedia 1913:

"The name Waldenses was at first exclusively reserved to the perfect; but in the course of the thirteenth century the friends were also included in the designation. The perfect were divided into the three classes of bishops, priests, and deacons. The bishop, called "major" or "majoralis", preached and administered the sacraments of penance, Eucharist, and order. The celebration of the Eucharist, frequent perhaps in the early period, soon took place only on Holy Thursday. The priest preached and enjoyed limited faculties for the hearing of confessions. The deacon, named "junior" or "minor", acted as assistant to the higher orders and by the collection of alms relieved them of all material care. The bishop was elected by a joint meeting of priests and deacons. In his consecration, as well as in the ordination of the other members of the clergy, the laying-on of hands was the principal element; but the recitation of the Our Father, so important in the Waldensian liturgy, was also a prominent feature. The power of jurisdiction seems to have been exercised exclusively by one bishop, known as the "rector", who was the highest executive officer. Supreme legislative power was vested in the general convention or general chapter, which met once or twice a year, and was originally composed of the perfect but at a later date only of the senior members among them. It considered the general situation of the sect, examined the religious condition of the individual districts, admitted to the episcopate, priesthood, or diaconate, and pronounced upon the admission of new members and the expulsion of unworthy ones." (Catholic Encyclopedia, 1913)

As can be seen above it is shown that they have Priests, Bishops, Holy Orders, the Sacraments of Confession, and the Eucharist, not to mention the fact that they had a Liturgy. One will note that all of these things are rejected by Diane and FCFC. They have no Liturgy, they have not the Sacraments of Confession, the Eucharist, or Holy Orders, they have no Priests or Bishops. Indeed, it is amazing that they would attempt to claim that they were the Waldensians - or related to them in any way.

Diane herself has written extensively on the "priesthood of Rome," which she rejects as being "unscriptural, presumptious" and she considers the claims "Rome has given her priests" to be "blasphemous," and yet she holds that some groups that had Priests and Bishops from the Roman Catholic Church (the Donatists and the Waldensians) were "true believers."

Further on in her article, Diane Groetz states that one of the marks of the New Testament Church was tithing. To cite her article:

9. Its financial plan—‘even so (tithes and offerings) hath the Lord ordained that they which preach the gospel should live of the gospel’" (1 Cor. 9:14).

And yet, as Reinarius Saccho stated in his book "Of the Sects of Modern Heretics" (1254) in his section on the Waldensians:

"They (the Waldensians) say.... That tithes are not to be given, because first fruits were not given to the church."

Hence, the Waldensians are lacking at least one of the marks of the New Testament Church that Diane Groetz put forth as a requirement. And yet they are considered to be "true believers"? Obviously, these marks are not all that essential.

The anabaptist sect was a violent and "extremely radical body of ecclesiastico-civil reformers which first made its appearance in 1521 at Zwickau, in the present kingdom of Saxony, and still exists in milder forms." (Catholic Encyclopedia, 1913) They were considered radicals and were persecuted by numerous religions, as the following citation shows:

"Luther, who in 1528 had counseled lenience with the new heretics, advised in 1530 ‘the use of the sword’ against them as ‘not only blasphemous but highly seditious’; and Melancthon concurred." ("The Reformation," p. 401)

The Anabaptists also hired their own soldiers, and sponsored an uprising in the province of munster where they established a communistic government, and founded their own version of the monarchy (Cf. "The Reformation," pp. 398-402). This alone is enough to disqualify them according to Diane’s "Marks of the New Testament Church" which states in mark 10 that the New Testament Church endorsed separation of church and state, and yet here we see the Anabaptists forming their own government.

If it is Christian to reject the Old Testament (that Christ Himself and the Apostles cited), as well as portions of the New Testament, then we must hold that it is still Christian to do so. If it is Christian to hold that there are two gods (one of evil and one of good), then we must hold that it is still Christian to do so. If it is Christian to hold the seven Sacraments of the Catholic Church, then we must hold that it is still Christian to do so. If this is so then we must reject Diane Groetz and her "church" for what they are, followers of error, and sons of satan, for they do not believe the same things that their alleged predecessors in the "Christian" religion did, they do not have the same Sacraments as they did, as a matter of fact they don't even accept the same Scriptures! And furthermore, Diane Groetz only accepts one god! She’s not a polytheist as some of her claimed predecessors were! Hence, either Diane is wrong with her beliefs, or she is wrong with her history - no matter where we go, though, she is still wrong, and her article is full of error.

If the religion which Diane Groetz currently holds is Christianity, then we must hold that what Diane claims was early Christianity is false and heretical, for the "early Christianity" (i.e. waldensians, paulicians, etc) taught many things totally different from those taught by Diane now. Whereas, the same holds true if Diane’s "true believers" of the early centuries were "true Christians." For then Diane would have departed from their doctrines, and really can’t claim any form of relation to them at all - for she broke off from their doctrines and formed her own doctrines as well as her own church. Either they are "true believers," or she’s a "true believer," or neither are "true believers." There is no fourth choice.

Diane continues.

Some would argue that indeed, these were heretics. However, one must keep in mind that it was the enemy of these people who wrote their history.

If the enemies "of these people" wrote their history, then how in the world can Diane claim that they were "true believers"? How does she account for the fact that the majority of modern scholars, and even sources which she obviously considers reliable (such as the Encyclopedia Britannica), who have described their belief systems, describe a belief system that is heretical? For example, how can someone believe in two gods, and not be a heretic? Where does Diane get her "true history," and how does she know that it is "true history," despite the fact that most modern scholars disagree with her on this issue?

They have made it appear that these groups were tiny, insignificant splinter groups at variance with the "great united Christian Church", meaning Roman Catholicism. Truth be known, it is Roman Catholicism which teaches heresy and who did not splinter from the true church, but rather was never part of it.

After seeing what sort of "churches" Diane holds as "true churches," even though they 1) contradict her own personal beliefs, 2) contradict the Bible (or, at times, even reject large portions of the Bible), and 3) contradict each other, I am more than happy to say that Roman Catholicism the "great united Christian Church" never partook of their errors, or were parts of their "churches."

Furthermore, I would like to point out that in the above paragraph Diane takes a very arrogant position with regards to the Catholic Church. She presumes that she has the authority to judge the Catholic Church, to judge what is heresy and what is not, and she also seems to think that she is infallible in this regard as well. Since this seems to be the case, I must ask her where she gets her authority, who gave it to her, and how it is that she herself is personally infallible. If she has no authority to judge the Catholic Church heretical, then she has no right to make any such judgment concerning it. If she is not infallible when she makes such judgments, then she might be in error, in which case it is up to the reader to investigate the Catholic Church for himself, and up to her to point out to the reader that she is but a fallible individual stating her personal views on the subject.

But, as it is, Diane seems to have taken the position that the Catholic Church is wrong, it is heretical, it is blasphemous, and she cannot be wrong on this matter at all. This is nothing but simple arrogance and pride, the allies of the devil. Diane’s entire article betrays her anti-Catholic prejudice, even to the point where she is willing to accept false history in order to attack the Catholic Church.

As a matter of fact, their doctrines and teachings are so far from what the Apostles taught,

And the Waldensians, Paulicians, Donatists, and so forth, didn’t teach anything which was contradictory to what the Apostles taught? The Paulicians, for example, rejected the Old Testament - which the Apostles and Christ accepted and cited numerous times - and the Epistles of St. Peter - which were written by an Apostle. The Montanists, as another example, held that the Holy Spirit was finishing the teachings of the Apostles through Montanus - I’d like to see Diane support this using Sacred Scripture.

Furthermore, I would also like to point out that Diane seems to have set herself up as the infallible judge of what the Apostles taught, and how every Church conforms to what they taught. She has no basis other than the Sacred Scriptures, which she received from the Catholic Church and which she has only because of the Catholic Church. She presumes to think that she has the right, the authority, and the infallibility necessary to judge the Most Holy Roman Catholic Church, this she has no right to do.

Diane writes under the impression that she has the true Christian doctrine, and is invested with ample authority to define what is, and what is not, the word of God. She assumes her personal stance on certain doctrines/teachings to be true, and it is proven that Catholicism contradicts it, she concludes at once that Catholicism is false. But her stance on these issues is only her private judgment, and therefore of no authority. By what right does she erect her private judgment into a criterion of truth and falsehood, assume that it is infallible, and proceed to pronounce ex cathedra on the revealed Word of God? I cannot recognize her authority as sovereign pontiff, unless she brings me credentials from heaven, duly signed and witnessed. She is confessedly fallible, and her decisions we cannot even entertain. She does not come to us duly commissioned by Almighty God to teach us His Word; she is simply a woman, with no authority in the premises which may not be claimed and exercised by every other man as well as by herself. In an argument with Catholics she can be only a woman, and is at liberty to adopt no line of argument that would not be equally proper in the case of a pagan, Mohammedan, or any other infidel.

Protestant and non-Catholics who claim to be "Christian" quite often forget this. They assume that they have the Word of God, that they know and believe what God has revealed, and that they have in their opinions a standard by which to try the Church. Regardless of whether or not the Catholic Church is commissioned to declare the Word of God, it is certain that Diane and her fellow protestors are not. It is indeed certain that, if Holy Mother Church is not authorized to declare the Word of God, no one else is; and it is equally certain that no one who is not so authorized has any right to bring forth in an argument any thing he or she takes to be the Word of God, save by the sufferance or consent of his or her opponents.

I shall make my own Diane’s next words:

one must come to the conclusion found in 1 John 2:19:

"They went out from us, but they were not of us: for if they had been of us, they would no doubt HAVE CONTINUED with us: but THEY WENT OUT that they might be made manifest that they were not all of us."

Jeremiah 23:22 shows the impact of those who stand firm in the teachings of the word of God:

"But if they HAD STOOD IN MY COUNSEL, and caused my people to HEAR MY WORDS, then they should have turned them from their evil way, and from the evil of their doings." (Emphasis mine)

Diane continues

If Catholicism would have clung to the true teachings of the Apostles, they would have caused the people to turn from their idolatry and paganism. Instead, they have led multitudes further and deeper into superstition.

And yet, Diane’s own article shows that, in order to avoid Catholicism, she would turn even to the heretics of the early centuries for support. In her hatred for Catholicism, she would turn to those who held that there were two gods, to those who rejected the Old Testament, to those who reject portions of the New Testament, she would turn to those who claimed to be able to add to the Deposit of Faith, in order to be able to attack the Catholic religion. She is willing to walk deeper into superstition, into paganism, in order to get farther away from the Catholic Church. She wishes to distance herself from the Catholic Church at all costs, even though it means taking up false history, calumniating Holy Mother Church, and taking upon herself authority which she does not have, namely that which is necessary for one to be able to judge the Catholic Church and her doctrines and teachings. And yet this is an example of a "true believer"? Would a "true believer" unite himself/herself to false believers and polytheists (II Corinthians 6:14)?

If Roman Catholicism did not originate with the Apostles, where did she originate? We can see the roots of Catholicism in the Bible, but not where one would think!

"But this thou hast, that thou HATEST THE DEEDS OF THE NICOLAITANES, WHICH I HATE ALSO…so hast thou also them that hold the DOCTRINE of the NICOLAITANES, WHICH THING I HATE." (Rev.2:6,15) (Emphasis mine)

For those of you unfamiliar with the term Nicolaitanes, (#3531 in Strong’s Concordance) it is taken from two Greek words: nikos which means "conquest, i.e. (by implication) triumph;-victory" and laos which means "people". Therefore Nicolaitanes means "victorious over the people". This is the sect who wanted to introduce "holy orders" into the church to put men above other men. They had forgotten the words of Paul to the church:

The Nicolaites were a heretical sect founded by the deacon Nicolaus, who was one of those appointed by the Apostles to minister to the poor. Eusebius in his "Ecclesiastical History" points out that they were very short-lived (Book III, XXIX), and, as Eusebius said, "became extinct." Their primary doctrine seems to have been impurity and fornication, as St. Irenaeus said:

"The Nicolaitanes are the followers of that Nicolas who was one of the seven first ordained to the diaconate by the apostles. They lead lives of unrestrained indulgence. The character of these men is very plainly pointed out in the Apocalypse of John, [when they are represented] as teaching that it is a matter of indifference to practise adultery, and to eat things sacrificed to idols. Wherefore the Word has also spoken of them thus: ‘But this thou hast, that thou hatest the deeds of the Nicolaitanes, which I also hate.’" (Adversus Haereses, I, XXVI, III )

This doctrine has always been condemned by the Catholic Church, which condemns adultery. A simple reading of some Catholic Moral Theology books would be sufficient to show this. To claim that the Catholic Church has its roots in such a vile and disgusting sect as the Nicolaites is something utterly ridiculous, especially when one considers the fact that the Catholic Church condemns the doctrines of the Nicolaites and the Nicolaites themselves.

As far as Diane’s theory concerning "holy orders" goes, I have been unable to locate any statement which might have even hinted at such a thing. The title of their sect does not mean that they held a form of "holy orders" at all. And considering Diane’s past track record with regards to the Early Sects, one is almost bound to hold this statement of hers with the utmost suspicion, especially considering the fact that Diane obviously has no wish to do any real research on what she teaches, just so long as what she teaches is anti-Catholic.

"And these things, brethren, I have in a figure transferred to myself and to Apollos for your sakes; that ye might learn in us not to think of men above that which is written, that no one of you be puffed up for one against another."

(1Cor.4:6 )

Diane cites this verse as if it contradicted the Catholic hierarchy of authority, but this is not so. As the Haydock Bible says concerning this verse:

"These things, brethren, I have in a figure transferred to myself and to Apollo. Lit. these things have I transfigured in me and Apollo, that is, I have represented the divisions and disputes among you, as if it were by your contending, whether I, or Apollo, or Cephas were the best preachers, without naming those, as I might do, who are the true causes of these divisions, by striving who should be thought men of the greatest and brightest parts. – That in us, and by our example, who have no such proud disputes, you might learn that one be not puffed up against the other, and above that which is written, against the admonitions given in the Holy Scriptures of being humble: or against what I have now written to you, that we must strive for nothing, but to be the faithful ministers of God, and not seek the esteem of men." (Haydock Bible, Vol. II, p. 216)

Should Diane wish to contest the interpretation of the verse in question in the above-given citation from the Haydock Bible, then let her 1) explain where the above-given interpretation is mistaken, 2) why we should accept her personal interpretation and not the one given in the Haydock Bible, 3) how we can be certain that her interpretation is correct, and that she is not in error regarding the interpretation of the verse in question - i.e. whether or not she is infallible.

But, as it is, I shall put another interpretation/application to the verse. It preaches humility, and yet Diane’s entire article speaks of pride and arrogance. What she personally holds is true, all else is false. Catholicism is wrong, no matter what, and she is right. Diane might not have the authority to declare what is right or wrong with regards to doctrine and doctrinal teachings, but she will do so anyways, because the Catholic Church must be wrong no matter what. It cannot be right. This is pure arrogance, and something completely contrary to the humility referred to in the verse Diane cited. It is pure hypocrisy for her to cite that verse, and then continue acting in the arrogant manner which she has adopted.

Revelation 2:15, when speaking of the doctrine of the Nicolaitanes, is a reference to the notion of a dominating priesthood that would, and did, creep into the hierarchy of the church, just as Jesus prophesied.

In the first place, as pointed out above, Diane has no right to declare to Catholics what any verse in the Sacred Scriptures mean. She has no authority to do so, and she has not the necessary learning and knowledge to do so (as is evidenced by her false history). In the second place, the chapter to which Diane refers doesn’t even mention the priesthood, or that arrogance and domination was a doctrine of the Nicolaitanes - though it is quite interesting to note that Diane’s entire article is full of arrogance and domination. The chapter states explicitly that one of the doctrines of the Nicolaites was fornication, and yet the Catholic Church condemns this doctrine whole-heartedly. Diane has yet to prove that the Nicolaites are related to the Catholic Church and that they have crept into the hierarchy of the Christian Church and have remained there for nearly 2,000 years. All she has done is make conclusions. The Nicolaites "did creep into the hierarchy of the Church," why? Because Diane says so. Where’s her proof? And furthermore, where’s her proof that the current hierarchy of the Christian Church is related to them? Can she trace them all the way up to the present time?

According to The New Concise Bible Dictionary the Nicolaitanes "compromised with paganism", which is exactly what history proves to be true of Catholicism. She herself admits to this:

"Temples, incense, oil lamps, votive offerings, holy water, holydays, and seasons of devotion, processions, blessing of fields, sacerdotal vestments, the tonsure (of priests, monks and nuns), images, are all of pagan origin" (The Development of the Christian Religion , Cardinal Newman, 359) (Emphasis mine).

In the first place, a book written by Cardinal Newman is hardly an official pronouncement of the Catholic Church. It is not an official statement of the Catholic Church. In the second place, Diane has modified the citation to fit her personal agenda, and to prejudice against anything Catholic. This is complete dishonesty, and shows that Diane is not above resorting to deception in order to "get her point across" and "convince" her readers that the Catholic Church is evil. To provide the REAL citation:

"The use of temples, and these dedicated to particular saints, and ornamented on occasions with branches of trees; incense, lamps, and candles; votive offerings on recovery from illness; holy water; asylums; holydays and seasons, use of calendars, processions, blessings on the fields; sacerdotal vestments, the tonsure, the ring in marriage, turning to the East, images at a later date, perhaps the ecclesiastical chant, and the Kyrie Eleison, are all of pagan origin, and sanctified by their adoption into the Church."

This listing is quite a bit longer than Diane’s, and says quite a bit about Diane’s dishonesty. Take the portion about the "ring in marriage," which is said by Cardinal Newman to be of pagan origin. This would mean that the vast majority (if not all) so-called Christian religions are making use of pagan practices in their wedding ceremonies. The use of calendars is also said to be of pagan origin, and yet I have yet to see a non-Catholic who claims to be "Christian" who doesn’t use a calendar. As far as images are concerned, their usage goes much further back than just the Catholic Church. They can be traced back, ultimately, to the Old Testament, as the Catholic Encyclopedia pointed out. "Holydays and seasons" can also be traced back to the Hebrew religion. The Jews used to observe numerous "Holydays and seasons," in fact, they still do so. This must mean that they are all false religions, based upon paganism, and that their members are going to hell.

Not only does Roman Catholicism admit that her practices are of pagan origin, but also that her dogma is.

In the first place, as stated above, the citation from Cardinal Newman is hardly an official declaration of the Roman Catholic Church. In the second place, the citation, as given by Diane, does not state that her practices are of pagan origin, but only that certain practices are, all of which are truly non-essentials and it really would not matter if they were. It would not prove that the Catholic Church is not of Divine origin, nor would it prove that the Catholic Church is false. In the third place, the below citation does not state that Dogmas are of pagan origin. It is a blatant mis-representation of Catholicism to claim that she teaches such a horrible thing. This is most certainly not a tenet of the Catholic religion.

"Or again, dogma is like a cathedral stil in process of construction; so far we cannot grasp its exact proportions; only the nave is completed; we still have to wait for the placing of the last stone"

(The Virgin Mary, Guitton, III)

This is true, insofar as it is understood to mean that things are perpetually being defined by Holy Mother Church. But the Catholic Church does not invent dogma, nor does she create new teachings. She does not add the deposit of Faith as passed down to us by the Apostles. As The New Catholic Dictionary, Vatican Edition, says:

Dogma, ... a truth appertaining to faith or morals, revealed by God, transmitted by the Apostles in the Scriptures or tradition, and proposed by the Church as an article of faith, to be accepted by the faithful. ... The dogmas of the Church, being the intellectual conception and verbal expression of Divine truth, naturally take on the characteristic of truth, viz., unchangeableness or immutability. (The New Catholic Dictionary, p. 304)

The Dogmas of the Catholic Church are unchanging. New ones might be defined, but not in the sense that they are new in and of themselves, but that they were recently defined. Furthermore, the above citation also disagrees with Diane concerning the "pagan origin" of the Dogmas of Holy Mother Church.

This is diametrically opposed to the word of God which states:

"Beloved, when I gave all diligence to write unto you of the common salvation, it was needful for me to write unto you, and exhort you that ye should earnestly contend for the faith once delivered unto the saints ." (Jude.3:1)

Only if one is operating from a misrepresentation of the Catholic Church. As The New Catholic Dictionary stated above, Dogmas are "transmitted by the Apostles in the Scriptures or tradition." The above verse does not oppose this at all, in fact, it supports it! This is an example of the fact that Diane is not infallible, but can make mistakes, and is so blinded by her own anti-Catholicism that she won’t even take the trouble to find out what we truly believe, but must operate from her own anti-Catholic prejudices and misrepresent the Catholic religion.

The gospel did not "develop" or "evolve". It does not change according to the century we live in. Paul clearly tells us that he has not "shunned to declare unto you ALL the counsel of God," not just part of it. (Acts 20:27)

I agree. The Gospel does not develop or evolve, and it does not change according to the century we live in. The above citation given by Diane does not state that it does, and the Catholic Church does not teach that it does. This is a complete fabrication of Diane’s anti-Catholic imagination. Diane continues.

The Encyclopedia Britannica

, 15th edition, 1984, vol. 4:

"The DEVELOPMENT of the Western notion ...of the priesthood is also dominated by legal concept...In the sphere of this kind of legal thinking the papacy and the doctrine of the papal primacy DEVELOPED. The idea of a jurisdictional primacy played a prominent role in the FORMATION OF THE DOCTRINE OF THE PAPACY...On the basis of this legal consciousness the Western church also DEVELOPED its own canon law...Judicial thinking was similarly significant in the theology of the West, TERTULLIAN, (200) INTRODUCED a series of fundamental juridical concepts into theology...Through indulgences, requiems, and other acts, the church expanded its spiritual-judicial authority even to this realm of the departed souls of purgatory…‘There EVOLVED the concept of CAESAROPAPISM...The Roman popes used this power, which was in fact allotted to them by circumstances, to DEVELOP a specific ecclesiastical state and to base this state upon a new theocratic ideology—the idea that the pope was the representative of Christ and the successor of Peter’"(508-509) (Emphasis mine).

"legal concept" "Judicial thinking" "canon law" "judicial authority" "ecclesiastical state" The above citation is referring to temporal political developments, and we have no problem admitting that the political position of the Catholic Church - as well as it’s judicial concepts - did develop over a period of time. But since these are not relevant to the spiritual position of the Papacy, or the spiritual authority of the Church, I really don’t know where Diane is going with this. Insofar as the position of the Papacy is concerned, reliable historians - Diane not included - are more than willing to testify to the fact that it existed before Constantine, as the following citation shows:

"The Empire within the Empire.—Long before the fall of Rome there had begun to grow up within the Roman Empire an ecclesiastical state, which in its constitution and its administrative system was shaping itself upon the imperial model. This spiritual empire, like the secular empire, possessed a hierarchy of officers, of which deacons, priests or prebyters, and bishops were the most important. The bishops collectively formed what is know as the episcopate. There were four grades of bishops, namely, country bishops, city bishops, metropolitans or archbishops, and patriarchs. At the end of the third century there were five patriarchates, that is, regions ruled by patriarchs. These centered in the great cities of Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem.

"Among the patriarchs, the patriarchs of Rome were accorded almost universally a precedence in honor and dignity. They claimed further a precedence in authority and jurisdiction, and this was already very widely recognized ...Besides the influence of great men, such as Leo the Great, Gregory the Great, and Nicholas I, who held the seat of St. Peter, there were various historical circumstances that contributed to the realization by the Roman bishops of their claim to supremacy and aided them vastly in establishing the almost universal authority of the see of Rome. In the following paragraphs we shall enumerate several of these favoring circumstances. These matters constitute the great landmarks in the rise and early growth of the Papacy.

The belief in the Primacy of St. Peter and in the Founding by him of the Church at Rome.—The Catholic Church teaches that the apostle Peter was given by the Master primacy among his fellow apostles and, furthermore, that Christ intrusted that disciple with the keys of the kingdom of heaven and invested him with superlative authority as teacher and interpreter of the Word by the commission "Feed my sheep"; . . ."feed my lambs," thus giving into his charge the entire flock of the Church. It also teaches that the apostle Peter himself founded the church at Rome. Without doubt he preached at Rome and suffered martyrdom there under the Emperor Nero.

"The Pastor as Protector of Rome.—With the advent of the barbarians there came another occasion for the Roman bishops to widen their influence and enhance their authority. Rome’s extremity was their opportunity. Thus it will be recalled how mainly through the intercession of the pious Pope Leo the Great the fierce Attila was persuaded to turn back and spare the imperial city; and how the same bishop, in the year A.D. 455, also appeased in a measure the wrath of the Vandal Geiseric and shielded the inhabitants from the worst passions of a barbarian soldiery...

"Thus when the emperors, the natural defenders of the capital, were unable to protect it, the unarmed Pastor was able, through the awe and reverence inspired by his holy office, to render services that could not but result in bringing increased honor and dignity to the Roman see." (Mediaeval and Modern History, By Myers, Pg 26-27 Ginn and Company New York, 1905 )

Diane continues.

Once again, Rome herself admits:

"Writers of the fourth century were prone to describe many practices as apostolic institutions which certainly had no claim to be so regarded" (Catholic Encyclopedia, III, 484) (Emphasis mine).

Diane again shows herself to be unable to distinguish between the writings of various Catholic individuals, and the Catholic Church herself. A statement in the Catholic Encyclopedia is not an official statement of the Catholic Church at all. To claim that it is, is to misrepresent the Catholic Faith. In fact, the Encyclopedia itself also admits that it was printed in New York, and not Rome (Heh! :). Secondly, the above-given citation is taken completely out of context, and has been modified to fit Diane’s arguments (which is one reason why I doubt the accuracy of other citations which Diane gives). The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. III, p. 484, states:

"Writers in the fourth century were prone to describe many practices (e.g. the Lenten fast of forty days) as of Apostolic institution which certainly had no claim to be so regarded." (Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. III, p. 484 emphasis mine)

In the above citation it makes it clear that it is not referring to doctrinal or dogmatic issues, but disciplinary issues such as the Lenten fast. This does not concern the teachings of the Catholic Church at all. The citation given by Diane has also been modified to obscure this fact - that is to be found even in the online version of the Encyclopedia ( ). I have no idea what Diane could have done to the other citations which she has given.

Though God has always had a people, and a remnant would always remain that did not bow to paganism: That such a religious system as the papacy would overtake the church, was the prophecy of Jesus, and that is exactly what happened! At first, the church was able to resist, but later it could not; because she let her guard down and did not "earnestly contend for the faith once delivered". The church had forgotten the warning from the apostles:

The Papacy has been in place in the Christian Church since the earliest times, much as Diane would wish it otherwise - and considering Diane’s ridiculous claims that the Paulicians (for one example) were "true believers" and were the predecessors of whatever church she claims to follow, I wouldn’t put much stock in her statement that the Papacy "overtook the church." That the Papacy was founded by Christ has been proven again and again by various Catholic Apologists, and I will not go into it here. As it is, I would recommend the following articles by Catholics if one wishes to examine the issue more deeply:

The Catholic Encyclopedia ( )

The Pre-eminence of St. Peter - 50 New Testament Proofs ( )

"Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I shall build My Church" ( )

For those who wish to see what the Early Church taught concerning the primacy of the Papacy, I recommend that the reader visit the "Corunum" Catholic Apologetics website ( ).

"For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock. Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears."

(Acts 20:29-31)

The citation given above by Diane does not necessarily refer to the Papacy, nor does it necessarily refer to Catholicism as being the wolves. There are many various interpretations which can be given to it, one of which is that Diane’s "true believers" were the ones being warned against in that verse.

It wasn’t long before those who held to the deeds of the Nicolaitanes finally gained the upper hand in the visible (but not true) church.

As Eusebius stated "At this time the so-called sect of the Nicolaitans made its appearance and lasted for a very short time." (Book III, XXIX). And furthermore, if the "visible" church was not the True Church, that meant that the True Church was invisible. This is sort of like the ghost man on third base theory, or, rather, ghost church. If it was invisible, how in the word does Diane know that it was even in existence at that time? It is also interesting to note that Diane also admits that the Roman Catholic Church was the only visible Church in existence at this point.

During the first century after Christ Jesus, the persecution endured by the Christian church kept it relatively pure and free from error;

In the first place, it is not "persecutions" which kept the Church free from error, it was because of the Teachings and Guidance of God and the Apostles that the Church was kept free from error, and still is kept so. Matthew 16:18 shows that the Church herself is a Divine Institution, with a structure authorized by Christ. In order to keep it free and pure from all errors. Christ Himself said that He would with it until the end of time. Unlike Diane, we Catholics know that it was God who keeps His Church free from error, and not persecutions waged by pagan empires. Hence, we give the credit to the God, and not to pagans as Diane would wish us to do.

Secondly, the Early Christian Church, yes, even the Church of the first century, accepted the Primacy of the Popes. As the following citations show:

"The church of God which sojourns at Rome to the church of God which sojourns at Corinth ... But if any disobey the words spoken by him through us, let them know that they will involve themselves in transgression and in no small danger." Clement of Rome,Pope,1st Epistle to the Corinthians,1,59:1 (c.A.D. 96)

"Ignatius, who is also called Theophorus, to the Church which has obtained mercy, through the majesty of the Mast High God the Father, and of Jesus Christ, His only-begotten Son; the Church which is sanctified and enlightened by the will of God, who farmed all things that are according to the faith and love of Jesus Christ, our God and Saviour; the Church which presides in the place of the region of the Romans, and which is worthy of God, worthy of honour, worthy of the highest happiness, worthy of praise, worthy of credit, worthy of being deemed holy, and which presides over love..." Ignatius of Antioch, Epistle to the Romans, Prologue (A.D. 110)

"There is extant also another epistle written by Dionysius to the Romans, and addressed to Soter, who was bishop at that time. We cannot do better than to subjoin some passages from this epistle, in which he commends the practice of the Romans which has been retained down to the persecution in our own days. His words are as follows: For from the beginning it has been your practice to do good to all the brethren in various ways, and to send contributions to many churches in every city. Thus relieving the want of the needy, and making provision for the brethren in the mines by the gifts which you have sent from the beginning, you Romans keep up the hereditary customs of the Romans, which your blessed bishop Soter has not only maintained, but also added to, furnishing an abundance of supplies to the saints, and encouraging the brethren from abroad with blessed words, as a loving father his children.' In this same epistle he makes mention also of Clement's epistle to the Corinthians, showing that it had been the custom from the beginning to read it in the church. His words are as follows: To-day we have passed the Lord's holy day, in which we have read your epistle. From it, whenever we read it, we shall always be able to draw advice, as also from the former epistle, which was written to us through Clement.' The same writer also speaks as follows concerning his own epistles, alleging that they had been mutilated: As the brethren desired me to write epistles, I wrote. And these epistles the apostles of the devil have filled with tares, cutting out some things and adding others. For them a woe is reserved. It is, therefore, not to be wondered at if some have attempted to adulterate the Lord's writings also, since they have formed designs even against writings which are of less accounts.' " Dionysius of Corinth, To Pope Soter(A.D. 171)

"Since, however, it would be very tedious, in such a volume as this, to reckon up the successions of all the Churches, we do put to confusion all those who, in whatever manner, whether by an evil self-pleasing, by vainglory, or by blindness and perverse opinion, assemble in unauthorized meetings; [we do this, I say,] by indicating that tradition derived from the apostles, of the very great, the very ancient, and universally known Church founded and organized at Rome by the two most glorious apostles, Peter and Paul; as also [by pointing out] the faith preached to men, which comes down to our time by means of the successions of the bishops. For it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its pre- eminent authority, that is, the faithful everywhere, inasmuch as the apostolical tradition has been preserved continuously by those [faithful men] who exist everywhere." Irenaeus,Against Heresies,3:3:2 (A.D. 180)

"A question of no small importance arose at that time. For the parishes of all Asia, as from an older tradition, held that the fourteenth day of the moon, on which day the Jews were commanded to sacrifice the lamb, should be observed as the feast of the Saviour's passover. It was therefore necessary to end their fast on that day, whatever day of the week it should happen to be. But it was not the custom of the churches in the rest of the world to end it at this time, as they observed the practice which, from apostolic tradition, has prevailed to the present time, of terminating the fast on no other day than on that of the resurrection of our Saviour...Thereupon Victor, who presided over the church at Rome, immediately attempted to cut off from the common unity the parishes of all Asia, with the churches that agreed with them, as heterodox; and he wrote letters and declared all the brethren there wholly excommunicate.But this did not please all the bishops. And they besought him to consider the things of peace, and of neighborly unity and love. Words of theirs are extant, sharply rebuking Victor. Among them was Irenaeus, who, sending letters in the name of the brethren in Gaul over whom he presided, maintained that the mystery of the resurrection of the Lord should be observed only on the Lord's day. He fittingly admonishes Victor that he should not cut off whole churches of God which observed the tradition of an ancient custom ..." Pope Victor & Easter(c.A.D. 195)

"And he says to him again after the resurrection, 'Feed my sheep.' It is on him that he builds the Church, and to him that he entrusts the sheep to feed. And although he assigns a like power to all the apostles, yet he founded a single Chair, thus establishing by his own authority the source and hallmark of the (Church's) oneness. No doubt the others were all that Peter was, but a primacy is given to Peter, and it is (thus) made clear that there is but one flock which is to be fed by all the apostles in common accord. If a man does not hold fast to this oneness of Peter, does he imagine that he still holds the faith? If he deserts the Chair of Peter upon whom the Church was built, has he still confidence that he is in the Church? This unity firmly should we hold and maintain, especially we bishops, presiding in the Church, in order that we may approve the episcopate itself to be the one and undivided." Cyprian, The Unity of the Church,4-5 (Primacy Text,A.D. 251/256)

"After such things as these, moreover, they still dare--a false bishop having been appointed for them by, heretics--to set sail and to bear letters from schismatic and profane persons to the throne of Peter, and to the chief church whence priestly unity takes its source; and not to consider that these were the Romans whose faith was praised in the preaching of the apostle, to whom faithlessness could have no access." Cyprian, To Cornelius, Epistle 54/59:14(A.D. 252)

"For Dionysius, Bishop of Rome, having written also against those who said that the Son of God was a creature and a created thing, it is manifest that not now for the first time but from of old the heresy of the Arian adversaries of Christ has been anathematised by all. And Dionysius, Bishop of Alexandria, making his defence concerning the letter he had written, appears in his turn as neither thinking as they allege, nor having held the Arian error at all." Athanasius, Dionysius of Rome,13 (A.D. 352)

"Supposing, as you assert, that some offence rested upon those persons, the case ought to have been conducted against them, not after this manner, but according to the Canon of the Church. Word should have been written of it to us all , that so a just sentence might prceed from all. For the sufferers were Bishops, and Churches of no ordinary note, but those which the Apostles themselves had governed in their own persons. And why was nothing said to us concerning the Church of the Alexandrians in particular? Are you ignorant that the custom has been for word to be written first to us, and then for a just decision to be passed from this place? If then any such suspicion rested upon the Bishop there, notice thereof ought to have been sent to the Church of this place; whereas, after neglecting to inform us, and proceeding on their own authority as they pleased, now they desire to obtain our concurrence in their decisions, though we never condemned him. Not so have the constitutions of Paul, not so have the traditions of the Fathers directed; this is another form of procedure, a novel practice. I beseech you, readily bear with me: what I write is for the common good. For what we have received from the blessed Apostle Peter, that I signify to you; and I should not have written this, as deeming that these things were manifest unto all men, had not these proceedings so disturbed us." Athanasius, Pope Julius to the Eusebians,Defense Against the Arians, 35(A.D. 347)

Athanasius attended and sanctioned the deliberations of the Council of Sardica and referred to the Council of Sardica as "the great Council" (Defense Against the Arians 1) or "the Holy Synod" (Letter to the People of Antioch 5)

"Bishop Hosius said: This also it is necessary to add, that no bishop pass from his own province to another province in which there are bishops, unless indeed he be called by his brethren, that we seem not to close the gates of charity. And this case likewise is to be provided for, that if in any province a bishop has some matter against his brother and fellow-bishop, neither of the two should call in as arbiters bishops from another province. But if perchance sentence be given against a bishop in any matter and he supposes his case to be not unsound but good, in order that the question may be reopened, let us, if it seem good to your charity, honour the memory of Peter the Apostle, and let those who gave judgment write to Julius, the bishop of Rome, so that, if necessary, the case may be retried by the bishops of the neighbouring provinces and let him appoint arbiters; but if it cannot be shown that his case is of such a sort as to need a new trial, let the judgment once given not be annulled, but stand good as before." Council of Sardica, Canon III (A.D. 343/344)

"Bishop Gaudentius said: If it seems good to you, it is necessary to add to this decision full of sincere charity which thou hast pronounced, that if any bishop be deposed by the sentence of these neighbouring bishops, and assert that he has fresh matter in defence, a new bishop be not settled in his see, unless the bishop of Rome judge and render a decision as to this."

Council of Sardica, Canon IV (A.D. 343/344)

"Bishop Hosius said: Decreed, that if any bishop is accused, and the bishops of the same region assemble and depose him from his office, and he appealing, so to speak, takes refuge with the most blessed bishop of the Roman church, and he be willing to give him a hearing, and think it right to renew the examination of his case, let him be pleased to write to those fellow-bishops who are nearest the province that they may examine the particulars with care and accuracy and give their votes on the matter in accordance with the word of truth. And if any one require that his case be heard yet again, and at his request it seem good to move the bishop of Rome to send presbyters a latere, let it be in the power of that bishop, according as he judges it to be good and decides it to be right that some be sent to be judges with the bishops and invested with his authority by whom they were sent. And be this also ordained. But if he think that the bishops are sufficient for the examination and decision of the matter let him do what shall seem good in his most prudent judgment. The bishops answered: What has been said is approved." Council of Sardica,Canon V (A.D. 343/344)

"What we have always believed, that we now know, for experience is proving and confirming for each of us what he has heard with his ears. It is true what the Apostle Paul, the most blessed teacher of the Gentiles, said of himself: 'Do ye seek a proof of him who speaks in me?' For, since the Lord Christ dwelt in him, there can be no doubt that the Spirit spoke by through his soul and animated the instrument of his body. And thus you, dearly beloved brother, though distant in body, have been with us in unison of mind and will. The reason for your absence was both honorable and imperative, that the schismatic wolves might not rob and plunder by stealth nor the heretical dogs bark madly in the rapid fury nor the very serpent, the devil, discharge his blasphemous venom. So it seems to us right and altogether fitting that priests of the Lord from each and every province should report to their head, that is, to the See of Peter, the Apostle." Council of Sardica, To Pope Julius (A.D. 342)

"You cannot deny that you know that in the city of Rome the Chair was first conferred on Peter, in which the prince of all the Apostles, Peter,sat ... in which Chair unity should be preserved by all, so that he should now be a schismatic and a sinner who should set up another Chair against that unique one." Optatus of Mileve, The Schism of Donatists,2:2-3 (c.A.D. 367)

"For the good of unity Blessed Peter deserved to be preferred before the rest, and alone received the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven, that he might communicate them to the rest." Optatus of Mileve, The Schism of Donatists,7:3 (c.A.D. 367)

"Yet, at the very outset, error was so far set right by the bishops on whom the attempt was made at Ariminum to compel them to manipulate or innovate on the faith, that they confessed themselves seduced by opposite arguments, or owned that they had not perceived any contradiction to the opinion of the Fathers livered at Nicaea. No prejudice could arise from the number of bishops gathered at Ariminum, since it is well known that neither the bishop of the Romans, whose opinion ought before all others to have been waited for, nor Vincentius, whose stainless episcopate had lasted so many years, nor the rest, gave in their adhesion to such doctrines. And this is the more significant, since, as has been already said, the very men who seemed to be tricked into surrender, themselves, in their wiser moments, testified their disapproval." Pope Damasus[regn. A.D. 366-384],About Council at Arminum,Epistle 1 (A.D. 371)

"Since the East, shattered as it is by the long-standing feuds, subsisting between its peoples, is bit by bit tearing into shreds the seamless vest of the Lord, woven from the top throughout,' since the foxes are destroying the vineyard of Christ, and since among the broken cisterns that hold no water it is hard to discover the sealed fountain' and the garden inclosed,' I think it my duty to consult the chair of Peter, and to turn to a church whose faith has been praised by Paul. I appeal for spiritual food to the church whence I have received the garb of Christ. The wide space of sea and land that lies between us cannot deter me from searching for the pearl of great price.' Wheresoever the body is, there will the eagles be gathered together.' Evil children have squandered their patrimony; you alone keep your heritage intact. The fruitful soil of Rome, when it receives the pure seed of the Lord, bears fruit an hundredfold; but here the seed corn is choked in the furrows and nothing grows but darnel or oats. In the West the Sun of righteousness is even now rising; in the East, Lucifer, who fell from heaven, has once more set his throne above the stars. Ye are the light of the world,' ye are the salt of the earth,' ye are "vessels of gold and of silver." Here are vessels of wood or of earth, which wait for the rod of iron,and eternal fire. Yet, though your greatness terrifies me, your kindness attracts me. From the priest I demand the safe-keeping of the victim, from the shepherd the protection due to the sheep. Away with all that is overweening; let the state of Roman majesty withdraw. My words are spoken to the successor of the fisherman, to the disciple of the cross. As I follow no leader save Christ, so I communicate with none but your blessedness, that is with the chair of Peter. For this, I know, is the rock on which the church is built! This is the house where alone the paschal lamb can be rightly eaten. This is the ark of Noah, and he who is not found in it shall perish when the flood prevails. But since by reason of my sins I have betaken myself to this desert which lies between Syria and the uncivilized waste, I cannot, owing to the great distance between us, always ask of your sanctity the holy thing of the Lord. Consequently I here follow the Egyptian confessors who share your faith, and anchor my frail craft under the shadow of their great argosies. I know nothing of Vitalis; I reject Meletius; I have nothing to do with Paulinus. He that gathers not with you scatters; he that is not of Christ is of Antichrist." Jerome, To Pope Damasus, Epistle 15:1-2(A.D. 375)

"But he was not so eager as to lay aside caution. He called the bishop to him, and esteeming that there can be no true thankfulness except it spring from true faith, he enquired whether he agreed with the Catholic bishops, that is, with the Roman Church?" Ambrose, The death of his brother Satyrus,1:47(A.D. 378)

"Your grace must be besought not to permit any disturbance of the Roman Church, the head of the whole Roman World and of the most holy faith of the Apostles, for from thence flow out to all(churches) the bonds of sacred communion." Ambrose, To Emperor Gratian,Epistle 11:4(A.D. 381)

"To your inquiry we do not deny a legal reply, because we, upon whom greater zeal for the Christian religion is incumbent than upom the whole body, out of consideration for our office do not have the liberty to dissimulate, nor to remain silent. We carry the weight of all who are burdened; nay rather the blessed apostle Peter bears these in us, who, as we trust, protects us in all matters of his administration, and guards his heirs." Pope Sircius[regn. A.D. 384-399],To Himerius,Epistle 1(A.D. 385)

"Or rather, if we hear him here, we shall certainly see him hereafter, if not as standing near him, yet see him we certainly shall, glistening near the Throne of the king. Where the Cherubim sing the glory, where the Seraphim are flying, there shall we see Paul, with Peter, and as a chief and leader of the choir of the Saints, and shall enjoy his generous love. For if when here he loved men so, that when he had the choice of departing and being with Christ, he chose to be here, much more will he there display a warmer affection. I love Rome even for this, although indeed one has other grounds for praising it, both for its greatness, and its antiquity, and its beauty, and its populousness, and for its power, and its wealth, and for its successes in war. But I let all this pass, and esteem it blessed on this account, that both in his lifetime he wrote to them, and loved them so, and talked with them whiles he was with us, and brought his life to a close there. Wherefore the city is more notable upon this ground, than upon all others together. And as a body great and strong, it hath as two glistening eyes the bodies of these Saints. Not so bright is the heaven, when the sun sends forth his rays, as is the city of Rome, sending out these two lights into all parts of the world. From thence will Paul be caught up, from thence Peter. Just bethink you, and shudder (frixate) at the thought of what a sight Rome will see, when Paul ariseth suddenly from that deposit, together with Peter, and is lifted up to meet the Lord. (1 Thess. iv. 17.) What a rose will Rome send up to Christ! (Is. xxxv. 1) what two crowns will the city have about it! what golden chains will she be girded with! what fountains possess! Therefore I admire the city, not for the much gold, not for the columns, not for the other display there, but for these pillars of the Church. (1 Cor. xv. 38.) Would that it were now given me to throw myself round (pericuqhnai) the body of Paul, and be riveted to the tomb, and to see the dust of that body that "filled up that which was lacking" after "Christ" Col. i. 24), that bore "the marks" (stigmata,) (Gal. vi. 17) that sowed the Gospel everywhere yea, the dust of that body through which he ran to and fro everywhere!" Chrysostom, Epistle to the Romans, Homily 32:24(c.A.D. 391)

"Number the bishops from the See of Peter itself. And in that order of Fathers see who has succeeded whom. That is the rock against which the gates of hell do not prevail" Augustine, Psalm against the Party of Donatus,18(A.D. 393)

"I am held in the communion of the Catholic Church by...and by the succession of bishops from the very seat of Peter, to whom the Lord, after His resurrection commended His sheep to be fed up to the present episcopate." Augustine, Against the Letter of Mani,5(A.D. 395)

"Carthage was also near the countries over the sea, and distinguished by illustrious renown,so that it had a bishop of more than ordinary influence, who could afford to disregard a number of conspiring enemies because he saw himself joined by letters of communion to the Roman Church, in which the supremacy of an apostolic chair has always flourished" Augustine, To Glorius et.al, Epistle 43:7(A.D. 397)

"If the lineal succession of bishops is to be considered with how much more benefit to the Church do we reckon from Peter himself, to whom, as bearing in a figure the whole Church, the Lord said: Upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not conquer it!' For to Peter succeeded Linus,Clement...Damsus, Sircius, Anastasius. In this order of succession no Donatist bishop is too be found." Augustine, To Generosus, Epistle 53:2(A.D. 400)

"The chair of the Roman Church, in which Peter sat, and in which Anastasius sits today." Augustine, Against the Letters of Petillian,2:51(A.D. 402)

"In making inquiry with respect to those things that should be treated with all solicitude by bishops, and especially by a true and just and Catholic Council, by preserving, as you have done, the example of ancient tradition, and by being mindful of ecclesiastical discipline, you have truly strengthened the vigour of our religion, no less now in consulting us than before in passing sentence. For you decided that it was proper to refer to our judgement, knowing what is due to the Apostolic See, since all we who are set in this place, desire to follow the Apostle from the very episcopate and whole authority of this name is derived. Following in his footsteps, we know how to condemn the evil and to approve the good. So also, you have by your sacredotal office preserve the customs of the Fathers, and have not spurned that which they decreed by a divine and not human sentence, that whatsoever is done, even though it be in distant provinces, should not be ended without being brought to the knowledge of this See, that by its authority the whole just pronouncement should be strengthened, and that from it all other Churches (like waters flowing from their natal source and flowing through the different regions of the world, the pure streams of one incorrupt head),should receive what they ought to enjoin, whom they ought to wash, and whom that water, worthy of pure bodies, should avoid as defiled with uncleansable filth. I congratulate you, therefore, dearest brethren, that you have directed letters to us by our brother and fellow-bishop Julius, and that, while caring for the Churches which you rule, you also show your solicitude for the well-being of all, and that you ask for a decree that shall profit all the Churches of the world at once; so that the Church being established in her rules and confirmed by this decree of just pronouncement against such errors, may be unable to fear those men, etc." Pope Innocent [regn A.D. 401-417],To the Council of Carthage, Epistle 29(A.D. 417)

"Although the tradition of the Fathers has attributed to the Apostolic See so great authority that none would dare to contest its judgements...For(Peter) himself has care over all the Churches, and above all that in which he sat nor does he suffer any of its priveleges or decisions to be shaken" Pope Zosimus[regn A.D. 417-418 ],To Aurelius and the Council of Carthage, Epistle 12(A.D. 418)

"For it has never been allowed to discuss again what has once been decided by the Apostolic See" Pope Boniface [regn A.D. 418-422],To Rufus Bishop of Thessalonica, Epistle 13(A.D. 422)

"The rising pestilence was first cut short by Rome, the see of Peter, which having become the head to the world of the pastoral office, holds by religion whatever it holds not by arms." Prosper of Aquitaine, Song on the Enemies of Grace,1(A.D. 429)

"Joining to yourself, therefore, the sovereignty of our See, and assuming our place with authority, you will execute this sentence with accurate rigour: that within ten days, counted from the day of your notice, he shall condemn his [Nestorius'] false teachings in a written confession." Pope Celestine [regn. A.D. 422-432],To Cyril of Alexandria, Epistle 11(A.D. 430)

"The Holy Synod said:'Since most impious Nestorius will not obey our citation, and has not received the most holy and God-fearing bishops whom we sent to him, we have necessarily betaken ourselves to the examination of his impieties; and having apprehended from his letters, and from his writings, and from his recent sayings in this metropolis, which have been reported, that his opinions and teachings are impious, we being necessarily compelled thereto by the canons and by the leter of our most holy father and colleague, Celestine, bishop of the Roman Church, with many tears, have arrived at the following sentence against him:--'Our Lord Jesus Christ, Who has been blasphemed by him, defines by this present most holy synod that the same Nestorius is deprived of episcopal dignity and of all sacredotal intercourse." Council of Ephesus, Session I(A.D. 431)

"And all the most reverend bishops at the same time cried out. This is a just judgment. To Coelestine, a new Paul! To Cyril a new Paul! To Coelestine the guardian of the faith! To Coelestine of one mind with the synod! To Coelestine the whole Synod offers its thanks! One Coelestine! One Cyril! One faith of the Synod! One faith of the world! ....Arcadius...said:... Wherefore we desire to ask your blessedness, that you command that we taught what has been already decreed by your holiness.... Theodotus...said: The God of the whole world has made manifest the justice of the judgment pronounced by the holy Synod by the writings of the most religious bishop Coelestine, and by the coming of your holiness. For ye have made manifest the zeal of the most holy and reverend bishop Coelestine, and his care for the pious faith. And since very reasonably your reverence is desirous of learning what has been done from the minutes of the acts concerning the deposition of Nestorius your reverence will be fully convinced of the justice of the sentence, and of the zeal of the holy Synod, and the symphony of the faith which the most pious and holy bishop Coelestine has proclaimed with a great voice, of course after your full conviction, the rest shall be added to the present action." Council of Ephesus, Session II (A.D. 431)

"Philip, presbyter and legate of the Apostolic See, said: There is no doubt, and in fact it has been known in all ages, that the holy and most blessed Peter, prince and head of the apostles, pillar of the faith, and foundation of the Catholic Church, received the keys of the kingdom from our Lord Jesus Christ, the Saviour and Redeemer of the human race, and that to him was given the power of loosing and binding sins: Our holy and most blessed Pope Celestine the bishop is according to due order his successor and holds his place....Accordingly the decision of all churches is firm, for the priests of the eastern and western churches are present....Wherefore Nestorius knows that he is alienated from the communion of the priests of the Catholic Church." Council of Ephesus,Session III (A.D. 431)

"B. Peter in his successors has delivered what he received." Pope SixtusIII [regn. A.D. 432-440],To John of Antioch, Epistle 6 (A.D. 433)

"For he [Pope Sixtus] wrote what was in accord with the holy synod [Council of Ephesus],and confirmed all of its acts, an is agreement with us." Cyril of Alexandria, To Acacius of Meletine, Epistle 40 (A.D. 434)

"And since these heretics were trying to bring the Apostolic See round their view, African councils of holy bishops also did their best to persuade the holy Pope of the city(first the veneranle Innocent, and afterwards his successor Zosimus) that this heresy was to be abhorred and condemned by Catholic faith. And these bishops so great a See successively branded them, and cut them off from the members of the Church, giving letters to the African Churches in the West, and to the Churches of the East, and declared that they were to be anathematised and avoided by all Catholics. The judgement pronounced upon them by the Catholic Church of God was heard and followed also by the most pious Emperor Ho they had wandered, and are yet returning, as the truth of the right faith becomes known against this detestable error." Possidius, Life of Augustine,18(A.D. 437)

"The example of Pope Stephen in resisting the Iteration of Baptism. Great then is the example of these same blessed men, an example plainly divine, and worthy to be called to mind, and medirated upon continually by every true Catholic, who, like the seven-branched candlestick, shining with the sevenfold light of the Holy Spirit, showed to posterity how thenceforward the audaciousness of profane novelty, in all the several rantings of error, might be crushed by the authority of hallowed antiquity. Nor is there anything new in this? For it has always been the case in the Church, that the more a man is under the influence of religion, so much the more prompt is he to oppose innovations. Examples there are without number: but to be brief, we will take one, and that, in preference to others, from the Apostolic See, so that it may be clearer than day to every one with how great energy, with how great zeal, with how great earnestness, the blessed successors of the blessed apostles have constantly defended the integrity of the religion which they have once received. Once on a time then, Agrippinus, bishop of Carthage, of venerable memory, held the doctrine--and he was the first who held it --that Baptism ought to be repeated, contrary to the divine canon, contrary to the rule of the universal Church, contrary to the customs and institutions of our ancestors. This innovation drew after it such an amount of evil, that it not only gave an example of sacrilege to heretics of all sorts, but proved an occasion of error to certain Catholics even. When then all men protested against the novelty, and the priesthood everywhere, each as his zeal prompted him, opposed it, Pope Stephen of blessed memory, Prelate of the Apostolic See, in conjunction indeed with his colleagues but yet himself the foremost, withstood it, thinking it right, I doubt not, that as he exceeded all others in the authority of his place, so he should also in the devotion of his faith. In fine, in an epistle sent at the time to Africa, he laid down this rule: Let there be no innovation--nothing but what has been handed down.' For that holy and prudent man well knew that true piety admits no other rule than that whatsoever things have been faithfully received from our fathers the same are to be faithfully consigned to our children; and that it is our duty, not to lead religion whither we would, but rather to follow religion whither it leads; and that it is the part of Christian modesty and gravity not to hand down our own beliefs or observances to those who come after us, but to preserve and keep what we have received from those who went before us. What then was the issue of the whole matter? What but the usual and customary one? Antiquity was retained, novelty was rejected." Vincent of Lerins, Commonitories, 6 (A.D. 434)

"Although, therefore, dearly beloved, we be found both weak and slothful in fulfilling the duties of our office, because, whatever devoted and vigorous action we desire to do, we are hindered by the frailty of our very condition; yet having the unceasing propitiation of the Almighty and perpetual Priest, who being like us and yet equal with the Father, brought down His Godhead even to things human, and raised His Manhood even to things Divine, we worthily and piously rejoice over His dispensation, whereby, though He has delegated the care of His sheep to many shepherds, yet He has not Himself abandoned the guardianship of His beloved flock. And from His overruling and eternal protection we have received the support of the Apostles' aid also, which assuredly does not cease from its operation: and the strength of the foundation, on which the whole superstructure of the Church is reared, is not weakened by the weight of the temple that rests upon it. For the solidity of that faith which was praised in the chief of the Apostles is perpetual: and as that remains which Peter believed in Christ, so that remains which Christ instituted in Peter. For when, as has been read in the Gospel lesson, the Lord had asked the disciples whom they believed Him to be amid the various opinions that were held, and the blessed Peter bad replied, saying, Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God,' the Lord says, Blessed art thou, Simon Bar-Jona, because flesh and flood hath not revealed it to thee, but My Father, which is in heaven. And I say to thee, that thou art Peter, and upon this rock will I build My church, and the gates of Hades shall not prevail against it. And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven. And whatsoever thou shall bind on earth, shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever thou shall loose on earth, shall be loosed also in heaven.'The dispensation of Truth therefore abides, and the blessed Peter persevering in the strength of the Rock, which he has received, has not abandoned the helm of the Church, which he undertook. For he was ordained before the rest in such a way that from his being called the Rock, from his being pronounced the Foundation, from his being constituted the Doorkeeper of the kingdom of heaven, from his being set as the Umpire to bind and to loose, whose judgments shall retain their validity in heaven, from all these mystical titles we might know the nature of his association with Christ. And still to-day he more fully and effectually performs what is entrusted to him, and carries out every part of his duty and charge in Him and with Him, through Whom he has been glorified. And so if anything is rightly done and rightly decreed by us, if anything is won from the mercy of God by our daily supplications, it is of his work and merits whose power lives and whose authority prevails in his See. For this, dearly-beloved, was gained by that confession, which, inspired in the Apostle's heart by God the Father, transcended all the uncertainty of human opinions, and was endued with the firmness of a rock, which no assaults could shake. For throughout the Church Peter daily says, Thou an the Christ, the Son of the living God,' and every tongue which confesses the Lord, accepts the instruction his voice conveys. This Faith conquers the devil, and breaks the bonds of his prisoners. It uproots us from this earth and plants us in heaven, and the gates of Hades cannot prevail against it. For with such solidity is it endued by God that the depravity of heretics cannot mar it nor the unbelief of the heathen overcome it." Pope Leo the Great [regn. A.D.440-461],Sermon 3:2-3(A.D ante 461)

"Who does not cease to preside in his see,who will doubt that he rules in every part of the world." Pope Leo the Great [regn. A.D.440-461],Sermon 5(A.D ante 461)

"After the reading of the foregoing epistle [i.e. the Tome of Pope Leo], the most reverend bishops cried out: This is the faith of the fathers, this is the faith of the Apostles. So we all believe, thus the orthodox believe. Anathema to him who does not thus believe. Peter has spoken thus through Leo [regn. A.D. 440-461]. So taught the Apostles. Piously and truly did Leo teach, so taught Cyril. Everlasting be the memory of Cyril. Leo and Cyril taught the same thing, anathema to him who does not so believe. This is the true faith. Those of us who are orthodox thus believe. This is the faith of the fathers. Why were not these things read at Ephesus [i.e. at the heretical synod held there] ? These are the things Dioscorus hid away." Council of Chalcedon,Session II (A.D. 451)

"Wherefore the most holy and blessed Leo, archbishop of the great and elder Rome, through us, and through this present most holy synod together with the thrice blessed and all-glorious Peter the Apostle, who is the rock and foundation of the Catholic Church, and the foundation of the orthodox faith, hath stripped him of the episcopate, and hath alienated from him all hieratic worthiness. Therefore let this most holy and great synod sentence the before mentioned Dioscorus to the canonical penalties." Council of Chalcedon, Session III (A.D. 451)

"The great and holy and universal Synod...in the metropolis of Chalcedon...to the most holy and blessed archbishop of Rome, Leo....being set as the mouthpiece unto all of the blessed Peter, and imparting the blessedness of his Faith unto all...and besides all this he [Dioscorus] stretched forth his fury even against him who had been charged with the custody of the vine by the Savior, we mean of course your holiness, ...." Leo the Great, Pope, Chalcdeon to Pope Leo, Epistle 98:1-2 (A.D. 451)

The Primacy of the Apostolic See was held and supported by the Early Christians. By refusing to listen to, or even acknowledge, the Apostolic See, Diane follows in the footsteps of her heretical cohorts, the Paulicians, the Donatists, the Waldensians, and so forth.

but with the cessation of persecution under Constantine, Christianity entered the courts of kings. The nominal conversion of Constantine in the early part of the 4th century opened the way for the apostasy to progress (develop) more rapidly.

Paganism, while appearing to be vanquished, became the conqueror. Her spirit controlled the church; her doctrines, ceremonies, rituals, and superstitions were incorporated into the faith of the professed followers of Christ.

Diane has yet to prove that any of the doctrines of Catholicism were taken from paganism, or had pagan origins. Granted various ceremonies and rituals might have once been used by pagans, but that does not mean that they can’t be used in Christian worship at all, because of that. They are merely customs, or ways of doing things, they are not an integral part of the Catholic Church at all. And insofar as "superstitions" are concerned, Diane is very vague on what she considers to be a "superstition." Throughout history we have seen that heretics have used Sacred Scripture in their ceremonies, does this disprove Scripture or eliminate it from use by the True Christian Church? Of course not.

Constantine increased the role of the Catholic Church in Roman government by placing bishops in high political positions. So as any one can see, Constantine’s role in history was a major pivotal point in providing the Roman Catholic Church a power structure from which to build. The Roman Empire was slowly giving its power to the Roman Catholic Church. Pagan Rome was developing into Papal Rome. By the 6th century the papacy was firmly established and the Bishop of Rome declared to be the head of the entire church.

The Bishop of Rome was declared the head of the entire Church much earlier than the 6th century - as was shown above by my citation from Mediaeval and Modern History -, and was considered to be the head of the Church by the Early Christians - as can be seen from the above given listing of citations. To claim that he wasn’t considered the head of the Church during the early centuries is to close ones eyes to historical fact - something Diane seems to have a habit of doing. Furthermore, we openly admit that the political power of the papacy did, indeed, develop. And, as Diane’s own citation from the Encyclopedia Britannica below, the Church that became the partner of the state was the Early Christian Church of the first centuries.

No wonder the Lord HATES THE DOCTRINE of the Nicolaitanes!

Of course the Lord hates the doctrines of the Nicolaites, hence the reason why they didn’t last but as short time, as Eusebius said. The Nicolaites also advocated fornication and adultery, something the Catholic Church most certainly does not teach and something the Catholic Church has always condemned. Though, as a matter of fact, one might also state that Luther and the Mormons - to give some non-Catholic "christian" examples - were far closer to the Nicolaites than the Catholic Church ever could be. To provide a short citation from Luther: "As to divorce, it is still a moot question whether it is allowable. For my part, I prefer bigamy." (De Wette, Vol. 2, p. 459)

They claimed to be the head of the church yet the word of God is clear and God is not the author of confusion: "And he [Jesus] is the head of the body, the church...." (Col.1:18) (Emphasis mine)

Nor is God the author of deception. The Catholic Church readily acknowledges that Christ is the head of the Church, we have no problem with this. Christ is the head of the Church, while the Pope is His deputy, and head of the Church on earth, under Him and subject to Him in all things.

The claims of the papacy to rule the church are based on a forgery called the "Donation of Constantine".

The Papacy does not base its claim upon this forgery, it’s claims are based upon the Words of Christ in the Gospel of St. Matthew, St. John, and other places. They are based upon the Word of God, and Sacred Tradition. Even if the "Donation of Constantine" had never existed the Papacy would still have ruled the Church.

The oldest known copy of the "Donation of Constantine" was written in the ninth century, and the Donation itself was probably originally fabricated sometime between 750 and 850 A.D. The Papacy was in existence long before then, and, as shown by the citations from the Early Christians and given above, the Primacy of the Pope was accepted by the Christian Church at that time.

It is historical fact that his "donation" is indeed a forgery. Rome herself now admits this. Let’s turn to the Encyclopedia Britannica again, Vol. 4, pages 511-512:

Certainly we agree that the "Donation of Constantine" was a forgery, written sometime between 750 and 850 A.D. But the Primacy of the Papacy was not based upon it, as can be seen from the fact that the Primacy was accepted by the Early Christians before the "Donation" was even written. And yet, contrary to what Diane would like the reader to believe, the forgery was not discovered by some "pious" protestant, but was discovered by several Catholic Bishops and scholars centuries before protestantism existed, as the following citation from the Catholic Encyclopedia 1913 shows:

"As early as the fifteenth century its falsity was known and demonstrated. Cardinal Nicholas of Cusa (De Concordantiâ Catholicâ, III, ii, in the Basle ed. of his Opera, 1565, I) spoke of it as a dictamen apocryphum. Some years later (1440) Lorenzo Valla (De falso credita et ementita Constantini donatione declamatio, Mainz, 1518) proved the forgery with certainty. Independently of both his predecessors, Reginald Pecocke, Bishop of Chichester (1450-57), reached a similar conclusion in his work, ‘The Repressor of over much Blaming of the Clergy’, Rolls Series, II, 351-366." ( Catholic Encyclopedia 1913, )

Hence, if the Papacy’s claim to rule the Church were truly based upon this forgery, then why was it that supporters of the Primacy of the Pope and Catholics were the ones who demonstrated the document’s falsity in the 1400's? Furthermore, why is it that we can trace the Papacy back to Christ, and furthermore that its primacy was attested to by the writings of the Early Christians, who existed centuries before the "donation of Constantine" was even dreamed of? Diane continues and gives some alleged citations from the Encyclopedia Britannica concerning the Donation of Constantine, to provide her first citation:

"On the ideological basis of the ‘gift of the emperor Constantine’ - THE DONATION OF CONSTANTINE (a forged document that granted the papacy territorial rights to much of the western world)-became possible, to which the later development of the papacy was connected. The Donation ATTEMPTED TO*** RECONSTRUCT THE HISTORY OF THE PAPACY IN RETROSPECT*** IN ORDER TO MAKE LEGITIMATE THE *** NEWLY GAINED ECCLESIASTICAL AND POLITICAL POSITION *** OF THE POPES after the extinction of the Western Roman imperial reign...In this theory, the myth of the Byzantium, the ‘new Rome,’ was reconstructed by a new myth of the Christian Rome: THE ROMAN BISHOP, THE *NEW* LORD in the Christian Rome, HAD TAKEN OVER ALL THE FUNCTIONS OF THE EMPEROR HIMSELF...The Roman popes not only based their claim to form and lead their own church state on a spiritual-SECULAR JUDICIAL UNDERSTANDING but they also created a theocracy within areas that until then were part of the provinces of the Byzantine emperor. They renounced a number of former imperial rights and claimed them for themselves. They extended a secular claim of government of the church beyond the borders of church-state and DEVELOPED the so-called theory of two swords, stating that Christ gave the pope not only spiritual power over the church, but also secular power over the worldly kingdoms"

(Emphasis mine).

In the first place, we have no wrong with admitting that the political position of the Papacy did "evolve and develop," as Diane said. This does not prove that the Catholic is wrong, or that it’s false, or that the Papacy has no authority, or that this spiritual authority developed. The truth is, when the Roman Empire disintegrated, a great void was created. The Papacy was the natural filler of that void.

In the second place, the Donation of Constantine (as the Encyclopedia Britannica itself admits) was first certainly used in favor of the Papacy in 1054 by Pope Leo IX. This was centuries after the Primacy of the Roman Bishop had already been established. It was not necessary for the continuance of the Papacy, nor was the Papacy founded upon it. And furthermore, even if it was used by certain Popes to gain political power, this would not disprove the office of the Papacy nor would it disprove the Catholic Church. After all, even the Sacred Scriptures have cited from fraudulent books, as can be seen in the Epistle of St. Jude 1:14-15 where it cites the apocrypha book of Enoch - but of course, this does not disprove the Sacred Scriptures. Diane then continues on to provide another citation from the Encyclopedia Britannica:

Encyclopedia Britannica

, 15th edition, 1984, vol. 4, page 468 also states:

"Christianity...The early Christian church…** of the first three centuries *TURNED DECISIVELY AGAINST THE STATE RELIGION OF ROME...BECAUSE THEIR RELIGION** COULD NOT** BE FITTED INTO THE POLITICALLY SANCTIONED PAGAN RELIGIOUS SYSTEM...Constantine, in the 4th century...ended the persecution of the church and made it itself the basis for the spiritual unity of the Roman Empire. The church thereby BECAME the partner of the state...." (Emphasis mine)

First we must note that Diane herself openly admits that this church which became a partner to the state through Constantine is the Roman Catholic Church. Allow me to cite her:

"So as any one can see, Constantine’s role in history was a major pivotal point in providing the Roman Catholic Church a power structure from which to build. The Roman Empire was slowly giving its power to the Roman Catholic Church."

As anyone can see, the Encyclopedia Britannica (as cited by Diane) makes no distinction between the Early Church, and this Church that became the partner of Rome. Hence we see that this citation really supports the Church, rather than harms it. It is evidence in favor of the fact that the Catholic Church was in existence long before Constantine, and was the True Church of the Early Christians.

Let it be known that it is a historical and well documented fact that the Roman Catholic Church has a long history of attempting to "reconstruct the history of the Roman papacy in retrospect."

No, it is not well-known nor is it a fact that the Catholic Church has reconstructed history. As can be seen even insofar as the "Donation of Constantine" goes, it cannot be proven that the author of the document in question (the forged "Donation of Constantine") was a Roman Catholic Ecclesiastic, or that he was acting under orders from the Papacy, or was influenced by the Papacy, or that the Catholic Church itself as a whole had anything to do with the forgery of this document. Any claims to that effect are groundless. As the Catholic Encyclopedia says:

Occasionally, but without sufficient reason, critics have attributed it to the author of the False Decretals (q.v.) or to some Roman ecclesiastic of the eighth century.

Diane continues.

Take Constantine for example, Rome would have you believe that he converted to Christianity and hence the reason for his "gift".

Rome would not have you believe this, because Rome openly admits that the document was a forgery, as Diane above openly states.

A careful study of the character of Constantine will reveal that from an early date Constantine combines the Christian symbol (a cross) with his personal image as a conquering general; the cross as a symbol of victory over darkness imposed with imperial fervor. His coins reveal a picture of him in the conqueror’s pose and armor next to a cross topped by a globe, while his helmet bears the name of Christ. The emperor stands in for the departed Christ, yet, for many years he used Apollonian imagery as well. A pragmatist, the image of Christ seemed to blur in his mind with that of the Sun god. He was aware that the majority of the inhabitants of the Empire were still pagans and so he cleverly incorporated some pagan imagery into his personality cult. A tactic Roman Catholicism continues to this day.

The character of Constantine has nothing to do with the authority of the Catholic Church, and is really quite irrelevant to the topic at hand, as we have shown above, the Catholic Church existed long before Constantine, and existed after Constantine.

"To convert and civilize her new subjects SHE [Catholicism] DESCENDED TO THEIR LEVEL and EMPLOYED MEANS IN KEEPING WITH THEIR NOTIONS AND CUSTOMS" (History of the Church of God, B.J.Spalding,407) (Emphasis mine).

"Gregory ‘The Great’, 590 AD, ordered the heathen temples etc. be preserved in order to attract the heathens who once worshipped in them: ‘Among other directions, he advises them not to destroy the temples but only the idols of the false gods, and to consecrate to the worship of the true God the buildings still fit for use, ‘IN ORDER’, as he wisely said, ‘THAT THE PEOPLE SEEING YOU RESPECT THE MONUMENTS TO WHICH THEY ARE ACCUSTOMED, AND MAY MORE READILY COME TO THEM’" (General History of the Catholic Church,Darras, Vol.II, 188 - see Life of Saint Patrick, 73) (Emphasis mine).

After seeing Diane’s bad habit of altering and rewriting various citations, I am forced to question the accuracy of the above two citations. Secondly, by now it should become apparent to even the most ignorant person that Diane has an intentional faulty concept of History - even to the point where she will falsify citations. Diane would have you believe the Catholic Church became pagan and "took on pagan rituals," but the "true believers" from which she receives her doctrine held to the teachings of Christ, such as more than one god, believed the Old Testament was from the devil, and that various New Testament writings (such as the Epistles of St. Peter) are not to be trusted. Is this Christian? Diane thinks so.

We see that Rome has clung closer to paganism than to true Christianity and that instead of following the teachings of Christ, they developed and formed new doctrines.

Clearly we see that Diane has a problem understanding what Christianity is, and what the differences between Christianity and paganism are. For example, she believes that polytheists are Christians. Furthermore, we also see that she openly admits that the Catholic Church was the only visible Church in existence. Hence, Christianity would have disappeared from the face of the earth.

Their entire "authority" is based on a lie, a forgery.

Nobody bases their authority on the "Donation of Constantine," even Diane herself admits that Rome acknowledges the fact that it’s a fabrication. Secondly, we have already shown that history shows that the Papacy and structure of the Church existed long before the creation of this ninth century false document.

The Roman Catholic church has a long history of false statements deliberately presented as being true; saying things meant to deceive or give a wrong impression; presenting false information with the intention of deceiving; conveying false images and impressions, which coincidentally happens to be the definition of a liar.

Unfortunately, the only one here who seems to have a long history of false statements deliberately presented as being true; saying things meant to deceive or give a wrong impression; presenting false information with the intention of deceiving; conveying false images and impressions, which coincidentally happens to the definition of a liar, is Diane. After all, we have seen above that she has even stooped so far as to falsify citations, pretend that polytheists were Christians, promote heretical sects that denied the Old Testament and rejected portions of the New Testament, rewrite history, and completely chop up citations from the Encyclopedia Britannica, in order to force them into the mold of the pseudo-history which she wishes to present. Hence, I would like to make Diane’s next words my own:

Therefore, nothing that comes out of her can be accepted as fact without further corroboration.

Diane continues.

Those whom Rome would label "heretics" are more than likely those who "believe all that is written in the law and in the prophets."

The law of the prophets? Is that not the Old Testament which the Paulicians - Diane’s "true believers"- rejected as being written by the devil? Does anyone else see a problem here? Furthermore, I would like to point out Diane’s open prejudice against anything Catholic. She here states her belief that "If Rome condemns it, what it condemned must be true." She is not willing to accept anything Rome says, or anything that is in favor of the Catholic Church. Hence, we also see that her only determining factor of the Truth is "Does it attack the Catholic Church?"

In order for a church to be considered true, it must meet certain requirements set forth in the word of God. It must have the right founder– Jesus Christ. (Matthew 16:18)

I agree. It is nice to see that Diane openly admits that He founded His Church in Matthew 16:18. For more information on this verse, I would like to refer the reader to Charles the Hammer’s fantastic article on the subject entitled "Blessed are you Simon Bar-Jonah.".

Jesus is the way, the truth and the life, any church founded upon a lie such as the "Donation of Constantine" cannot be the true church. It must also cling to the faith "ONCE delivered unto the saints".

I agree. Nor can any belief which is based upon polytheism and the denial of Sacred Scripture be considered to be a Christian belief "ONCE delivered to the saints." But since the Catholic Church is in no way based upon the "donation of Constantine," and readily admits that it’s a forgery, Diane’s above statements are really quite irrelevant.

As Rome herself admits, she does not. Her doctrines and dogmas developed and evolved.

In the first place, Diane herself admitted above that Rome admits that the "Donation of Constantine" was a forgery. And unfortunately for Diane, she has yet to show where a single dogma or doctrine of the Catholic Faith has developed and evolved.

And Roman Catholicism readily admits this self-damning fact:

"If only ONE INSTANCE could be given in which the [Catholic] Church CEASES TO TEACH A DOCTRINE WHICH HAD BEEN PREVIOUSLY HELD, that SINGLE INSTANCE would be a DEATH BLOW of her claim to INFALLIBILITY" (Faith of our Fathers, Gibbons, 61) (Emphasis mine).

Permit me to continue the citation from this source which Diane obviously holds as authoritative on the Roman Catholic Church:

"But it is a marvelous fact worthy of record that in the whole history of the Church, from the nineteenth century to the first, no solitary example can be adduced to show that any Pope or General Council ever revoked a decree of faith or morals enacted by any preceding Pontiff or Council. Her record in the past ought to be a sufficient warrant that she will tolerate no doctrinal variations in the future."

Lastly, I would like to point out that a statement by Cardinal Gibbons is not an official declaration of the Roman Catholic Church. This is yet another example of Diane’s inability to distinguish between an individual and the Church.

"...If it be not identical in belief, government, etc…with the primitive church, then it is not the church of Christ" (Catholic Facts, 27).

It is interesting to note, 1) that Diane gives a one sentence citation from this book, and even that one sentence citation has a section chopped out of it. 2) Diane has a history of altering citations, as we have seen above. 3) The Catholic Church does not, in any way, shape, or form, have to have a government that is perfectly identical with that of the primitive church. The basics were there, the structure was there, the Papacy was there, but there is no place in the Bible that says that the whole government must be identical with that of the Early Church.

Amazing admission considering they also admit that the New Testament church knew nothing of the hierarchy of the Roman Church!

Amazing twist of facts there Diane. We make no such admission. As we have proven above, through the statements of the Early Christians, the Papacy was well-known at that time, as was it’s authority, and the Early Christians readily accepted it.

Now that it has been proven that Roman Catholicism is not now, nor has it ever been part of the true church, we must look at those who came out from them during the Reformation.

Unfortunately, Diane has proven no such thing. As we have pointed out above, even the Encyclopedia Britannica - as cited by Diane - shows that the Early Church is the same as the Roman Catholic Church. If the Roman Catholic Church is not the True Church, then there is no such thing as a "true church," or even "Christianity." Furthermore, Diane herself openly admitted above that Roman Catholicism was the only visible Church in the early centuries, thereby implying that True Christianity was nowhere to be found.

Could they have been the true church? Does it not seem ridiculous to you to believe that Christianity was given birth to by a lie?

I agree. It is very ridiculous, especially when one takes into consideration the fact that 1) Diane is a liar, 2) the religions that she claims Christianity came from were liars and polytheists, 3) Christianity was founded upon St. Peter in Matthew 16:18.

Protestantism was made up of those who, while seeing the corruption of the "Church",

Corruption of the church? Diane is insinuating that the Church which was founded by Christ can corrupt? In other words, Christ founded a Church that was doomed to failure? Doomed to corruption? Now I’m not saying that there weren’t corrupt men in the Church at that time, for indeed even one of Christ’s own twelve Apostles was corrupted by greed and betrayed Him. What I am saying is that the Church itself can never be corrupted.

broke off to form a new religion of their own, instead of returning to the "faith once delivered to the saints".

That is true, they did break off and form their own new religions, instead of staying with the "faith once delivered to the saints."

They retained many of the pagan practices of Roman Catholicism.

Pagan practices such as wedding rings and the use of calendars, Diane? Oh, wait! I forgot... you chopped those out of your citation because you yourself use them. The hypocrisy of Diane should be by now quite obvious. Even to the most ignorant of readers.

As they did not remove themselves entirely from Catholicism, they are now readily returning to their "mother" with open arms. We see this in the ecumenical movement of today. Had these churches came out from Romanism in reality, and returned to the faith once delivered unto the saints, they would not even think of joining with her again.

As the faith once delivered to the saints is to be found only in Roman Catholicism, and since Diane has been very unable to prove otherwise - after all, the faith once delivered to the Saints did not include pentecostal-type activities, nor polytheism, nor the rejection of Sacred Scriptures - , it stands to reason that they could not find the True Faith outside the Catholic Church, and especially amongst Diane’s so-called "true believers."

The "wound" (Rev.13:3) which the Reformation inflicted appears to be "healing". The end result? The one-world church under the banner of the pope So what are the characteristics of the true church? The following is from an excellent book by J.M. Carroll, tracing the Trail of Blood of the true martyrs of the faith:

You mean the Baptist J.M. Carroll? A member of a protestant sect that fled the "lies" of Catholicism during the reformation, and did not return to the "true believers" imagined by Diane to have been in existence at that apart from the Catholic Church? As the Encyclopedia Britannica states concerning the Baptists:

"Baptist: member of a group of Protestant Christians who share the basic beliefs of most Protestants but who insist that only believers should be baptized and that it should be done by immersion rather than by the sprinkling or pouring of water." (Encyclopedia Britannica,)

Carroll’s belief in "Baptist successionism," as outlined in the book "Trail of Blood," is a view that is held by very few scholars today. In fact, the majority of scholars can easily see how ridiculous and stupid the theory is. As the Encyclopedia Britannica states - and remember, Diane considers this to be a trustworthy source:

"Some Baptists believe that there has been an unbroken succession of Baptist churches from the days of John the Baptist and the Apostles of Christ. Others trace their origin to the Anabaptists, a 16th-century Protestant movement on the European continent. Most scholars, however, agree that Baptists, as an English-speaking denomination, originated within 17th-century Puritanism as an offshoot of Congregationalism."

Funk and Wagnall’s Encyclopedia concurs:

"Baptists espoused some of the religious convictions of the Ana-baptists, although no established connection existed between the two groups. ... Originally, Baptists originated in the early 17th century in Holland and England, with John Smyth (c. 1554/1612) and Thomas Helwys (c. 1560/1616), English Separatists from the Anglican church." (Funk Wagner Encyclopedia )

Diane then continues and gives what she supposes to be the "marks of the New Testament church" as given by the Protestant Baptist, Carroll.

"MARKS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT CHURCH

1. Its head and founder—Christ. He is the lawgiver; The church is only the executive. (Mat.16:18, Col.1:18).

Christ? Does Diane mean to say that there is only one God? Or more than one as held by the Paulicians - "true believes"?

2. Its only rule of faith and practice—The Bible. (2 Tim.3:15-17).

And yet we find that a group of Diane’s "true believers," the Paulicians, rejected large portions of the Bible. And furthermore, I would also like to point out that the Canon of the Sacred Scriptures wasn’t compiled completely until end of the fourth century and beginning of the fifth. Meaning that the "true church" didn’t exist before then.

3. Its name—‘Church,’ ‘Churches.’ (Matt.16:18, Rev. 22:16).

Unfortunately, I know of no "christian" denomination that fails this mark. Furthermore, I would like to point out that even Carroll admits that his church was not called simply "church," or "churches," but "ana-baptists." To provide a brief citation from his "Trail of Blood," as cited by Diane:

"A striking peculiarity of these Christians was and continued to be in succeeding centuries: They rejected the man-made doctrine of ‘Infant Baptism’ and demanded rebaptism, even though done by immersion for all those who came to them, having been baptized in infancy. For this peculiarity they were called ‘Ana-Baptists’."

Diane continues:

4. Its policy—congregational—all members equal. (Matt.20:24-28; Matt.23:5-12).

Unfortunately, here we have a contradiction between this mark, and mark number 7. How can a church have officers, or leaders, such as pastors and deacons, and yet have all members equal? The only group that even comes close to this mark would be the ana-baptists in Munster, when they tried to establish a communistic government.

5. Its members — only saved people. (Eph.2:21; 1 Pet.2:5).

In other words, Judas wasn’t a member of the church? Or was he saved?

6. Its ordinances—believers’ baptism, followed by the Lord’s supper. (Matt.28:19-20).

While the Waldensians and the Donatists did not have the "Lord’s supper," as is meant by Diane - i.e. a communal meal - but the Mass of the Catholic Church. They believed that Christ was truly present on the altar - in His Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity - something Diane does not. Hence, the Waldensians and the Donatists fail Diane’s sixth mark.

7. Its officers—pastors and deacons. (1 Tim.3:1-16).

The Waldensians had Bishops, while the Donatists split from the Catholic Church over the election of a certain Bishop into a certain diocese - which Bishop they wanted replaced with another Bishop. Hence, we see that among Diane’s "true believers," there was a far more complex hierarchy.

8. Its work—getting folks saved, baptizing them (with a baptism that meets all the requirements of God’s word), teaching them ("to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you"). (Matt.28:16-20).

"Baptism"? As in what was believed by the Ana-baptists, i.e. no baptism of infants? And total submersion? The funny thing about infant baptism is that it was believed by the Early Church.

GIVE RIGGS CITATIONS

9. Its financial plan—‘even so (tithes and offerings) hath the Lord ordained that they which preach the gospel should live of the gospel’" (1 Cor. 9:14).

And yet the Waldensians rejected "tithing." Meaning that they fail this ninth mark of the New Testament Church, and yet are still "true believers." Something’s wrong.

10. Its weapons of warfare—spiritual, not carnal. (2 Cor.10:4; Eph.6:10-20).

And yet the Ana-baptists waged war around Munster, with far more than just spiritual weapons. While the Paulicians started an armed military and political rebellion against the Roman Empire.

11. Its independence—separation of church and state" (Matt.22:21) (Emphasis mine).

Something the Ana-baptists and Paulicians obviously didn’t believe in. So they fail the last of these eleven marks.

Now let’s look at an overview Mr. Carroll gives concerning the period known as the "Dark Ages" and of those Christians that existed at that time:

The only Christians around during that time were the Catholics. All other sects at that time, if there were any, were just as heretical as the other sects mentioned above.

"1. During every period of the ‘Dark Ages’ there were in existence many Christians and many separate and independent Churches, some of them dating back to the times of the Apostles, which were never in any way connected with the Catholic Church. They always wholly rejected and repudiated the Catholics and their doctrines. This is a fact clearly demonstrated by credible history.

Unfortunately, we have seen an example of Carroll and Diane’s "credible history," and "very credible" list of "true believers," which included polytheists, pentecostals, and those who rejected Sacred Scripture, and those who accepted all the Sacraments of the Catholic Church, including the Mass and Confession.

Insofar as their rejection and repudiation of Catholic doctrines goes, that didn’t make them Christians... that made them heretics.

2. These Christians were perpetual objects of bitter and relentless persecution. History shows that during the period of the ‘Dark Ages’, about twelve centuries, beginning with AD 426, there were about fifty millions of these Christians who died martyr deaths. Very many thousands of others, both preceding and succeeding the ‘Dark Ages’ died under the same hard hand of persecution.

In the first place, Carroll has neglected to show that these "christians" could be traced back to the Apostles. All he has done is make claims, which, in several cases, were proven to be ridiculous. In the second place, the "Dark Ages" did not last about "twelve centuries," but rather less than six. As the "Random House College Dictionary," says:

"Dark Ages: the period in European history from about A.D., 476 to about 1000." (Random House College Dictionary, p. 338)

Thirdly, Carroll has yet to prove that there were 50 million "christians," so-called, who were persecuted and slain during that time. Or that these people were even "christian." We’ve already seen an example of what Carroll and Diane consider "true believers." Fourth, I would like to point out that if what Carroll says about these 50 million so-called "Christians" being "martyred" is true, over a 1200 hundred year time period, that would mean that about 115 people were killed every day, 41,666 killed every year, 416,660 people killed every decade, for one thousand two hundred years. This is twice as many people as were killed during the black plague in Europe, which wiped out over a third of the population. Meaning Carroll would have us believe that about two-thirds of the population of Europe died martyrs and "true believers." An atrocity of this magnitude would dwarf Hitler and the holocaust (who killed only about six million people). In the Vietnam war, a ten year war, only took about 60,000 American lives. World War I only caused about thirty million casualties. This would mean that more people were "martyred" during the "dark ages" - when Europe was sparsely populated and one could ride for days without finding a sign of life - than were killed during World War I, a war on a global scale - hence the name "world war." It stands to reason that a mass holocaust on this scale (115 a day, 41,666 a year) would have been found in every single history book and be quoted by every scholar who has ever studied this time period and wanted to attack the Catholic Church. And yet I can find no references to this anywhere. I challenge Diane, since I cannot challenge Carroll - he probably being dead -, to prove this incredible massacre through credible history. Of course, this should be an easy task for her... in the first place, because, as I said above, something of this magnitude should be very easy to research. In the second place, we have already seen how "scholarly" Diane can be. In the third place, seeing that a big portion of Diane’s research is based upon Carroll’s claims, if she cannot prove this to be other than Carroll’s own vivid imagination, then we must discount a large portion of her article. For, indeed, the credibility of the original author has died along with him.

3. These Christians, during these dark days of many centuries, were called by many different names, all given to them by their enemies. These names were sometimes given because of some specially prominent and heroic leader and sometimes from other causes; and sometimes, yea, many times, the same people, holding the same views, were called by different names in different localities. But amid all the many changes of names, there was one special name or rather designation, which clung to at least some of these Christians, throughout all the ‘Dark Ages’, that designation being ‘Ana-Baptist.’ This compound word applied as a designation of some certain Christians was first found in history during the 3rd century; and a suggestive fact soon after the origin of Infant Baptism, and a more suggestive fact even prior to the use of the name Catholic. Thus the name ‘Ana-Baptists’ is the oldest denominational name in history.

In the first place, Carroll’s lack of citations and scholarly support in the above statement is quite telling.

In the second place, the title "Anabaptist" was first applied to a heretical group of "revolutionaries" against the Catholic Church in the sixteenth century. As the Encyclopedia Britannica said: "The Anabaptist movement originated in Zürich among a group of young intellectuals who rebelled against Zwingli's apparent subservience to the magistrates and his reluctance to proceed swiftly with a complete reform of the church."

In the third place, The term, "The Catholic Church" appears in extant Christian literature for the first time in the letter of St. Ignatius of Antioch who was ordained a Bishop of the Catholic Church by St. John the Apostle. In a letter written to the People of Smyrna in the year 110 A.D. he says, "Wheresoever the bishop is found there likewise let the people be found, even as where Jesus Christ may be, there is the Catholic Church." This is fully a century before the title "Anabaptist" was allegedly first applied to "true believers" in the third century. This alone is sufficient to show that Carroll doesn’t know what he’s talking about. The title "anabaptist" is not the oldest denominational name in history, the title "Catholic" came before it.

In the third place, infant baptism was practiced by the Early Church long before the third century. Scripture itself teaches it, as the Catholic Encyclopedia 1913 explains:

The Catholic Church, however, maintains absolutely that the law of Christ applies as well to infants as to adults. When the Redeemer declares (John 3) that it is necessary to be born again of water and the Holy Ghost in order to enter the Kingdom of God, His words may be justly understood to mean that He includes all who are capable of having a right to this kingdom. Now, He has asserted such a right even for those who are not adults, when He says (Matt., xix, 14): "Suffer the little children, and forbid them not to come to me: for the kingdom of heaven is for such." It has been objected that this latter text does not refer to infants, inasmuch as Christ says "to come to me". In the parallel passage in St. Luke (xviii, 15), however, the text reads: "And they brought unto him also infants, that he might touch them"; and then follow the words cited from St. Matthew. In the Greek text, the words brephe and prosepheron refer to infants in arms. Moreover, St. Paul (Coloss., ii) says that baptism in the New Law has taken the place of circumcision in the Old. It was especially to infants that the rite of circumcision was applied by Divine precept. If it be said that there is no example of the baptism of infants to be found in the Bible, we may answer that infants are included in such phrases as: "She was baptized and her household" (Acts, xvi, 15); "Himself was baptized, and all his house immediately" (Acts, xvi, 33); "I baptized the household of Stephanus" (I Cor., i, 16). (Catholic Encyclopedia, )

As was shown above, the Scriptures themselves teach infant baptism. The statements of the Early Church Fathers themselves are sufficient to show that infant baptism was of great antiquity, and could be traced farther back than the third century. As Origin said: "The Church received from the Apostles the tradition of giving baptism also to infants" (cap. vi, Ep. ad Rom). St. Augustine stated concerning infant baptism: "This the Church always had, always held; this she received from the faith of our ancestors; this she perseveringly guards even to the end." (Serm. xi, De Verb Apost) St. Irenaeus of Lyons stated "For He came to save all through means of Himself--all, I say, who through Him are born again to God--infants, and children, and boys, and youths, and old men." (Against Heresies,2,22:4) Infant baptism was a practice held by the Early Church Fathers, "received from the Apostles," and a practice that "the Church always had, always held;" which "she received from the faith of our ancestors."

In addition to the above, we have already seen an example of Carroll and Diane’s pseudo-history, when he claimed there were over 50,000,000 "martyrs," [twice the amount killed during the Black Plague] who were all "true believers" like the Paulicians, the Donatists, and the Waldensians. Carroll has shown himself in this statement alone to be completely untrusthworthy as far as history goes. And, of course, Diane’s own statements are evidence to this effect.

4. A striking peculiarity of these Christians was and continued to be in succeeding centuries: They rejected the man-made doctrine of ‘Infant Baptism’ and demanded rebaptism, even though done by immersion for all those who came to them, having been baptized in infancy. For this peculiarity they were called ‘Ana-Baptists’.

This is true. One of the striking peculiarities of some of these heretics was the rejection of the Divinely instituted doctrine of infant baptism, and demanded a sacrilegious rebaptism. Of course, we all know that John 3:5 does not say "reborn again of water, and then reborn yet again of water." The second "baptism" would be invalid in that case. Did not Moses commit a sin when he struck a rock to bring forth water more than once?

5. This special designation was applied to many of these Christians who bore other nicknames; especially is this true of the Donatists, Paulicians, Albigenses, and Ancient Waldenses and others.

Firstly, it is interesting to note that there is no historical evidence for Carroll’s claims that any of these heretical sects ever bore the name of "Ana-Baptist." Once again, Carroll and Diane’s lack of credible history is obvious.

The Donatists, as we have seen above, accepted the seven Sacraments of the Catholic Church. Hence, we must assume that it is Christian to do so. And since this is so, why don’t Diane and Carroll accept them?

The Paulicians, as we have also seen above, rejected portions of the Bible, and held to more than one God - which, in turn, means that St. Paul could not have been a True Christian for he said in I Timothy 2:5 he said that there was only one God. And since this is so, and since they were "Christians" and "true believers," then we must certainly wonder why it is that Diane and Carroll don’t do this. This is very curious.

With the introduction of the Albigensians to this list we see that Carroll and Diane’s support of polytheism was not relegated to simply the Paulicians, but has even extended to include the Albigensians. The Albigensians believed in two gods, a god of good, and a god of evil. Another interesting belief of the Albigensians, was the following:

And since the Albigensians were "Christians" and "true believers," then we must assume that these were Christian beliefs. If this is so, then why don’t Diane and Carroll believe them?

The Waldensians, founder, Valdes (also called Peter Waldo, or Valdo) attended the third Lateran Council (1179) in Rome and was confirmed in his vow of poverty by Pope Alexander III. He also made a Profession of the Catholic Faith (which still survives); it is a statement of orthodox beliefs such as accused heretics were required to sign. it was not untill the archbishop of Lyon condemned him, and Pope Lucius III placed the Waldenses under ban with his bull Ad Abolendam ( issued during the Synod of Verona, 1184 A.D.) that the Waldenses departed from the teaching of the Roman Catholic church.

Waldensian... little is known with certainty about the reputed founder, Valdes (also called Peter Waldo, or Valdo). As a layman, Valdes preached in Lyon (1170-76), but ecclesiastical authorities were disturbed by his lack of theological training and by his use of a non-Latin version of the Bible. Valdes attended the third Lateran Council (1179) in Rome and was confirmed in his vow of poverty by Pope Alexander III. Probably during this council Valdes made his Profession of Faith (which still survives); it is a statement of orthodox beliefs such as accused heretics were required to sign. Valdes, however, did not receive the ecclesiastical recognition that he sought. Undeterred, he and his followers (Pauperes: "Poor") continued to preach; the archbishop of Lyon condemned him, and Pope Lucius III placed the Waldenses under ban with his bull Ad Abolendam (1184), issued during the Synod of Verona.

Thereafter, the Waldenses departed from the teaching of the Roman Catholic church by rejecting some of the seven sacraments and the notion of purgatory. (© 1999-2000 Britannica.com Inc.)

Since the Waldensians were Christians, and "true believers," we must assume that their founder - Peter Waldo - was also a "Christian," and yet he took a Profession of the Catholic Faith. Since Peter was a "Christian," we must assume that this is a Christian practice. Hence, one may be allowed to wonder why it is that Diane and Carroll have not taken a Profession of the Catholic Faith - after all, was this not what founder of the sect of "true believers," and a "true believer" himself, did?

In later centuries this designation came to be a regular name, applied to a distinct group. These were simply called ‘Ana-Baptists’ and gradually all other names were dropped. Very early in the sixteenth century, even prior to the origin of the Lutheran Church, the first of all the Protestant Churches, the word ‘ana’ was beginning to be left off, and they were simply called ‘Baptists’.

The Anabaptists are currently in existence today, as can be seen from the following website entitled "Anabaptist Mennonites" ( ) - an interesting point, on their website they openly admit that it was during the Protestant Revolt of the sixteenth century that "The term anabaptist was used to describe and define certain Christians". Another interesting point... they’re not called "baptists," they still retain the name "anabaptist," and one would assume that the Anabaptists would know their own history better than Carroll does, considering the fact that Carroll is a Baptist and not an Anabaptist. As Funk and Wagnall’s Encyclopedia states:

"Baptists espoused some of the religious convictions of the Ana-baptists, although no established connection existed between the two groups. ... Originally, Baptists originated in the early 17th century in Holland and England, with John Smyth (c. 1554/1612) and Thomas Helwys (c. 1560/1616), English Separatists from the Anglican church." (Funk Wagner Encyclopedia)

The Encyclopedia Britannica concurs:

"Some Baptists believe that there has been an unbroken succession of Baptist churches from the days of John the Baptist and the Apostles of Christ. Others trace their origin to the Anabaptists, a 16th-century Protestant movement on the European continent. Most scholars, however, agree that Baptists, as an English-speaking denomination, originated within 17th-century Puritanism as an offshoot of Congregationalism." (Encyclopedia Britannica )

6. Into the ‘dark ages’ went a group of many churches which were never in any way identified with the Catholics."

This is true, and they were also never in any way identified as Christians. Although we must also remember that Mr. Carroll also believes that the Dark Ages existed six hundred years longer than it really was, that twice as many people were "martyred" during that time as died in the Black Plague (which wiped it one third of the population of Europe - interesting point... what is three thirds of three thirds of a population?), that polytheists can be Christians, that one can take a Profession of the Catholic Faith, accept all the Catholic Sacraments - while, at the same time, believing it to be a false pagan church full of pagan ceremonies and beliefs, and lies openly - and so on, and so forth. I would venture to say that Carroll is pretty untrustworthy in any of his statements, and certainly a very confused man.

I am not promoting the Baptist Church here,

And yet Carroll was obviously promoting the Baptist Church. If Diane truly considered Carroll’s version of history to be true, which she obviously does - her article is based upon it -then she would be forced to become a Baptist, if she truly wanted to be member of the One True Christian Church.

but merely pointing out that anyone who refused to be part of Rome were labeled by their enemies as "Ana-Baptist".

Anyone who refused to be part of Rome were labeled "Ana-Baptist"? Then why is it that the Paulicians are labeled Paulicians, and the Donatists are labeled Donatists, and the Waldensians are labeled Waldensians? And the Anabaptists openly state that the name "Anabaptist" originated, along with their sect, in the sixteenth century? Is Diane called an "Anabaptist"? I should think she wouldn’t have anything to do with Rome.

So next time you hear someone tell you that all churches came from Roman Catholicism, be sure to inform them that in all reality, the Ana-Baptists predate Roman Catholicism.

This myth has already been refuted above. Furthermore, the Catholic Church does not claim that all churches come from Roman Catholicism. Nor does she even claim that all Christian Churches came from Roman Catholicism, for, after all, there is no Christian Church outside Roman Catholicism.

There was always a people true to the word of God, just as the Lord promised, a remnant that would not bow their knee to Baal. (Rom.11:2-5) And today there still exists a people who will hear the voice of the true Shepherd and will not listen to the voice of strangers. (John 10:1-5) They have the promise of God: "Lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world." (Matt. 28:20) God is never without a people, and His people are never without God! His people love His word and cling to it.

This is true, and this people are called Catholics. Not to mention the fact that we also have God’s Word about the fact that in Matthew 16:18  His Church was founded upon St. Peter, the First Pope of the Catholic Church, and that the Gates of Hell will not prevail against His Church. I will here make Diane’s last words my own as well:

"But this I confess unto thee, that after the way which they call heresy, so worship I the God of my fathers, believing all things which are written in the law and in the prophets."

Will you follow Jesus, who is the way, the truth and the life, (John 14:6) or will you be like those who follow lies and falsehood? Which "church" do YOU fit in?

Do not be liars against the truth. This is not the wisdom that descends from above. It is earthly sensual, devilish---James 3:1-15

I