4Unity archive

Bartholomew's Day

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

The Saint Bartholomew's Day Massacre

This is a refutation of the unhistorical Anti-Catholic article called by the same name at The Reformation Online. I came across this article while surfing the Net, I was shocked by the extreme lack of historical accuracy it Contained. The author attempted to falsify history and the truth  by turning a sad political incident into a religious atrocity. considering this articles complete lack of truth, It is not surprising than that this author lists Foxe's Book of Martyrs as a References.

(The Reformation Online Article) August 24, 1572, was the date of the infamous St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre in France. On that day, over 400 years ago, began one of the most horrifying holocausts in history. The glorious Reformation, begun in Germany on October 31, 1517, had spread to France—and was joyfully received. A great change had come over the people as industry and learning began to flourish, and so rapidly did the Truth spread that over a third of the population embraced the Reformed Christian Faith.

    First let us look at the "joyful" spread of this "glorious Reformation" founded by Calvin who himself stated "Persons who persist in the superstitions of the Roman Antichrist . . . deserve to be repressed by the sword.".[1] between 1517 and 1572 there were Ten religious wars commonly known as the Huguenot wars. In the fall of 1561 the Calvinists of France, well supplied with money, took arms under Conde’ and Coligny (and leader of the Huguenots during the early years of the Wars of Religion 1562-98) and began marching through the country to mobilization points, often under the leadership of preachers armed to the teeth.[2]

    While these "Reformed Christian" men thundered against the Scarlet Women of Babylon and preached slaughter with a fervor more becoming to Mohammedans than to men who called themselves Christians... they had begun to sack bishops’ houses and churches, to destroy altars and images of Christ and of the saints, and to deprive Catholics of their faith.

    In 1561 well-organized bands of these reformed Christians (Calvinists) fell upon the Catholic churches, convents, schools and libraries. At Montpellier they sacked all the sixty churches and convents, and put one hundred-fifty priests and monks to the sword. At Nimes they made a great pile of statues and relics in front of the Cathedral, danced around it while the flames arose, yelled that they would have no more Mass or idolaters, and then wrecked and plundered the churches. At Montauban they dragged the Poor Clare from their convent, exposed them half-naked to the jibes of the paid mob, shouted insults at them and told them to get married. At Castres, in December, a Reformed Consistory or Sanhedrin, ordered the city officials to take every one found on the streets to Huguenot sermons. Priests were dragged from the altars, the Poor Clare were scourged at the whip’s end, peasants were driven with blows to hear the preachers inveigh with their peculiar nasal intonation against the Mass, Confession, the Pope. The fields and vineyards around Catholic villages where the people refused to listen to the preaching were burned or cut down.[3]

    Within the year of 1561 the Calvinists, according to one of Their Own estimates, "murdered 4,000 priests, monks and nuns, expelled or maltreated 12,000 nuns, sacked 20,000 churches, and destroyed 2,000 monasteries " [4] with their priceless libraries and works of art. The rare manuscript collection of the ancient monastery of Cluny was irreparably lost, with many others. Sacred vessels from the churches were melted into money to pay German mercenaries, who were urged to be ruthless.

    Coligny took an active part in many of the atrocities. He displayed such cold and vindictive cruelty, especially to priests and nuns, that Catholics came to call him Holofernes. In some places the entrails of the victims were plucked forth, stuffed with straw, and given to the horse of the Huguenot troopers to eat. Hundreds of cities and villages were burned. Lyons and its prosperous commerce were ruined.now let us examine the claim that the Calvinists were "over a third of the population" French historians tell us that by 1572 only five percent of the population had "embraced" Calvinistism.[5] In 1572 a army of French Calvinists under the command of Genlis invaded the Catholic Netherlands burning and plundering. It cannot be denied that the Catholics had abundant evidence of the ruthless cruelty of their enemies, and of the insincerity of their claim to be fighting only for freedom of worship. It was the Calvinists, not the Catholics, who introduced into civil warfare the gory practice of giving no quarter and taking no prisoners.

(The Reformation Online Article) However, alarm bells began to ring at the Vatican! France was her eldest daughter and main pillar—the chief source of money and power. . . . King Pepin of the Franks (the father of Charlemagne) had given the Papal States to the Pope almost 1000 years earlier. Almost half the real estate in the country was owned by the clergy.

    Of course the Vatican was alarmed, but the incident on St. Bartholomew's Day had nothing to do with Rome or the Catholic Church. The St. Bartholomew's Day massacre was purely engineered by the French monarchy for political purposes.[6] Coligny had became the most trusted and influential councilor of the king. He endeavored to embitter the Weak mind of Charles IX. against his mother Catharine de' Medici, against the Duke of Anjou and the family of Guise. No effort was spared by him to bring France into the closest relations with England and the Netherlands against Spain, and as a sign of the reconciliation that had been effected between the court and the Huguenots a marriage was arranged between Henry, the Calvinist King of Navarre and Margaret of Valois, the sister of Charles IX.

    The Queen mother Catharine de' Medici,  believed that Coligny was using his power to alienate the young king from herself, and to win him from the policy she had advocated. She was only waiting an opportunity to wreak her vengeance on Coligny and the whole Huguenot party, knowing well as she did that she could count upon the popular feeling of the nation to support her. [7]

    The opportunity had come on the occasion of the marriage between the King of Navarre and Margaret of Valois. The leading Calvinists anxious to take part in the ceremony flocked to Paris, where they and their followers paraded the streets armed to the teeth and with the air of
conquerors. Catharine de' Medici took steps to secure the murder of Coligny on the 22nd August, 1572, but the attempt failed. Such a step served, however, to embitter feelings on both sides.  Paris awoke the next morning to find the streets full of drunken armed Calvinists (furious at Catharine de' Medici failed attempt of their leaders life.) shouting threats against the monarchy and threats of another bloody war. [8]

(The Reformation Online Article) Meanwhile, back in Paris, the King of France and his Court spent their time drinking, reveling and carousing. The Court spiritual adviser—a Jesuit priest— urged them to massacre the Protestants—as penance for their many sins! To catch the Christians off-guard every token of peace, friendship, and ecumenical good will was offered.

    There is no evidence of a drunken party being held by the King, or of "a Jesuit priest" even taking part in the discussions.  The queen-mother was scared of  the repercussion of her failed assassination attempt saw a new opportunity for the destruction of Coligny and his supporters. In an audience with the king she represented to him that Coligny and the Calvinists leaders were plotting to take his life, and that the only way to secure himself against them was to anticipate them. In view of the previous history of the party and the suspicious temperament of the king, it required little to convince him of the "truth" of this allegation, the King exclaimed "I consent, provided not one you cannot be left alive in France to reproach me with the deed "[9] with this the King signed an order that on a certain pre-arranged signal having been given the soldiers should let loose on the Huguenots. what started out as a plot by the Queen Mother to assassinate her political rivals turned by order of King Charles (the civil leader of France not a representative of the Catholic Church) into a plan to exterminate ALL the Calvinists in France. there was no religious purpose behind the massacre nor did Catholic Church have any part in the planning or execution of these atrocities.

(The Reformation Online Article) Suddenly—and without warning—the devilish work commenced. Beginning at Paris, the French soldiers and the Roman Catholic clergy fell upon the unarmed people, and blood flowed like a river throughout the entire country. Men, women, and children fell in heaps before the mobs and the bloodthirsty troops. In one week, almost 100,100 Protestants perished. The rivers of France were so filled with corpses that for many months no fish were eaten. In the valley of the Loire, wolves came down from the hills to feel upon the decaying bodies of Frenchmen. The list of massacres was as endless as the list of the dead!

    Again, we see extreme historic inaccuracies, incredibly enough you would have the readers believe that all 100,100 of the Calvinists who only days before raced through the streets of Paris drunken and very well armed shouting threats against the monarchy and threats of another bloody war. [9] were suddenly "unarmed". you also disregard the fact that these well armed militant "Reformed Christian" had just finished their third bloody uprising against the French government, rather the obvious reason this incident stayed a massacre instead of a open war in the streets of Paris was not because the Queens political enemies were "unarmed" but  the King's soldiers had the element of surprise. secondly you wish us to believe that the Kings soldiers were led by "Roman Catholic clergy" when even the famous Protestant historian professor Merriman admits that this was purely a political action.[10] the true story is , on the night preceding the feast of St. Bartholomew (23-24 Aug.) the bells of the church of St. Germain-en- Laye were rung, and the troops sallied forth to carry out their instructions. Rumors of a Huguenot plot had been spread through the city. The people were alarmed, and the general body of the citizens took up arms to support the soldiers. In the melee that followed hundreds of Calvinists including Coligny were put to death. The movement spread through the provinces where about the same number suffered as in the capital, even the Huguenot of the time only claim the exaggerated number of deaths to be 70,000 (the contemporary Huguenot Duke de Sully, who himself barely escaped death.)[11] historians tell us the number of slain were not fewer than 10,000 nor more than 50,000 [12] the truth this many of the Catholic clergy, as for example, the Bishop of Lisieux, exerted themselves to put an end to the butchery, as did the Catholic priest in Dijon, Macon, Rouen, and the very Catholic city of Nantes where the Roman Catholic clergy protected the Calvinists and hid them from the wrath of the civil government.[13]

(The Reformation Online Article) Many were imprisoned—many sent as slaves to row the King's ships—and some were able to escape to other countries. . . . The massacres continued for centuries. The best and brightest people fled to Germany, Switzerland, England, Ireland and eventually America and brought their incomparable manufacturing skills with them. . . . France was ruined. . . . Wars, famine, disease and poverty finally led to the French Revolution—the Guillotine—the Reign of Terror—the fall of the Roman Catholic Monarchy—atheism—communism etc., etc.

    This writer claims the "persecutions" in France "continued for centuries." whereas history tells us they Huguenot problem ended only 46 years later in 1628 with the fall of La Rochelle [14] it is true many Huguenots fled to Germany, Switzerland, England but I definitely would not call them "The best and brightest" of France. that as writer claims this exodus of trouble makers is responsible for everything from the French Revolution to the rise in communism and because these "Reformed Christian" left France was plagued by wars. a quick look at history would tell us that between 1562 - 1628 less than 100 years these "Reformed Christian" were responsible for 10 RELIGIOUS WARS.[15]

  • First War (ended by Peace of Amboise) . . . . . . . . . .1562-1563
  • Second War (ended by Peace of Longjumeau). . . . . 1567-1568
  • Third War (ended by Peace of St. Germain). . . . . . . 1568-1570
  • Massacre of St. Bartholomew’s Day, . . . . . . . . . . . .August 24, 1572
  • Fourth War (ended by Edict of Boulogne). .  . . . . . . 1572-1573
  • Fifth War (ended by Peace of Monsieur). . . . . . . . . .1574-1576
  • Sixth War (ended by Peace of Bergerac). . . . . . . . . .1577
  • Seventh War (ended by Treaty of Fleix). . . . . . . . . . .1580
  • Eighth War (War of the Three Henry’s). . . . . . . . . . . 1585-1589
  • Ninth War. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1589-1598
  • Edict of Nantes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1598
  • Tenth War (Siege and fall of La Rochelle). . . . . . . . . . 1627-1628

(The Reformation Online Article) When news of the Massacre reached the Vatican there was jubilation! Cannons roared—bells rung—and a special commemorative medal was struck—to honor the occasion! The Pope commissioned Italian artist Vasari to paint a mural of the Massacre—which still hangs in the Vatican! Medal struck by Pope Gregory XIII, to commemorate the slaughter of over 100,000 French Christians....Gregory had the great red dragon of Satan as his heraldic symbol!!

    The king presented himself before the Parliament of Paris on the day following the massacre, and declared that he alone was responsible for what had happened. He explained that
a plot had been formed against his life and that he had taken the only measures that it was possible for him to take. This was the account of the affair that was forwarded to the French diplomatic representatives abroad, and which they gave at all courts to which they were
accredited. Gregory XIII., acting on the report of the French ambassador, ordered
a special commemorative medal was struck and a /Te Deum/ should be sung in thanksgiving for the safety of the king and royal family, and not, as has been so often alleged, as a sign of rejoicing for the murder of the Calvinists. On the contrary he was deeply pained when he learned the true state of affairs, Pope   Gregory XIII Cried out of sorrow.[16]

    The massacre of St. Bartholomew was indeed unjustifiable, but it was done neither to promote religion nor at the instigation of the Church. It was merely political in its object as far as the king and the queen-mother were concerned, and it was a sudden popular outburst in so far as the citizens of Paris or the
people of the country took part in it. In judging the responsibility and blame for what took place nobody can put out of mind the terrible excesses, of which the Huguenots had been guilty during their long struggle against their own countrymen. The German Lutherans, who looked upon the slaughter as a judgment from Heaven on the Calvinist heretics, were rejoiced at their execution.[17]

    The Huguenots flew to arms to avenge their brethren who had fallen, and the fourth civil war began. The Duke of Anjou laid siege to their strongest fortress, La Rochelle, but failed to take it,

(The Reformation Online Article) The Huguenots won a short period of relief from persecution with the ascension of Henry IV to the throne. The Edict of Nantes gave full freedom to his Protestants subjects. The signing of this Edict inaugurated an era of peace and great prosperity for France.

    It is True that  Catholic France did grant  full freedoms to Protestants, which is far more than the Protestants in England would give the Catholics of England and Ireland.  These grateful Huguenot chiefs, were revolving in mind the founding in France of a Protestant commonwealth like that which the Prince of Orange and his adherents had set up in the Netherlands. The capital of this new republic was to be La Rochelle, on the western coast of France. In 1627, an alliance having been formed between England and the French Protestants, and English fleet and army were sent across the Channel to aid the Huguenot enterprise.  This brought about the tenth religious war in France.

(The Reformation Online Article) This Edict of Toleration was revoked in 1685, and a new storm of persecution ensued. The exodus began again with over a million Huguenots fleeing France to avoid certain torture and death.

    Again, we see a severe twist of history when King Louis XIV revoked The Edict of Nantes in 1685 there was not "over a million Huguenots fleeing France" granted many Huguenots did leave France there number were only about   ten thousand.[18]

(The Reformation Online Article) The descendants of the survivors that reached America were determined that this tragedy should not occur here. Many of them were prominent in the founding of the country. They knew that an armed citizenry in France would have prevented this tragedy from ever happening—and as a result—they gave us the First and Second Amendments to the Constitution. They knew that freedom of religion and an armed citizenry go hand in hand:

    The truth is the founding fathers of our nation did indeed know that freedom of religion and an armed citizenry go hand in hand it is for this reason that they rose up against the Protestant (Anglican) English monarchy. The stain is the stain of bigotry and hatred of the Catholic Church it was there from the very beginning of America's Anglican Establishment. The first Virginia Charter in 1606 established the Anglican Church. The second, in 1609, repeated the terms of the establishment and prescribed the Oath of Supremacy. In support of the Establishment, the draconian laws of Governor Dale in 1611 were directed mainly against the moral laxity of the colonists and were soon abrogated. When lawmaking passed to the Colonial Assembly the Establishment was maintained, but penalizing laws were still directed towards the moral uplift of the church. Intolerance of dissent was latent and implicit. Lord Baltimore, refusing as a Catholic to acknowledge the ecclesiastical supremacy of the king, in 1628 was denied temporary residence in the colony. Following this incident a new Act of Uniformity passed the Assembly, fining absentees from service. Another, in 1642, specifically disenfranchised Catholics and enforced the expulsion, within five days, of a priest coming to the colony. Under Governor Berkeley an Act, directed mainly against the Puritan franchise, was limited to church members. Men making active profession of an alien faith were banished. The General Court made provision for a general church tax to be levied and collected by civil officers. In 1631 came the famous law admitting only church members to civic freedom. In 1635 the magistrates were given inquisitional powers over the churches themselves. Congregationalism became law and Church and State were identical. Colonists were compelled to live within easy distance of meeting houses. Heresy was punished by banishment. Contempt toward ministers merited magisterial reproof, a fine, or standing placarded on a block. In 1656 denial of the Bible meant whipping or banishment, and as late as 1697 a law against "Blasphemy and Atheism" mentions as penalties the pillory, whipping, and boring the tongue with red-hot irons. Catholics of course were not suffered to live in the colony, and Jesuits, if banished, were to be put to death on return. The latter law was never enforced, though latent intolerance may be detected in such an ordinance as that of 1659 making the observance of Christmas a punishable offence. The persecution of Quakers and the inflicting of the death penalty in four instances brought about a rebellion within the colony which,with the endeavor of the Crown to force recognition of the Anglican Church, worked the initial movement in undermining the theocracy. With the appointment of a royal governor the franchise was broadened, Episcopalianism was established, and it was decreed in 1691 that "forever hereafter there shall be liberty of conscience allowed in the worship of God to all Christians (except Papists)".

    In Connecticut, Congregationalism under its famous instrument, the Saybrook Platform, became the State religion. But toleration was unstintingly allowed to every other licensed religion. Even laws against Quakers, apparently unenforced, imposed penalties not upon them but upon the communities that harboured them; while the universal "except Papists" phrase is significantly lacking, though in 1743 a law allowed dissenters "being Protestants" to apply for relief.

    The short-lived attempt of the settlement at New Haven to found a theocratic colony based upon the Mosaic Law is interesting only in its failure. The famous "Blue Laws", now known to be ironic forgeries, were not much more severe than the Mosaic penalties enforced by the New Haven Legislature, according to their own records. The colony was soon incorporated with that of Connecticut, in whose democratic tolerance it was speedily absorbed.

    The first settlers of New Hampshire established a broadly tolerant congregationalism which allowed civil privileges to be independent of religious belief, but the Puritan establishment was firmly planted throughout the years of the colony's union with Massachusetts. To the influence of this union, perhaps, may be traced the single example of persecution in the colony, that against three Quakers in 1659. In 1679 the union with Massachusetts was dissolved, and a royal governor sought, unsuccessfully, to enforce the establishment of the Anglican Church. The assembly of 1680 fixed the Congregational Establishment. The franchise was limited to Protestants, and subsequent laws, notably those of 1692, 1702 & 1714, defined the union of Church and State, allowing the constable to collect the church tax-that from dissenters to go to the support of their own ministers. Under the Toleration Act of 1689 all citizens were obliged to make a declaration against the pope and the doctrines of the Catholic Church.

    Under the Duke of York all churches were established with governmental rights, though those of power and induction were placed in the governor's hands. Persecution for conscience's sake seems unrecorded. Much of this tolerant attitude is due to the older Dutch foundation. It was renewed in the "Charter of Liberties", passed by the Assembly in 1683. When the Duke of York came to the throne a faint attempt was made to establish the Anglican Church. Later the council suspended "all Roman Catholics from Command and Places of Trust", and the franchise was soon confined to Protestants. This attitude was given universal royal warrant under the Great Toleration Act, and a supposititious Established Church existed in New York to the American Revolution, suffering the same kind of political opposition that the Establishment endured in Virginia and the Carolinas. The Establishment seized church property and banished Moravians, under the belief that they were "disguised Papists", though its powers began to wane before the American Revolution.

    The Palatinate of Maryland under the Baltimores furnishes, with the Colony of Rhode Island, the first example in history of a complete separation Of Church and State with religious tolerance. Religious freedom was proclaimed in the famous "Act for Church Liberties", passed by the assembly and practically carried out. Under this Catholic toleration a Catholic was fined for "interfering by opprobrious reproaches with two Protestants", and Jesuits were refused the privileges of the canon law. The Toleration Act of 1649 denied toleration only to non-Christians and Unitarians, and imposed upon every resident an oath declaring for liberty of conscience. The outcome of the disgraceful Puritan "Plot" resulted in the voiding of the charter, the erection of Maryland as a royal province, and the Episcopal Establishment in 1692. The majority of the colonists were so overwhelmingly non-Episcopal that the legislatures never seem to have insisted upon conformity, though they compelled church support. Against Catholics alone persecution endured. They were deprived of all civil and religious rights -- the latter only in private homes; the Law of 1704 laid a tax of twenty shillings on every Irish servant imported; while in 1715 it was enacted that children of a Protestant father and a Catholic mother could, in case of the father's death, be taken from the mother. However, the first Catholic church of Baltimore was erected without opposition in 1763, though the rights of the franchise were not extended to Catholics until the American Revolution put an end to all penal enactment's.

    The Presbyterian and Quaker settlers of the Jerseys, under their proprietors, were granted entire liberty of conscience. But with the assumption of the provinces, the Crown seems to have assumed that, per se, the Anglican Church was established, though no specific act to that effect seems to have been passed. At any rate, excepting troubles with Quakers in the French Wars, the annals of New Jersey are free from records of official persecution, though Catholics were disenfranchised when Jersey became a royal province. Georgia with its two score years of provincial history excluded "Papists" from its confines. The Anglican Church entered with the Crown and was formally, though unsuccessfully, established by the colonial legislature in 1758, the settlement remaining from the beginning indifferent toward Dissent.

(The Reformation Online Article) The French Protestants were called Huguenots: President George Washington had a Huguenot ancestor, as did at least 5 other Presidents: John Adams, John Quincy Adams, John Tyler, James Garfield, and Theodore Roosevelt. A Huguenot refugee named Apollos de Revoire settled in Boston, and had a son who signed his name Paul Revere! Remember his famous midnight ride? Three members of the Continental Congress - Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and Elias Boudinot were Huguenots. Other great names include Francis Marrion, General George Patton, Clair Chennault, Admiral Dewey, Du Ponts, Henry Thoreau, Longfellow etc., etc. A Huguenot colony was founded in Florida in 1562 (years before the English landed), but was later destroyed by Spanish raiders.

    President George Washington also had many Catholic ancestors , as did   Presidents: John Adams, John Quincy Adams, John Tyler, James Garfield, and Theodore Roosevelt so did Paul Revere! Remember his famous midnight ride? All members of the Continental Congress had Catholic ancestors. their is substantial evidence showing that President George Washington was baptized a Catholic on his death bed [19], over 1/3 of Washington's colonial army was Irish/Catholic[20].

For more Information on the Bloody persecutions of the Catholic Church by Protestants, under : The Anabaptists, The Anglican, The Calvinists, The Puritans,


Foot Notes

[1] Harkness, Georgia, John Calvin: The Man and His Ethics, NY: Abingdon Press, NY, 1931.

[2] William Thomas Walsh, Philip II 1937 

[3]  Hanoteaux, /Etudes historiques sur le XVIe et le XVIIe siecle en France/, 1886.

[4] Novuvelle Collection de memoires relatif a l'histoire de France, Ch.  XI, p. 512 also read William Thomas Walsh, Philip II 1937

[5] Vacandard, /Etudes de critique et d'histoire religieuse/, 1905.

[6] Funk & Wagnalls new encyclopedia vol. xxi 1995

[7] Myers,/ Medieval and Modern History/ , 1910

[8] William Thomas Walsh, Philip II 1937 

[9] Myers,/ Medieval and Modern History/ , 1910

[10] Bordier, /La St. Barthelemy et la critique moderne/, 1879.

[11] Encyclopedia Britannica, 1999

[12] James A. Richards, /THE HISTORY OF THE WORLD/, volume v, 1925

[13] William Thomas Walsh, Philip II 1937 

[14]  Rouquette, /L'inquisition protestante, Les Saint-Barthelemy
calvinistes/, 1906.

[15] Myers,/ Medieval and Modern History/ , 1910

[16] William Thomas Walsh, Philip II 1937 

[17] De la Ferriere, /La St. Barthelemy/, 1892.

[18] Funk & Wagnalls encyclopedia vol. xvi/, 1956

[19] Fauriel, /George Washington our president/, 1972

[20] Frank Moriss, /A Neglected Glory, the Catholic Presence in America/, 1976