4Unity archive

Witnesses and the Watchtower 3

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.
Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower

copyright 1995 by David Wesley

CHAPTER 3 - THE TRUTH IS FALSE

"Because they fail to worship God in the right way, most persons are on the road to
destruction," proclaims the Watchtower. "Only a few are on the road leading to life."
Let me guess which few they are referring to. As proof that today's religions are false,
the Watchtower likes to use war as an example that "Satan...controls the religions
practiced by the people of the world." They quote Catholic leaders on both sides during
World War II as glorifying war and demanding that they kill each other. However,
they leave no way for an inquisitive reader to verify their sources. "And Protestants did
the same," they say. What they fail to point out is that the Catholic Church is credited
with saving 800,000 Jews during the war, and that many<A
HREF="http://www.ici.net/cust_pages/ffi/whostmax.html"> Catholic priests
died</A> in Nazi concentration camps. The Catholic Church and most Protestant
churches have never glorified war, as they say, but acknowledge that one must protect
freedom and liberty even at the cost of war if all other means have failed. If it were up
to the Watchtower,<A HREF="nazi.html"> they would have allowed the Nazis to have
continued unhindered</A> until all the world was under the heal of <A
HREF="http://www.nano.no/~telemark/Hitler/HitlerEng.html">Adolf Hitler</A>.
They degrade the memory of those who gave up their lives so that we may be free from
fascist oppression.

The Watchtower is very proud that, "Jehovah's Witnesses stand outside the
establishment and accept no responsibility to bless whatever the secular government
decides to do." This is also the basis for their doctrine that Jehovah's Witnesses must
never serve in or act in a supportive role to any military service. However, scripture
does not condemn military service even in countries which oppose God and religion.
For example, when a centurion asks Jesus to heal his servant, Jesus replies that He has
not found faith as great as this anywhere in Israel, and implies that the centurion will
have a seat reserved for him in heaven. Never does Jesus tell him to desert his regiment
nor does He tell him to never fight another battle (Mt 8:5-13). Saint Paul writes to the
Romans that they must submit to civil authority. He does not exclude military service
from this demand. He even goes so far to say that the sword is the symbol of authority
and is used to bring retribution (Rm 13: 1- 7).

Also consider the holy wars discussed throughout the old testament. The Watchtower
will claim that these soldiers were serving under a theocratic government and, as such,
were justified, but service under a civil government is condemned by God. However,
we need only look as far as the example of King David to know that the Watchtower's
notion is wrong. We all know that David was a humble servant of God, especially prior
to his coronation. Samuel had ordained him as King to replace Saul who had fallen out
of favour with God. Consequently, Saul made war against the surrounding pagan
nations as well as David and his followers. When David was exiled into the Philistine
kingdom of Gath, he and his followers offered allegiance to the Philistine king and
offered to go to war for him against God's own chosen people. Nowhere does God
condemn David for such actions (1 Sam 27-29).

In order to justify their failure to submit to civil authority, the Watchtower quotes John
17:16, which reads, "they do not belong to the world any more than I belong to the
world." This is a clear example of selective quotation, for the verse just before it reads,
"I am not asking you to remove them from the world, but to protect them from the Evil
One." Later verses have a similar message. Jesus sees the importance of his disciples
remaining free from temptation and distractions to God. He is here speaking of freeing
them from the constraints of worldly possessions that compete with God, and only
satisfy the ego (as discussed in chapter two). Note that this whole chapter from Saint
John's gospel is a prayer for the twelve apostles. In their role as leaders of the Church,
they would need to devote themselves completely to preaching the gospel to a world
which has never heard of Jesus Christ. This tradition of separating themselves from the
world is continued today in the Catholic Church by orders such as the Franciscans, who
are forbidden to own material goods.

Next, the Watchtower refers to Acts 5:29 to support their notion that early Christians
"obeyed God as ruler rather than men!" That verse actually reads, "obedience to God
comes before obedience to men." Two messages can be taken from this verse. First,
remember that Peter was speaking before the Sanhedrin. They did not like any
suggestion that they had taken part in the crucifixion of Jesus. Peter could have said
that he never meant to make them feel guilty, but that it had all been a big
misunderstanding. If he had done so, he would have only been protecting himself and
looking for praise from his accusers. Instead, he professes our Lord as Saviour. In so
doing, he demonstrates his devotion to God above seeking praise from men. Second,
we must consider times when we are asked to perform individual actions which are
clearly offensive to God, such as procuring an abortion. In such cases, the law of God
supersedes the law of man. Peter never said obey God instead of men, as the
Watchtower suggests, but obey God above men.

Saint Paul in his letter to the Romans demands that early Christians submit to civil
authority. "Anyone who disobeys an authority is rebelling against God's ordinance; and
rebels must expect to receive the condemnation they deserve" (Rm 13:2). Can scripture
be made any more plain than this. Paul adds, "Pay...respect where respect is due;
honour where honour is due" (Rm 13:7).

The Watchtower quotes Paul's second letter to the Corinthians as proof that Satan is the
leader of all other world religions. He writes, "the unbelievers whose minds have been
blinded by the god of this world, so that they cannot see the shining light of the gospel
of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God" (2 Cor 4:4). Saint Paul is not referring to
world religions, but unbelievers who are challenging the Corinthians with matters
which seem to focus on worldly gain rather than the glorification of God. In the second
verse of this chapter, Paul tells the Corinthians that he has no wish to deceive them or
to falsify the word of God. This is good advice for the Watchtower when they quote
scripture out of context even to the point of quoting Satan (Mt 4:8,9) or Elihu's "ignorant
words" (Job 38:2).

The Watchtower is so hateful of other religions, they tell their follows that "[God]
destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah. Soon he will do the same to all modern-day false
religion." In this I must repeat Jesus' warning that "the judgements you give are the
judgements you will get" (Mt 7:2). They go on to say that such religion is the prostitute
spoken of in Revelation 17. Worldwide Bible scholarship is fairly consistent in their
interpretation that the prostitute represents pagan Rome not modern day religion. In
verse 16 where John speaks of them eating her flesh and burning the remains with fire,
he is likely referring to Emperor Nero who sacked Rome upon his return. Even if this
passage could refer to modern day religion, which it cannot, what makes them so sure
that they are not included among these. After all, the Watchtower is but one hundred
years old. As such, they should consider themselves more of a modern day religion
than those which go back many hundreds or thousands of years. Regardless of one's
interpretation, John's apocalyptic vision was certainly referring to events happening
during his lifetime. I could elaborate further on Revelation, but I feel that it is
sufficiently dealt with elsewhere. Pick up almost any study Bible or commentary and
you will find many more plausible interpretations of this book.

The Watchtower goes on to say that "the crimes committed by members of different
religions" have caused millions of people to turn away from God. Are Jehovah's
Witnesses excluded from this statement? So it seems. I admit (even announce) that
Christians commit crimes against goodwill and conscience. Every Christian, every day,
is responsible for such sins. In a sense, we are all murderers, prostitutes, and thieves in
varying degrees (cf. Rm 3:9,10 Eccl 7:20). It is to free us from this sin that Christ died for
us (cf 1Cor 15:3). If we were perfect, we would have no need for a Saviour. Even Job,
who was a highly favoured servant of God, recognized this (Job 9:20, 21). Can anyone,
including the Watchtower, claim to be free from the spiritual crimes which result from
original sin? Anyone who does is a liar (1Jn 1:10). Yet, if the Watchtower admits that
they are not free from sin, that their followers are not free from sin, that all suffer from
the human condition, then how can they condemn other religions for sins committed by
their proponents. Saint James is very clear on this matter. He writes, "there is only one
lawgiver and he is the only judge and has the power to save or destroy. Who are you to
give a verdict on a neighbour?" (Jas 4:12).

Even though "the Church of the living God [is the] pillar and support of the truth" (1
Tim. 3:15) She is made up of both the righteous and the unrighteous. This Church was
given the power to exercise judgement on its members (Mt. 16:19) while those outside
the Church, only God will judge (1 Cor. 5:12-13). If all the members of the Church were
righteous, what need would there be "to judge those who are inside" the Church. Jesus
instructs the Church to correct their brothers and if they do not listen, report them to
the Church, since She has the authority to bind and loose (Mt. 18:15-18). What value
would there be in saying this unless brothers would need correction. Indeed, only some
among the house of the Lord are "fit for the Master" (2 Tim. 2:20,21). "Even from your
own ranks there will be men coming forward with a travesty of the truth on their lips
to induce the disciples to follow them" (Acts 20:30) despite our Lord's promise that the
gates of Hell will not prevail against His Holy Church (Mt. 16:18). Elsewhere He speaks
of the chaff (heretics) in His barn (the Church) which He will burn with fire (Mt. 3:12).
That members of the members of "the Church of the living God" have commited
atrocities and espoused heresy does not prove that she is an apostate church, but just
the opposite, that She is the True Church. She is the pillar of truth, Her doctrines are
infallible, and within Her fold are both wheat and chaff, sheep and goat, saint and
heretic.

"How can we know if we are...worshipping God in a way that he approves," asks the
Watchtower. First, they say, "it is not any man, but God, who is the judge of what is
true worship." Then they immediately contradict themselves by giving instruction on
how to worship God, their instruction being based on the opinion of the author who is
himself a man. Is he "not any man?" His instruction is as follows; "if our worship is to
be acceptable to God, it should be firmly rooted in God's Word of truth, the Bible." I
would agree that our worship should be rooted in the Bible, but the Bible does not say
this anywhere. How could it, since it did not exist when the authors of the Bible were
writing their respective books. We know that worship should be Biblical because
various councils of Catholic bishops in the third and fourth centuries decided that it
should be. The Catholic Church believes that these councils were guided by God's Holy
Spirit when they put together the Bible. From there, they incorporated and followed
scripture when developing the liturgy of the Mass. In the early church, there were in
excess of fifty gospels in circulation, yet only four are contained in our present day
Bible. Someone (or some few) had to decide not to include the larger portion of
scripture as uninspired. How do we know that they made a correct decision? And if we
cannot know so much as this, how can we base our worship on a Bible which may
contain inaccuracies? By asking us to root our worship in the Bible, the Watchtower
must concede that God worked through the Catholic bishops who put together the
Bible. Why can they not concede that these same men were guided by God when they
developed the various forms of worship used by the Christian Church?

To back up their argument, the Watchtower quotes Romans 3:4, "Let God be found
true, though every man be found a liar." They feel that Paul is telling us that we must
not rely on men to guide us in our worship of God. However, this is not the message
that Paul is conveying. I prefer the New Jerusalem Bible (NJ) rendering of the passage
which reads, "God will always be true even if no human can be relied on." Paul wants
to ease concerns that God will break his covenant due to the unfaithfulness of men. This
is out of the question since God will remain true to His promises regardless of the
actions of any man. Even if no one on earth can be relied on to remain faithful to God,
He will never break His covenant. Even as much as it is impossible for man to be
without sin, it is impossible for God to break a promise. Paul's message actually
supports the Catholic position that God works through the Church even when
members of the Church are not faithful to Him. For this reason, the Mass is still valid
even when the priest is in mortal sin. It is not the priest who makes himself present to
the congregation, but God. He uses fallible human beings to work his perfect mysteries.
How else could fallible, sinful men write sacred scripture except by the marvellous
grace of God. The Watchtower may think it impossible for God to work through a
church of sinners, but our Lord says, "by human resources it is impossible, but not for
God: because for God everything is possible" (Mk 10:27). Here He is speaking of
salvation, but what is the Church if not God's instrument of salvation.

As further "evidence," they point to Matthew 15: 1-9. Their worship is in vain, we are
told, "because they teach the commands of men as doctrines." This is not evidence at all,
but another example of quoting scripture out of context. Here Jesus rebukes the
Pharisees, not because they are men, but because they seek their own glorification
above that of God. As an example He refers to their violation of the commandment to
honour one's parents. By giving all their earnings to the temple, the Pharisees could
avoid sharing their wealth with their parents. In fact, they never gave to the temple, but
placed their earnings in trust, much like a bank, under the pretence that they were
making a donation. This "tradition" was in direct violation of one of the ten
commandments. They paid lip service by pretending to serve God (ie. donating to the
temple) while in reality serving their own selfish interests. What the Watchtower fails
to point out is that Jesus never criticizes sincere devotion to Semitic tradition. Even
Moses, who handed down the most important Jewish laws and customs, was a fallible
sinner. He was severely chastised for his lack of faith and trust in God (Num 20: 11,12).
Is the Watchtower suggesting that Israel should not have followed Moses because of his
imperfections? In fact, Israel did not, and severe retribution fell upon them. So what is
the Watchtower really saying? On the one hand, they say 'do not follow men,' but on
the other hand, they do not hesitate to condemn anyone who fails complete submission
to their organization. What is this if not hypocrisy? Is it not hypocrisy that Jesus
condemns in the very verses they quote?

The hypocrisy of the Watchtower is exemplified in the following statement: "The
religion that is approved by God must agree in every way with the Bible; it will not
accept certain parts of the Bible and reject others." What I have shown, and will
continue to show throughout this book, is that the Watchtower breaks this rule in a
very big way. Misquotations, quotations out of context, and outright deception are the
tools that the Watchtower uses to reject the truth of the Bible. Even in a literal way they
have rejected parts of the Bible, by changing many important passages in their New
World Translation (NWT). The following passage is a blatant example:

- And YOU, fathers, do not be irritating YOUR children, but go on bringing them up
in the discipline and mental-regulating of Jehovah. (Eph 6:4 NWT)

Compare this with the New Jerusalem Bible.

- And parents, never drive your children to resentment but bring them up with
correction and advice inspired by the Lord. (Eph 6:4 NJ)

May I venture to say that "mental-regulating" refers to "brain-washing."

Further, I must reiterate the dilemma faced by the Watchtower when they declare that
"the religion that is approved by God must agree in every way with the Bible." As
proof, the Watchtower refers to Saint Paul's second letter to Timothy. There he writes,
"All scripture is inspired by God and useful for refuting error, for guiding peoples lives
and teaching them to be upright" (2 Tim 3:16). Which scripture? Is Paul referring to The
Assumption of Moses, The Gospel of Thomas,or The Prayer of Manasseh? These books
are, or have been, considered scriptural by various Jewish and Christian sects. Yet these
are only a few of hundreds of books purporting to be scripture that are not contained in
Catholic, Protestant, or Watchtower Bibles. Why are they not included if ALL scripture
is useful? Because in the fourth century, the Catholic Church determined that these
books were not scripture. Since the Watchtower asserts that the Church had fallen into
apostasy well before the fourth century, how can they be sure that the religion
approved by God must agree with the Bible? Without conceding the authority of the
Catholic Church in this matter, they may as well follow that Koran or the Gnostic Bible.

The absurdity is carried further when you note the use of the singular in their quotation
"the religion...approved by God." Yes, they are referring to all religions when they
speak of false religion being destroyed by God. 'Unless you conform to the "mental-
regulating" of the religion (headed by the Watchtower of course), damnation awaits
you,' is the message which underlies Watchtower doctrine. If the Watchtower heads the
one and only true religion upon which salvation is based, how do they explain the
doctrinal inconsistencies and contradictions which seem to inhabit every corner of the
Watchtower? Jehovah's Witnesses will claim that the light is getting brighter as they
come closer and closer to the truth. It is a sign of the true religion that they are willing
to change their doctrine as they discover more and more. They criticize the Catholic
Church for never changing its doctrine. What they fail to realize is that Jesus Christ
promised complete truth to His apostolic church and this truth has been handed down
through apostolic succession to the present day.

God's truth is the same today as it was two thousand years ago. It was not discovered
through studying the Bible, but given as a gift through God's Holy Spirit. In the words
of our Lord Jesus Christ to the Apostles, "when the Spirit of truth comes he will lead
you to the complete truth" (Jn 16:13). He is not promising them partial truth, nor is he
promising complete truth to some organization which will not exist for another 1,900
years. What he is promising the apostles is complete truth, nothing less. Saint Paul
speaks to this in his letter to the Corinthians. "Such is the confidence we have through
Christ in facing God; it is not that we are so competent that we can claim any credit for
ourselves; all our competence comes from God. He has given us the competence to be
ministers of a new covenant, a covenant which is not of written letters, but of the Spirit"
(2Cor 3:4-6). Paul was not one of the twelve to whom Jesus spoke of the "Spirit of
truth." Therefore, Paul must have received this gift through apostolic succession. And
Christ was not referring to everyone, otherwise there would not be more than 20,000
Christian denominations. "At the same time, we must recognize that the interpretation
of scriptural prophesy is never a matter for the individual" (2Pet 1:20). Therefore when
the Watchtower claims that they are acquiring truth as they go along, and that truth is
gained by individual study of the Bible, they actually contradict the Bible.

Yet, apostolic succession is nothing more than a myth according to the Watchtower. As
apostolic succession is the basis for Catholic authority in matters of faith and morals,
we should examine their position in some detail. When Peter declared that Jesus was
the Christ, Jesus replied, "Simon, son of Jonah, you are a blessed man! Because it was
no human agency that revealed this to you but my Father in heaven. So I now say to
you: You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my community" (Mt 16:17,18). The
Watchtower declares that since "[Peter] would later deny Christ three times," "Jesus
himself would be that solid rock foundation of the church, not Peter." However, Jesus
clearly referred to Peter as blessed. Significantly, Jesus began his reply by calling Peter
by his former name, Simon. This name referred to a small stone or pebble. Jesus had
earlier on given Simon his new name, Peter or Cephas, which itself means Rock (cf. Mk
3:16). If modern day English had been the language in use, Jesus may have referred to
him as "Rocky." Reading on into the next verse, the Watchtower's argument that Jesus is
referring to himself is discredited. "I will give you the keys to the kingdom of Heaven,"
Jesus says, "whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you
loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (Mt 16:19). Jesus didn't say he was giving
himself the keys, but says you, referring to Peter. It is by this authority that sins may be
absolved and indulgences may be granted.

That Peter could not be the rock because he denied that he knew Jesus on the night of
the Passion is contrary to logic. Any human organization, regardless of its moral basis,
is subject to human sin and error. Peter is an example of this, as was Moses, and every
other human being that ever lived, save Jesus and Mary. The Watchtower likes to refer
to the sale of indulgences in the middle ages as evidence of the apostasy of the Catholic
Church. ("An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to
sins whose guilt has already been forgiven" - The Catechism of the Catholic Church).
Yet, all they prove is that clergy are human and sinners. There were abuses in the
middle ages, and there have been abuses before and after, even to the present day.
However, such abuses are explicitly condemned by the Church. In 1551, the Council of
Trent strongly condemned any exchange of favours, including money, for sacraments
such as indulgences. A cartoon published by the Watchtower which depicts "the pope's
sale of indulgences" is an outrageous falsification of history.

Getting back to Peter, the Watchtower claims that "there is no evidence in Scripture or
history that Peter was regarded as having primacy over his peers." Besides the
reference to Peter as the Rock, there are, in fact, many examples of his primary role
among the apostles. In Matthew, as well as the other gospels, whenever dialogue occurs
between Jesus and His apostles, Peter is more often than not the spokesman. He is
referred to by name far more often than any other apostle throughout the New
Testament. Continuing, the Watchtower notes, "He makes no mention of [his primacy]
in his own letters." Was that the purpose of his letters? Popes throughout the ages have
written apostolic letters on various matters, they do not need to explain the basis of
their authority in each letter. Peter does, nonetheless, declare his role publicly. "Peter
stood up and said to [the apostles and the elders], 'My brothers, you know that in the
early days God made a choice among you, that I should be the one through whom the
Gentiles would hear the message of the good news and become believers'" (Acts 15:7
NRSV). Yet the Watchtower continues, "There is not even any absolute proof that Peter
was ever in Rome." First, the issue is rather irrelevant since the papal office has been
exercised in various locations in Egypt, Italy, and France over the past two thousand
years. Second, Peter's first letter to the Roman provinces is addressed from Babylon (1
Pet 5:13) which is the term used at the time in reference to Rome (cf. Rev 17:5,18).
Finally, the Watchtower reveals, "He was not a 'pope,' nor was he known as such." Of
course he wasn't known as such since the title only developed some centuries later as
an affectionate nickname for the Bishop of Rome and means Papa!

Clearly the Watchtower has a foundation of quicksand for their attack on the papacy.
When all their false rhetoric is about complete, they still must resort to questioning the
dialogue in which Peter is called the rock of the Church. "The other three Gospels," they
note, "do not even mention Jesus statement to Peter." What is the point they are trying
to make here? Are they suggesting that Matthew is a fraud, a forgery, or a fantasy?
Does the message need to be repeated over and over again for it to be valid? It seems to
me that they are backtracking on their assertion that the true religion must agree with
the Bible in every way. In fact what they are saying is that it must agree with their
interpretation of the Bible even to the point of questioning the validity of various
passages. This is the same error that Martin Luther made when he questioned whether
certain books that disagreed with his doctrine should have been included in the Bible.
If part of the Bible is false, then it casts into doubt the whole Bible, and every religion
based on it.

The Watchtower continues its attack on the Catholic Church in particular by claiming
that doctrines of the immortal soul and terms such as heaven, hellfire, purgatory,
paradise, and Limbo were invented "for a priestly class to keep their flocks submissive
and in fear of the Hereafter and to extract gifts and donations from them." This led to a
life of luxury for those "who have ruled in the sumptuous setting of the Vatican." This
argument is the most ludicrous so far. First, a doctrine of the immortal soul certainly
incorporates a much smaller element of fear than the Watchtower's doctrine that those
who are not baptized and practicing Jehovah's Witnesses will be utterly annihilated.
For some reason, even hell extracts less fear for the average person than being removed
from existence altogether. With the exception of Limbo, all the afterlife destinations
referred to by the Watchtower are solid doctrines based on scripture. They are all
clearly explained in The Catechism of the Catholic Church. (Limbo is a theory
developed to explain what happens to infants, the unborn, and others who were never
given the choice to know God when they died. Yet it is only a theory and espoused by
the Church as such.) Contrast this with Watchtower doctrine that "when a person is
dead he is completely out of existence", that only 144,000 will reach heaven, and that
"millions now living will never die" but will reside forever in an earthly paradise
reserved for faithful Jehovah's Witnesses. Which of the two doctrines are more likely to
"keep flocks submissive and in fear of the Hereafter?" As far as the life of luxury is
concerned, it takes a stretch of the imagination to envision the Vatican City's celibate
priests living the good life. Contrast your own image of life at the Vatican with your
image of a beachfront San Diego mansion. The Watchtower purchased such a mansion
for the resurrection of the prophets in 1925. It just so happened that their president,
Joseph Rutherford, who normally resided in Brooklyn, spent his winters at the San
Diego mansion. After all, until the prophets came, there was no sense letting it go to
waste.

Popes and Saints through the ages have given themselves to sacrifice and poverty, not
the type of luxury enjoyed by leaders of the Watchtower. Pope Saint Gregory the Great
was the son of a Roman senator and donated all his properties and estate to the use of
the Church's religious communities and charities. Augustine, Francis of Assisi, and
Thomas Moore are a few of the more famous saints who gave up wealth and glory for
the sake of service to God.

Yet, as I pointed out at the beginning of this chapter, Catholicism is only one of many
world religions they feel are doomed to destruction at Armageddon. In the Watchtower
publication, Mankind's Search for God all the world's religions are examined and
condemned. Granted, there is an inordinate focus on the Catholic Church. As well, the
Watchtower presents heretics such as the Albigenses in a heroic light because of their
rejection of "the Virgin Birth, hellfire, and purgatory." Suggesting that "they actively
put in doubt the teachings of Rome." But the Watchtower's criticism does not end there.
They go on to condemn the protestant reformers and everyone else along the route that
preceded their own religion. They claim that they root themselves in the same faith
held by early Christians before apostasy spoiled God's plan in the second century. In
fact, they are a bizarre offshoot of 19th century Adventists. Their examination of the
world's religions ends with an exhortation to "avoid the broad road to destruction"
which is "staring world religions in the face." "Practicing the truth, doing God's will, is
what counts," claims the Watchtower. However, if everything we have, including out
own existence, is due to God, how can we ever hope to repay him by good works.
Nothing a person can do can ever come close to meriting salvation (Rm 3:20, 4:16).

If you are sufficiently successful to get this far in your discussion with the Jehovah's
Witnesses, you will have planted many questions, if not doubts, in their minds. Here it
may be appropriate to ask them to take some of the Watchtower's advice that "if you
learn from an examination of your Bible that you are travelling a wrong religious road,
be willing to change."