![]()
THE ROMAN CATHOLIC MASS
This is a refutation of a deceitful Protestant article by the same name written by Baptist named David Cloud. This article is typical of the trash was found at the militant Anti-Catholic BibleBelievers.net and the Way of Life websites.
EZCODE CENTER START
[Mr. Cloud] FOLLOWING ARE THE REASONS WE REJECT THE MASS: (1) Jesus could not possibly have meant that the bread and juice would actually become His body and blood.
To start with, if we search the Bible for the word "juice" we will find that it was never used any were in the New Testament. On the contrary the word 'wine' is used "29" times in the New Testament. Now we know that the words 'fruit of the vine' were used by Jesus to describe what was in the cup, we know that it was 'wine', as was prescribed for the Passover diner.
[Mr. Cloud] When He instituted the Supper, He was there in His physical body, "so the piece of wafer which He said was His body, and the cup of wine which He said was His blood, could not possibly have been His body and His blood in any literal sense; certainly, He was indicating that these were symbols that He was using" (Let Rome Speak for Herself, pp. 14-15).
Mr. Cloud seems to forget that Jesus was GOD. The scriptures tell us that Christ was both human and Devine, there for he was omnipresent, omniscient and omnipotent by his Devine nature. Father Dalgairns this issue thusly:
"The whole question resolves itself into this can a body be unextended? Who will say that God cannot take from a body the property of extension? What contradiction is there in it? Is it not easy for us to conceive substance without extension? If we take to pieces the idea of substance, we shall find that it is quite independent of quantity, on which extension depends; for the smallest grain of gold is as really and substantially gold, as ail the precious metal contained in the whole universe. Again, quantity is a sensible thing which is seen by the eye and felt by the touch; but as for substance, it is revealed to us by the mind alone. Let God but only reduce a body to the state of pure substance, and it ceases at once to be extended, without ceasing to be a body. It is by extension that a body becomes subject to the laws of space; take extension away. and it partakes at once of some of the prerogatives of spirit.
This then is what God has done to the Body of Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament. It has ceased to be extended, and all at once it is freed from the fetters which bound it to place. It is not so much that it is in many places at once, as that it is no longer under the ordinary laws of space at all. It pervades the Host like a spirit. It uses, indeed, the locality formerly occupied by the bread, in order to fix itself in a definite place, but it only comes into the domain of space at all indirectly through the species, as the soul only enters into its present relations with space through the body. Who will say that this involves contradiction, or that it is beyond the power of Omnipotence?"
[Mr. Cloud] Paul plainly says the Lord's Supper is a symbolic, memorial meal (1 Co. 11:23- 25).
I would Like mister Cloud to
read 1 Cor. 11: 27-32 and I ask him, how can a symbol be taken unworthily? How can a symbol cause one
to be guilty for the body and blood of the Lord? How can a symbol taken
unworthily cause damnation?
[Mr. Cloud] In Jn. 6 Jesus explained the meaning of His demand that men eat His flesh and drink His blood, and He said it had a symbolic, not a literal meaning (Jn. 6:35,38,41,48,53).
Catholics make a distinction between the first part of John vi. (verses 26 to 51), wherein Christ speaks of Himself figuratively as the Bread of Heaven, a spiritual food to be received by faith, and the second part (vv. 51 to 59), wherein He speaks literally of His Flesh and Blood as a real food, and a real drink. In the first part, the food is of the present, in the second of the future; there it is given by the Father, here by the Redeemer Himself; there it is simply called "bread," here the "Flesh of the Son of Man"; there our Lord speaks only of bread, here of His Flesh and Blood; there, it is true, He calls Himself "bread," but He avoids the expression "to eat Me," where one would expect to meet it; here He speaks both of "eating Me" and of "eating My Flesh and drinking My Blood"
A careful study of the whole chapter calls for a literal interpretation of the words "to eat the Flesh of the Son of Man and drink His Blood" (John vi. 54). Christ makes a clear-cut distinction between three kinds of bread: the bread or manna of the desert (Exod. xvi. 15; John vi. 49), given by Moses to the Jews in the past to nourish the body; the Bread of Heaven or the Bread of Life (John vi. 32, 35), Christ Himself, given by the Father in the present to the Jews as an object of faith; and the Bread of Life, Christ Himself in the Eucharist, to be given in the future by Christ for the life of the world (John vi. 52).
Again a figurative interpretation is impossible, according to the rules of language. If a figure of speech has a definite meaning, we cannot use it in a new sense, merely for purposes of controversy. To eat one's flesh was a familiar figure among the Jews of old, as it is a common figure among the Arabs of to-day, but it always means to do a person some serious injury, especially by calumny or by false accusation. Is it not absurd to imagine that our Lord would promise eternal life and a glorious resurrection to those who calumniated Him?
To drink one's blood was also a familiar figure among the Jews, but it always meant a chastisement of God (Isa. xlix. 26; Rev. xvi. 6) upon His enemies, a meaning impossible here. Drinking blood was expressly forbidden by the Jewish law (Gen. ix. 4; Lev. iii. 17; vii. 26; xix. 26; Deut. xii. 16; xv. 23), and was therefore regarded as a heinous crime (1 Kings xiv. 33; Judith xi. 10, 11; Ezech. xxxiii. 25). Cardinal Wiseman well says: "The ideas of drinking blood and eating human flesh presented something so frightful to a Jew, that we cannot allow our Savior, if a sincere teacher, to have used them as images for consoling and cheering doctrines; nor in fact to have used them at all under any circumstances than an absolute necessity of recurring to them, as the most literal method of representing His doctrines" (Lectures on the Real Presence, 106).
The Jews certainly understood our Lord literally, for they said: "How can this man give us His flesh to eat?" (John vi. 53.) Our Lord's reply to them proves that He meant them to do so. We must remember that Christ, like every good teacher, made two sorts of answers to men who objected to His teaching. If they did not understand His meaning, He explained His doc-trine more fully. In this way He explains Baptism to Nicodemus (John iii. 3-5), the possibility of the rich man being saved (Matt. xix. 24-26), the fact of Lazarus death (John xi. 11-14), the idea of freedom (John viii. 32-34; Cf. John iv. 31-.34; viii. 21-23).
When His hearers understood His teaching but refused to accept it, He repeated His teaching with even more emphasis. Thus He insisted upon His power to forgive sins, when the Scribes accused Him of blasphemy (Matt. ix. 2-7), and insisted upon His being Eternal, when the Jews said He was not yet fifty years old (John viii. 56-58).
In like manner He acted with the Jews who objected to His teaching about the Real Presence. When they objected: "How can this man give us His flesh to eat?" He did not explain His doctrine in a figurative sense, but He repeated the doctrine that gave offence in a most emphatic manner. He puts His doctrine in the form of a precept: "Except you eat of the Flesh of the Son of Man, and drink His Blood, you shall not have life in you"; and declares "My Flesh is meat indeed, and My Blood is drink indeed." He tells them that this eating and drinking is a pledge of everlasting life, a bond of intimate union with Him, an earnest of supernatural life here and of resurrection hereafter (John vi. 54-59).
When many of the disciples still refused to accept this doctrine, saying: "This saying is hard, and who can hear it (John vi. 61), Christ did not retract His words, and say that He spoke merely in figure. On the contrary. He rebuked them for their lack of faith, and asked them to accept His words, because He came from heaven, and would one day "ascend up where He was be-fore." The unbelieving Jews "walked no more with Him," but the faithful Apostles, who did not comprehend the mystery of the Holy Eucharist, humbly accepted Christ's word. Peter answered for them: "Lord, to whom shall we go? Thou hast the words of eternal life. And we have believed and have known, that Thou art the Christ, the Son of God" (John vi. 62-70).
The doctrine of the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist may be studied in the writing's of the early Church Fathers They held that the Body of Christ is really present in the Eucharist; they cited the doctrine of the Real Presence to refute the various heresies of their time on the Incarnation; they expressly denied that the Eucharist is a mere figure of Christ's Body; they assert that Christ is received in Communion, physically and corporeally.
St. Ignatius writes: "They (The Docetae) abstain from the Eucharist and prayer, because they confess not that the Eucharist is the flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ, the flesh which suffered for our sins, which the Father in His mercy raised up" (Ad Smyrn., 7).
St. Justin writes: "We have been taught that the food over which thanksgiving has been made by the prayer of the word which came from Him-by which (food) our blood and flesh are nourished by transmutation-is both Flesh and Blood of that same Incarnate Jesus" (Apol., i., 65, 66).
St. Irenxus writes: "How shall they feel assured that that bread over which thanksgiving has been made is the Body of their Lord, and the chalice of His Blood, if they do not declare Him the Son of the world's Creator?" (Adv. Haer., iv., 18.)
Theophylact writes: "Saying, `This is My Body,' He showed that the bread sanctified upon the altar is the very Body and not a figure; for He did not say, `This is a figure,' but, `This is My Body"' (In Matt., viii., 26).
St. Cyril of Alexandria writes: "Just as a person who joins one piece of wax to another and applies both to the fire, makes the compound of both one, so by means of our participation of the Body of Christ and of His Precious Blood, He is indeed in us, and we are united in Him" (In John., x., 4).
[Mr. Cloud] The sacrifice of Christ was a once for all event (He. 9:12,26,28; 10:10,12,14). When Christ died on the Cross, He said, "It is finished" (Jn. 19:30). The RCC, with its repeated sacrifices of Christ, denies the eternal sufficiency of Christ's Atonement.
The Eucharist is thus a sacrifice because it re-presents (makes present) the sacrifice of the cross, because it is its memorial and because it applies its fruit: [Christ], our Lord and God, was once and for all to offer himself to God the Father by his death on the altar of the cross, to accomplish there an everlasting redemption. But because his priesthood was not to end with his death, at the Last Supper "on the night when he was betrayed," [he wanted] to leave to his beloved spouse the Church a visible sacrifice (as the nature of man demands) by which the bloody sacrifice which he was to accomplish once for all on the cross would be re-presented, its memory perpetuated until the end of the world, and its salutary power be applied to the forgiveness of the sins we daily commit.1367 The sacrifice of Christ and the sacrifice of the Eucharist are one single sacrifice: "The victim is one and the same: the same now offers through the ministry of priests, who then offered himself on the cross; only the manner of offering is different." "In this divine sacrifice which is celebrated in the Mass, the same Christ who offered himself once in a bloody manner on the altar of the cross is contained and is offered in an unbloody manner"
[Mr. Cloud] A sacrifice without blood cannot atone for sins (Le. 17:11; He. 9:22).
Christ offered Himself with the shedding of blood on Calvary. Without that shedding of blood there would be no remission of sin. Yet since the Mass is but an application of Calvary with its shedding of blood there is no real difficulty. There is a difficulty for one who denies the Sacrifice of the Mass, for without that there is no fulfillment of Malachy’s prophecy that there will be offered in every place a clean oblation, without shedding of blood, from the rising to the setting of the sun.
[Mr. Cloud] The intrusion of a special priesthood between Christ and the believer is an unbiblical abomination (1 Ti. 2:5; He. 7:24-27; 1 Pe. 2:5,9).
At the Last Supper, Jesus Christ, the High Priest of the New Law according to the order of Melchisedech (Ps. cix. 4; Heb. vii. 11), instituted as a permanent and official act of worship the Eucharistic Sacrifice which He had just offered, and in commanding His Apostles to do what He Himself had done, He gave them the power to do what He commanded; i. e., to offer this selfsame Sacrifice as the representatives and sharers of His Eternal Priesthood. And to complete the communication of His Priesthood to His Apostle, He added on the first Easter day the other strictly sacerdotal power of forgiving and retaining sins. (John 20: 21-23)
Although most likely Christ made His Apostles priests with out any special ceremony, the Acts of the Apostles and the Epistles of St. Paul mention all the elements of the Sacrament of Orders; the external symbolic rite of the imposition of hands and prayer; the internal grace given by this rite; and its institution by Christ.
The external sign is the imposition of hands. "These (the seven deacons) they set before the Apostles, and they praying, imposed hands upon them" (Acts 4:6). "Then they, fasting and praying, and imposing their hands upon them (Paul and Barnabas), sent them away" (Acts 13:3). Paul and Barnabas ordain priests for the different churches. "And when they had ordained to them priests in every church, they commended them to the Lord, in whom they believed" (Acts 14:22). St. Paul, writing to Timothy (1 Tim. 5:22), tells us that the Sacrament of Orders was to be handed down by an external rite: "Impose not hands lightly upon any man."
That the imposition of hands communicates internal grace is taught clearly by St. Paul. "Neglect not the grace that is in thee, which was given thee by prophecy, with imposition of the hands of the priesthood" (1 Tim. 4:14). "I admonish thee that thou stir up the grace of God which is in thee by the imposition of my hands" (2 Tim. 1:6).
The divine institution of Orders is also mentioned by St. Paul who says that He (Christ) "gave some Apostles, and some prophets, and other some evangelists, and other some pastors and doctors, for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the Body of Christ" (Eph. 4:11, 12).
No one has the right to teach the Gospel authoritatively, or carry on its sacred ministry, unless he is divinely commissioned as a successor of the Apostles, or a sharer in the Priesthood of Jesus Christ. "Neither does any man take the honor to himself, but he that is called by God, as Aaron was" (Heb. 5:4). "How can they preach," asks St. Paul, "unless they be sent?" (Rom. 5:4) i. e., divinely commissioned.
[Mr. Cloud] The supposed changes which occur in the Mass are clearly deceptions. The bread and wine remain unchanged in appearance, color, odor, or form, yet the Catholic Church requires its people to believe the elements actually become Christ. They call this deception a miracle, but true biblical miracles are real and observable.
What Mr. Cloud has presented here is a atheistic - like argument? I wonder if when the Holy Spirit appeared as a dove, if it would have carried the characteristics of a dove or of divinity under physical eye. Christ himself in appearance, color, odor, and form would have appeared to a "mere man", yet the scriptures tell us he was divine. Mr. Cloud seem to wish us to base our faith on our physical censes and "appearances", I recommend that he read John Chapter twenty (5:29) and Christ's reply to doubting Thomas:
"because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed."
It Mass is a mystery of faith. All external appearances remain as before consecration, but the substance of bread and the substance of wine are changed into the substance of our Lord’s Body and Blood. The reason why we believe is not in the Host as such, but in God. He has revealed this truth, and we believe because He must know and could not tell an untruth.
[Mr. Cloud] It is idolatry to worship the elements of the Mass (Ex. 20:4-5; Jn. 4:24).
The "elements of the mass" are the body blood soul and divinity of Jesus Christ (who is God), so than we see that it is really God himself we are worshiping. The worship of God is not only proper, it is required by the scriptures.
[Mr. Cloud] There is no semblance between the drama of the Catholic Mass and the simple ceremony initiated by Christ and practiced by the N.T. churches (Mt. 26:26-29; Mk. 14:23-25; Lk. 22:19-20; 1 Co. 11:23- 25).
Anti-Catholics are always trying to compare the acorn to the oak tree that it grew into, Since they cannot, they conclude that they are not related.
To start with Malachias, the last of the Prophets, foretold the abolition of the Mosaic sacrifices, and the establishing of a new Sacrifice, which was to be offered up everywhere. The words used by the prophet muctar, muggas, mincha are used over three hundred times in the Old Testament in the sense of a real sacrifice; they are never used to mean a mere internal worship of praise and thanksgiving. He says: "I have no pleasure in you (the priests), saith the Lord of Hosts, and I will not receive a gift of your hand. For from the rising of the sun even to the going down, My name is great among the Gentiles and in every place there is Sacrifice, and there is offered to My name a clean oblation; for My name is great among the Gentiles, saith the Lord of Hosts" (Mal. i. 10, 11).
The Teaching of the Twelve Apostles (100) held that the Mass was the Sacrifice foretold by Malachias (ch. xiv.), thus anticipating the Council of Trent by fourteen centuries (Sess. xxii., ch. 1).
The sacrificial character of the Mass is proved from Christ's words in consecrating the chalice. St. Luke's words: "This is the chalice, the New Testament in My Blood, which is shed for you" clearly mean that the Blood contained in the chalice is shed at the present time for you (Luke xxii. 20). St. Matthew: "This is My Blood of the New Testament, which is shed for many unto remission of sins" (xxvi. 28) and St. Mark: "This is My Blood of the New Testament which is shed for many" (xiv. 24), also declare that Christ's Blood is being shed for us. The shedding of blood for remission of sins is a real sacrifice. "For the life of the flesh is in the blood, and I have given it to you upon the altar to make atonement: for it is the blood that maketh atonement by reason of the life" (Lev. xvii. 11).
The consecration of the bread affords another proof of the sacrificial character of the Mass. The words, "This is My Body, which is given for you" (Luke xxii. 19), or "which is delivered for you" (1 Cor. xi. 24), clearly show that Christ offered Himself up to death. When the priest at Mass to-day consecrates the Body and Blood of Christ, he offers up to God the Victim of the Passion. St. Cyprian in the third century wrote: "The Passion of the Lord is the Sacrifice we offer" (Epis., lxiii., 17). At Mass the priest does what Christ did at the Last Supper. "Do this for the commemoration of Me" (1 Cor. xi. 24). When Christ consecrated the bread and wine into His Body and Blood He offered up His death, so that the priest, consecrating at Mass, also offers up Christ's death.
"This is My Body," He says, "which is delivered up for you," -delivered unto death. "This is My Blood, which is shed for you," in atonement for your sins. "My Blood which flows for you": is that not death? Death indeed put before us in a symbol, by means of that sacramental parting of the Blood from the Body; but death at the same time pledged to God for all its worth, as well as all its awful reality, by the expressive language of that sacred symbol. The price of our sins shall be paid on Calvary; but here the liability is incurred by our Redeemer, and subscribed in His very Blood. The Flesh of the Lamb is consigned in God's hands, for as much as it is assigned as our ransom, Christ is bound for His Passion, from which it is henceforth impossible for Him to step back without taking from God what He has given to God, and thus violating that principle of justice, according to which everyone is bound to render unto God the things that are God's" (Catholic Faith in the Eucharist, 117).
The whole argument of St. Paul in 1 Cor. x. 16-21, supposes that the Christians have a Sacrifice of their own, which is far superior to the Pagan and Jewish sacrifices, for it enables the Christian to partake of the Body and Blood of the Lord.
"Why partake of the table (altar) of devils," He asks them, "when you can be partakers of the table (altar) of the Lord?" It is a grievous sin of idolatry to share in the sacrificial banquets of the pagans, for this eating and drinking unites you with the altar, the sacrificing priest, and the victim slain. The chalice of benediction and the bread which we break unites us with the Blood of Christ, and makes us partakers of His Body-by
Communion we are united to the altar, the sacrificing priest and the Victim slain. Unless there was at Corinth a Christian Sacrifice of the Mass, the comparison of the Apostle would be utterly meaningless.
The Teaching of the Twelve mentions the Eucharistic Sacrifice: "Having assembled together on the Lord's day, break bread
and give thanks, having confessed your sins beforehand in order that your Sacrifice may be pure" (xiv.).
![]()
This page has helped
People find the truth since November 1999