4Unity archive

Chriatian martyrs

Restored archive: This page originated on CatholicApologetics.net and may contain dated links, terminology, quotations or commentary. It is being preserved while 4Unity is progressively reviewed and updated.

How Many Martyrs did you say The Catholic Church Killed?

A look the Protestant claim of fifty million "true Believers murdered" 

When surfing the internet it is not uncommon to run across anti-Catholic Website wishing spread lies about the Catholic Church. One of the most ridiculous ones is that the Catholic Church killed tens of millions of "True Believers".  The "exact" number of those supposed to have been murdered fifty million.[1]

In all of these cases we generally find that they have two thing in common:

1) We note that the perpetrators of these lies fail to provide documentation for these shocking statement, because no such documentation (of reputable sort exists).

2) They all seem claim these murders took place during the "dark ages". [If any time period is given at all for these supposed murders]

The "Random House College Dictionary," says:

"Dark Ages: the period in European history from about A.D., 476 to about 1000." (Random House College Dictionary, p. 338)

I would like to point out that if what these Protestants says about 50 million so-called "True Believes" being "martyred" is true, over a five hundred and twenty year time period, that would mean that about 263 people were killed every day, 96,154 killed every year, 961,540 people killed every decade, for a five hundred and twenty year. This is twice as many people as were killed during the black plague in Europe, [which wiped out a estimated one third of the European population.] These Protestants would have us believe that during this time period about two-thirds of the population of Europe died martyrs and "true believers."

An atrocity of this magnitude would dwarf Hitler and the holocaust (who killed only about six million people). In the Vietnam war, a ten year war, only took about 60,000 American lives. World War I only caused about thirty million casualties. This would mean that more people were "martyred" during the "dark ages" - when many parts of Europe was sparsely populated that it is said that one could ride for days without finding a sign of life - than were killed during World War I, a war on a global scale - hence the name "world war." It stands to reason that a mass holocaust on this scale (115 a day, 41,666 a year) would have been found in every single history book and be quoted by every scholar who has ever studied this time period and wanted to attack the Catholic Church. And yet I can find no references to this anywhere.

I challenge these Protestants to prove this incredible massacre through credible history. Of course, this should be an easy task for them... in the first place, because, as I said above, something of this magnitude should be very easy to research. This claim seem not to come from valid history but rather from there own vivid imagination.

The 1994 "Almanac of the Christian World" [Pg, 502] tells us that only about 40,725,000 Christian’s have died for their faith since 33 AD, and according to this Protestant publication, of these forty million Christian martyrs, 16,301,250 were Catholics and Orthodox, only 2,694,700 Protestants.

The "Almanac of the Christian World" tells us that of these forty million martyrs since 33 AD, 32,900,00 were put to death by non-Christians [Secular governments, Atheists, Muslims, Hindus, Pagans].  As we can see from the chart bellow that the vast majority of the Christian martyrs died during 

Martyrdom.jpg (513601 bytes)

while it is true that at times, Protestants were put to death by Catholics, we must remember this fact goes both ways, there have been many Catholics murdered by Protestants. Here are a number articles which deal with the Bloody persecutions of the Catholic Church by Protestants, under : The Anabaptists, The Anglican, The Calvinists and The Puritans during the reformation. The purpose of these articles set history straight."They have been rebellious to the light, they have not known his ways, neither have they returned by his paths."---Job. xxiv 13 


FOOT NOTES:

1]For example, the Protestant the Ant-Catholic  Website "Jesus is Lord" claims "killed over 50 million" [This Protestant article is refuted Here].

Another example is Diane Groetz - an apostate Catholic and a popular author on the "Former Catholics For Christ" Website also claims  "About 50 million Christians" died. [This Protestant article is refuted Here]