4Unity archive

Witnesses and the Watchtower 7

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.
Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower

copyright 1995 by David Wesley

CHAPTER 7 - THE KINGLESS KINGDOM

The year 1914 has always played an important role in Watchtower theology. In 1897,
the founder of the Watchtower, Charles Taze Russell, wrote, "We have seen that the
period of our Lord's presence from 1874 to 1914 is a 'harvest' time, the earlier part of it
for gathering his elect bride, and the latter part at time of trouble, for the overthrow of
the present institutions, in preparation for the new kingdom...Our Lord, the appointed
King, is now present, since October 1874...The beginning of the earthly phase of the
Kingdom in the end of A.D. 1914 will, we understand, consist wholly of the resurrected
holy ones of olden time, - from John the Baptizer back to Abel." Well, 1914 came around
and "the present institutions" remained in place, and there was no sign of "the
resurrected holy ones." As damage control, the Watchtower announced that the First
World War was a sign of the "war in heaven." At that time "Satan was removed from
the heavens" and unleashed on Earth. "This means that Jesus Christ began to rule as
king of God's heavenly government in 1914." In such recent publications, the
Watchtower has selective amnesia with regard to Russell's self declared prophesy.
Consider what he was preaching, namely that Christ would establish His "new
kingdom" in 1914 consisting "wholly of the resurrected holy ones of olden time."
Surely, this "new kingdom" would be beautiful and peaceful. These days the
Watchtower undercuts their founder by declaring that "prominent world leaders...just
before 1914...were saying that conditions promising world peace were never more
favorable." Russell was not only saying that such conditions were "favorable," but that
they were inevitable. By including him among "world leaders" because of his
predictions, the Watchtower is declaring that Russell was among "Satan's human
representatives." Further to this, Russell never said that "Christ began to rule...in 1914."
Instead, he insisted that Christ has been ruling "since 1874."

Either way, both claims are contradicted by Holy Scripture which show that Christ has
always reigned through His Holy Catholic and apostolic Church. Even when Christ
passed on His authority to the apostles at Pentecost (Jn. 16:13; Acts 2:1-12), He
remained Head of the Church (Eph. 1:22). The reign of the Church is also the reign of
Christ. So closely He identifies with His Church that when His Church is persecuted,
so is He (Acts 9:5). Indeed, the Church is His Body (Eph. 4:12). How ludicrous to
suggest that Christ could sever Himself from His Body, in a sense decapitating Himself,
only to transplant Himself onto another body in 1914. Saint Paul rules out such a
possibility in his letter to the Romans. He writes, "There is no change of mind on God's
part about the gifts he has made or of his choice" (Rm. 12:29).

When the angel Gabriel came to Mary, he announced, "The Lord God will give him the
throne of his ancestor&127; David; he will rule over the house of Jacob for ever and his
reign will have no end" (Lk. 1:32-33). That Christ's "reign will have no end" openly
contradicts the Watchtower's notion that "Jesus Christ was enthroned as king...in 1914."
In fact, the Watchtower cannot help but contradict themselves. "In the true church,"
they write, "there is only one Head, Jesus Christ, who since his resurrection, is 'alive
forever,' and so needs no successors." If the Watchtower recognizes Jesus Christ as
"Head...since his resurrection," what was He if not King (def.: 1. A male sovereign; 2.
One that is preeminent in a group, category, or sphere)? How could He be "enthroned"
in 1914 if He had already been enthroned at His resurrection. The Catholic Church, in
her God given wisdom, goes further declaring that she is the kingdom and that Christ
was her King even before His resurrection. Christ Himself declares, "Mine is not a
kingdom of this world" (Jn. 18:36).

Some time before His death, Jesus also tells His disciples, "there are some standing here
that will not taste death before they see the Son of man coming with his kingdom" (Mt.
16:28). Not only were most of them were still alive when they saw Jesus "coming with
his kingdom" at the transfiguration, but with exception of Judas, we find them also
present at His resurrection. Our Lord not only came with His angels (Mt. 28:2) and the
full authority of His kingdom (Mt. 28:17,18), but also with the keys to the kingdom of
Heaven which He promised to give Peter (Mt. 16:19; Jn. 21:15-17). Yet, according to
Watchtower teaching, believe it or not, Jesus is speaking to the generation of Jehovah's
Witnesses who lived prior to 1914. Some of them, they say, will not taste death. As time
goes by, very few from that generation remain alive, such that soon the Watchtower
will need to revise their doctrine and hope once again that their followers will have
selective amnesia. In any event, the Watchtower has a vested interest in interpreting
this passage as such, for it shows that Christ has always been King and Lord. When He
spoke the kingdom of Heaven was already His. The future tense only refers to His
coming with the kingdom which He has always possessed, clothed with the glory
which He surrendered for only a short time (Hb. 2:7). How could our Lord ever be
"enthroned" as king of a kingdom which already belongs to Him.

God cannot withdraw from the covenant He has made with His Church since "His
dynasty shall endure for ever" (Ps. 89:36). How contrary to the Watchtower's notion
that His dynasty ended in apostasy in the second century. Does Christ not tell His
disciples, "I am with you always; yes, to the end of time" (Mt. 28:20)? In this instance,
the Watchtower may claim that Christ was only referring to those in His midst, yet this
cannot be so for He also says, "make disciples of all nations" (Mt. 28:19). There can be
no denial that Christ's promise was succeeded to subsequent generations (Acts 1:20).

As further evidence that Christ never divorced His Bride, consider how the Catholic
Church with its rich diversity of traditions has survived 20 centuries of adversity and
persecution. Scripture reveals that if the Church had been of human origin, she would
have broken up of her own accord, but by her very survival, the Church is revealed to
be from God (Acts 5: 38-39). On the other hand, so many heresies have come and gone
that they are impossible to count. Today among Protestant and pseudo-Christian sects
there is so much division, one cannot keep up. Every day new cults and denominations
seem to appear out of nowhere. Each is teaching something different, and all are
claiming to follow the Bible. In contrast, consider the Rock, instituted by Jesus. Her
doctrine has never wavered from the truth; she has never submitted to public opinion.
Her unbroken lineage can be traced back to Christ Himself when He said to Peter, "on
this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it" (Mt.
16:18).

Indeed, how absurd to suggest that God would instruct the faithful to report erring
brothers to the Church if the Church was herself erring (Mt. 18:17). What value would
there be in this? Even more so, would God not be instructing the faithful to commit evil
when He asks them to bring their erring brothers to "the whore of Babylon," as the
Watchtower refers to God's Holy Church? Even in suggesting this, the Watchtower
makes God a liar. What blasphemy! By such notions does the Watchtower not also call
Christ the Head of this despicable whore. Surely, the Watchtower should "take care not
to find yourselves fighting against God" (Acts 5:39), "for every unfounded word people
utter they will answer on the Judgement Day, since it is by your words you will be
justified, and by your words condemned" (Mt. 12:36-37).

"Beyond all doubt, the evidence points to 1914 as the year when the kingdom of God
went into operation," proclaims the Watchtower. "Beyond all doubt?" How many times
Jehovah's Witnesses have told me that the Watchtower is not "inspired" or "infallible," I
cannot count. When all the errors in predicting "the end of this wicked system" are
pointed out, they claim that "the light is getting brighter as time goes on," and they "are
coming closer to the truth." Yet, the Watchtower's statement here does not sound like
speculation. "Beyond all doubt" leaves no room for error. In addition, if the kingdom of
God "went into operation" in 1914, what was this kingdom prior to 1914, 'out of
operation,' or like the sign on pay phone which reads "out of order." In contrast, King
David sings, "Your kingship is kingship forever, your reign lasts from age to age" (Ps.
145:13). How could He make His "mighty deeds" known to "the children of Adam" if
His kingdom was not operational? When Jesus was "asked by the Pharisees when the
kingdom of God was to come, he gave them this answer, 'the coming of the kingdom of
God does not admit of observation and there will be no one to say, 'Look it is here!
Look it is there!' For look the kingdom of God is among you'" (Lk. 17:20,21).

So how did the Watchtower come up with the year 1914 in the first place? What makes
them so sure that this was the year the "Jesus Christ was enthroned as king?" In the
early years of the Watchtower "the present truth&127; chronology" was calculated from
"the passages of the Great Pyramid of Gizeh" and proves that "God designed both
pyramid and plan." By calculating the length of these passages with each inch
corresponding to a year, "the Pyramid witnesses that the close of 1914 was the
chronological beginning of the times of trouble." In later years the Watchtower decided
that the pyramids of Gizeh were built "under the direction of Satan the Devil." But
rather than admit their mistake and abandon their predictions, they decided to prove
that 1914 was still the year by manipulating scripture to agree with their conclusions.
Always keep in mind that they have already decided that their initial calculations were
done using an instrument built by "Satan the Devil." These days, according to the
Watchtower, "in Revelation chapter 12, verses 6 and 14, we learn that 1,260 days are
equal to 'a time, that is 1 time, and times, that is 2 times, and half a time.' That is a total
of 3 and a half times. So 'a time' would be equal to 360 days. Therefore, 'seven times'
would be 7 times 360, or 2,520 days. Now if we count a day for a year, according to
Bible rule, the 'seven times' equal 2,520 years. -Numbers 14:34; Ezekiel 4:6. We have
already learned that 'the appointed times of the nations' began in the year 607 B.C.E. So
by counting 2,520 years from that date, we come to 1914 C.E."

For heaven's sake! The Watchtower comes up with some pretty unusual concepts, but
this equation takes the cake. Yet, Jehovah's Witnesses, believe it or not, swallow it
without question. Let's look at what the Watchtower is saying and see if their theory
measures up. First, the year "607 B.C.E." refers to the year that Jerusalem fell to
Nebuchadnezzar. Yet authoritative sources place that event closer to 587 B.C.. In any
event, no one can be certain of the date that this event took place. Since the Watchtower
does not claim to be inspired or infallible, they cannot claim to know any disputed
historical dates "beyond all doubt." So even on this one variable, their calculation is
thrown completely out.

Next consider their interpretation of the passages in Revelation. The Watchtower makes
several assumptions here. One is that "Bible rule" shows that a day is equal to a year.
Yet there are no Bible rules without the proper authority to interpret the Bible, which
comes only from the Church. The Church has never held that the days in Revelation
refer to years, besides which, elsewhere Holy Scripture makes clear "that with the Lord,
a day is like a thousand years" (Ps. 90:4; 2 Pet. 3:8). Since the Watchtower is referring to
the time appointed by God for Christ to assume the throne, you would think that any
calculations should be based on the Lord's time, where "a day is like a thousand years."
Applying this "Bible rule" to the Watchtower's equation, Jehovah's Witnesses should
not expect Jesus to be "enthroned as king" for another two million years. The passage
referred to also never says anything about multiplying the number of days in a time by
seven. Interestingly, the Watchtower comes up with a very elaborate equation in order
to explain away the reference to 42 months in the wilderness, yet they interpret the
144,000 servants in Revelation 7:4 as literally representing a heavenly population limit
of 144,000. Surely you can't have your cake and eat it too.

The Watchtower's conversion of days into years parallels the conversion of the passages
of the pyramid of Gizeh from inches to years allowing the Watchtower to come up with
their initial prediction of 1914. Are they now saying that the passages of this pyramid
also follow "Bible rule?" How could this tribute to the pagan gods of Egypt correspond
so closely to the Bible? The answer is simple: it doesn't. Both are instruments of the&127;
Watchtower's "mental-regulating," with the express purpose of instilling fear in their
adherents. They have always, and will always, keep Jehovah's Witnesses looking just
around the corner for Armageddon. Yet with all their usage of pagan instruments and
theology, such as those borrowed from the Egyptians and Aztecs, they dare denounce
"veneration of Mary with a child" as echoing "much older worship of pagan goddesses"
such as "Egypt's Isis." Hypocrites! Not even our Lord's beloved mother, Mary, Queen of
Heaven, is sacred in the eyes of the Watchtower.

Jesus told his disciples in no uncertain terms, "It is not for you to know the times or
dates that the father has decided by his own authority" (Acts 1:7). In addition, the
Watchtower's obsession with calculating the end of the world can easily be interpreted
as a form of divination. Does the Lord not command that "there must not be anyone
among you...who practices divination" (Dt. 18:10)? Later in the same chapter Moses
asks, "How are we to tell that a prophecy does not come from Yahweh? When a
prophet speaks in the name of Yahweh and the thing does not happen and the word is
not fulfilled, then it has not been said by Yahweh" (Dt. 18:21,22). In those days the
penalty for such heresy was severe; "the prophet who presumes to say something in my
name which I have not commanded him to say...that prophet must die" (Dt. 18:20).
Well, the world is not inhabited by "the resurrected holy ones" and the Nazis did not
"destroy the British" as the Watchtower predicted. Indeed, the number of times the
word of the Watchtower has not been fulfilled are too numerous to count. Luckily,
today the world is much more tolerant.

Unlike Christ's message to "love your enemies" (Mt. 5:44), Jehovah's Witnesses long for
the day when God will put an end to "this wicked system." According to the
Watchtower, after Christ was enthroned as king in 1914, Satan was given a short time to
rule the world. Following this, will come Armageddon when God "will use angelic
forces under Christ to carry out the execution" of mankind, save Jehovah's Witnesses of
course. Christ will even execute little children, for the Watchtower declares, "when God
destroyed the wicked he likewise destroyed their little ones." So one finds Jehovah's
Witnesses glued to their radios and televisions during news time watching for "signs"
and reveling in every human tragedy. Whenever a new war starts or an earthquake
devestates a region of the world, Jehovah's Witnesses rejoice, for these are all signs that
Christ is coming to destroy the wicked. Meanwhile, the rest of the world mourns these
tragedies and come together to offer whatever assistance is available. Truly, Jesus "felt
sorry" for the crowds that came to Him (Mt.9:36). How morbid and evil the
Watchtower must be to suggest that the "Prince of Peace" will come to execute "the
children of unbelievers". Did Jesus not say, "Let the little children come to me, and do
not stop them; for it is to such as these that the kingdom of God belongs" (Lk. 18:16)?
Should Christ be compared with the wicked King Herod who destroyed all the "little
ones" in Bethlehem (Mt. 2:16-18)?

"So there will be no more newspaper lists of war casualties, no more war widows or
war orphans, no more homes and cities bombed into ruins." Of course there won't be
any of these if Christ comes and executes everyone. An all-out global thermonuclear
war would have much the same effect. Only, according to the Watchtower, the "elect"
will be spared and have free access to the spoils of the executed. Picture the world
inhabited by Jehovah's Witnesses as they loot and pilfer the goods that we shall leave
behind when we are destroyed by Jesus. Unlike Abraham, who set his eyes on his
heavenly home (Hb 11:8-16), Jehovah's Witnesses place their hope in world. Yet the
world is passing away and those who place their hope in it do not have the love of the
Father in them (1 Jn. 2:15-17). May God have mercy.