4Unity archive

Witnesses and the Watchtower 1

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.
Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower

copyright 1995 by David Wesley

CHAPTER 1 - GOD'S MISTAKE


One of the major tenets of Jehovah's Witness doctrine is that God's select people will
inherit a paradise on earth. This paradise will be like a wonderful fountain of youth
where people of all races and nationalities will live together in perfect harmony. They
appeal to science which they say cannot explain why people age. "Humans should be
able to live forever," they assert. This was God's original intention when He placed
people on earth, that "the entire earth [was to be] brought under the control of a
righteous human family all living together in peace and happiness." If only Adam and
Eve had not sinned, death would be unknown, and man would still be living in a
garden of Eden. God never intended to have the world inhabited in such a manner as it
is today, with war, poverty, illness and sin abounding everywhere.

Here a Christian must ask himself, "Is God capable of such a mistake?" Not if He is All
Powerful, Almighty, and All Knowing. Surely if a meteorologist can predict whether a
hurricane will hit the coast of Florida on Friday of next week, God knows this. He also
knows if another one will hit the coast of Florida ten thousand years from now. How
then, could He have not known that man would sin and rebel against His authority?
Here the Witnesses will admit that God could know such things if it was His will to
know. "But God chose not to know," they reply. For what purpose?

"We can be sure that God's purpose for the earth did not change." On this point we can
agree. But what was God's purpose for the earth? Surely God did not intend the
pinnacle of His earthly creations to be a slave to His will, mere robots. Rather, we all
know that God created man in his own image. In order to do so, He also gave us free
will. The difficulty, however, does not come from an inability to conceptualize a God
that would allow His creation to disobey him, but rather from the inability to
conceptualize infinity.

God is without beginning or end. Remember back to your summer holidays as a child.
They seemed to go on forever. Having only lived a short time, two months was large
stretch of that lifetime. Now that you are an adult, it seems like every time you sneeze,
two months have gone by. It has become a smaller fraction of your lifespan. Now
imagine God. He has no beginning and no end. There is no relative time span. To Him,
a day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like a day (cf.Ps 90:4). He
inhabits all time and all space. This concept is very important to an understanding of
why the fall of Man could never have been unknown to God. The combined sins of
man are as real to him now as the world before Adam, even before dinosaurs. This is
why every time a priest celebrates mass, he offers the same sacrifice that Christ made
when he died on the cross. Christ does not suffer over and over again during each
eucharistic consecration. Time is an invention of man to help us put order into our
lives.

Indeed, the Watchtower undercuts their own argument in this respect. "God is able to
foretell the future," they note. "He describes himself as 'the One telling from the
beginning the finale, and from long ago the things that have not been done; the One
saying, My own council will stand, and everything that is my delight I shall do.' (Isaiah
46:10)" Still, wishing to show that God "chooses not to foreknow," the Watchtower
presents the following argument: "would it not have been hypocritical for God to offer
the prospect of everlasting life to Adam and Eve, fully aware that they would be unable
to realize it?" How dare they call God a hypocrite! What blasphemy! God always gave
Adam and Eve "the prospect of everlasting life" even after the fall, through the eternal
and Holy Sacrifice of our Lord Jesus Christ. If God wanted our first parents to remain
in paradise forever, he could have done so by simply not creating a tree of knowledge,
thereby preventing any means for disobedience. Yet, predestination in no way implies
that choice is not given. One is predestined to heavenly glory by choosing this glory
freely just as one who is predestined to eternal damnation makes the choice to follow
such a destiny. There is nothing hypocritical about God knowing who will betray him
and who will be faithful. Holy Scripture tells us, for example, that Judas was "destined
to be lost" (Jn. 13:11; 17:12). Since Judas had not yet betrayed Jesus, he was indeed
predestined to be lost, not by any interference from God, but by Judas' own free will
which God knew "from the beginning."

Reverend Francis Spirago in The Catechism Explained clarifies this issue with the
following analogy. "When God foresees that some man will be lost forever, God's
foreknowledge is not the cause of the man's damnation. The physician foresees the
approaching death of his patient, but his knowledge is not the cause of the man's
death." The Watchtower argues, "If God has already chosen the ones to be saved,
would this not dampen the zeal Christians show in evangelizing? Would it not make
the preaching work essentially pointless." To such arguments, Rev. Spirago relates the
following story: "The learned Franciscan Duns Scotus, once heard a farmer uttering
terrible curses and begged him not to damn his soul so thoughtlessly. The farmer
answered: 'God knows everything. He knows whether I shall go to heaven or to hell. If
He knows that I shall go to heaven, why to heaven I shall go; if He knows that I shall go
to hell, I shall go to hell. What then does it matter what I do or say?' The priest
answered, 'In that case why plough your fields? God knows whether they shall bear a
good crop or not. If He knows that they will bear a good harvest, the harvest will be
good, whether you plough the land or not. If he knows that they will be unfruitful, why
unfruitful they will be. Why then should you waste time ploughing?' Then the farmer
understood that it is not the omniscience of God, but the free action of man, that
determines both our temporal and our eternal happiness or misery." That free action of
man is determined in the mind of God by His absolute foreknowledge and is thereby
predetermined. By His foreknowledge, God already knows who will be saved and who
will be damned. Through this foreknowledge, God has "chosen the ones to be saved"
based on their faith, humility, and obedience. Only a feeble mind would consider such
virtues "pointless" simply because God knows who possesses them.

Yet, the Watchtower maintains, "the Scriptures reveal that there are situations in which
God chooses not to foreknow the outcome. Just before the destruction of Sodom and
Gomorrah, he declared: 'I am quite determined to go down that I may see whether they
act altogether according to the outcry over it that has come to me, and, if not, I can get
to know it.' (Genesis 18:21). This text clearly shows us that God did not foreknow the
extent of the depravity in those cities before he investigated matters." Really?
Remember that God is here in dialogue with Abraham, and that Abraham attempts to
intercede on behalf of Sodom, just as the Saints in Heaven intercede and "pray for us
sinners." God willed this dialogue between Himself and Abraham as a means of
drawing out and demonstrating that His pleasure is that the righteous plead on behalf
of the unrighteous. He shows us how to "love your enemies and pray for those who
persecute you" (Mt. 5:44). Also take note that the language used in this passage is how
God revealed himself to Abraham, for at the end of the conversation, "Yahweh went
away." In the literal sense this is impossible since God "fill[s] heaven and earth?" (Jr
23:24) and "all things" (Ep 4:10). Just as God is not constrained by a burning bush (Ex.
3), He chooses various forms through which He reveals Himself to man. God already
knew the fate of Sodom and He never says anything to the contrary. "God is no human
being that he should lie, no child of Adam to change his mind" (Nb. 23:19). We only
change our mind because of imperfection, yet God is Perfect. Who are we to question
His will that we "pray for those who persecute [us]" or His will that Abraham plead for
Sodom.

The Watchtower's position also creates problems in logic. They say "that there are
situations in which God chooses not to foreknow," yet they do not describe the method
which God uses to make this choice. How does God decide which events He will
foreknow and those He will not? In making this choice He must have criteria, yet
knowledge of the criteria already suggests foreknowledge. For example, the
Watchtower asserts that "God exercised his foreknowledge to reveal the succession of
world powers," and "God can see certain events." How did God decide to know that
foreknowledge of "the succession of world powers" was relevant to His purpose and
that foreknowledge of other events, such as "the extent of the depravity of [Sodom and
Gomorrah]" were not? Would He not need to foreknow the events which were to take
place in Sodom and Gomorrah in order to make His decision not to foreknow those
same events? The answer to this question, according to Watchtower logic, is as
impossible to define as the riddle about whether the chicken came before the egg, or the
egg before the chicken. The only solution is to admit that God knows all things at all
times, including our destiny.

But what is that destiny for the ones chosen to be saved? The Watchtower cites
Scriptural passages which they feel imply that the earth will last forever, and that the
righteous will always inhabit it. However, one must be careful to read the quoted
passages in context. Often they refer to the return of the Jews from the captivity of
Babylon and Egypt. Other times, as in Psalms 67 and 72, they refer to blessings
bestowed upon the king. In contrast, the Bible proclaims that His Kingdom is not of this
world (Jn 18:36). Neither will ours be.

What makes us Christians is our belief that God became Man. He only lived among us
for a short time, after which He died to pay the ransom for our sins. This is a major
point of contention with Jehovah's Witnesses who proclaim that Jesus is none other
than Michael the Archangel. This will be discussed later in the book. However, this
point is particularly relevant when interpreting Revelation 21: 3, 4. "Then I saw a new
heaven and a new earth; the first heaven and the first earth had disappeared now, and
there was no longer any sea. I saw the holy city, the new Jerusalem, coming down out
of heaven from God, prepared as bride dressed for her husband. Then I heard a loud
voice call from the throne, 'Look here God lives among human beings. He will make his
home among them; they will be his people, and he will be their God, God-with-them.
He will wipe away every tear from their eyes; there will be no more death, and no
more mourning or sadness or pain. The world of the past has gone' (Rev 21:1-4)."

The Watchtower chooses to interpret the above passage as a reference to a renewed
earth where there will be no death or sadness, and God will live among them.
However, there are several problems with such an interpretation. First, cross reference
this passage to Matthew's account of the nativity (Mt 1:23). Here, Immanuel is the name
used to describe the child Jesus, meaning God-with-us. Surely in Jesus, God does live
among human beings. Second, the holy city, the new Jerusalem, is a metaphor used by
Jews and early Christians to describe heaven. This is particularly evident in an account
given in the letter to the Hebrews (Hb 11:8-16). In this account, Abraham's descendants,
which are "as numerous as the stars" are looking forward to "their heavenly homeland"
since God has "founded the city for them." They recognize that they are "strangers and
nomads on earth."

The story of Abraham and his descendants is also relevant to the question of time,
which was discussed above. We know that salvation only comes through Christ Jesus
as we are reminded in the famous passage of John 3:16. How then could God have
founded the city of heaven for them unless Christ died for our sins for all time. For an
infinite God this is possible; for one constrained by time, only those alive after the
death and resurrection of Jesus Christ can be saved, as only they will know who he is.
Yet this is what the Watchtower proposes. Before Christ, nobody could even hope for a
"heavenly homeland." As evidence, they point to John 3:13: "No one has gone up to
heaven except the one who came down from heaven." Yet what is the context in which
he says this? After Jesus describes how one must be "born again" through baptism
before he can enter the kindom of God, Nicodemus asks, "How is that possible?" (Jn.
3:9). In reply, Jesus notes, "In all truth I tell you, we only speak about what we know
and witness only to what we have seen and yet you people reject our evidence. If you
do not believe me when I speak about earthly things, how will you believe me when I
speak about heavenly things?" (Jn. 3:11,12). The point he is making here is not that
nobody has ever gone to heaven, but that among those living, nobody has seen heaven,
and therefore nobody, Nicodemus included, can understand it.

Quoting Saint Gregory the Great, Saint Francis de Sales suppliments Jesus' point with
the following parable: "Picture a pregnant woman who is put into prison, where she
remains until the time of her delivery. She even gives birth there and is then
condemned to pass the remainder of her life in the dungeon and to bring up her child
there. As he grows older his mother desires to give him some idea of things in the
outside world, for having lived only in continual darkness he has no idea of the light of
the sun, the beauty of the stars, or the loveliness of nature. Since the mother wants to
teach him all these things, they lower a lamp or a lighted candle to her. With this she
attempts to make him conceive, as best she can, the beauty of a bright day. She tells
him: 'The sun and the stars are made like this and spread out a great light.' It is all in
vain, for the child, having had no experience of the light of which his mother speaks,
cannot understand." Even though Abraham and his descendents could not understand
heaven, heaven was still their hope. They trusted their Lord (Ps. 22:4) and His promise
was their hope, just as the child in Gregory's parable trusted his mother and hoped that
one day he would see the light of day, green flowing hills, and towering forests.

Continuing on, the Watchtower proclaims that the earth was made for man, and that
the earth will last forever, even though Paul reminds the Philippians that "they will be
lost...since their minds are set on earthly things. But our homeland is in heaven...(Phil
3:19-20)." Saint Luke also reminds us that when Christ comes again, "no one on the
housetop, with his possessions in the house must come down to collect
them...Remember Lot's wife (Lk 17:31-32)." Certainly there is greater glory in the
presence of God in His heavenly kingdom than can ever be attained through all the
riches of the world. Over and over, scripture tells us to set our eyes on God who has
prepared the city of heaven, the new Jerusalem, for a multitude as numerous as the
stars in heaven (cf. Hb 11:12). Those who set their eyes on the riches of this world will
only find death. Of course Witnesses will deny that they are coveting the things of this
world. The transformed earth will be vastly different from the one of today, since there
will be no hoarding or greed. In fact, what they are describing is a perfect socialist
utopia. In developing countries, the ranks of the Jehovah's Witnesses are swelling in
alarming numbers. The poor of those countries are buying into a dream of a life that
they cannot hope to attain in their present state. They are told that in the last days when
the angels of God come to execute His judgement, only Witnesses will survive.
Afterwards, they will be free to take what is left behind from wealthy Catholics,
Protestants, Atheists, and others, who will not survive the final judgement. In the
meantime, these hard working peasants will send what little they have to support the
multimillion dollar publishing empire which the Watchtower has established in
Brooklyn, New York.

Watchtower books are filled with beautiful colour illustrations of the paradise on earth.
Happy smiling faces are waiting to greet those wanting to convert. "Look how healthy
and youthful they appear! If you were told that these people had already lived
thousands of years, would you believe it?," exclaims the Watchtower. To back up their
claims about this, yet undiscovered, fountain of youth, they cite Job 33:25. There Elihu,
Job's young and proud friend, tells Job that "his flesh will recover it's childhood
freshness, he will return to the days of his youth." If you recall the story of Job, you will
remember that Job had lost all his family and his wealth when God decided to prove
Job's faith. In his despair, Job was counselled by four sages. The last and youngest to
speak was Elihu. We know that Elihu cannot be trusted for God declares, "Who is this,
obscuring my intentions with his ignorant words?(Job 38:2)" When challenged on this,
the Witnesses will respond that God was only referring to the other three sages. Yet, it
is not until chapter 42 that the other three are rebuked (Job 42:7-9). Still, they will
maintain that Elihu was wise and inspired by God. But this argument doesn't wash.
First, in the same chapter quoted by the Watchtower, Elihu announces, "keep quiet, and
I will teach you wisdom (Job 33:33)." Certainly Elihu was not only proud, but arrogant
to declare himself as such in the presence of God's favoured servant Job. Doesn't Saint
Matthew tell us that "Anyone who raises himself up will be humbled, and anyone who
humbles himself will be raised up (Mt 23:12)." After all, "God opposes the proud, but
he accords his favour to the humble (Jas 4:6)." As further evidence of his pride, Elihu
also declares, "I guarantee, nothing I shall say will be untrue, you have a man of sound
learning here (Job 36:4)."

What was lost by Adam's sin was the garden of Eden. The Watchtower promises that
this state will be restored under Jesus Christ and the faithful of Jehovah will be
permitted to reside in this paradise on earth. As evidence they cite Luke 23:43.
Remember that Christ is speaking with a thief who, near death, sincerely professes his
faith in our Lord. Jesus then "answered him, 'In truth I tell you, today you will be with
me in paradise.'" In the Watchtower's New World Translation (NWT), the comma is
shifted so that it falls after today. "Truly I tell you today,..." it reads, thus permitting an
interpretation where the good thief will be resurrected at Armageddon and live with
Jesus in his earthly paradise. The thief will not be in paradise today. Jesus is telling him
"today," that he will live in a paradise on earth some thousands of years into the future.
This goes back to the conception of time and how man measures the seasons in a way
far different from God, as we discussed earlier. But all this is beside the point. Paradise
is referred to elsewhere in the New Testament. For example, Paul describes a vision in
a letter to the people of Corinth. "I know a man in Christ who fourteen years ago - still
in the body? I do not know; or out of the body? I do not know - God knows - was
caught up right into the third heaven. And I know that this man - still in the body? - or
outside the body? I do not know, God knows - was caught up into Paradise (2 Cor 12:2-
4)." Here, Paradise is equated to the third heaven.

Then we are asked to put ourselves in God's shoes (those are pretty big shoes to fill).
"Would you bring to an end all the things that cause human suffering?...of course you
would," declares the Watchtower. It's a good thing were're not God. He has given us
free will so that we can chose between good and evil, between Jesus and Satan,
between Heaven and Hell. After all, if God could see no benefit in allowing us to sin
and to suffer, he could have ended those things long ago. But then how would we ever
hope to share in his divinity as mere automatons. Suddenly, your JW study partner
objects. "You're not suggesting that Jehovah God created evil are you?," he retorts. God
forbid, as St. Paul would say. All I am saying is that when man was created in the
image of God, he was also created with free will. Along with free will comes Ego. And
with Ego comes the desire to be God (cf. Gen 3:5). It is this desire to become God that
has helped popularize the New Age movement. Take for example a family. The parents
become one flesh, and through the gift of God, create new life. The children born unto
them will grow up and become like them. They will make mistakes, but they will also
have successes. They will hate, but they will also love. When my child does wrong, am
I responsible? Not if I have given good guidance to the best of my abilities. On the
other hand, children learn from their mistakes, which helps them to become more
responsible, like mom and dad. Parents know in advance that when they procreate,
their offspring will commit sin. Just because they sin, doesn't mean that couples should
not have children, nor are they (usually) responsible for the sins of their children. So it
is with our Heavenly Father. He knew that we would sin, but he chose to create man in
his image so that man could someday share in his divinity. We are responsible for our
own sins. God has given us a conscience and his Holy Word to guide us. We are free to
choose.

To add to this, refer to Paul's letter to the Romans. "[God] decided beforehand who
were the ones destined to be moulded to the pattern of his Son, so that he should be the
eldest of many brothers; it was those so destined that he called; those that he called, he
justified, and those that he has justified he has brought into glory (Rm 8:29,30)." In
essence, God knows what we are doing today, tomorrow, and the next day. To Him, it
is as though those things have already happened. Notice the tense used in the above
verse. He knows that path our lives will take and to Him, those who love Him already
share in His glory. As an illustration, if a king could see into the future and know the
paths his children will take in life, he will be better able to plan the inheritance of his
kingdom by those children who have shown to be responsible. Still, he must allow
them to run the course of their lives so that they are able to mature and learn from their
mistakes. If he were to suddenly divide his estate beforehand, he would be interferring
in their destiny and impeding their ability to mature.

Our predestined salvation through Christ is also mentioned in Ephesians 1:4,5. We are
told that He chose us before the world was made. The Watchtower condemns this
theology since "they could not fail, regardless of what they did." There they make the
big mistake of assuming that we are saved by our works, rather than the grace of God.
If it were only for our actions that we are chosen, then none of us could ever hope to
share in His glory. Rather, those who accept Christ are ransomed from death by His
sacrifice from the cross. Instead, the Watchtower suggests that there will be a class of
people who will prove faithful and receive a just reward. This notion does nothing but
belittle Christ's sacrifice.

The Watchtower suggests that the passage in Saint Paul's letter to the Ephesians is
paralleled by Luke 11:50, 51 where the founding of the world refers to "the time of
Abel," and thus after the fall of man. In this passage Jesus warns his listeners that they
will be held accountable for the blood of the prophets which has been shed since the
foundation of the world from Abel to Zechariah. There is false logic in this argument
which I will illustrate in the following example. Suppose we transpose the words
"blood of the prophets" with the words "airplane crashes." If we now say that they will
have to pay for the airplane crashes since the foundation of the world from the Wright
brothers to Locherbey, would this suggest that the foundation of the world corresponds
to the invention of the airplane? God forbid! All it would mean is that there were no
airplane crashes before the Wright brothers because there were no airplanes! The same
holds true for the passage in Luke since there were no prophets murdered before Abel.
Don't let them tell you that there were no prophets before Abel. What was Adam if not
a prophet. Did he not speak to God and receive reply, and did he not hand down his
story to his sons so that it could eventually be recorded by Moses into the book we now
call Genesis. Still, Adam was never murdered.

To counter this argument, they will say that the world does not refer to the earth, but
rather to mankind. This will not help their argument, however, since Adam and Eve
were the first humans and they were created without sin or shame. Therefore, when
God speaks to us about those who are predestined to share in His glory, He does so
from a vantage point before (and after) sin came into the world. If some are predestined
to share in His glory, then others are not. Since the wages of sin are death, then He
must have known that man would disobey Him even before mankind came into being.
For this reason we all need a Saviour, and by putting our faith and trust in Him, He
may redeem us from our sin, and lead us to everlasting life (cf Jn 3:16).

Next comes the Watchtower's proclaimed end to wickedness on earth. "It will mean an
end to only bad people and their way of living." Would this not mean an end to us all?
Absolutely, if it were not for the sacrifice of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. Again,
JWs are led to believe that they will be saved by their works and only the righteous will
be saved. May I here suggest that none of us are righteous? "If we say, 'We have no sin,'
we are deceiving ourselves, and the truth has no place in us (1 Jn 1:8)." It is by God's
grace alone that we are saved. How can anyone claim a reward from Him who has
given us all that we have. As C.S. Lewis puts it, we are like children who ask their
father for ten dollars in order to buy him a present. Only a fool would suggest that the
father is ten dollars richer. Nonetheless he is still pleased with the gift he receives. Do
his children deserve a reward? This by no means invalidates the value of good works,
for we are told that faith without works is dead (Jas 2).

The Watchtower's main tactic for converting people is to predict that the end is near.
We must study the signs of the times, they claim. For this reason, the Watchtower uses
statistics to prove that the present era is coming to an end. (If you have studied
advanced statistics, you know that the outcome can usually be manipulated to prove
any point unless the strictest guidelines are followed.) They say that earthquakes are
increasing, as are wars, famine, lawlessness, etc. For biblical proof they point to the
apocalypse in Matthew 24, failing however to mention verse 44 of that chapter. In that
passage, Jesus promises that He will return at a time least expected. Therefore, all their
calculations and statistics are pointless. To prove my point, all we need to do is refer to
previous attempts by the Watchtower to predict the second coming. The years 1874,
1910, 1914, 1918, 1925, and 1975 have all been referred to for the ushering in of the new
era where Christ will return and assume His kingly throne. Every time these
predictions have failed, the Watchtower has moved the date forward, not by a large
amount, just far enough that they can continue to instill fear. Do they not realize that
Christ has always been Immanuel, God-with-us. Whenever we gather together to hear
His word or pray together, He is with us (cf. Mt 18:20). For true believers, the date of
His reign, the day of judgement, does not matter, since He has promised us salvation if
we only believe in Him. We shouldn't only follow Him at times when we think the end
is near, but at all times. The JWs will deny that they do this, but you just need to go
back to 1974 in order to prove my point. They were expecting the end of the world to
come the following year. Many quit their jobs, sold their houses, and began witnessing
full time (standing on street corners, knocking on doors, etc.). Since the time was so
near, they would not need material possessions any longer. After all, they were making
an investment in their future. Surely Jehovah God would reward their good works.
Their motto became "stay alive 'til 75." When 1975 came and went without any great
calamity, many became disillusioned and left the Watchtower organization.

The Watchtower cautions that we are experiencing so much anguish, suffering, and
dispair, the end must be near. But I challenge you to consider whether this has not
always been the case. Since the time of Christ there have been vast empires based on
repression and genocide. Pagan Rome, the Mongolians, the Turks, the French under
Napoleon, and, very recently, the Nazis have all bought victory at the price of innocent
blood. And what of the great plague? Surely if anyone was to predict a time of great
suffering it would have been during this horrific stage in world history. So what has
changed that makes our time so special? Nothing! Man still opresses others for the sake
of his own greed, there are still wars, famine, and disease. Since the time of Adam these
conditions have existed, and will continue to exist as long as man inhabits the earth.
What the Watchtower fails to convey is the amount of love, charity, self-sacrifice, and
peace that exists in the world today. These are precious gifts from God who is working
through us and for us, God-with-us, for all time.

"If you love life and want to live forever on the earth...then you must hurry to take
accurate knowledge of God..." declares the Watchtower. How can JWs ever hope to
obtain accurate knowledge when they are forbidden to read almost anything that is not
published by the Watchtower. The publishers of their liturature are obviously free to
read and quote from any source they choose (frequently they quote the New York
Times and the Catholic Encyclopedia), selectively extract whatever statements suit their
purpose, and then demand that their followers accept their version at face value.