4Unity archive

Answeres to CEC

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

Rebuttal of "Catholicism Proved by Protestant Bible."

This is a refutation of a deceitful Protestant article by the same name, found on the Anti-Catholic  Christians Evangelizing to Catholics websites. 

While surfing the the web, I ran across this article, claiming to be a refutation of the pamphlet called "The Catholic Religion Proven By the Protestant Bible". The supposed "refutation" written by a Mr. Bill Jackson, who runs a very small anti-Catholic website.  Mr. Jackson When reading Mr. Jackson's article several things stood out, the biggest one being that he did not actually address any of the scriptural proofs found in the pamphlet. I was also amazed by the over all very poor scholarship of the refutation.  Normally I would have just kept surfing but Mr. Jackson mentioned that the pamphlet was distributed by by some friends of mine at Our Lady of the Rosary Library, (based out of Louisville Kentucky), so I felt the need to address Bill's comments.    

In this refutation I will address Mr. Jackson's point one by one in the order in which they were posted. for the ease of the reader, and to prevent confusion, all of the quotes from the Catholic Pamphlet (i.e. "The Catholic Religion Proven By the Protestant Bible") will be in "blue", all of Mr. Jackson's statements will be in "red",   and my replies will be "Black".


[Catholic Pamphlet] Comment: If reading the Bible were a necessary means of salvation, Our Lord would have made that statement and also provided the necessary means for his followers.

[Mr. Jackson ] We do not believe that reading the Bible is necessary for salvation. Jesus did make means for others to hear by sending forth preachers and inspiring some with apostolic gifts that, along with the (already written) Old Testament, was sufficient for the needs of His people.

First, allow me to point out that Mr. Jackson’s first argument, is in fact a non argument. This pamphlet was written for Protestants in general, and the fact remains that there are many, many, Protestants who do believe that “reading the Bible were a necessary means of salvation”. Weather or not Bill himself personally holds this belief does not negate the pamphlet’s statement. Mr. Jackson is simply a individual, and does not speak with any real “authority” nor does he speak for Protestants as a whole. According to "The Christian Sourcebook" (1986 pg.326), there were "21,000 denominations in 1986, with 270 new ones being formed each year." All of these are Protestant. As of January, 1997, there were more than 28,000 Protestant denominations.

Secondly, I agree with Bill’s statement that “Jesus did make means for others to hear by sending forth preachers and inspiring some with apostolic gifts ”. The intent to the apostles was simple, the word of God was to be preached verbally, it is for this reason that out of twelve apostles who were with Christ from the beginning only two left us written gospels. St. Paul tells us our faith is to be based on HEARING (this is verbal teach) St. Paul does not say nor did he ever intend faith comes from reading any written book or collection of books. Maybe that’s why himself did not write a gospel. Of course, this should be obvious to any reader scripture Christ commanded them to "preach" and "teach", NOWHERE did Christ say to "write" and "read". Maybe that’s why Christ established a Church to instead of a book. If the authors of the New Testament believed in sola Scriptura, why did they sometimes draw on oral Tradition as authoritative and as God's Word (Matt 2:23; 23:2; 1 Cor 10:4; 1 Pet 3:19; Jude 9, 14 15)?

"If so ye continue in the faith, grounded and settled, and immovable from the hope of the gospel which you HAVE HEARD, which is PREACHED (verbal teaching not written) in all the creation that is under heaven, where of I Paul am made a minister." (Col. i. 23)

"Faith then cometh BY HEARING; AND HEARING by the word of Christ. But I say: Have they not HEARD? Yes, verily, THEIR SOUND hath gone forth into all the earth, and their words unto the ends of the whole world." (Rom. 10:17,18)

Third, I would like to point out that at the time of Christ, the cannon of the Old Testament was not a settled matter. There was much debate among the Jews as to which books belonged in it, this is evidenced by examining books the Septuagint Bible (sometimes called the LLX) which contained seven more books than the modern Jewish Old Testament does.

Scholars generally agree that the authors of the New Testament often quoted the LLX, And portions of the LXX were found in Judea among the Dead Sea Scrolls. which dated to before 70 A.D.


[Catholic Pamphlet] The Protestant Bible itself teaches that the Bible does not contain all Our Lord’s doctrines.

[Mr. Jackson ] The scriptures he uses are John 20:30 and 21:25, “And many other signs did Jesus in the presence of his disciples which are not written in this book.” “And there are also many other things which Jesus did . . .” John is not talking about doctrine.

“John is not talking about doctrine” here Bill makes a ridiculous personal assumption, that he can not prove, and tries to pass it of as fact. If the items were not preserved in the written text of the gospels, how does Bill know what they were? How does he know if the were Doctrine or not? In reality he does not.

It has been said, that all that is written in the Gospels cumulatively, would only cover 18 days in the life of Christ. Jesus lived for 33 years or 33 X 365 = 12045 days. What about the missing 12027 days? Christ walked among humanity and gave us 3 years or 3X 365 = 1095 days of verbal teaching before his death. There are 1077 days verbal preaching of the missing from the written text of the Scriptures.

Did not Christ promise "the heavens and earth shall pass away but, my words shall not" where are they? Where are the 'writings' of over 99% of His life? Are most of Christ’s words and actions lost to Christianity? The remainder is, no doubt are the unwritten SACRED APOSTOLIC TRADITION!

A good example of this would be the "Agrapha" (unwritten things). Agrapha denotes words of Christ not written in the Four canonical gospels. Some examples within the Bible itself are Acts 20:35 and 1 Corinthians 11:24-24, many more are found to the writings of the early Christian fathers.
 

[Catholic Pamphlet] The New Testament itself teaches that it doesn’t contain all that Our Lord did, or consequently, all that He taught. (The same two scriptures are used.)

[Mr. Jackson ] Writing that there were many unwritten things Jesus did does not in any way prove that there were unwritten teachings that were necessary either for salvation or a successful Christian life. . See John 20:31, “But these are written . . .” The Greek for written is grapho, which means to write, with reference to the form of the letters; to delineate (or form) letters on a tablet, parchment, paper, or other material; to write, with reference to the contents of the writing; to express in written characters; to commit to writing (things not to be forgotten), write down, record.

This is essentially the same argument Mr. Jackson uses Just above, since it has already been answered there is no need to go in to it again. The only real difference between Bill’s two answers, is the irrelevant and unnecessary defining if the Greek word “grapho” (i.e “written ”). It is clear that Bill is wishing to puff him self up by the use of facts which has no bearing on the topic at all.

[Catholic Pamphlet] Since the Bible is incomplete, it needs something else to supplement it, i.e., the spoken or historically recorded word which we call Tradition.

[Mr. Jackson ] Historically recorded word is an unsure term. Was this Tradition written; if so, by whom? There are numerous traditional teachings found in Rome’s catechisms which are simply untrue. For instance, the Catechism of the Council of Trent said the Apostles’ Creed came from the Day of Pentecost when each of the twelve Apostles shouted out one sentence of the Creed. We do not even have to examine the monstrous false decretals (of which the Donation of Constantine is probably best known) which were, before they was debunked, part of Roman Catholic Canon Law.

First, It should be pointed out that the "Donation of Constantine" was never considered sacred tradition. a forged document of Emperor Constantine the Great, by which large privileges and rich possessions were conferred on the pope and the Roman Church. While many looked at the document as supporting the Primacy of the Pope, It was not the basis of this doctrine.

Secondly, I agree that the "Donation of Constantine" was a forgery. What Bill fails to mention was that it was the Roman Catholic Church that exposed and denounced this document as a fraud. The forgery was discovered by several Catholic Bishops and scholars centuries before Protestantism existed, as the following citation from the Catholic Encyclopedia 1913 shows:

"As early as the fifteenth century its falsity was known and demonstrated. Cardinal Nicholas of Cusa (De Concordantiâ Catholicâ, III, ii, in the Basle ed. of his Opera, 1565, I) spoke of it as a dictamen apocryphum. Some years later (1440) Lorenzo Valla (De falso credita et ementita Constantini donatione declamatio, Mainz, 1518) proved the forgery with certainty. Independently of both his predecessors, Reginald Pecocke, Bishop of Chichester (1450-57), reached a similar conclusion in his work, ‘The Repressor of over much Blaming of the Clergy’, Rolls Series, II, 351-366." ( Catholic Encyclopedia 1913)

The “Donation of Constantine” does not disprove the office of the Papacy nor would it disprove the Catholic Church. After all, even the Sacred Scriptures have cited from fraudulent books, as can be seen in the Epistle of St. Jude 1:14-15 where it cites the apocrypha book of Enoch - but of course, this does not disprove the Sacred Scriptures.
 

[Catholic Pamphlet] The Church has carefully conserved this “word of mouth” teaching by historical records called Tradition.

[Mr. Jackson ] Then why does the Catholic Encyclopedia (1912 edition) say, “Substituting of false documents and tampering with genuine ones was quite a trade in the Middle Ages,” and “Writers of the 4th century were prone to describe many practices as of apostolic origin which certainly had no claim to be so regarded.”

This is no special revelation, there have always been unscruplous men (such as Mr. Jackson ) who have attempted to alter the truth for there own gain. The “Substituting of false documents and tampering with genuine ones ” has always been a problem (both civil and religious), in every age, through out time. Even today such crimes as Identity theft is skyrocketing.

On the religious front, the Roman Catholic Church has always been at the forefront of exposing these frauds, and protecting the truth. As we say with the last answer, The “Donation of Constantine” is a very good example of this, It was the Church that exposed the truth about the documents fraudulent nature.

[Mr. Jackson ] Traditional statements passed through “the Church” have no divine approval. 1 Peter 1:19 speaks of a more sure word of prophecy.

According to who? Who established Mr. Jackson as the determining authority on what has “divine approval ”? I find this funny, because Mr. Jackson can not even provide the correct verse numbers for the scripture he wishes his reader to examine. 1 Peter 1:19 makes no reference to “prophecy”, the verse Bill is looking for is 2 Peter 1:19.

The casual and honest reader of the article must agree with me when I say that Mr. Jackson is clearly not a authority on anything, especially the scripture.

Shortly before 400 A.D. a General Council of the Catholic Church, using the infallible authority which Christ had given to his own divine institution, finally decided which books belonged to the New Testament and which did not.


[Mr. Jackson ] The Council of Carthage, referred to above, was not a General or ecumenical (world-wide) Council. It was a local Council, and no infallibility was ever guaranteed to a local Council. Likewise was the Council of Hippo and the Council of Laodicea. The former agreed with Carthage; the latter omitted the Book of Revelation.

It is true that these synods were merely local, and they in themselves did not have universal binding authority, their decrees were submitted to various Popes. After the Popes approved the decrees, they became part of the Ordinary and Infallible teaching of the Magisterium of the Catholic Church. The time line of the approval of the New Testament Canon goes like this:


Pope Damasus I and the Council of Rome (382): A meeting of Western church officials and theologians which took place in 382 under the authority of Pope Damasus I, (366-384) gave a complete list of canonical books of the OT and NT which is identical to the canon used today by the Catholic Church.

Council of Hippo (393): Local North African Church council approved a list of OT and NT canon (The list is same as the canon used today by the Catholic Church)

3rd Council of Carthage (397): Local North African Church approved a list of OT and NT canon (The list is same as the canon used today by the Catholic Church)

Pope Innocent I, Bishop of Rome, (405):Responded to a request by Exuperius, Bishop of Toulouse, with a list of canonical books of Scripture. (The list is same as the canon used today by the Catholic Church)

4th Council of Carthage (419): Local North African Church council approved a list of OT and NT canon (The list is same as the canon used today by the Catholic Church)
 


[Mr. Jackson ] The whole question about whether this Council was even Roman Catholic is important.
 

This point shows Mr. Jackson’s ignorance of the Councils or the people attending them. Let’s have St. Augustine [A.D. 397] , who attended both of the councils Hippo (397) and third council of Carthage (397), answer this point:

"I would not believe in the Gospel if the authority of the Catholic Church did not move me to do so." (St. Augustine, Conra Epist. Fundam. i,6)



[Mr. Jackson ] This system, which is probably dated from the decree of Roman Emperor Theodosius toward the end of the 4th century that made what he termed “the Catholic Church” the favored religion of Rome, was by no means universally accepted in 397 A.D.

Once again Mr. Jackson’s shows his ignorance on the topic of history. The combination "the Catholic Church" (he katholike ekklesia) was first used by St. Ignatius of Antioch in the early second century. So we see that Bill’s claim is off by almost two hundred years, and that Mr. Jackson was wrong in claiming that it was a Roman Emperor who coined the phrase.

The term "Catholic Church" is found for the first time in the letter of St. Ignatius to the Smyrnaeans, written about the year 110. The words run:

"Wheresoever the bishop shall appear, there let the people be, even as where Jesus may be, there is the universal [katholike] Church."

By the middle of the fourth century the term “Catholic Church” was widely used and accepted. St. Cyril of Jerusalem says in his Catecheses (AD 348), the church is called Catholic (Katholikos) on the ground of its worldwide extension, its doctrinal completeness, its adaptation to the needs of men of every kind, and its moral and spiritual perfection.


[Mr. Jackson ] We understand that the true Church, the Body of Christ, was not identical with the institutionalized church that became, through its development, the Roman Catholic Church.

The true Church, the Body of Christ, since the death of Christ, has and always will be the Catholic Church. And all of Mr. Jackson’s wishes to the contrary, will not change this fact.



[Mr. Jackson ] Further, we know that identifying certain books as the Bible did nothing to establish the Bible.

This statement is so ridiculously stupid I don’t know were to begin. It has been estimated that by the end of the forth century there were over 200 false gospels, acts, and letters floating around, claiming to be true Scripture.


Establishing witch books were authentic sacred scriptures and which were deceitful forgeries does a LOT to “establish the Bible ”.

Assembling and compiling the identities of the books that are true scripture, does a LOT to “establish the Bible ”.

Using the accepted authority of the Church and Popes to give this list of Scared Books validity, does a LOT to “establish the Bible ”.

Ending the debate over the validity of the different Texts of the New Testament does a LOT to “establish the Bible”.

Promulgating and circulating the accurate list of true scripture for all to receive, love , and charish does a LOT to “establish the Bible”.


Any honest historian will acknowledge the fact that it was these Councils, Saints and Popes that “establish the Bible” as we know it.
 

[Mr. Jackson ] You might correctly identify my car as a Honda, but you didn’t establish this identity. It was a Honda since its manufacture.

Here Again, I am shocked by the ignorance of Mr. Jackson’s statement. Before Bill’s Honda was assembled (i.e manufactured), it wasn’t a Honda, it was a pile of loose and individual parts, laying around the factory floor. This is also the same with the Bible, before the different texts were assembled together by the Councils and Pope into one list/book, there was no Bible, it was a bunch of loose and scattered books and letters.
 

[Catholic Pamphlet] If our non-Catholic brethren today had no Bibles, how could they even imagine following the “Bible-only privately interpreted” theory; but before 400 A.D. New Testaments were altogether unavailable.

[Mr. Jackson ] God spoke through the Gifts of the Holy Spirit to those who had no book.

This is true, Christ established a Church with a structured leadership to spread his teachings and he sent the Holy Ghost to guide the church he established. The Holy Ghost has continued to guide the church for over two thousand years.

[Mr. Jackson ] However, by the end of the first century, most if not all churches had some portion of the Bible, and the inspired books were quickly accepted by Christians.

“the inspired books were quickly accepted”? As we have seen above it took almost four hundred years for all the books of what we now call the New Testament to be accepted. We have to wonder where does Mr. Jackson get this absurd stuff.


[Mr. Jackson ] That is why, as Alex Dunlap wrote, when Councils defined the books of the Bible, it only brought a stifled yawn from Christians who already loved God’s Word, even if, for a time, that was not completed.


Mr. Jackson wishes us to believe that these people “truly loved the word of God” yet the did not care is it was completed or accurate. Bill wants us to believe that they did not care about the item he claims they “truly loved”. Is anyone else seeing the blatant contradiction here? For if you “truly loved the word of God” would you not be truly exited to finely have it in a accurate and completed form?

Second both Mr. Jackson and Alex Dunlap (who ever he is), show a sever lack of knowledge of the writings of the Church fathers and the history of the New Testament. The validity of canon of the new testament was a very import mater to the early Christians (as it is to modern Christians) and it was a hotly be item in the early Church. Many canonical books, which we hold as "inspired Scripture", which were disputed in the church during the first four centuries after Christ, some examples are:

Hebrews: Irenaeus of Lyons lists it as disputed. Tertullian this epistle as not canonical . Both Origen and the forth century historian Eusebius puts this epistle among the Antilegomena or contested writings. (Hist. eccl., III, 25, 3)

The Epistle of James: In the first centuries of the Church the authenticity of the Epistle was doubted by some, It is wanting in the Muratorian Canon, and because of the silence of several of the Western Churches regarding it, the forth century Christian historian Eusebius classes it amongst the Antilegomena or contested writings (Hist. eccl., III, 25, 3); St. Jerome gives the like information (De vir. ill., ii), but adds that with time its authenticity became universally admitted.

Second Peter: In the first two centuries there is not in the Apostolic Fathers and other ecclesiastical writers, if we except Theophilus of Antioch (180), a single quotation properly so called from this Epistle. In the Western Church there is not explicit testimony in favour of the canonicity and Apostolicity of this Epistle until the middle of the fourth century. Tertullian and Cyprian do not mention it. The forth century Christian historian Eusebius classes it amongst the Antilegomena or contested writings (Hist. eccl., III, 25, 3)


Second John: Tertullian does not list this epistle in the sacred canon. Both Origen and the forth century Christian historian Eusebius puts this epistle among the Antilegomena or contested writings.(Hist. eccl., III, 25, 3)


Third John: Tertullian does not list this epistle in the sacred canon. Both Origen and the forth century historian Eusebius puts this epistle among the Antilegomena or contested writings. (Hist. eccl., III, 25, 3)

The Epistle of Jude: Tertullian does not list this epistle in the sacred canon. Both Origen and the forth century historian Eusebius puts this epistle among the Antilegomena or contested writings. (Hist. eccl., III, 25, 3)


The Apocalypse [or the book of Revelations]: The forth century historian Eusebius the tells us "The Apocalypse is by some accepted among the canonical books but by others rejected" (Hist. Eccl., III, 25, 4). St. Cyril of Jerusalem does not name it among the canonical books (Catech. IV, 33-36); nor does it occur on the list of the Synod of Laodicea, or on that of Gregory of Nazianzus.