4Unity archive

Witnesses and the Watchtower 4

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.
Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower

copyright 1995 by David Wesley

CHAPTER 4- MAY THE FORCE BE WITH YOU

"God - Who is he," asks the Watchtower. "Can we be sure he exists?" Having
considered the discussion to this point, you should not be surprised that the
Watchtower conception of God is very simplistic. It leaves no room for forms of
existence beyond human comprehension. "Since God is a person with a spiritual body,
he must have a place to live." They go on to say "that the heavens are God's 'established
place of dwelling,' citing 1 Kings 8:43. However, Solomon's prayer to God in heaven in
no way implies that God is limited by physical space. As with their argument about
God not knowing the future (see chapter one) they feel obliged to explain everything
according to humanity's three dimensional conception of space. Their current doctrine
is toned down from declarations made when the Watchtower Society was just starting.
Not only did they believe that God resided in the constellation Pleiades, but the
"Almighty [governed] his universe" from the star "Alcyone." No matter how much they
argue the point, the Watchtower will never convince me that God is an astronaut. This
was only one of many weird doctrines espoused by the founder of the Watchtower,
Charles Taze Russell. Another was determining the end of the world (chronology) by
calculating the angles and arcs of the great pyramids of Egypt. In fact, these two
doctrines seem to have been borrowed from ancient Aztecs who calculated their
century as the period of time required for the constellation Pleiades to line up with
Aztec pyramids. When this occurred, a war party would be sent out to neighbouring
tribes. Prisoners would be sacrificed to the sun god. Again the Watchtower
demonstrates their hypocrisy when they criticize Babylonian astrologers because "they
viewed the stars as the heavenly abodes of the gods."

Further to the Watchtower's argument that God has an "established place of dwelling,"
they note that Christ appeared "before the person of God for us" (Heb 9:24 NWT). The
New Jerusalem rendering of that passage reads, "he now appears in the presence of
God on our behalf." From their translation they infer that since God is a person, he
must inhabit a particular physical space. The New World Translation also helps to
support their position that Christ is separate from God and, therefore, cannot be God.
This position is not supported in other renderings of the verse. Regardless of whether
or not the word "person" is used to describe God, one cannot make a logical conclusion
that God's being is confined to a relative space on this passage alone. The definition of
person is simply an "individual divine being" - Webster's Dictionary. There is never an
automatic supposition that such a being is confined within three dimensional space. As
mentioned in chapter two, the Watchtower likes to limit their concept of God (in a
sense placing him in a box), thereby limiting his power such that even Satan appears to
be more powerful than God at times.

Based on this false supposition, the Watchtower asks, "If God is a real person who lives
at a certain place in heaven, how can he see everything that happens everywhere?"
Here they delve into the realm of Science Fiction, with "his invisible active force"
guiding the universe much like the Force from the Star Wars Trilogy. Because He can
send out "his active force," he can "do whatever he wants even though he is far away."
What a cold perception of God. He has never told us that "he is far away," but that he is
Immanuel - God with us (Mt 1:23). As Saint Paul puts it, "From one single principle, he
not only created the whole human race so that they could occupy the entire earth, but
he decreed the times and limits of their habitation. And he did this so that they might
seek the deity and, by feeling their way towards him, succeed in finding him; and
indeed he is not far from any of us" (Acts 17:26,27). When Paul says that God is not far
from any of us, he is in direct opposition to Watchtower doctrine. Contrast such a
theology with the Watchtower's declaration that "the religion that is approved by God
must agree in every way with the Bible." After all, God's declares in Jeremiah, "Do I not
fill heaven and earth?" (Jr 23:24). This too is said of Christ, "for the one who went down
is none other than the one who went up above all the heavens to fill all things" (Ep
4:10). Clearly the One who went down is the One who descended to Hades for three
days, was resurrected, and ascended into Heaven. Yet if Christ were a mere creature,
an archangel as the Watchtower claims, how could He "fill all things."

"[He] also shows what kind of God he is...He does not show favoritism to certain races
of people," notes the Watchtower. However, they did not always feel this way about
God. In 1902, the Watchtower believed in a different "kind of God." At that time, the
Watchtower announced "that the white race exhibits some qualities of superiority over
any other."

So then, "who is this wonderful God," they ask. "Did Jesus ever say that he was God?
No he never did." Such heresy is not new as the Watchtower would have you believe.
In fact, it is almost as old as Christianity itself. Arius proposed the exact same position
which became known as the Arian heresy. The Watchtower raises many questions with
their position, so let us examine them one by one beginning with the assertion that
Jesus never said that He was God.

Let's begin by examining Jesus' discussion with the Pharisees in Chapter 8 of John's
gospel. In verse 56, Jesus explains that Abraham rejoiced because he saw His day.
When the Pharisees challenged Him saying that He is not old enough to know
Abraham, Jesus replies, "before Abraham ever was, I am" (Jn 8: 58). Here Jesus clearly
asserts His divinity, for "I am" is the name by which God reveals Himself. When God
disclosed Himself to Moses, Moses asked Him by what name should He be revealed to
the Israelites. In reply, God said, "'I am he who is.' and he said, 'This is what you are to
say to the Israelites, "I am has sent me to you...the God of Abraham...has sent me to
you." This is my name for all time" (Ex 3:13-15). Jesus says "I am the light of the world,"
and "I am he" (Jn 8: 12,24). In fact, chapter eight of John's gospel contains no less than
eleven references to Jesus as "I am." To the Pharisees, the Arians, the Watchtower, and
all those who deny that "I am he," Jesus replies, "Why do you not understand what I
say? Because you cannot bear to listen to my words. You are from your father, the
devil, and you prefer to do what your father wants...because he is a liar and the father
of lies" (Jn 8:43,44). As further evidence to the purpose of Christ's statement to the
Pharisees, the Pharisees "picked up stones to throw at him" (Jn 8:59). Clearly Jesus' use
of the divine name evoked a strong reaction in the Pharisees.

The Jews also sought to kill Jesus after He healed a man on the Sabbath day, not so
much for violating the law, but because "he spoke of God as his own Father and so
made himself equal to God" (Jn 5:18). The revelation that Jesus is equal to God is not
isolated to this verse. Note what Saint Paul writes to the Church in Phillipi; "Who,
being in the form of God, did not count equality with God something to be grasped"
(Ph 2:6). If Jesus is equal to God, and this concept is something which cannot "be
grasped," would it not then be a mystery? Yet the Watchtower contends that God
would not allow mysteries beyond the comprehension of human beings, "because
divine revelation itself does not allow for such a view of God." To support their
position, they quote Paul's first letter to the Corinthians which reads, "God is not a God
of confusion" (1Cor 14:33). Taken in context, Paul advised the Church to use the gifts of
the Spirit with prudence. He exhorted them to prophesy one at a time, since
prophesying or speaking in tongues all at the same time would only lead to confusion.
This context is a far cry from condemning belief in the Trinity, which Paul recognized
as something which could not be grasped. He clearly recognized the "mystery" of faith
in his letter to Timothy. He writes, "without any doubt, the mystery of our religion is
very deep indeed: He was made visible in the flesh" (1Tim 3:16). According to
Webster's dictionary mystery is defined: of hidden meaning, especially in a religious
sense. As such, the Watchtower contradicts itself on the very fundament of Christian
belief. They say, "God's interests are not served by making him confusing and
mysterious...it is [Satan the Devil] who promotes such false doctrines." Are they saying
that Paul was "Satan the Devil" for promoting "the mystery of our religion?"
Interestingly, the Watchtower's translation uses the term "sacred secret" instead of
"mystery." Their purpose in doing so is clear, as any admission to the existence of
mysteries undermines their entire theology. Perhaps you may wish to ask your JW
friend what exactly a "sacred secret" is. I think you'll find their definition much the
same as that for "mystery."

To counter the argument just presented, the Watchtower claims that it was "not Jesus"
who claimed to be equal to God. Although that particular line does not appear as a
direct quotation, it is neither attributed to the Jews. As such, the narrator, John the
evangelist, has every authority, granted by God, to present this fact. But Jesus said that
he could do nothing by himself, argues the Watchtower. "Can we imagine someone
equal to Almighty God saying that he could do nothing by himself." Here they miss the
whole point. Jesus is not "someone" claiming to be equal to Almighty God, He is
Almighty God.If we grant that Jesus is the Word, which even the Watchtower will
admit, then a word requires a speaker, just as the Word spoken by Almighty God.
Without the speaker, there is no word. As long as the speaker is present, so is the word,
whether spoken or in anticipation of being spoken. Part of the problem is that the
Watchtower is stuck on the very ancient and pagan idea of gods confined by space and
time but very powerful. We can imagine the clash of the titans very easily since they
have their basis in human experience. As one god battles another, the more powerful is
triumphant. Yet each is separate and different. This is how they view the Trinity as
illustrated in their publications. As Jesus implored his disciples to be one, so this is how
they view the Trinity: three separate beings united by some form of alliance or such.
Yet, the true Church does not believe in three gods glued together by a unity of
purpose, but in one God manifest in three persons.

Likewise, they answer the verse in Philippians 2:6 by suggesting that many different
translations of the same verse oppose each other. Granted, this verse has been
presented in many ways from "Who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to
be equal to God" (Douay-Rheims) to "He always had the nature of God, but he did not
think that by force he should try to become equal to God" (TEV). However, Paul's
intent here is clear. He writes, "and for this God raised him high, and gave him the
name which is above all other names; so that all beings in the heavens, on earth, and in
the underworld, should bend the knee at the name of Jesus and that every tongue
should acknowledge Jesus Christ as Lord" (Ph 2:9-11). Compare this with Isaiah's
prophesy in which God proclaims, "There is no other god except me, no saving God, no
Saviour except me!...what comes from my mouth is saving justice, it is an irrevocable
word: All shall bend the knee to me, by me every tongue shall swear, saying, 'In
Yahweh alone are saving justice and strength'" (Is 45:21-24). What is this "irrevocable
word" except the Word, Jesus Christ. Throughout the New Testament it is Christ who is
called Saviour. The Watchtower says that "Paul, and first century believers used the
Scriptures as the foundation for their teaching." Of course, the scriptures in use at the
time were of the Jewish Canon or Old Testament. If Paul used such scripture for his
teaching why would he contradict Isaiah by proclaiming Jesus as Saviour. God says
there is "no Saviour except me." The answer is clear, He is the selfsame God speaking to
Isaiah who became flesh and lived among us (Jn 1:14). Paul knew this. After all, what
name is "above all other names" besides the name of God Himself!

"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God"
(Jn 1:1). To this the Watchtower claims that the reference to God in this passage is
mistranslated from the original Greek. I am not familiar with ancient Greek and,
therefore, refuse to argue the point. However, many Greek scholars have refuted the
Watchtower's translation that "the word was a god." In their rendering they believe that
this "word," who is Jesus, is a powerful being, the Archangel Michael. He, like Satan, is
a god, but not Almighty God. In contrast, let us consider verses two and three; " He
was with God in the beginning. Through him all things came into being, not one thing
came into being except through him." Yet Moses tells us that "in the beginning God
created the heavens and the earth" (Gen 1:1). Then we are told that every time "God
said...," something came into being. What is said is a Word, namely the Word of God.
So John logically concludes, with the help of the Holy Spirit, that "not one thing came
into being except through [the Word]." When the sixth day came, "God said, 'Let us
make man in our own image, in the likeness of ourselves" (Gen 1:26). Notice the use of
the plural. Yet in the next verse he uses the singular; "in the image of God he created
him" (Gen 1:27). This has never created "confusion," but emphasizes the wonderful
mystery of the Trinity. Paul clarifies this further, "for in him were created all things in
heaven and on earth; everything visible and everything invisible" (Col 1:16). To this the
Watchtower claims that it was the Archangel Michael who was with God in the
beginning. This claim has already been refuted in chapter two. However, let us
consider one more point on this subject. If the Word was indeed Michael the Archangel,
then he would be a creature. As a creature, Michael needed a creator. Yet Sacred
Scripture tells us that "all things" were created by Jesus. Therefore as Michael, he would
have had to create himself, which is impossible. To create "all things," one had to exist
before "all things." As the only being without beginning or end, only God could be this
creator. The Word is "the firstborn of all creation" (Col 1:15) because "God said..." First
He speaks the Word and then His creation comes into being. Hence, the Word is the
first born.

The first born of creation is also revealed in the Apocalypse of John. "I am the Alpha
and the Omega, says the Lord God...Do not be afraid; it is I, the First and the Last; I am
the Living One, I was dead and look - I am alive for ever and ever" (Rev 1:8,17-18).
Later, the Alpha and Omega, First and Last are used together to describe the same
person (Rev.22:12,13). To this the Watchtower argues that the translations of Alpha and
Omega are "spurious" and do not necessarily refer to the same person. From this, one
can rightly conclude that the Watchtower is grasping at straws. In fact, there is no
adequate refutation to God's revelation that he "was dead." No JW will ever admit that
Jehovah God "was dead." Clearly it is God in the person of Jesus Christ since "everyone
will see him, even those who pierced him" (Rev 1:7).

The Watchtower is further confounded when Thomas exclaims "My Lord and my
God," (Jn 20:28) upon seeing Jesus resurrected. Here they must admit that "there is no
objection to referring to Jesus as 'God'." They try to explain that great men are often
referred to as "gods" in the Old Testament. However, such an explanation is
inadequate. In Psalm 82, which they quote, the delineation between "the gods" and

"God" is clear. That Thomas is referring to the one and only "God" is also clear. One
unprepared JW actually commented that Thomas was just using a figure of speech
which emphasized his surprise. It's a good thing Thomas didn't say "Holy Cow!"
Perhaps this can be suggested to the Watchtower as consideration for future revisions
of their translation.

"At Hebrews 1:6, the angels are instructed to 'worship' Jesus," notes the Watchtower.
They go on to explain, " This is the term used in Matthew 14:33 to express what the
disciples did toward Jesus; at Hebrews 1:6 to indicate what the angels are to do toward
Jesus; at Genesis 22:5 in the Greek Septuagint to describe what Abraham did toward
Jehovah and at Genesis 23:7 to describe what Abraham, in harmony with the custom of
the time, toward the people with whom he was doing business." Here the Watchtower
refutes their own argument. In all the examples they give, it is in reference to "Jesus" or
"Jehovah," with the exception of Abraham's business dealings. Yet, are we to consider
that the angels "worship" Jesus because it is "in harmony with the custom?" What the
custom of angels is, the Watchtower fails to declare. Yet we need only return to the
book of Revelation to learn the inadequacy of the Watchtower's innuendo. John writes,
"when I had heard and seen them all, I knelt at the feet of the angel who had shown
them to me, to worship him; but he said, 'Do no such thing: I am your fellow servant
and the fellow servant of your brothers the prophets and those who keep the message
of this book. God alone you must worship'" (Rev 22:8,9). Evidently, the "custom" of
angels is to worship "God alone."

In dealing with the matter of the Trinity, the Watchtower contends, "a person who is
really seeking to know the truth about God is not going to search the Bible hoping to
find at text that he can construe as fitting what he already believes. He wants to know
what God's Word itself says. He may find some texts that he feels can be read in more
than one way, but when these are compared with other Biblical statements on the same
subject their meaning will become clear." In fact, I couldn't have said it better myself.
When raising the arguments presented in this book, observe how your JW study
partner frantically searches his literature for an argument to counter the Catholic
position. Then, finding none, he will change the subject, or rationalize it away. The
hypocrisy the Watchtower's statement becomes even more clear when one notes the
number of times they use enclosed brackets, -italics added, or -italics ours, to insert
their own words into quotations, even into Scripture. For example, consider the
following quotation from the Watchtower publication Reasoning from the Scriptures:
"was John saying that Jesus was God? Obviously not. Toward the end of his Gospel,
John summarized matters, saying: 'These are written that you may believe that Jesus is
the Christ, [not God, but] the Son of God.' -John 20:31 RS." The only way they can prove
their point is to insert the words "not God" into Scripture where it never appeared in
the original. This technique is repugnant.

The Watchtower would like you to believe that the Trinity was an invention of the
Catholic Church in the fourth century. To substantiate this view, they misquote and
mistranslate the early Church Fathers. As noted, the common practice of the
Watchtower is to insert words and phrases that never existed in the original, the
purpose of which is clearly deception. An example is a quotation of Hippolytus which
reads, "But he was One, alone by himself; who willing it, called into being what had no
being before, such as the created prehuman Jesus." Note that the italics portion is not

part of the quotation, but is used in such a way as to deceive the reader into believing it
is. The Watchtower further asserts that the doctrine of the Trinity began its
development at "the Council of Nicaea in 325 C.E." (C.E. is used in place of A.D. in
order to avoid any recognition of "the year of our Lord"). In fact, the early Church
Fathers did recognize the divine nature of Christ. Irenaeus says, "in what manner, then,
would the word of God-indeed the great God himself, since he is the Word-differ from
the word of men?" Tertullian confirms that "the Father makes him equal to himself, and
the Son." Even Hippolytus, contrary to what the Watchtower would have you believe,
recognized that the "Word is from himself and is therefore also God, becoming the
substance of God." And long before the Council of Nicaea, Dionysius, in the year 262
A.D., contends, "If the Son was made, there was a time when these were not, which
would mean there was a time when God was without them, which is truly absurd."
And how can a Jehovah's Witness question these words of Dionysius, since the
Watchtower calls him "a professed Christian overseer." Other examples abound. Suffice
it to say that the Watchtower has grossly misrepresented the Church Fathers in its
publications, which any reading of the original will clearly reveal.

Yet, if the Bible teaches the Jesus is God, as do the Church Fathers, how can one explain
Jesus' prayers to the Father. So the Watchtower asks, "if Jesus were the Almighty God,
he would not have prayed to himself, would he?" Since they assert that God is "far from
us," the purpose of prayer must obviously be to communicate one's desires and wishes,
in a sense to make God aware. Yet is this the true reason for prayer? We have already
determined that God is not "far from us" at all. In fact, He is always with us and knows
intimately the hearts of everyone (1Sam 16, 7, Mt 1:23, Acts 1:24). And since it is the
heart that prays, we do not need to communicate with God for Him to know us. He
knows every thought that ever existed in our minds, even if we never say a single
prayer. Nonetheless, since the faithful are instructed to pray constantly, prayer must
serve an important function. The intentions of prayer are too numerous to include here.
Entire volumes have been devoted to this subject. Clearly prayer allows one to become
more attuned to the Holy Spirit, to demonstrate faith and love, to worship God, and to
resist temptation. Christ, too, had many reasons to pray. He needed to teach His
disciples how to pray (Lk 11:1). Since He had taken on human flesh, He also needed to
humble His human nature (Rm 8:13, Gal 5:24). And He needed to fulfill His role as
mediator between God and men (1 Tim 2:5). The Watchtower makes the error of
assuming that God, according to the formula of the Trinity, must be either three gods,
or one person. This is clear in their statement that "since Jesus prayed to God, asking
that God's will, not his, be done, the two could not be the same person." In fact, He is
one God in three Persons. The second Person, Jesus Christ manifested Himself in the
flesh, and, therefore, had two natures, one human and one divine. Since this Word
made flesh needed a Speaker, there must exist a relationship between the Speaker and
the Spoken Word. So Justin in 155 A.D. maintained that These were "numerically
distinct." As such, there is nothing in the Son's prayers to His Father which proves that
he is not God. The Watchtower consequently reaches an impasse. This is the "mystery
of our religion" (1Tim 3:16).

Even as the Watchtower asserts that Jesus cannot be God since they are not "the same
person," the author of this same document refers to the Holy Spirit as "the so-called
third Person of the Trinity." What seems to be happening here is another intentional
deception. The author clearly recognizes distinct Persons of the Trinity, but in
attempting to advance his previous argument suggests to his readers that Christianity
believes in one person. One may conclude that the author has distorted a truth, of
which he is well aware, as an end to his goal. If this is so, one must also question the
author's motives.

Yet, "at Matthew 4:1, Jesus is spoken of as being 'tempted by the Devil,' notes the
Watchtower. "Satan was trying to cause Jesus to be disloyal to God. But what test of
loyalty would that be if Jesus were God," they ask. "It is unimaginable that God could
sin and be disloyal to himself...So if Jesus had been God, he could not have been
tempted." In fact, Jesus was not "tempted," according to the proper context of the
passage. Matthew 4:1 reads, "Jesus was led by the Spirit out into the desert to be put to
the test by the devil." Here it is the devil who tests and in reply Jesus asserts His
divinity as the Son of God for He replies, "Do not put the Lord your God to the test"
(Mt 4:7). This is the commandment given by God, and handed down to His people by
Moses, for Moses declares, "Do not put Yahweh your God to the test as you tested him
at Massah" (Dt 6:16). Clearly, God is tested by Satan and man. This fact, in no way,
implies "that God could sin." On the contrary, Jesus commands Satan to depart and
Satan is vanquished (Mt 4:10,11). After making this point clear to your JW friend, ask
him where in scripture one finds that "Jesus could have been disloyal," as the
Watchtower professes.

Further to this, the Watchtower notes that Jesus was a perfect human who gave himself
as a ransom for all (1Tim 2:5,6). "If Jesus, however, were part of a Godhead, the ransom
price would have been infinitely higher than what God's own Law required," they
claim. "It was only a perfect human, Adam, who sinned in Eden, not God." However,
the Holy Catholic Church teaches that God took on human flesh, manifest in two
natures, fully God and fully man. God in His human nature died for our sins to ransom
us from death. To this, "John has borne witness to the Word of God and to the witness
of Jesus Christ" (Rev. 1:2,9). The Watchtower admits that Jesus is this Word. In Saint
John's Apocalypse, He is revealed as these two, the One who is First, through whom all
creation came into being, and the One who is Last, in whom God manifested Himself
clothed in human weakness, to become the Saviour, the spotless Lamb of God, the
perfect offering to redeem man from the captivity of sin. To support their idea that "the
ransom price would have been infinitely higher than what God's own Law required,"
they quote Moses who says a "life for life, eye for eye," and so on (Ex 21:23,24; Lev.
24:19-21). After all, Paul notes, "Just as all die in Adam, so in Christ all will be brought
to life." Thus they argue that since one man caused death to come into the world, only
one man was needed to redeem mankind. In contrast, Moses also says, "Parents may
not be put to death for their children, nor children for their parents, but each must be
put to death for his own crime" (Dt 24:16). Since God does not forgive Adam only, but
rather forgives all our sins through "the blood of Jesus" (1 Jn 1:7), without His sacrifice
we are all guilty before the Lord (1 Jn 1:8-10). It is through our first parents, Adam and
Eve, that sin came into the world by way of a corruptible human nature that is passed
on from generation to generation. If we trust what Moses is saying, Adam cannot be
accountable for my sin or your sin, but each "for his own crime." Therefore, the
sacrificial Lamb of God, Jesus Christ, died for many billions, each one "for his own
crime." Then, by the Watchtower's own measure of a life for a life, how well would
Christ measure up to God's justice if he were but a mere man.

The Watchtower continues; "Thus when God sent Jesus to earth as the ransom, he made
Jesus to be what would satisfy justice, not a god-man, but a perfect man, 'lower than the
angels.' (Hebrews 2:9; compare Psalm 8:5, 6.) How could any part of the Godhead,"
they add, "even be lower than angels?" The answer to this has been laid out above.
First, that Paul calls the incarnation "the mystery of our religion," and angels who
worship "God alone" have been instructed to worship Jesus Christ (1 Tim 3:16; Heb 1:6;
Rev. 22:8,9). This also refutes their argument that "countless other created spirit beings,
angels, are also called 'sons of God'." In addition, as was pointed out in chapter two,
Paul has devoted the entire first portion of his letter to the Hebrews to refuting any
notion that Christ is an angel (Heb 1,2).

This leads into their next argument. "If Jesus had been God, how could Jesus have been
exalted, that is, raised to a higher position than he previously enjoyed." Further to this,
they add, "If, before his exaltation, Jesus had been equal to God, exalting him any
further would have made him superior to God." In answer to this, Paul notes that Jesus
was made lower than the angels for "a short time" (Heb 2:7), and was made like man in
every way except sin (Heb 4:15). The purpose for this was to share in our suffering and
weakness (Heb 5:2) and to offer himself as an eternal sacrifice to redeem mankind from
sin (Heb 10:14,17-18). If He became fully man, as Paul says, He would need to be
subject in every way, except sin, to this human nature. And if His human nature was
somehow greater than all other human beings, he would not have been fully human,
but another species more advanced than humans. Nevertheless, this "mystery of our
religion" maintains that Jesus has always been and always will be fully God (1 Tim
3:16; Heb 13:8). Even while He was subject to His human nature, His divine nature was
maintained. Many do not take the time to understand this and pray for guidance
through the Holy Spirit, for Paul says, "Do not be led astray by all sorts of strange
doctrines: it is better to rely on grace for inner strength than food, which has done no
good to those who concentrate on it" (Heb 13:9).

The mystery of His incarnation explains why Jesus would need to learn and advance in
wisdom while subject to His human nature. Therefore, the Watchtower in confounded
when they ask, "Can we imagine that God had to learn anything?" We do not imagine
Jesus, on the day of His birth, immediately preaching on all the truths of the universe.
Instead, we think of a newborn child not unlike any other newborn child. To be fully
human He had to learn how to walk, how to speak, and, later, how to be a carpenter.
The Watchtower maintains that this is proof that Jesus is not God, but then what do
they believe He is, if not God. As we examined in chapter two, the Watchtower
professes that Jesus is the Archangel Michael. They believe that he was the first creature
created in the whole universe, and that he helped God create the universe. To do so,
Michael would have had to have a knowledge of Astrophysics, Geology, Biochemistry,
etc. Yet, when, as the Watchtower professes, Michael became Jesus Christ, he did not
know any of these things. So lets turn their own argument on them and ask, "Can we
imagine that" Michael who helped create the universe "had to learn anything?"

Given the matters as set out above, dealing with the doctrine of the Holy Spirit becomes
rather academic. The arguments presented by the Watchtower to show that the Holy
Spirit is not God, but His "active force," are much the same as those presented in their
denial of Christ as Lord. "John had been baptizing with water. Hence in the same way
that water is not a person," argues the Watchtower, "holy spirit is not a person." They
go on to say, "what John foretold was fulfilled when, following the death and
resurrection of Jesus, holy spirit was poured out on his followers gathered in
Jerusalem...Were they filled with a person?" Yet Jesus tells us that He will send the
Paraclete from the Father, "the Spirit of truth who issues from the Father" (Jn 15:26). If
God fills the heavens and the earth, as noted previously, and Christ fills "all things,"
how could He issue the Spirit? This question necessarily implies a relationship between
the One who issues and the Spirit that is issued. Notice that such reasoning is not
unlike the discussion on the relationship between the Speaker (the Father) and the
Spoken Word (Jesus Christ). According to the Gospel of John, not only is the Spirit
issued "from the Father," but is also sent by the Son. As such, the Spirit is numerically
distinct from both the Father and the Son. This is also evident as the Paraclete witnesses
to Jesus (Jn 15:26). Scripture further tells us that the Spirit is One who leads, speaks, and
reveals. He is also One who says "only what he has been told" (Jn 16:13). Now let's
consider the Watchtower's argument. They contend that the "holy spirit is not a person"
in the same way as water. From this one must conclude that water leads, speaks, and
reveals, and water does "only what he has been told." If one makes such a conclusion,
he must necessarily be a Pantheist, a charge the Watchtower would deny.

But, the Watchtower would contend, "at 1 John 5:6-8 (NE) not only the spirit but also
'the water, and the blood' are said to be 'witnesses.' But water and blood are obviously
not persons, and neither is the holy spirit a person." Let's look further into what John is
really saying when he speaks of water and blood as "witnesses." John writes, "He it is
who came by water and blood, Jesus Christ, not with water alone but with water and
blood, and it is the Spirit that bears witness, for the Spirit is Truth. So there are three
witnesses, the Spirit, water and blood; and the three of them coincide" (1 Jn 5:6-8).
Notice how John makes very clear that "the three of them coincide." So it is that they
coincide when Christ is pierced on the cross. "This is the evidence," we are told, "so that
you may believe as well" (Jn 19:15). "Everyone will see him, even those who pierced
him" (Rev. 1:7). So it is that these three coincide as testimony that Jesus is the Christ, but
it is the Spirit who witnesses in all these.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church 694 clarifies this further: "The symbolism of
water signifies the Holy Spirit's action in Baptism, since after the invocation of the Holy
Spirit it becomes the efficacious sacramental sign of new birth: just as the gestation of
our first birth took place in water, so the water of Baptism truly signifies that our birth
into the divine life is given to us in the Holy Spirit. As 'by one Spirit we were all
baptized,' so we are also 'made to drink of one Spirit.' (1 Cor. 12:13). Thus the Spirit is
also the living water welling up from Christ crucified (Jn 19:34; 1 Jn 5:8) as its source
and welling up in us to eternal life. (Cf. Jn 4:10-14;7:38;Ex 17:1-6;Isa 55:1;Zech 14:8;1 Cor
10:4;Rev 21:6;22:17)"

Through Baptism we are born again of the Spirit, into the new covenant of Jesus Christ,
for "the real circumcision is in the heart, a thing not of the letter but of the spirit" (Rm
2:29). But just as circumcision did not remove one's responsibility to make a sin offering
before the Lord (Ex 29:36), so is it that Christ did not come "with water alone," but by
His own blood which He offered up as a sacrifice for all time (Heb 10:10). Because of
this, "the Holy Spirit attests this to us...there can be no more sin offerings" (Heb
10:15,18). Insofar&127; as the water and blood are witnesses, therefore, they are the means
by which the Holy Spirit reveals salvation in the new covenant of Jesus Christ. "We are
the true people of the circumcision since we worship by the Spirit of God and make
Christ Jesus our only boast" (Ph 3:3). Without the Spirit of Truth, water and blood
reveal nothing. Salvation does not come from the blood of goats, but the blood of God's
only begotten Son (Jn 3:16, Heb 10:3).

Next consider that the Holy Spirit is true God. When God's Spirit is sent out, creation
comes into being (Gen 1:2, Job 33:4, Ps. 104:30), but it is God who is Creator of all. In a
sense, the Spirit represents the will of God, and His love for creation. Furthermore, we
are told that we are God's temple wherein His Spirit resides (1Cor 3:16). Let us further
consider Saint Paul's letter to the Romans. In the eighth chapter, the Romans are
exhorted to put to death their "natural inclinations." It is "by the Spirit that you put to
death the habits of the body" so as not to be ruled by our human nature (Rm 8:12,13).
Since God already fills everything, we do not obtain something lacking when we are
filled with the Spirit. Rather, as we put to death the natural inclinations of the flesh, our
awareness grows of that wondrous Spirit within us, as if being full of the Spirit without
any hinderance from "the habits of the body." If the Watchtower replies that God's
Spirit is different from the "holy spirit," the following proof texts should suffice. In
corresponding passages in Matthew and Mark, disciples are warned of the persecution
they must suffer. In one Jesus says, "what you are to say will be given to you when the
time comes, because it is not you who will be speaking; the Spirit of your Father will be
speaking in you" (Mt 10:20). In the other He makes the same point: "it is not you who
will be speaking; it is the Holy Spirit" (Mk 13:11).

How does the Spirit of God speak through the disciples of the Lord? According to the
Watchtower, "The action of the spirit in such instances is like that of radio waves
transmitting messages from one person to another far away." This is in keeping with
the Watchtower's contention that "[God] is far away." Imagine, if you will, the
Watchtower's image of Almighty God ruling the universe from his home at the star
"Alcyone" in the constellation Pleiades, sending out radio waves to his followers "far
away" on planet earth. On the other hand, Paul asks, "Do you not realize that your
body is the temple of the Holy Spirit." One cannot imagine a temple for radio waves or
anything that "is like that of radio waves," for a temple is consecrated to God.

We have already seen that God fills "heaven and earth" (Jr. 23:24), and Christ fills "all
things" (Ep. 4:10). So too "the spirit of the Lord fills the world" (Wis. 1:7). There is
nowhere one can go where the Holy Spirit is not also (Ps. 139:7,8). Therefore, both
Christ and Holy Spirit are God. Elsewhere we find that when a man lies to the Holy
Spirit, he lies to God (Acts 5:3-4). Can a man lie to "radio waves?" In addition, "whoever
keeps his commandments remains in God" (1 Jn. 3:24). Does the person who keeps His
commandments send "radio signals" back?

The arguments used by the Watchtower to deny our Lord and God's Spirit of Truth are
fallacious and repugnant, especially in areas where deception appears to be deliberate.
As such, a warning from Saint Paul may be appropriately directed to the Watchtower.
"Anyone who tramples on the Son of God, and who treats the blood of the covenant
which sanctified him as if it were not holy, and who insults the Spirit of grace, will be
condemned to a far severer punishment" (Heb 10:29).