copyright 1995 by David Wesley
CHAPTER 5 - DISHONOUR THY MOTHER
The Watchtower contends that anyone who venerates an image of a saint, the mother of
God, or even God Himself, is an idol worshipper. Such acts will condemn Roman
Catholics and Protestants alike to eternal oblivion. The Watchtower notes that "they
may say they do not worship the image, but that seeing and touching it helps them
worship God. Yet does God want us to worship him with the aid of images?" They go
on to answer their question declaring, "it is wrong to use images in worship." The
Watchtower condemns Catholics for "Mary Worship" which "echoes much older
worship of pagan goddesses." These are strong indictments that must not go
unchallenged.
First let us examine the use of images for veneration and worship. The Watchtower
presents the following argument: "Moses told the Israelites that God never appeared to
them in any visible form. (Deuteronomy 4:15- 19) In fact, one of the Ten
Commandments says: 'You shall not make yourself a carved image or any likeness of
anything...you shall not bow down to them or serve them.'" I hope I have adequately
demonstrated in the previous chapter that God did appear in visible form as Jesus
Christ our Lord. The events of the Old Testament are a foreshadowing of this salvific
mystery. And such foreshadowing will be instrumental in the refutation that follows.
Ask yourself, what was the purpose of the first commandment? During the lifetime of
Moses, pagan worship flourished (as it does today). The Egyptians had their own gods
which they worshipped and many in Israel also worshipped these, even after their
departure from Egypt (Ex. 32:1; 34:16). Graven images were considered gods in
themselves, not images intended to lead to the Almighty. This contrasts images
fashioned after various subjects that, in themselves, were blessed by God and, in turn,
lead to God. The Lord Himself required this, for he commanded Moses; "Make a fiery
serpent and raise it as a standard. Anyone who is bitten and looks at it will survive.
Moses then made a serpent out of bronze" (Num 21:8,9). "Whoever turned to it was
saved, not by what he looked at, but by...the Saviour of all" (Wis. 16:7). Even the New
Testament recognized this, for John writes, "as Moses lifted up the snake in the desert,
so must the Son of man be lifted up" (Jn. 3:14).
God created matter and saw that it "was good...indeed it was very good" (Gen 1:4,31).
For this reason it is also good to use matter as a means of coming closer to God and His
Truth. This is evident in the bronze serpent made by Moses. Yet, these objects have no
power to save or heal except by the power of God. God simply uses matter to offer His
gifts to man. In fact, He loves matter so much that the Word took on material form
Himself&127; through the incarnation (Jn 3:16). In His human form, the Son of man also
used matter to perform miracles, as He did with the man who was blind from birth.
"He spat on the ground, made a paste with the spittle, put this over the eyes of the
blind man," further telling him to go wash. Upon returning, the blind man was cured
an could see (Jn 9:6,7). Yet, it was not the mud that cured the blind man, but the power
of God.
Solomon also used matter to construct images for the Great Temple. These were "two
great winged creatures of wild-olive wood" (1 Kgs 6:23) and a large basin, known as a
sea, which was supported by twelve replicas of oxen (1 Kgs 7:23-25). Contrast these
oxen with the golden calf constructed by Aaron. Although the images may have been
similar, Solomon's oxen were not worshipped.
As with many heresies adopted by the Watchtower, this refusal to accept matter as an
instrument of God's salvation, whether it be the incarnation, or the use of images, is
merely a reflection of Gnosticism. The Gnostics hated matter so much that they abused
their own bodies through grotesque excesses that included widespread fornication.
This is also reflected in liberal protestantism with their ordination of active
homosexuals and acceptance of abortion. The diseases associated with homosexual
behaviour and the willful destruction of life can only be attributed to a hatred of
matter. The Watchtower will deny any association with such groups as they are on the
other end of the behavioral spectrum. However, the Watchtower speaks highly of the
Albigenses who were a Gnostic cult of the twelveth century. The Albigenses also hated
matter and engaged in widespread fornication and other abuses contrary to natural
law, not to mention God's law. They considered marriage evil and promoted
euthanasia. Yet the Watchtower defends Albigensianism since "they rejected the
doctrines of the Trinity, the Virgin Birth, hellfire, and purgatory. Thus they actively put
in doubt the teachings of Rome...The root of the problem for the Catholic Church was
evidently the existence of the Bible in the language of the people." Is the Watchtower
suggesting that reading the Bible led to the development of Albigense doctrine? The
appropriate use of the Bible will be examined in the next chapter. In the mean time, lets
return to our examination of the use of images in worship.
The most important graven image of the Old Testament is the ark of the covenant, the
construction of which is described in detail (Ex. 25). It was to be perfect in every way
possible and treated with great care and veneration. It had to be carried and handled in
a specific way, otherwise God would pour out His wrath on those responsible (2 Sam
6:6-7). Upon it were placed winged creatures, images of holy angels. "The winged
creatures had their wings spread upwards, protecting the ark with their wings and
facing each other, their faces being towards the mercy seat" (Ex. 37:9). Inside the ark
was placed the word of God written by His own finger upon the tablets given to Moses
(Ex. 25:21). Later, the Word of God "became flesh" (Jn 1:14) carried inside the womb of
another perfect ark, Mary. So, too, she is to be treated with honour and veneration.
What makes Catholics so sure that the ark of the covenant foreshadows Mary? After all,
the Watchtower is not the only sect to attack what they consider to be idol worship.
Most protestants as well are angered by the honour payed to Mary by the universal
(Catholic) Church.
After Uzzah was struck down by God for touching the ark, David placed it in the care
of Obed-Edom. It stayed there for three months during which time Obed-Edom's whole
family was blessed (2 Sam. 6:10,11). Likewise, after Mary conceived by the power of the
Holy Spirit, she went to visit Elizabeth for the same amount of time, and "the
Lord...lavished on [Elizabeth] his faithful love" (Lk. 1:56-58). When the ark first came
into David's possession, he asked "How can the ark of Yahweh come to be with me?" (2
Sam. 6:9). Elizabeth asks much the same question, "Why should I be honoured with a
visit from the mother of my Lord?" (Lk. 1:43). Then, "David danced...before Yahweh
with all his might" (2 Sam.6:14). So too, "as soon as Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, the
child leapt in her womb and Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit" (Lk 1:41). If
Mary is indeed the ark of the living God, should she not be given even more honour
and veneration than an ark constructed by human hands out of acacia wood? After all,
Mary was fashioned by the hand of God himself. When Elizabeth realized this, she
payed honour and respect to Mary, even though Mary had probably visited Elizabeth
regularly prior to her pregnancy. All of a sudden she is "honoured" by her visit and
proclaims her "blessed." Elizabeth makes clear that she is referring to Mary, not the
fruit of her womb, Jesus who of course is blessed above all (Lk 1:45).
Now consider the Watchtower's lowly estimation of Mary: "Over the centuries, one
result of the Trinity teaching has been that the one true God Jehovah has been
submerged in the quagmire of Christendom's God-Christ theology. The next logical
consequence of that theology was that if Jesus really was God Incarnate, then Jesus'
mother, Mary, was obviously the "Mother of God." Over the years, that has led to
veneration of Mary in many different forms, this in spite of the total lack of texts that
speak of Mary in any role of importance except as the humble biologic mother of Jesus."
Such language shows the utter contempt the Watchtower has for the mother of our
Lord. Indeed, Holy Scripture shows just the opposite, since Mary was spoken of by the
prophets (Is. 7:14;Mc. 5:1,2) and throughout the New Testament. If Mary did not have
"any role of importance," why then did the inspired writers of the Bible speak of her for
more than 700 years? Even the archangel Gabriel spoke of Mary as one who enjoys
"God's favour" (Lk. 1:28).
Are we not to follow our Lord's example (Heb 12:1,2)? Did He not tell us to keep the
commandments (Mt.&127; 19:17) and to "honour your father and your mother" (Mt. 19:19)?
We know that Mary was His mother, and that He honoured her as such. If our Lord
honoured His mother, should we dishonour her by accusing her of sin, sexual union
with her husband, and unfaithfulness to our Lord. This is the tactic the Watchtower,
and many protestant sects, use to ridicule Mary's holy name.
They say that Jesus had brothers and sisters, and, therefore, Mary could not have been
a perpetual virgin. Yet, brother and sister are often used in the Greek to mean many
things including, cousin, relative, friend, and disciple (see Jas 4:11). Next consider
Christ's own words as He was dying on the cross, for John writes, "Near the cross of
Jesus stood his mother, and his mother's sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary of
Magdala. Seeing his mother and the disciple whom he loved standing near her, Jesus
said to his mother, 'Woman, this is your son.' Then to the disciple he said, 'this is your
mother.' And from that hour the disciple took her into his home" (Jn 19:25-27). Now
consider the Watchtower's claim, "she had other sons and daughters." If she had other
sons and daughters, why would Jesus need to commend her to the care of one of His
disciples. Were her other children so disrespectful that they did not want to care for
her? Was she so poor a mother that they did not want to follow the fourth
commandment and care for her in her old age? Impossible! But if she had no other
children, this statement would make sense. Also consider that Mary the wife of Clopas
is called Mary's sister. Does this make sense? Would Anne and Joachin have given two
daughters the exact same name? Imagine the confusion if they had to call them. More
likely, Mary the wife of Clopas is Mary's relative.
So what about the Watchtower's "evidence" that Jesus had brothers and sisters. Just
look at Matthew 13:53-56, they say. "'When Jesus had finished these parables he left the
district; and, coming to his home town, he taught the people in their synagogue in such
a way that they were astonished and said, 'Where did the man get his wisdom and
these miraculous powers? This is the carpenter's son, surely? Is not his mother the
woman called Mary, and his brothers [Greek, a del phoi ] James and Joseph and Simon
and Jude? His sisters [Greek, a del phai ], too, are they not all here with us?' (On the
basis of this text, would you conclude that Jesus was Mary's only child or that she had
other sons as well as daughters?)." However, elsewhere James and Joseph are referred
to as children of another Mary, probably the wife of Clopas. Saint Mark writes, "There
were some women watching from a distance. Among them were Mary of Magdala,
Mary who was the mother of James the younger and Joset, and Salome. These used to
follow him and look after him when he was in Galilee" (Mk. 15:40,41). The words, "they
used to follow him" indicate that these were all His disciples. Saint Matthew confirms
this; "And many women were there, watching from a distance, the same women who
had followed Jesus from Galilee and looked after him. Among them were Mary of
Magdala, Mary the mother of James and Joseph, and the mother of Zebedee's sons" (Mt.
27:55,56). Notice that neither Matthew nor Mark refer to Mary "the mother of Jesus" (Jn.
2:1) as she is referred to elsewhere. We also know that Mary, the wife of Clopas was
with Mary of Magdala, an implicit reference to her as the same "sister" of Mary "his
mother."
The Watchtower further argues, "No one claims that the reference to Jesus' mother
means anything different from what it says. Is it consistent, then, to reason that his
natural brothers were not that but were perhaps cousins? When what is meant is not
brothers but relatives, a different Greek word [syg ge-non ] is used as at Luke 21:16." In
fact there are many references to brothers that go far beyond the meaning of brothers,
or even relatives, to encompass then entire community of believers, even mankind as a
whole. The epistles provide ample evidence of this usage. As I am not versed in the
Greek language, I defer to someone who is. In his booklet, Refuting the Attack on Mary,
Father Mateo notes, "The writers (except for Luke) and the very early readers of the
New Testament, being Jews of that period, were 'Septuagint conditioned." They were
accustomed to the Septuagint usage of adelphos/adelphe as the ordinary Greek
rendering of the Hebrew word ach in all its familial and extra-familial meanings,
meanings much broader than uterine brother/sisterhood. Texts which call James, Joses,
Simon, Judas and unnamed women the adelphoi and adelphai of Jesus cannot be
understood except by calling these people Jesus' relatives, not his uterine brothers and
sisters." Father Mateo also refers to New Testament scholars who concur that the Greek
used is taken after the Septuagint usage. Henry Wansborough, editor of The New
Jerusalem Bible notes in his introduction to the Gospel of Luke, "Luke writes in a more
sophisticated Greek than the other evangelists." As such, the Watchtower's reference to
Luke 21:16 proves nothing other than their, usually deliberate, misrepresentation of the
facts. Saint Luke tells us of the annual pilgrimage to Jerusalem made by Jesus and His
parents. When He was twelve, Jesus stayed behind to discuss theology with the
teachers "without his parents knowing it. They assumed he was somewhere in the
party, and it was only after a day's journey that they went to look for him among their
relations and acquaintances" (Lk 2:43,44). If Luke had used the same form of Greek as
the other evangelists, the passage would possibly read, 'they went to look for him
among their brothers and sisters.' As it stands, there is no reference in this passage,
already twelve years after the birth of Christ, that Jesus had any brothers or sisters.
Considered along with the fact that there is never reference to Mary giving birth to any
other children, one can see the gross error of the Watchtower. The doctrine of Mary's
perpetual virginity is theologically sound.
Nothing unclean can enter into the presence of God (Ex. 3:5,6; 19:21,22). Since Mary is
the mother of God, she would need to be preserved from sin (uncleanness) in order to
act as an ark for the new covenant (see below). This is why she remained a virgin. Since
nothing is impossible for God, Christ could have been conceived by the Holy Spirit
after she had "knowledge of man," but such sexual union, even under holy matrimony,
would have defiled her, making her unsuitable to be the Theotokos (God-bearer). This
is foreshadowed by Moses instructions to refrain from sexual union prior to God's
descent on Mount Sinai. Even then, the people were to remain at the base of the
mountain distant from God's actual appearance "on the top of the mountain" (Ex. 19:
15,20).
In his address to the Corinthians, Saint Paul elaborates further on this theme. He
writes, "the unmarried woman, and the virgin, gives her mind to the Lord's affairs and
to being holy in body and spirit" (1 Cor. 7:34). Paul continues, "If someone with strong
passions thinks that he is behaving badly towards his fiancee and that things should
take their due course, he should follow his desires. There is no sin in it; they should
marry" (1 Cor. 7:36). How could Mary be the handmaid of the Lord (Lk. 1:38) without
devoting "her mind to the Lord's affairs" as the ever-virgin? Can one describe the
mother of God as one with strong passions and desires. In addition, there can be no
other explanation for her surprise when the angel told her she would conceive and give
birth to a Son (Lk. 1:34). Was she not already "betrothed to a man named Joseph" (Lk.
1:27)? If she had planned to enter into sexual union with her husband, she would
expect to conceive at some point in her life. The only explanation for her surprise is that
she planned to remain chaste even after her marriage.
The Church fathers understood this clearly. In the fourth century, Saint Athanasius
wrote the following in regard to the Arian heresy, but it may as well have been written
to the Watchtower: "Let those, therefore, who deny that the Son is by nature from the
Father and proper to his essence deny also that he took true human flesh from the ever-
virgin Mary." Saint Augustine, in the early fifth century, was more direct: "Heretics
called Antidicomarites are those who contradict the perpetual virginity of Mary and
affirm that after Christ was born she was joined as one with her husband."The Watchtower further denies that Mary was preserved from original sin. They feel
that she was a sinner like everyone else. Yet, in the beginning, Genesis, after Eve had
eaten from the forbidden fruit, God tells the serpent who tempted her, "I shall put
enmity between you and the woman and between your seed and her seed" (Gen. 3:15
NWT). How can this be so? In every other Bible passage, the seed only refers to the
male, who is the father (ie. Gen. 19:32,34). Since Mary is the only woman to ever
conceive a child without the aid of a human father and his seed, Jesus must be this
seed. He, being free from sin, would have enmity between Himself and His adversary
Satan. This passage cannot refer to Eve and her descendants since they were all sinners
and under Satan's influence. And even if it could refer to Eve's descendants, why
would God not refer to Adam's seed. Further to this, consider the next thing God says
to the serpent, "He will bruise you in the head." Notice, God does not say they, but He
(singular). Therefore, the Israelites are not the ones to bruise Satan in the head. But God
also put enmity between Satan and the woman. In order to be an enemy to Satan, Mary
would also need to be preserved from sin.
Indeed, the Watchtower unwittingly points out this very fact. "But did Adam and Eve's
sin really thwart God's purpose?" asks the Watchtower. "No, for immediately after their
sinning, God announced that he would raise up a 'seed' to destroy Satan and his agents
and that he would again set matters straight." The Watchtower further identifies that
Jesus is the seed since it is Jesus who "cleansed the heavens of Satan and his demons,"
and "the Warrior-King Jesus Christ removes Satan and his unrighteous world." As
such, if Jesus is the "seed" who destroys Satan and his agents, then Mary must be "the
woman." This point will come as a surprise to your Jehovah's Witness friend since he
has been taught that "the woman" is Eve, yet nothing will be more convincing to him
than the very words of the Watchtower.
The Watchtower also refers to Jesus as the "second Adam." Adam was made perfect out
of the dust, they say, as part of a plan to make the world "into a paradise." When that
plan was thwarted by sin, Jesus "provided the ransom. This is because Jesus is the only
man that ever lived that was equal to Adam as a perfect human son of God." According
to their logic then, would there not also need to be a perfect woman to equal Eve "as a
perfect human" daughter "of God?" This is not to say that Mary was in any way equal
to Christ, for that is a heresy long condemned by the Church, but rather to expose the
false logic of the Jehovah's Witnesses who claim that Christ was but a mere man,
perfect like Adam, but certainly not God.
"Well then," the Watchtower retorts, scripture tells us that "everyone has sinned. (Rom.
5:12)" The answer to this is not at all complicated. First, Paul's letter is directed to
"God's beloved in Rome" (Rm. 1:7) of whom Mary is not included. Next, ask yourself if
there could be exceptions to Paul's edict. Are the unborn, little children, and the
mentally handicapped capable of sin? Do not many of these die (especially now with
the widespread promotion of abortion) before they are ever capable of committing a
single sin? Also consider what the archangel Gabriel told Mary. Did he not say
"nothing is impossible for God" (Lk. 1:37)? However, the Watchtower has anticipated
such a response, to which they reply, "Mary offered at the temple in Jerusalem a sin
offering for purification from uncleanness. She, too, had inherited sin and imperfection
from Adam." On the&127; contrary, this act points to Mary's sinlessness through her
humble service of God. When the angel comes to announce that she will be the mother
to the Saviour of Israel, she does not say 'of course, I only expected as much since I am
perfect,' a statement which would imply pride and, therefore, sin. Rather, she replies,
"how can this come about?" (Lk. 1:34). After this mystery is explained by the angel, she
answers, "You see before you the Lord's servant" (Lk. 1:38). A humble "servant" of the
Lord would not, all of a sudden, abandon a tradition more than a thousand years old,
for that too would imply pride. Our Lord is a perfect example of this. Baptism,
according to the Baptist himself, is "for repentance" (Mt. 3:11). Yet, Christ, who is
without sin, was Himself baptized (Mt. 3:16). John recognized the irony in this and
protested, "it is I who need baptism from you" (Mt. 3:14). Since Mary is "blessed," she
too would humble herself to sacred traditions and sacraments, for "blessed are those
who are poor in spirit" (Mt. 5:3). From the beatitudes, we can see that Mary is also
gentle, merciful, and pure in heart. She hungers and thirsts for uprightness, is
persecuted, and mourns (Mt. 5:3-10). For all this, hers "is the kingdom of Heaven" (Mt.
5:3,10).
The whole concept of veneration is lost to Jehovah's Witnesses. They do not understand
it and dare not try to understand it. From the examples of humility by both our Lord
and His mother, the Watchtower sees "evidence" that they are other than what we claim
them to be. Our Lord is not God because He humbled himself and Mary is not
immaculately conceived because she humbled herself. On the contrary, such acts
support the conclusion that they are, in fact, what the Church believes them to be, the
Word of God and the Immaculate Conception.
The Watchtower's conclusions about Mary and Jesus lend themselves to further errors.
"Should we venerate 'saints' as intercessors with God, perhaps using images of them as
aids to our worship?" As always, they distort Catholic theology by inserting ideas
different from the ones that they are condemning in an attempt to falsely discredit the
practice. In this case, they equate veneration with intercession, two very different
concepts. Both are very important aspects of the spiritual life of the Church, but the act
of one does not necessitate the act of the other.
First, let us examine the act of veneration. As we have seen above, veneration of objects
has a long standing history going back to Moses and the veneration of the ark of the
covenant. The word veneration itself means 'worthy of religious respect.' The
Watchtower claims that the Bible is worthy of religious respect and, as such, venerate it.
How, then, can they condemn those who they feel "are not worshipping God 'in spirit'
but...depend on what they can see with their physical eyes?" Interestingly, they also
condemn oral tradition, advocating instead for sola scriptura or the Bible alone. This in
itself denies the "spirit" as present in the early church which had no Bible. Contrary to
what the Watchtower may claim, the Catholic Church also venerates the Bible as the
holy word of God, but without rejecting other traditions.
The Watchtower's concept of veneration confuses it with worship, which is more than
religious respect, but adoration. The Catechism of the Catholic Church makes this very
clear: "The Christian veneration of images is not contrary to the first commandment
which proscribes idols. Indeed, 'the honor rendered to an image passes to its prototype,'
and 'whoever venerates an image venerates the person portrayed in it.' The honor paid
to sacred images is a 'respectful veneration,' not the adoration due to God alone."
Further to this, Pope John Paul II writes, "By proclaiming and venerating the holiness of
her sons and daughters, the Church gave supreme honor to God Himself; in the
martyrs she venerated Christ, Who was at the origin of their martyrdom and their
holiness."
As an example of the Watchtower's confusion on the matter they state: "'As Peter
reached the house Cornelius went out to meet him, knelt at his feet and prostrated
himself. But Peter helped him up. 'Stand up,' he said 'I am only a man after all!' (Since
Peter did not approve of such adoration when he was personally present, would he
encourage us to kneel before and image of him? See also Revelation 19:10.)" Here again,
their hypocrisy is showing. Remember, in our examination of the divinity of Christ in
Chapter Four, we examined Revelation 19:10 as evidence that Jesus is God since this
passage demands that worship be directed to God alone. However, in denying that
Christ is God, the Watchtower claims that Paul's statement in Hebrews 1:6 does not
refer to the angels worshipping Jesus, but rather "[showing] him reverence." In essence,
then, they are saying on the one hand, that veneration, also defined as reverence, is due
to God alone, but on the other hand, it is also due to Jesus, who they claim is not God,
but an angel.
The Watchtower's example of Peter confuses also the matter of intercession. Faithful
Catholics around the world, and at all times throughout history, have asked the saints
to intercede on our behalf. Interestingly, this is evident in the very same passage which
the Watchtower quotes in promoting their distorted point of view. In Paul's first letter
to Timothy (2:5), the Watchtower notes: "'There is only one God, and there is only one
mediator between God and mankind, himself a man, Christ Jesus.' (There is no
allowance here for others to serve in the role of mediator for the members of Christ's
congregation.)" Aux contraire! Here we must examine the context in which Paul is
saying this. "I urge then first of all," Paul writes, "that petitions, prayers, intercessions
and thanksgiving should be offered for everyone" (1 Tim. 2:1). He clearly states that the
faithful, who are united to Christ in His body (1 Cor. 12:12-30), are to offer "petitions,
prayers, [and] intercessions." The Watchtower fails to recognize that the saints are
"members of Christ's congregation," His body. For what purpose did Paul ask the
faithful to offer intercessions? "For everyone," Paul continues, "for Kings and others in
authority, so that we may be able to live peaceful and quiet lives with all devotion and
propriety" (1 Tim. 2:2). Paul believed that God would pour out His Spirit of grace to
everyone, including those in authority, as a direct result of the intercessions of the
faithful. Such intercessions are very similar to those of the Fatima prayer which is
frequently prayed after each decade of the rosary: "Oh my Jesus, forgive us our sins,
and save us from the fires of Hell, lead all souls to Heaven, especially those in most
need of Thy mercy." The prayers of the early Church were answered when, in the year
312 A.D., the Roman Emperor, Constantine himself, converted to Christianity. Paul
speaks of Christ as the one mediator, in this context, because he wanted to point out
that Christ is the saviour of "everyone," not just Christians. He wanted the faithful to
pray for the conversion of sinners everywhere because God "wants everyone to be
saved and reach full knowledge of the truth" (1 Tim. 2:4).
Other examples abound which call for the faithful to intercede on another's behalf (see
Jas. 5:16). That such intercessions are effective, one only need look at Abraham's
intercession on behalf of Sodom (Gen. 18:16-33). And how often can we see Moses
interceding on behalf of the Israelites (Ex. 32:11-14). Even consider how Solomon was
spared the wrath of God because of his father, David, who had long since passed away
(1 Kg 11:9-13). But here the Watchtower objects. "The living are conscious that they will
die; but as for the dead," the Watchtower points out, "they are conscious of nothing at
all" (Eccl. 9:5). Through selective quotation, the Watchtower again attempts to deceive
the uncatechized. The author of Ecclesiastes shares with us his journey to try to uncover
the meaning of life. Early in his quest he is clearly disillusioned, for he writes: "Human
is in no way better off than animal-since all is futile" (Eccl. 3:19). Surely the Watchtower
would not suggest that mankind is no better off than sea slugs! In contrast, towards the
end of his quest, the author of Ecclesiastes discovers, "the spirit returns to God" (Eccl.
12:7). Yet, in all this, one must not draw conclusions since the salvation of mankind,
Jesus Christ, was yet unknown. To this, the Watchtower adds, "Scientists and surgeons
have found no evidence of any conscious, living part of humans that survives when the
body dies." Since when does one rely on "scientists and surgeons" for spiritual advice?
Would you ask a priest or minister to remove your tonsils or construct a nuclear power
plant? To notions that no "living part of humans...survives when the body dies," Christ
answers, "have you not read what God himself said to you: I am the God of Abraham,
the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob? He is God, not of the dead, but of the living"
(Mt. 22:31,32). Also, were Elijah and Moses dead when they appeared to Peter, James,
and John, conversing with Jesus (Mk. 9:2-8).
"In fact," writes the Watchtower, "[Christ's] apostle wrote: 'We are walking by faith, not
by sight.' (2 Corinthians 5:7)." In quoting this passage, the Watchtower hopes to
discourage the practice of veneration. In doing so, however, they refute their argument
that the dead "are conscious of nothing at all." They would be conscious of nothing if
they were really dead, but instead they are alive in the spirit as Paul shows in this
passage. Let's consider the context. "We are always full of confidence," he writes,
"realizing that as long as we are home in the body we are exiled from the Lord, guided
by faith and not yet by sight; we are full of confidence, then, and long instead to be
exiled from the body and to be at home with the Lord" (1 Cor. 5:6-8). Unlike Thomas
who would not believe until he actually could see the risen Lord (Jn. 20:29), Christians
must rely on faith. Yet they hope "to be at home with the Lord" some day, and on that
day they will be perfected (cf. Rev. 21:27). Why would those who are perfected need to
pray (cf. Rev. 5:6; 8:4) if they are lacking nothing. The only purpose could be to offer
intercessions on behalf of those who have not yet reached perfection (1 Tim. 2:1).
In the Apocalypse of John, the elders, we are told, offer the "prayers of the saints" (Rev.
5:8; 8:4). This was well known to early Christians. Origen (233 A.D.) writes, "The souls
of the saints who have already fallen asleep...pray for those who pray sincerely." And
Saint Jerome in the fourth century writes, "If the saints had such power when in the
flesh, what can they not obtain for us now that they have secured their victory?" There
are many similar quotations both before and after Jerome too numerous to reproduce
here.
How unfortunate that the Holy word of God has fallen into the hands of dogs (Mt. 7:6),
who misuse it to dishonour our Lord, His blessed mother, and the Holy martyrs and
saints. In keeping with the theme of this chapter, let us offer our prayers and
intercessions for those under Watchtower's "mental-regulating." Ask your patron saint
to pray for them or say a decade of the rosary on their behalf. Moreover, pray that
Christ's Holy Church will be renewed through the promotion of catechises, which I'm
afraid is sorely lacking everywhere. The truth is too important to keep to ourselves. In
the words of Saint James, "My brothers, if one of you strays away from the truth, and
another brings him back to it, he may be sure that anyone who can bring back a sinner
from his erring ways will be saving his soul from death and covering over many a sin"
(Jas. 5:19,20).