4Unity archive

II Timothy and Tradition.

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

Does 2 Timothy 3:16-17 "All Scripture...Profitable" Disprove Sacred Tradition?

"All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: That the man of God may be perfect throughly furnished unto all good works." (2 Timothy 3:16-17).

Besides the Apostles teaching and tradition, the reading of Holy Scriptures is, indeed, a great benefit for the faithful, and especially for a clergyman, not only to avoid and condemn heresies, but also to the guiding of an individual in justice, good life, and works. But the Apostle Paul, was not here giving this commendation to the books of the New Testament only (as a matter of fact, he could not have been referring to the books of the New Testament, as a large portion of them had not yet been written) but to the Scriptures of the Old Testament also, and to every book of it. For there is not one of them, nor any part of them, but is profitable for the ends mentioned by Saint Paul, if the verses are read in accordance with the spirit of the individual writing them.

But, as it is, various heretics and ignorant people, pretend that this commendation of Holy Scriptures implies that nothing is necessary to justice and salvation but Scriptures - as though everything that is profitable or necessary to any effect, to the exclusion of all other help, were contained within the Scriptures. By which reason a man might as well assume that the Old Testament were sufficient (as these were the Scriptures referred to by Saint Paul, for the greater part of the New Testament had not yet been written), and thereby exclude the New Testament; For Saint Paul affirms every Scripture to have the aforesaid perseverance in the doctrine which Saint Paul had taught him over and above that as he had learned out of the Scriptures of the Old Testament, which Testament he had read from his infancy, but could not thereby learn all the mysteries of the Christian religion. Nor does the Apostle affirm here that Saint Timothy had this knowledge of Scripture by reading only, without the help of teachers, as heretics such as yourself (in an attempt to commit Holy Writ into the realm of the private judgment of every individual, be they ignorant and unstable, or not) conclude; but Saint Paul affirms only that Saint Timothy knew the Scriptures, and therefore had studied them by hearing good readers and teachers - as Saint Paul himself did of Gamaliel, and the like.

In fact, in verses 14-15 Saint Paul says " But thou, continue in those things which thou hast learned, and are committed to thee; knowing of whom thou hast learned; and because from thine infancy thou hast known the Holy Scriptures, ...." Take note of the fact that Saint Paul refers to another source, outside of the Scriptures, from which Saint Timothy obtained his learning.

In addition to the above, is the fact that Saint Paul himself utilized Tradition in his teaching of the Gospel, as can be seen in this very epistle to Saint Timothy. For in verse 8, Saint Paul says "But as Jannes and Jambres resisted Moses, so these also resist the truth, men corrupted in mind, reprobate concerning the faith." Whereas the names of these individuals are not recorded in any part of the Old Testament, therefore it came to the Apostle’s knowledge by tradition. Hence, we see that even Saint Paul realized that Sacred Tradition is also profitable for teaching the truths of the Gospel.