![]()
CAN PRIESTS REMIT SIN?
This is a refutation of a deceitful Protestant article by the same name written by Baptist named David Cloud. This article is typical of the trash was found at the militant Anti-Catholic BibleBelievers.net and the Way of Life websites.
EZCODE CENTER START
JOHN 20:23 __ "Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose so ever sins ye retain, they are retained."
[Mr. Cloud] The Roman Catholic Church claims to find in this verse the authority exercised by its pope and priests to remit sins. This is a perversion of Scripture and a great blasphemy. Consider these two facts: First, Catholicism places forgiveness of sins into the hands of its priests. There is nothing in John 20:23, though, about a priesthood which is ordained to offer sacrifices and remit sins. The Apostles were not priests and they did not offer sacrifices.
For a true Sacrifice we need a priest, an altar, a victim, and a covenant with God. Christ was truly the great High Priest, and He gave the power of priests to His Apostles, commissioning them to do repeatedly as He Himself had done in their presence. "Do this," He said, "in commemoration of Me." Luke 22:19. The power was to persevere in the Church, even as Malachy had predicted. As victim, Christ offered Himself at the Last Supper. Taking bread and wine He said, "This is My Body ... This is My Blood ... As often as you shall eat this bread and drink this chalice, you shall show the death of the Lord until He come." 1Cor. 11:24-26. The separate forms of consecration represented the separation of His Body and Blood when He ratified the Sacrifice by His death on the Cross next day. The victim, then, is Christ under the appearances of bread and wine representatively separated. This does not interfere with the value of Calvary, for Christ’s real death occurred there, and without it this representative function would be useless. Continuously through the ages the Sacrifice of the Mass has been offered daily in the Catholic Church, and is today offered in every place from the rising of the sun even to its going down, as Malachy predicted.
As for the altar, years after the death of Christ, St. Paul said, "We have an altar whereof they have no power to eat who serve the tabernacle." Heb. 13:10. Finally, there is the covenant with God. "This chalice is the New Testament in My Blood," said Christ. 1Cor. 11:25. It had legal documentary value in the sight of God. The Catholic Church alone fulfills Scripture in the Sacrifice of the Mass.
[Mr. Cloud] The only priesthood we read of in the New Testament church is (a) the high priesthood of Jesus Christ (Hebrews 7_8), and (b) the general priesthood of all believers (1 Peter 2:5,9).
As for the "universal priesthood", on which Mr. Cloud relies in its denial of the special priesthood, it may be said that Catholics also believe in a universal priesthood; this, however, by no means excludes a special priesthood but rather presupposes its existence, since the two are related as the general and the particular, the abstract and the concrete, the figurative and the real. The ordinary Christian cannot be a priest in the strict sense, for he can offer, not a real sacrifice, but only the figurative sacrifice of prayer.
It is in Mark 3:13 that we fined the first clerical ordination of the New Testament. Christ ordained the 12 apostles and sent them forth to preach. The apostles understood that they would not be around forever and THEY needed to establish a leadership to pass along their authority from generation to generation. In St. Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians (3:10-11) he explains he laid a foundation as an expert builder, and someone else is building on it. But each one should be careful how he builds. For no one can lay any foundation other than the one already laid, which is Jesus Christ.
So in theActs (6:2) the ordination of the seven Deacons of the church of Jerusalem. The implication here is very clear "Wherefore, brethren, look ye out among you seven men of honest report, full of the Holy Ghost and wisdom, whom WE (the apostles) may appoint over this business." in Acts 14:23 we read how Barnabas and Paul ordained presbyter in every church, and had prayed with fasting, they commended them to the Lord, on whom they believed. In St. Paul’s letter to Titus (1:5) St. Paul explains it was For this cause he left Titus in Crete, so Titus could set the church in order, and appoint presbyters in every city, as St. Paul commanded; clearly again an example of authority from above not power the congregation.
In St. Paul’s first letter to St. Timothy (who was ordained by St. Paul as a bishop: 1 Timothy 4:14; 2 Timothy 1:6) St. Paul praises this properly ordained leadership is being worthy of double honor "Let the elders that rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially they who labor in the word and doctrine."(1 Timothy 5:17)
Evidence or a special ordained Priesthood is clearly found in the writings of the early Christians as well, the "Didache", Hermas, Clement of Rome, and Irenææus often use the terms "bishop" and "priest" indiscriminately. In fact, it is really a moot question whether the presbyterate gradually developed as an offshoot of the episcopate--which is in the nature of things more likely and in view of the needs of the growing Church more readily understood--or whether, conversely, the episcopate had its origin in the elevation of the presbyterate to a higher rank (Lightfoot), which is more difficult to admit. On the other hand, even at the beginning of the second century, Ignatius of Antioch (Ep. ad Magnes., vi and passim) brings out with remarkable clearness the hierarchical distinction between the monarchical bishop, the priests, and the deacons. He emphasizes this triad as essential to the constitution of the Church: "Without these [three] it cannot be called the Church" (Ad Trall., iii). But, according to the law of historic continuity, this distinction of the orders must have existed in substance and embryo during the first century; and, as a matter of fact, St. Paul (I Tim., v, 17, 19) mentions "presbyters" who were subordinate to the real bishop Timothy. But in the Latin writers there is no ambiguity. Tertullian (De bapt., xvii) calls the bishop the "summus sacerdos", under whom are the "presbyteri et diaconi"; and Cyprian (Ep. lxi, 3) speaks of the "presbyteri cum episcopo sacerdotali honore conjuncti", i.e. the priests united by sacerdotal dignity with the bishop (see BISHOP).
[Mr. Cloud] Second, in the New Testament Scriptures we never read that the other Christians confessed their sins to the Apostles.
St. Paul certainly exercised the power of binding and loosing from sin and the effects of sin. In 2Cor. 2:10, he justifies his forgiveness of the repentant man by saying: "If I have pardoned anything, I have done it in the person of Christ."
[Mr. Cloud] The Bible teaches that it is blasphemous to claim that a mere man can forgive sins (Luke 5:21).
And that is the Catholic teaching also. But the question concerns the way in which God has chosen to administer that forgiveness. We Catholics add that God can delegate His power if He wishes, just as the supreme authority in the state can delegate a judge to administer justice. Would you deny to God that power?
[Mr. Cloud] Sin is always confessed directly to God (Ps. 32:5; 51:4; 86:5; Dan. 9:19). This is how Christ taught us to pray (Luke 11:2,3). James 5:16 says, "Confess your faults to one another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed,"
Here Mr. Cloud contradicts himself, first he says "Sin is always confessed directly to God" and that this is the method that Christ taught. Then he goes onto tell us the divinely inspired scriptures tell us to "Confess your faults to one another...that ye may be healed,". Second, Mr. Cloud shows his ignorance of the scriptures, in II Samuel (12:13) we find David confessing his sins to the prophet Nathan, and being given assurance of pardon. The gospel of Matthew (3:5-6) we read were "all Judaea, and all the region round about Jordan. And were baptized of him (John) in Jordan, confessing their sins."In the book of Acts (19:18) we read were many that believed came to the Apostles, and "confessed, and shewed their deeds"
[Mr. Cloud] but this (James 5:16) refers to all Christians and not merely to the Apostles.
Mr. Cloud seems to be adding to the text of the scriptures, I feel I must ask him, were in this text does St James say that this refers "to all Christians" and does not Just apply to the Apostles? I would like Mr. cloud to provide the chapter and verse that supports his assumption. James epistle was not written to all Christian’s, It was a General epistle to the Church which Christ founded, therefore James was referring to the Church.
[Mr. Cloud] And note that James does not say that Christians have the authority to forgive sins; he says they have the responsibility to pray for one another that GOD will heal and forgive sins.
No, James Does not say "Christians have the authority to forgive sins", but he imply it in his wording. There was no need for John to say that the Church had the power and authority to forgive sins, Christ himself proclaimed this fact Matt. 16:18; 18:18, Luke 24:46-47, John 20:23. It is through this auricular Confession and Prayer that we are healed, even Mr. Cloud does not deny that this "healing" is a forgiveness of sin.
[Mr. Cloud] 1. THIS [John 20:23] REFERS TO THE EFFICACY OF THE GOSPEL. In the previous verses Christ had commissioned the disciples to go forth with the Gospel. "Peace be unto you: as my Father hath sent me, even so send I you" (v. 21). In Matthew 28, Mark 16, and Luke 24 we see that this involves preaching the Gospel to every creature. In this connection the Lord Jesus Christ gave the disciples the Holy Spirit and instructed them that the ministry they would perform and the message they would preach would determine the eternal destinies of men. It speaks of the solemn obligation that belongs to every Christian in fulfilling the Great Commission.
Many scholars refer to this as the "Great Commission", and a simple reading of texts referred to by our opponent will show it involved far more than Just spreading the "Gospel" as Mr. Cloud would like us to believe.
1) Teach all nations (to observe all things commanded by Christ, Matthew 28:19-20, Mark 16:15), this work should begin in Jerusalem (Luke 24:47)
2) Baptizing them ( in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, Matthew 28:20, Mark 16:16)
3) Repentance should be preached (Luke 24:47)
4) The forgiveness of sins should be preached (Luke 24:47, John 20:23)
So we see that the forgiving of sins was indeed pat of the Commission that Christ gave to his disciples, so we see that John 20:23 was simply Christ teaching his disciples how this forgiveness should be obtained.
[Mr. Cloud] 2. THIS ALSO REFERS TO APOSTOLIC AUTHORITY. The Apostles had a unique position in laying the foundation for the churches (Eph. 2:20).
This is true, and the biblical doctrine articulate confession was part of that early Church foundation.
[Mr. Cloud] They wrote the New Testament Scriptures and established the first churches.
Not So, out of twelve Apostles who were with Christ from the beginning only two left us written gospels (Matthew and John), the other two Gospels (Mark and Luke )and the book of Acts (written by Luke) were not written Apostles.
[Mr. Cloud] They had authority which was unique to that work. We see this in such passages as Acts 5:3_9 and 13:9_11. This special apostolic authority ceased with the death of the Apostles.
Christ commissioned His Church to teach all nations till the end of the world. Matt. 28:19-20. The Apostles had to hand on all essential powers to their successors. And the conditions of salvation must be the same for us as for the first Christians. If those subject to the Apostles had to obtain forgiveness from their fellow men, there is no reason why we should be exempt. We share the same privileges as the early Christians and must have the same obligations. Till the Reformation all Christians went to Confession. In the fourth century we find St. Ambrose defending Confession by saying that if a man can forgive sin by baptizing he claims nothing greater when he claims the power to forgive sin through the Sacrament of Penance. That priests possessed such power was Christian doctrine in his time and is still the doctrine of the Catholic Church. The Greek Church, which broke away from the Catholic Church in the ninth century, has retained this Apostolic practice. Protestantism gave up the practice in the sixteenth century because it was uncomfortable and mortifying. But once admit such a principle, and one could abolish every uncomfortable commandment of God.
[Mr. Cloud] In eternity there are only 12 Apostles (Rev. 21:14). Their office was not passed on to others at their deaths.
To start with, there are more than just twelve Apostles found in the New Testament, first we have the twelve that were with Christ from the beginning:
Peter (Cephas), Andrew, James (the greater or elder), John, James (the less or younger), Jude, Philip, Bartholomew, Matthew, Thomas, Simon, Judas.
Than we have those that achieved the position of Apostle after the resurrection of Christ:
Paul (1 Cor. 1:1) , Matthias (Acts 1: 25-26), Barnabas (Acts 14:14), and the Apostles Andronicus and Junias (Rom. 16:7)
Second, I recommend that Mr. Cloud read the book Acts chapter one, were a apostle is ordained as a replacement for Judas, who had died. There is no reason to reject the position that this practice of continued after the deaths of each of the other Apostles.
[Mr. Cloud] Adam Clarke's Commentary on the Bible...Matthew Henry....
Mr. Cloud next attempts to prove his argument by providing two citations from protestant commentaries.... it suffices to say that the writings of early Church [which as Mr. Cloud pointed out were established by the Apostles], disagree with his position and support the Roman Catholic position on auricular Confession.
The Didache
"Confess your sins in church, and do not go up to your prayer with an evil conscience. This is the way of life. . . . On the Lord's Day gather together, break bread, and give thanks, after confessing your transgressions so that your sacrifice may be pure" (Didache 4:14, 14:1 [A.D. 70]).
The Letter of Barnabas
You shall judge righteously. You shall not make a schism, but you shall pacify those that contend by bringing them together. You shall confess your sins. You shall not go to prayer with an evil conscience. This is the way of light. (Letter of Barnabas 19 [A.D. 74]).
Ignatius of Antioch
"For as many as are of God and of Jesus Christ are also with the bishop. And as many as shall, in the exercise of penance, return into the unity of the Church, these, too, shall belong to God, that they may live according to Jesus Christ" (Letter to the Philadelphians 3 [A.D. 110]).
Ignatius of Antioch
"For where there is division and wrath, God does not dwell. To all them that repent, the Lord grants forgiveness, if they turn in penitence to the unity of God, and to communion with the bishop" (ibid., 8)
Irenaeus of Lyons
"[The Gnostic disciples of Marcus] have deluded many women. . . . Their consciences have been branded as with a hot iron. Some of these women make a public confession, but others are ashamed to do this, and in silence, as if withdrawing from themselves the hope of the life of God, they either apostatize entirely or hesitate between the two courses" (Against Heresies 1:22 [A.D. 189]).
Tertullian
"[Regarding confession, some] flee from this work as being an exposure of themselves, or they put it off from day to day. I presume they are more mindful of modesty than of salvation, like those who contract a disease in the more shameful parts of the body and shun making themselves known to the physicians; and thus they perish along with their own bashfulness" (Repentance 10:1 [A.D. 203]).
Tertullian
"[T]the Church has the power of forgiving sins. This I acknowledge and adjudge" (ibid., 21).
Tertullian
"I hear that there has even been an edict set forth . . . The Great Pontiff--that is, the bishop of bishops [i.e., the pope]--issues an edict: 'I remit, to such as have discharged penance, the sins both of adultery and of fornication" (Modesty 1 [A.D. 220]).
Hippolytus
"[The bishop conducting the ordination of the new bishop shall pray:] God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ . . . Pour forth now that power which comes from you, from your Royal Spirit, which you gave to your beloved Son, Jesus Christ, and which he bestowed upon his holy apostles . . . and grant this your servant, whom you have chosen for the episcopate, [the power] to feed your holy flock and to serve without blame as your high priest, ministering night and day to propitiate unceasingly before your face and to offer to you the gifts of your holy Church, and by the Spirit of the high-priesthood to have the authority to forgive sins, in accord with your command" (Apostolic Tradition 3 [A.D. 215])
Origen
"[A final method of forgiveness], albeit hard and laborious [is] the remission of sins through penance, when the sinner . . . does not shrink from declaring his sin to a priest of the Lord and from seeking medicine ,after the manner of him who say, 'I said, "To the Lord I will accuse myself of my iniquity"'" (Homilies in Leviticus 2:4 [A.D. 248]).
Cyprian of Carthage
"The Apostle likewise bears witness and says: ' . . . Whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord' [1 Cor. 11:27]. But [the impenitent] spurn and despise all these warnings; before their sins are expiated, before they have made a confession of their crime, before their conscience has been purged in the ceremony and at the hand of the priest . . . they do violence to his body and blood, and with their hands and mouth they sin against the Lord more than when they denied him" (The Lapsed 15:1
Cyprian of Carthage
"Of how much greater faith and salutary fear are they who . . . confess their sins to the priests of God in a straightforward manner and in sorrow, making an open declaration of conscience. . . . I beseech you, brethren, let everyone who has sinned confess his sin while he is still in this world, while his confession is still admissible, while the satisfaction and remission made through the priests are still pleasing before the Lord" (ibid., 28).
Cyprian of Carthage
"[S]inners may do penance for a set time, and according to the rules of discipline come to public confession, and by imposition of the hand of the bishop and clergy receive the right of communion. [But now some] with their time [of penance] still unfulfilled . . . they are admitted to communion, and their name is presented; and while the penitence is not yet performed, confession is not yet made, the hands of the bishop and clergy are not yet laid upon them, the Eucharist is given to them; although it is written, 'Whosoever shall eat the bread and drink the cup of the Lord unworthily, shall be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord' [1 Cor. 11:27]" (Letters 9:2 [A.D. 253]).
Cyprian of Carthage
"And do not think, dearest brother, that either the courage of the brethren will be lessened, or that martyrdoms will fail for this cause, that penance is relaxed to the lapsed, and that the hope of peace [i.e., absolution] is offered to the penitent. . . . For to adulterers even a time of repentance is granted by us, and peace is given" (ibid., 51[55]:20).
Cyprian of Carthage
"But I wonder that some are so obstinate as to think that repentance is not to be granted to the lapsed, or to suppose that pardon is to be denied to the penitent, when it is written, 'Remember whence thou art fallen, and repent, and do the first works' [Rev. 2:5], which certainly is said to him who evidently has fallen, and whom the Lord exhorts to rise up again by his deeds [of penance], because it is written, "Alms deliver from death" [Tob. 12:8]" (ibid., 51[55]:22).
Aphraahat the Persian Sage
"You [priests], then, who are disciples of our illustrious Physician, you ought not deny a curative to those in need of healing. And if anyone uncovers his wound before you, give him the remedy of repentance. And he that is ashamed to make known his weakness, encourage him so that he will not hide it from you. And when he has revealed it to you, do not make it public, lest because of it the innocent might be reckoned as guilty by our enemies and by those who hate us" (Treatises 7:3 [A.D. 340]).
Basil the Great
"It is necessary to confess our sins to those to whom the dispensation of God's mysteries is entrusted. Those doing penance of old are found to have done it before the saints. It is written in the Gospel that they confessed their sins to John the Baptist [Matt. 3:6], but in Acts [19:18] they confessed to the apostles" (Rules Briefly Treated 288 [A.D. 374]).
John Chrysostom
"Priests have received a power which God has given neither to angels nor to archangels. It was said to them: 'Whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever you shall loose, shall be loosed.' Temporal rulers have indeed the power of binding; but they can only bind the body. Priests, in contrast, can bind with a bond which pertains to the soul itself and transcends the very heavens. Did [God] not give them all the powers of heaven? 'Whose sins you shall forgive,' he says, 'they are forgiven them; whose sins you shall retain, they are retained.' What greater power is there than this? The Father has given all judgment to the Son. And now I see the Son placing all this power in the hands of men [Matt. 10:40, John 20:21The Priesthood 3:5 [A.D. 387]).
Ambrose of Milan
"For those to whom [the right of binding and loosing] has been given, it is plain that either both are allowed, or it is clear that neither is allowed. Both are allowed to the Church, neither is allowed to heresy. For this right has been granted to priests only" (Penance 1:1 [A.D. 388]).
Jerome
"If the serpent, the devil, bites someone secretly, he infects that person with the venom of sin. And if the one who has been bitten keeps silence and does not do penance, and does not want to confess his wound . . . then his brother and his master, who have the word [of absolution] that will cure him, cannot very well assist him" (Commentary on Ecclesiastes 10:11 [A.D. 388]).
Jerome
"We read in Leviticus about lepers, where they are ordered to show themselves to the priests, and if they have leprosy, then they are to be declared unclean by the priest. . . . Just as in the Old Testament the priest makes the leper clean or unclean, so in the New Testament the bishop or presbyter binds or looses not those who are innocent or guilty, but by reason of their office, when they have heard various kinds of sins, they know who is to be bound and who is to be loosed" (Commentary on Matthew 3:16:19 [A.D. 398]).
Augustine
"When you shall have been baptized, keep to a good life in the commandments of God so that you may preserve your baptism to the very end. I do not tell you that you will live here without sin, but they are venial sins which this life is never without. Baptism was instituted for all sins. For light sins, without which we cannot live, prayer was instituted. . . . But do not commit those sins on account of which you would have to be separated from the body of Christ. Perish the thought! For those whom you see doing penance have committed crimes, either adultery or some other enormities. That is why they are doing penance. If their sins were light, daily prayer would suffice to blot them out. . . . In the Church, therefore, there are three ways in which sins are forgiven: in baptisms, in prayer, and in the greater humility of penance" (Sermon to Catechumens on the Creed 7:15, 8:16 [A.D. 395]).
Augustine
"I realize what the incontinent can say: . . . that if a man, accusing his wife of adultery, kills her, this sin, since it is finished and does not perdure in him [i.e., since he does not keep committing it], if it is committed by a catechumen, is absolved in baptism, and if it is done by one who is baptized, it is healed by penance and reconciliation" (Adulterous Marriages 2:16:16 [A.D. 419]).
St. Patrick
"[The murderer] Coroticus . . . fears neither God nor his priests, whom he [God] chose and to whom he granted that highest, divine, and sublime power, that whom they should bind on earth should be bound in heaven" (Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus 6 [A.D. 452]).
Pope Leo I
"With regard to penance, what is demanded of the faithful is clearly not that an acknowledgment of the nature of individual sins written in a little book be read publicly, since it suffices that the states of conscience be made known to the priests alone in secret confession" (Magna indign. 2 [A.D. 459]).
![]()