4Unity archive

Witnesses and the Watchtower 8

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.
Jehovah's Witnesses and the Watchtower

copyright 1995 by David Wesley

CHAPTER 8 - FAITH WITHOUT FAITH

"Now as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and when he has said the blessing he
broke it and gave it to his disciples. 'Take it and eat,' he said, 'this is my body.' Then he
took a cup, and when he had given thanks he handed it to them saying, 'Drink from
this all of you, for this is my blood, the blood of the covenant, poured out for many for
the forgiveness of sins'" (Mt. 26:26-28). The central point of the Holy Sacrifice of the
Mass is the memorial consecration which transforms, by the power of the Holy Spirit,
the bread and wine into the real body and blood of Christ. Likewise, Jesus taught at the
synagogue at Capernaum that "if you do not eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink
his blood, you have no life in you" (Jn. 6:53). But, the Jews at the synagogue found his
teaching "intolerable" and "many of his disciples went away and accompanied him no
more" (Jn. 6:60,66). As with the Jews, so too we find the objections of the Watchtower.

"Regarding the expressions 'this is my body' and 'this is my blood,'" writes the
Watchtower, the New World Translation reads, "'it means my body,' 'this means my
blood.'" Elsewhere they ask, "What kind of translation is this?" A very good question
indeed. According to the Watchtower, "it is an accurate, largely literal translation from
the original languages. It is not a loose paraphrase." Yet in explaining the difference in
translating the aforementioned passage, they admit that "These renderings agree with
what is stated in context." Well, you can't have your cake and eat it to. On the one hand
they claim to translate "literally," but when their doctrine is contradicted, they choose to
alter the text to agree with what they claim to be the "context."

"Is this to be understood as meaning that they were literally to eat Jesus' flesh and drink
his blood," they ask. "If so, Jesus would have been advocating a violation of the Law
that God had given Israel through Moses. That Law prohibited the consuming of any
sort of blood. (Lev. 17:10-12)" On this point, the "context" is critical. First, immeditately
prior to His command to abstain from blood, the Lord demands that everyone refrain
from offering sacrifices to false gods (Lev. 17:7). Part of this ritualistic sacrifice may
have involved drinking the blood of victims, a practice not uncommon among pagan
cultures. But more importantly, the Jews are here admonished to stay within the
bounds of kosher dietary laws. If Jehovah's Witnesses truely wish to follow "the Law
that God had given Israel," they must also abstain from pork, rabbit, and all shellfish
(Dt. 14:7-10), but they don't.

Despite this, the Watchtower concludes, "Jesus spoke out strongly against breaking any
of the requirements of the Law." Can anyone deny that the Jews found Christ's teaching
"intolerable?" Did He not heal on the Sabbath day, contrary to the law? In His defence,
Christ asks the other Jews, for He too was a Jew, "Is it permitted on the Sabbath day to
do good or to do evil; to save life, or to kill?" (Mk. 3:4). So the Watchtower takes a giant
leap from kosher law and declares that blood transfusions are the same as eating blood.
How many Jehovah's Witnesses died because of this belief. Just recently an air
ambulance was dispatched to a small community near my home to evacuate a pregnant
Jehovah's Witness who was having complications due to her pregnancy. She was
refusing a blood transfusion and therefore needed treatment that she could only receive
in the city. On the way, under cover of darkness, the plane crashed killing all on board,
including doctors nurses, and two pilots. The woman is not to blame by any means for
this tragedy. Yet I cannot help but wonder how many people must die because of this
ridiculous interpretation. "Is it permitted...to save life, or to kill?"

"In a hospital," the Watchtower notes, "when a patient cannot eat through his mouth, he
is fed intravenously. Now, would a person who never put blood into his mouth but
who accepted blood by transfusion really be obeying the command to 'keep abstaining
from...blood'? (Acts 15:29)" Yes he would. Blood transfusions have never been
considered unkosher. In addition, the requirement laid out in the letter to Antioch only
goes so far that it does not scandalize another. Nearly the entire fourteenth chapter of
Saint Paul's letter to the Romans deals with this matter. "No food is unclean in itself."
Later, he writes, "any kind can be evil for someone to whom it is an offense to eat it"
(Rm. 14:14,20). Therefore, one would offend God if he knowingly ate pork in front of a
Jewish convert to Chrisitianity. A more modern example would be drinking in front of
an alcoholic. Drinking in itself is not evil, but when it causes a dry alcoholic to regress,
then it becomes evil. Certainly, violation of kosher law is not "equated with idolatry
and fornication," as the Watchtower asserts. If the Watchtower chooses to literalize
Scripture to the extreme, as in this case, they should also ask their adherents to refrain
from meat, since all meat contains some blood. If they say that the meat has been
properly drained of most of the blood, but not all, then they go back to devotion to
kosher law (Lev. 17:13), which they violate by eating pork, rabbit, and shellfish.

Because of their obsession with abstaining from blood, with regard to the Holy Sacrifice
of the Mass the Watchtower wrongly concludes that "what Jesus had in mind must
have been eating and drinking in a figurative sense, by exercising faith in the value of
his perfect human sacrifice." How does the Watchtower know what Jesus had "in
mind?" They are not inspired. How do they know that He was speaking figuratively?
There is no evidence whatsoever to substantiate this view, even though the Watchtower
may beg to differ. On the other hand, I wholeheartedly agree with the latter part of the
statement. One must have "faith in the value of his perfect human sacrifice," and part of
that faith includes believing in the real presence of our Lord as the Eucharist; "because
a person who eats and drinks without recognizing the body is eating and drinking his
own condemnation" (1 Cor. 11:29). In "recognizing the body," not the bread, one
exercises faith, but woe to him who eats the body of Christ without believing. Such a
person has nothing but contempt for the sacrifice that is offered. He mocks Christ and
blasphemes the Holy Spirit.

But, the Watchtower protests, "Jesus did not say that what he did at the Last Supper
was a sacrifice of himself or that his disciples were to renew his sacrifice." Although the
Watchtower would have you believe that they are protesting Catholic doctrine, that
each Mass is "a" sacrifice that is performed over and over, this is not the case. If we love
Jesus, we are not going to sacrifice Him again and again, in effect crucifying Him daily.
As the Catechism of the Catholic Church reads, "The sacrifice of Christ and the sacrifice
of the Eucharist are one single sacrifice...The Eucharist is thus a sacrifice because it re-
presents (makes present) the sacrifice of the cross...which he was to accomplish once for
all." The teaching of the Church is never contrary to the truth of Holy Scripture which
proclaims that Christ "offered himself only once" (Heb. 9:28). Therefore, the sacrifice
offered by the priest at the alter represents that one sacrifice, the same sacrifice that our
Lord and High Priest Jesus Christ offered at the Last Supper. But what about the
Watchtower's claim that "Jesus did not say that...the Last Supper was a sacrifice?" Did
He not say, "This is my body given for you" and "my blood poured out for you" (Lk.
22:19,20)? And although Christ did not ask that His disciples repeat His sacrifice, He
did ask them to "do this in rememberance of me."

In essence, the Watchtower has no valid argument against the Mass. The only way they
can attack the sacrifice of our Lord is to misrepresent it, twisting it so that it appears to
contradict scripture. The Watchtower's motive is clearly not truth. In fact, the
Watchtower has their own version of a mass which they call "the Memorial." "Jehovah's
Witnesses observe the Memorial after sundown on Nissan 14, according to the
reckoning of the Jewish calendar." Only those 144,000 that are destined for heaven are
permitted to partake of the bread and wine at "the Memorial." "That group began to be
selected in 33 C.E.. Reasonably, there would be only a small number partaking now."
Yet, Saint Paul in his letter to the Hebrews indicated that God has founded a city, a
"heavenly homeland" for a multitude "as numerous as the stars in heaven" (Heb. 11:12-
16). And Saint John, in his Apocalypse, saw "a huge number, impossible for anyone to
count" (Rev. 7:9). But now, by selecting those who are worthy to partake at "the
Memorial," the Watchtower has made itself judge of those who will receive the gift of
heaven. What purpose then does it serve for Christ to come again to judge the living
and the dead? The Watchtower has supposedly already done so.

For those priviledge few, what does "the Memorial" represent? According to the
Watchtower, "Eating his flesh and drinking his blood in a figurative sense is done by
exercising faith in the redeeming power of Jesus' flesh and blood laid down in
sacrifice." If this were the case, then one who had no faith could not partake of the flesh
and blood since the flesh and blood is faith. But Saint Paul tells us that "a person who
eats and drinks without recognizing the body is eating and drinking his own
condemnation" (1 Cor. 11:29). Since one who does not recognize the body does not have
faith, according to the Watchtower's interpretation this passage should read 'a person
who excercises faith without faith is eating and drinking his own condemnation.'
Therefore, eating and drinking are not the same as "exercising faith," since it is
impossible to exercise faith without faith.

"Earlier, in verse 40, when explaining what people must do to have everlasting life,
what did he say was the will of the father," asks the Watchtower in reference to John
6:40? "That 'everyone that beholds the Son and exercises faith in him should have
everlasting life.'" But do the Jehovah's Witnesses really exercise faith when they deny
the Eucharist is really the body of Christ? In essence, the Watchtower refuses to accept
that eating the body of Christ will lead to eternal life. This kind of questioning doubts
the will of God to provide for His people (Mt. 6:25-34). It questions God's reason for
using the matter of His creation to work His miracles. Consider the serpent made by
Moses (Num.21:8,9), surely God did not need a statue to cure the people from snake
bites (Wis. 16:6). Why was Naaman required to bathe in the Jordan River in order to be
cured of leprosy (2 Kgs. 5:8-14)? Surely God could have cured him by His very
command. And what of the blind man? Did Jesus not rub mud on his eyes and
command that the blind man wash in the Pool of Siloam (Jn. 9:6,7)? The miracle of the
Eucharist is very clear, "for my flesh is real food and my blood is real drink" (Jn. 6:55).
By questioning God's will, the Watchtower only exercises the antithesis of faith,
doubting the very words of Jesus.

Bibliography

Aquinas, Thomas. tr. 1957 by Charles J. O'Neil. Summa Conta Gentiles IV.
New York: Image. 358pp.

Craddock, Fred. 1994. Bible, (R) Encarta. Funk & Wagnall's Corporation.

Francis de Sales, St. tr. 1886 by Henry B. Mackey. The Catholic
Controversy. Rockford: Tan. 413pp.

Francis de Sales, St. 1622. tr. 1987 by Nuns of the Visitation. The Sermons
of St. Francis de Sales for Lent. Rockford: Tan. 226pp.

Gould, Stephen J. 1981. The Mismeasure of Man. New York: Norton.
352pp.

Graham, Henry G. 1911. Where We Got the Bible. Rockford: Tan. 154pp.

John Paul II, Pope. 1994 Tertio Millennio Adveniente.

Keating, Karl. Ed. 1991-95 This Rock (periodical). San Diego: Catholic
Answers.

Libreria Editrice Vaticana. 1994. Catechism of the Catholic Church.
Liguori: Liguori Publications. 803pp.

Mateo, Fr. 1993. Refuting the Attack on Mary. San Diego: Catholic
Answers. 22pp.

Reed, David A. Ed. 1990. Index of Watchtower Errors. Grand Rapids:
Baker Book House. 138pp.

Russell, Charles T. 1897. Studies in the Scriptures. Brooklyn: Watchtower.

Spirago, Francis. 1899. The Catechism Explained. New York: Benzinger
Bros. 752pp.

Wansbrough, Henry. Ed. 1990. The New Jerusalem Bible. New York:
Doubleday. 1463pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. Awake - Oct. 8, 1979. Brooklyn:
Watchtower.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. The Watchtower - Feb. 15, 1995.
Brooklyn: Watchtower. 30pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1991. The Greatest Man Who Ever
Lived. Brooklyn: Watchtower.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1990. Mankind's Search for God.
Brooklyn: Watchtower. 384pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1981. New World Translation of the
Holy Scriptures. Brooklyn: Watchtower. 1470pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1989. Reasoning from the Scriptures.
Brooklyn: Watchtower. 446pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1989. Should You Believe in the
Trinity?. Brooklyn: Watchtower. 32pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1968. The Truth That Leads To
Eternal Life. Brooklyn: Watchtower. 190pp.

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. 1982. You Can Live Forever in
Paradise on Earth. Brooklyn: Watchtower. 256pp.