4Unity archive

Witnesses and the Watchtower 2

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.
Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower

copyright 1995 by David Wesley

CHAPTER 2 - AN HONEST DEVIL 

The Watchtower claims that the world is governed by Satan, basing their whole
argument on two verses in the Bible. "Next, taking him to a very high mountain, the
devil showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their splendour. And he said to
him, 'I will give you all these if you fall at my feet and do me homage'"(Mt 4:8,9). "How
else could he have offered them to Jesus," claims the Watchtower, unless they belonged
to Satan. Did they ever think that Satan was lying, that he was trying to deceive Jesus?
He promised Eve that if she ate from the forbidden fruit she would not die, but rather
would become like a god (Gen 3:3-5). Elsewhere, we are told that he is a liar and the
father of all lies (Jn 8:44). The Watchtower even contradicts themselves in their
discussion of this matter when they refer to Satan as "a hateful liar" who "would like to
mislead us." Now, all of a sudden, because it suits their purpose, they claim that Satan
is telling the truth. So what about the kingdoms which Satan claimed to offer Jesus? Is
he the "unseen ruler of all the nations of the world" as the Watchtower claims?

Beginning with Old Testament wisdom, God tells us, "By me monarchs rule and
princes decree what is right; by me rulers govern, so do nobles, the lawful authorities"
(Pr 8:15,16). Saint Paul adds, "Everyone is to obey the governing authorities, because
there is no authority except from God and so whatever authorities exist have been
appointed by God" (Rm 13:1). Saint Peter agrees when he requests "For the sake of the
Lord" that the Christians of Asia Minor "accept authority of every human institution:
the emperor as the supreme authority, and the governors as commissioned by him to
punish criminals and praise those who do good" (1Pet 2:13, 14). Even our Lord, when
placed before Pilate tells Pilate that he has no power over Jesus except as given to him
from above. Rather it was Judas Iscariot, who betrayed him, that "has the greater guilt"
(Jn 19:11).

So what does God mean when he refers to Satan as the prince of this world? Since the
fall of man, we all have borne the sign of original sin. Ever since our first parents
decided to believe Satan's promise that they would be like gods, mankind has sought
after this illusion. Every sin committed is a reflection of this desire. Modern psychology
refers to it as Ego. So when Satan is called the prince of this world, we can be assured
that he is appealing to our ego. Idolatry, whether it is a golden calf or money, places
our love in the work of our own hands. It lifts us up and makes us feel as though we
are the creator, thereby neglecting to offer credit where credit is due.

The Watchtower refers Ephesians 6:12 in its discussion of this matter, and so will I.
They interpret that verse as saying that "we have to fight to keep from being
influenced by [Satan]." On this point I would agree, but it also says that "it is not
against human enemies that we have to struggle." To illustrate, put yourself before
Pilate. All that is required for you to achieve your freedom is to deny that Jesus is God.
For an ordinary Christian, the enemy would not be Pilate or any other oppressor, but
rather his own ego. It is that ego which fails to surrender and trust in God. It is that ego
which makes us deny Him and betray Him for gold and silver. And it is that ego that
prevents me from saying a dinner blessing at a restaurant, when I never neglect to do
so at home. Is it that we are embarrassed about our faith in a world which tends to
reject God? Do we hold our own esteem in the eyes of others higher than our
commitment to truth and love? How then could we hope to stay faithful when placed
before someone such as Pilate who holds the balance of life and death in his hands?
When we surrender ourselves completely to God, no enemy on earth can harm us. The
real enemy, the prince of this world, is working within us, building up our egos.

In the Watchtower's discussion of Ephesians 6:12, they ignore the portion of the verse
which I discussed above. Instead, they refer only to "principalities and ruling forces
who are masters of darkness in this world, the spirits of evil in the heavens." The
principalities and ruling forces are suggested as representing current governments and
institutions (ie. religions other than Jehovah's Witnesses, universities, international
relief agencies, etc.). But according to Saint Paul, these forces cannot represent "human
enemies," and, therefore, cannot represent human governments and institutions. Read
in context, that portion of Paul's letter is very allegorical. He speaks of the belt of truth,
the breastplate of uprightness, the shield of faith, the burning arrows of the Evil One,
and the sword of the Spirit (Eph 6:14-17). And all the while that his words conjure up
images of a holy war, he speaks of spreading the gospel of peace. When the Ephesians
are asked to put on "the full armour of God" (Eph 6:11), Paul is not speaking of a
hundred pounds of cast iron vestments. As such, it is highly misleading to take half a
verse out of this context and interpret it literally.

The battle that Paul is describing rages within us each moment of each day. It is a war
against the human ego in its attempt to separate us from God. Paul makes this very
clear when he notes that "although we are human, it is not by human methods that we
do battle" (2Cor 10:3). And "let anyone who wants to boast, boast of the Lord. For it is
not through self commendation that recognition is won, but through commendation"
(2Cor 10:17,18). When the Watchtower externalizes Paul's message by focusing on
governments and institutions, they throw away the belt of truth and open the door to
the ego's burning arrows. Think of the message they proclaim. They have the truth,
they are pure, and only those who follow them will survive the wrath of God against
this wicked world. How much of Paul's message of hope, faith, and charity is contained
in such absolutes. "If you pass judgement you have no excuse," he says. "It is yourself
that you condemn when you judge others since you behave in the same way as those
you are condemning" (Rm 2:1). After all, "there is no favouritism with God" (Rm 2:11).
When you think of what a large institution the Watchtower has itself become, we must
hope that Paul's warning does not fall on deaf ears.

Later in their discussion of Satan, the Watchtower speaks of Satan being present when
the earth was created. "He knew that after a while the whole earth would be filled with
righteous people worshipping God. That was God's purpose, "proclaims the
Watchtower. What these statements seem to suggest is that Satan is, at times, more
powerful than God. First, consider what we discussed in chapter one. Their idea that
God did not know that man was going to sin is plainly unscriptural, and insults God.
Now they further insult God by suggesting that Satan did know the future of the
world, that he knew God's intentions, and that he succeed in defeating God's purpose,
at least for a time. If their argument is valid, it would mean that God could not have
seen into the hearts of mankind, whom He created, nor into Satan, whom He also
created. Yet, if Satan could see a future hidden to the eyes of God, and succeed in
thwarting God's plan, would this not place Satan higher than God?

"The lie the Devil told Eve," they say, " worked just as he planned." How unfortunate
for God that His plan to fill the earth with righteous people was destroyed by Satan's
more powerful influence. I hope I am not being too sarcastic, but this whole notion
seems so ludicrous that I cannot help myself. Continuing, the Watchtower decrees that
"God allowed time for Satan to try and prove his claims." Again, they seem to suggest
that Satan's will is more powerful than God's, and that God has given in to Satan by
allowing him time to prove himself.

The result was that "governments of men,...the scriptures show, have been controlled
from behind the scenes by the Devil." What I have shown earlier in this chapter is that
scripture, in fact, shows that all authority is given by God and that governments rule by
Him. So what is the Watchtower saying? Are they saying that Satan is a god? Ask this
question to any Jehovah's Witness, and the answer will be an unequivocal "yes." Are
they saying that Satan is the God? If not, they seem to make him equal to, if not higher
than, God.

Jehovah's Witnesses believe that God will triumph over Satan in the battle described in
Revelation 12. The version they present, however, is somewhat different than the one
found in the Holy Scriptures. This tactic is often used by the Watchtower when quoting
sources which tend to disagree with their doctrine, including the Bible. Other examples
of this will be shown throughout this book. "Read carefully the following Bible
account," they ask. Well, lets do just that. "War broke out in heaven: Michael [who is
the resurrected Jesus Christ] and his angels battled with the dragon." Where in
Revelation 12:7, or anywhere in the Bible for that matter, does it say that Jesus is
Michael the archangel? Later in this book I will discuss the true nature of Jesus, but for
my present purpose, let's see what scripture says about notions that Jesus is an angel.
This belief seems to have been a problem for early Jewish converts to Christianity, since
Paul devotes the entire first chapter of his letter to the Hebrews to refuting such heresy.
How much clearer can he be when he writes, "To which of the angels has God ever
said: Take your seat at my right hand till I have make your enemies your footstool? Are
they not all ministering spirits, sent to serve for the sake of those who are to inherit
salvation?" (Heb 1:13,14), and "It was not under angels that he put the world to come,
about which we are speaking" (Heb 2:5). Yet, if Jesus is to be King over the new
paradise on earth, as the Watchtower claims, how could he be an angel? They will
reply that Jesus is not an ordinary angel, he is an archangel. Therefore, according to the
Watchtower, Paul is referring only to ordinary angels, not archangels. If this were so,
why wasn't Paul more clear? Why did he not say 'it was under an archangel that he put
the world to come?' The reason is simple. There is no distinction between angels and
archangels except rank. Just as there is no distinction between bishops and archbishops
except rank. When someone makes a general statement about bishops, archbishops are
included in such statements unless the author specifies clearly that they are not. And so
it is with Paul; when he speaks of angels, archangels are clearly included in his
statements.

When confronted on this, your Jehovah's Witness friend may refer to other verses
which purport to prove that Jesus is Michael the archangel. First they will say that "at 1
Thessalonians 4:16, the command of Jesus Christ for the resurrection to begin is
described as 'the archangels call'." Let's look at what that verse really says. "At the
signal given by the voice of the archangel and the trumpet of God, the Lord himself
will come down from heaven." Notice that they do not refer to the command of Jesus as
"the trumpet of God," but through selective quotation misread the whole verse. One
could as easily misinterpret it and say that since the voice of the archangel and the
trumpet of God are used together, that God is an archangel. In fact, that verse says
neither.

The Watchtower obviously accepts, as it refers to the previous paragraph, that the Lord
is Jesus Christ. With that in mind, let's go to the ninth verse of Jude's letter. There we
are told that "not even the archangel Michael, when he was engaged in argument with
the devil about the corpse of Moses, dared to denounce him in the language of abuse;
all he said was, 'May the Lord rebuke you.'" Clearly Michael is not the Lord referred to
in this passage.

Next they will refer to Revelation 19 which says that Christ will lead the armies of
heaven in battle against Satan. Since Revelation 12 says that Michael and his angels will
make war against the dragon, Christ and Michael must be one and the same. To equate
the two would be like saying that since Churchill led the armies of England in battle
against Hitler, and Montgomery made war against the Nazis, Churchill and
Montgomery must be one and the same.

Further to this, they say that "the expression 'archangel' is never found in the plural in
the scriptures, thus implying that there is only one." I beg to differ. Note that Daniel
10:13 refers to Michael as one of the chief princes. It does not say that he is the chief
prince, nor does it refer to him as Lord or King. Also, does this verse not imply that
there are more than one? In fact, we are told that there are "seven angels who stand
ever ready to enter the presence of the glory of the Lord" (Tob. 12:15).

"The evidence shows," the Watchtower claims, that the war in heaven described in
Revelation 12 "happened around the time of World War I." What evidence? They point
to increasing lawlessness, food shortages, etc., as proof that Satan has been "hurled
down to earth," but as I explained in chapter one, such conditions are not unique to this
time. In fact, the conditions they describe are only regional in their impact. One of the
examples they use is an increasing amount of disease. Surely they are not suggesting
that disease has a greater impact today than during the Black Plague which killed off
most of Europe and Asia, or during the Small Pox epidemics that wiped out nearly 90
percent of the aboriginal populations of North America and the South Pacific. As I
write this, nearly all deadly diseases can be prevented or cured.

The purpose of this negative view of the world seems to be rooted in an attempt by the
Watchtower to isolate their followers. The result is their members complete reliance on
the Watchtower and their publishing empire. Even "Christendom" is considered part of
"Satan's visible organization." 'Satan is everywhere and in everything except the
Watchtower hierarchy' seems to be what they are saying. Martin Luther King, Mother
Teresa of Calcutta, Billy Graham, and Pope John Paul II are all members of "Satan's
visible organization." That is why a faithful Jehovah's Witness can never be allowed to
read anything not written by the Watchtower. God forbid that their publishing empire
would have any competition! Their paranoia is so prevalent, that you cannot even ask a
Jehovah's Witness to pray with you without sparking a negative reaction. This all goes
back to giving Satan power over everything. As I have pointed out, they believe that
Satan is even more powerful than God is some respects.

How can a Jehovah's Witness be saved from this wickedness which is all pervasive. "If
we are to receive everlasting life," they are told, "we need accurate knowledge about
God." So far, I think it is clear that accurate knowledge about God is not what they are
receiving. In the sentence which I quoted, the Watchtower uses a cross reference to John
17:3. This verse does not exhort one to examine the Scriptures, as they suggest. At the
time it was written, there was no printing press, there was not even a Bible. Many of
the books of the Bible would not even be composed until many years later, and would
not be compiled until some three hundred years after that. Jesus was certainly not
speaking of Watchtower publications. So what was Jesus referring to? "And eternal life
is this," He says, "to know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have
sent" (Jn 17:3). He wants us to open our hearts so that the Holy Spirit which proceeds
from the Father and the Son may dwell within us (cf Jn 17:26). He is also praying for
the apostles who would endure many hardships for the sake of His glory and His
purpose.

All the Watchtower's theology on the subject of Satan, let us remember, is based on one
verse in the Bible which quotes the father of all lies, Satan himself. On this they base
their condemnation of all world religions from Catholicism to Buddhism, and all
institutions from the Red Cross to the United Nations. It is important to be aware of this
xenophobia when speaking with a Jehovah's Witness. You will not be trusted
regardless of who you are since they believe that you are controlled by Satan. Even
Christmas Carols are Satanic. No matter how convincing your argument, it will take
time to undo the "mind regulating" (also known as brain washing) which they undergo.
You may think to yourself, 'they seem harmless enough," but how harmless is a religion
that hates&127; anything different than itself, that quotes Satan as a source of truth, and
that believes that Satan can be more powerful than God.